PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

Not_a_boffin 13th Dec 2021 22:14

Poker logic. If you believe your oppo won't call you, keep raising the ante, till they fold.

Its not like Auntie will point this out when they can emphasize how terrible nookular war would be. After all, it's "only" Ukraine.

West Coast 14th Dec 2021 02:48


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11155521)
Putin does seem to be making increasingly unhinged threats.

Russia, as opposed to the USSR plus Warsaw Pact, doesn’t present a realistic threat to Europe - even if it does to the Baltic states and Ukraine.

Realistically, why deploy IRBM or the equivalent? There is no real threat to Russia - and no realistic chance would bomb its only major market.

For public consumption in Western Europe would be my guess.

ORAC 14th Dec 2021 04:58

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/b...sion-jd7x5ffxq

Boris Johnson warns Putin against Ukraine invasion

Boris Johnson has told President Putin that any invasion of Ukrainewould have “significant consequences” as Russia warned conflict was inevitable if Nato continued its expansion toward its borders.

In a phone call Johnson told Putin that the UK was committed to Ukraine’s “territorial integrity and sovereignty” and that any “destabilising action” by Russia would be met with a united response from the West.

In Moscow Russia’s deputy foreign minister gave the Kremlin’s first explicit warning of military action, amplifying tensions with Ukraine.

“A lack of progress towards a political-diplomatic solution would mean that our response will be military and military-technical,” Sergei Ryabkov told the state news agency RIA Novosti. “There will be confrontation”.

“There’s no trust in Nato as an alliance. We’re no longer playing these kinds of games and don’t believe in Nato’s assurances.”…..

Ryabkov is expected to meet Karen Donfried, the American assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs, this week in Moscow.

Asturias56 14th Dec 2021 12:41

I'm sure that really frightened Putin..............

NutLoose 14th Dec 2021 15:33

Putin has more men ready for the off than we have in the military, which brings about the question how are we going to handle so many prisoners when we struggle with a boatload of refugees.

:E

Beamr 14th Dec 2021 16:04


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11155903)
Putin has more men ready for the off than we have in the military, which brings about the question how are we going to handle so many prisoners when we struggle with a boatload of refugees.

:E

Ask the germans, they've experience in this matter.

ORAC 14th Dec 2021 16:23

Don’t ask the Poles, they still remember Katyn…..

dead_pan 14th Dec 2021 16:40

Interesting to look at the Line of Contact in eastern Ukraine - the area in separatist hands constitutes probably less than half of the Donbas. And its a long ol' distance to the much discussed land bridge to Crimea.
Would Vlad really try it on, one last hurrah? I'm beginning to think its all posturing.

henra 14th Dec 2021 19:08


Originally Posted by dead_pan (Post 11155930)
Would Vlad really try it on, one last hurrah? I'm beginning to think its all posturing.

I also have some doubts. After all he must keep it afterwards. That is easy if the majority of the inhabitants is pro- Russian. If not, it can get ugly quickly. Hello Afghanistan.
If he tries at all he will only try to occupy 'friendly' territory. He doesn't have the troops to keep 45 Million people (almost one third of his own population) in check permanently. After winning against Georgia he also refrained from pernmanently occupying.

squidie 14th Dec 2021 20:20


Originally Posted by dctyke (Post 11154852)
i believe that it is over 20% in Ukraine. If true that’s a lot of people.

More in Eastern Ukraine too.

NutLoose 15th Dec 2021 01:45

I personally think it’s all a bluff and he has another agenda that he is after accomplishing,such as the nord gas line or getting the start treaty on nukes that was allowed to lapse reinstated.

Asturias56 15th Dec 2021 07:47

No doubt there are people trying to figure out how to get Mr Putin to retreat. His problem is that having made a big noise he can't just do a U-Turn (he's not BoJo after all).

Sitting and doing nothing is easy but may not be wise - I think I'd go for an Energy Summit which would aim to codify energy arrangements in E & C Europe - and the plum for him would be that Norsdstream 2 would open - after all the damn thing has been built already. Using it isn't going to change Germany's dependence on Russian gas really - and if they are really worried they can move to LNG supplies over 2-3 years and gradully use less from teh east. Let Putin suggest it so he can bask in Russian media coverage.

I'm always a bit leery of backing dictators with large armies into corners.........

Less Hair 15th Dec 2021 08:07

So they dream about Soviet Union 2.0. Assuming they get all the territories: What would it be good for? Didn't they end up bankrupt the last time? Pure size clearly did not work for them.

NutLoose 15th Dec 2021 12:10

But things have changed, we now depend on their gas, we didn't in the coldwar.

Merkel has apparently twice stopped US arms sales to the Ukraine that they have paid for.

Angela Merkel 'blocked US from arming Ukraine against Russia' (msn.com)


dead_pan 15th Dec 2021 13:53


Originally Posted by squidie (Post 11156011)
More in Eastern Ukraine too.

I wonder how many Russian-speaking Ukrainians beyond the separatist areas are sympathetic towards Russia. If their recent elections are anything to go by, I suspect many aren't.

As for Putin marching his troops back down the hill, I'm sure he'll find some way as portraying this as some glorious victory against the evil West. Your average Russian probably won't know the truth, and certainly wouldn't openly question it.

ORAC 17th Dec 2021 21:03

Let there be war….


https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/r...rope-tdklrrvdg

Russia demands Nato remove all troops from eastern Europe

Russia has demanded that Nato, America and Britain withdraw all military bases and troops from central and eastern European countries, including those within the EU.

The Russian foreign ministry published Moscow’s demands to Nato, the US and allies on “security guarantees” in return for withdrawing a massive troop build-up on Ukraine’s border.

Russia’s demand in the form of two draft legal treaties is highly unusual in international diplomacy and is regarded as an ultimatum that threatens the existence of the western alliance and the EU.

The draft treaties call on Nato and Washington to halt any enlargement of the alliance eastwards and “not to deploy weapons and forces” where it “would be perceived by the other side as a threat to national security”.

The White House said it was discussing the proposals with European allies, adding that it “will not compromise the key principles on which European security is built”.

Demands include an incendiary call for all troop deployments in eastern Europe to be rolled back to the levels before 1997, effectively removing Nato protection from all countries that have since joined.

“Nato and the US must not station any additional military personnel or weapons outside the countries where they were stationed as of May 1997 (prior to the accession to the alliance of Eastern European countries) except in exceptional cases with the consent of Russia,” said the demands, according to the Russian RIA Novosti news agency.

Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic joined Nato in 1999, followed in 2004 by Bulgaria, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia and the former Soviet republics of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.

“Putin is demanding that President Biden abolish Nato,” said a diplomat from an eastern European country in the alliance. “If the West blinks then the alliance that stopped Soviet aggression and protected the peace is dead.”

Sergei Ryabkov, Russia’s deputy minister, warned that relations with Nato and the West were at a “dangerous point” and called for crisis talks with the US tomorrow in Geneva on the demands. “We are ready to immediately to go for talks with the US,” he said.

Other demands include a US commitment “not to establish military bases in former Soviet countries” or “to develop military co-operation” with countries that include the EU members Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania.

Russia is additionally demanding a ban on the deployment of Nato, US and Russian warships and aircraft to “areas where they can strike targets on the territory of the other party”.

“This is fantasy geopolitics. Putin is living in the USSR past. If he wants to be taken seriously he must engage with the reality of the present which is that Nato has enlarged,” a European diplomat said…….

Herod 17th Dec 2021 21:21

"This is my last territorial claim in Europe" Hitler 1938.

unmanned_droid 17th Dec 2021 21:50

Putins latest fantasy missive must be purely for internal domestic consumption. If he's serious I want some of what he's on, it looks to be fookin mental.

tdracer 17th Dec 2021 23:49


Russia is additionally demanding a ban on the deployment of Nato, US and Russian warships and aircraft to “areas where they can strike targets on the territory of the other party”.
Given the worldwide reach of some weapon systems, that would effectively ban their deployment anywhere in the world.
I don't know what Putin is smoking, but I'd like to have some...

NutLoose 18th Dec 2021 00:39


Demands include an incendiary call for all troop deployments in eastern Europe to be rolled back to the levels before 1997, effectively removing Nato protection from all countries that have since joined.
We’d have to seriously enlarge our forces and rebuild Bruggen Laarbruch Wildenwrath, Gutersloh Wegberg Rheindalen etc borrow our Harriers back from the USA and dust off the Jag and Tornado Fleets at Cosford.

I suppose the USA and U.K. should be flattered, we get mentioned twice, both as part of NATO and separately. He must think we are a serious threat lol.
Hasn’t he realised the only reason these countries wanted to join in the first place was to prevent him walking into them again, and they want nothing to do with him, they tried the Russian model once and it sucked.

I’ll have a pint of whatever he’s drinking.


​​​​​​…


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:29.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.