PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

NutLoose 14th Feb 2022 16:47


Originally Posted by henra (Post 11184236)
Putin will be very aware what WWIII would mean and what smoldering remains would be left from the planet (and thus especially also Russia as well - There are for each Russian town dozens of Nukes which have its name written on them) as a consequence.
I'm not sure I see any possibility for Russia to win a lot in this whole mess. I think Putin miscalculated the unity of the 'West' and now has the problem how to get out of this without losing face.

Sad fact isn't it that wars are often fought over the greed of a very few.

albatross 14th Feb 2022 18:34

Why am I reminded of Hitler’s annexation of the Sudetenland in 1938 and subsequent takeover of all of Czechoslovakia.
Supposedly justified as being to protect the German minority of the population.

Also the US and others have raised the possibility of the Russians faking a trans-border attack supposedly by the Ukraine into Russia to be used as a justification for Russia to invade Ukraine .
Did not Hitler do the exact same thing to “Justify” the Nazi invasion of Poland in 1939?

Beamr 14th Feb 2022 19:19


Originally Posted by albatross (Post 11184292)
Also the US and others have raised the possibility of the Russians faking a trans-border attack supposedly by the Ukraine into Russia to be used as a justification for Russia to invade Ukraine .
Did not Hitler do the exact same thing to “Justify” the Nazi invasion of Poland in 1939?

yes, the Gleiwitz incident.
the Soviets did the same a few months later, called the shelling of Mainila where the Soviet artillery shelled their own troops but the Soviets claimed that the shots were fired from Finland and so began the winter war.

minigundiplomat 14th Feb 2022 19:41

Willing to bet all those posting about impending invasions and war with Russia are the same people worried about climate change and are queuing up for their 4th booster.

it’s theatre - pure distraction.

fab777 14th Feb 2022 19:47


Originally Posted by minigundiplomat (Post 11184321)
it’s theatre - pure distraction.

What's not, then?

NutLoose 14th Feb 2022 19:51

Well if Putin thought it was all going to ramp up to ww 3, he wouldn’t have bothered collecting his yacht.

langleybaston 14th Feb 2022 21:04

Does Ukraine have any capability to counter-strike? Have they air assets that could [probably suicidally] attack Moscow?

Probably not, but once any invasion gets under way, the temptation to hit back [rather than just defend] must surely be a consideration.

henra 14th Feb 2022 21:56


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11184326)
Well if Putin thought it was all going to ramp up to ww 3, he wouldn’t have bothered collecting his yacht.

That's definitely not his plan and for sure not even an accepted outcome for him. HE (personally) has a lot to lose. The problem ist more an accidental escalation getting out of control.

tartare 14th Feb 2022 22:06


Originally Posted by langleybaston (Post 11184348)
Does Ukraine have any capability to counter-strike? Have they air assets that could [probably suicidally] attack Moscow?

Probably not, but once any invasion gets under way, the temptation to hit back [rather than just defend] must surely be a consideration.

From the limited reading I've done - it appears Russia has an overwhelming ability to knock out any Ukraine aircraft that avoid getting destroyed on the ground and might get airborne.
I doubt they'd even be able to cross the border.

NutLoose 14th Feb 2022 22:28

But you could have folks positioned in Moscow as well as other Russian cities and the rear ready to kick off if war is announced, it would bring it home to them as well as possibly disrupting road rail and power infrastructure.

tartare 14th Feb 2022 22:46

CBS now reporting Russian artillery now moving into attack positions.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/russia-...nkId=152198269
Speculation it will all kick off on Wednesday.

albatross 15th Feb 2022 00:30


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11184326)
Well if Putin thought it was all going to ramp up to ww 3, he wouldn’t have bothered collecting his yacht.

Wait til the shipyard tries to collect. $$$$$$$$ and are told the costs are retroactive reparations from WW2.
JUST JOKING.

BANANASBANANAS 15th Feb 2022 01:21


Originally Posted by henra (Post 11184236)
Putin will be very aware what WWIII would mean and what smoldering remains would be left from the planet (and thus especially also Russia as well - There are for each Russian town dozens of Nukes which have its name written on them) as a consequence.
I'm not sure I see any possibility for Russia to win a lot in this whole mess. I think Putin miscalculated the unity of the 'West' and now has the problem how to get out of this without losing face.


I'm also worried because an accident/misunderstanding could easily lead to escalation looking at the high tensions. I hope everyone is aware and reflects in each move what's at stake.

Agree 100% on both points.

ORAC 15th Feb 2022 04:45

The Duma, Russia's parliament, will vote on Tuesday to decide whether to ask President Vladimir Putin to recognise two Russian-backed breakaway regions in eastern Ukraine as independent, according to the speaker of the Duma lower house.

ORAC 15th Feb 2022 05:45

Suggestions in the press that Putin might not attack Ukraine for “months”.

But that seems to ignore the weather/terrain issue both in the Pinsk marshes and across Ukraine - “Rasputitsa” - which would, if not making an attack impossible, would greatly aid Ukrainian defence until next winter. Can Putin keep effectively his entire army deployed in the west, including all those sent from the Far East region on exercise in Belarus?

And, of course, it provides more months for allies to ship more modern equipment to the Ukraine and train their forces in its use.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/20...ukraine-border

Russia sending thousands more troops to Ukraine border

….”Although Liz Truss, the foreign secretary, has said “there could be a Russian invasion almost immediately”, on Monday she told MPs in a private conference call that Putin could keep up the military pressure on Ukraine for months, according to some of those who listened in.”…..

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rasputitsa

Rasputitsa

ORAC 15th Feb 2022 06:31


ORAC 15th Feb 2022 08:03

Armour on the move using operational tracks, not peacetime training tracks…


dead_pan 15th Feb 2022 08:13


Speculation it will all kick off on Wednesday.
They said that about Christmas eve too. I guess the signs are there if you look hard enough...

The public disagreement, albeit minor, between Putin and Lavrov was noteworthy, shows that there are doubts at the top too. I wonder was Lavrov stands to lose if sanctions kick in?

dead_pan 15th Feb 2022 08:16


Armour on the move using operational tracks, not peacetime training tracks…
But we don't know how many, whether this was a photo-opp/propaganda piece etc etc

Asturias56 15th Feb 2022 08:23

BBC leading with Russian news of "some troops pulled back"


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:24.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.