PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   All borders to reopen. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/632861-all-borders-reopen.html)

ruprecht 4th Dec 2020 21:56


Originally Posted by neville_nobody (Post 10940607)
The ADF aren't a normal employer, you sign away everything when you join up.

The military is where they take away your rights and reintroduce them as privileges. :E

kiwi grey 4th Dec 2020 23:02


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 10939957)
You would probably want the quarantine facilities near airports than can accept widebodies for direct international services. Less need for connecting internal flights. I'm thinking Curtin, Scherger, Alice Springs, quite a few of the FIFO ports (if any can be temporarily spared for quarantine use), Woomera, Rockhampton. Christmas Island could be an option although it could be a bit tight for some widebodies.

Far more can be done, it's just that no one wants to. More interested in arguing with each other and playing the blame game.
.

If the major city hotels weren't being used for Hotel Quarantine, they'd be empty, all their staff on the dole, no GST being paid by the hotel company or their employed staff.
On the contra side, the government would have to pay for setting up / maintaining, staffing and guarding these quarantine facilities in the remote areas.
That's why "no one wants to" do this.
$$$$$$$$$

BTW, we've had the same suggestions in NZ from opposition MPs "build a big new quarantine centre at RNZAF Base Ohakea".
I suspect that someone explained the financial facts of life, they've gone all quiet on it.

morno 4th Dec 2020 23:19


Originally Posted by KRviator (Post 10940073)
Yeah, nah. I won't be getting it, and neither will the kidlets.

I'm certainly not an anti-vaxxer, I'm all for standard vaccinations and the entire family is as up to date as we can be, but, both the KRviatrix and I have concerns about the speed with which these vaccines have progressed from development, through testing to distribution. I get that part of it is because there are so many companies etc collaborating on development & testing, but I'll wait a bit longer until I roll up the sleeves. History is littered with examples of "It was a good idea at the time..."

It’s not 1950, it’s 2020. I don’t think the speed makes one iota of difference.

There is risk with all vaccines, yet I’m guessing that you have had all those.

I’ll do whatever I have to do to get the world back to normal.

C441 5th Dec 2020 01:26


And if your employer has a no jab no work policy? What then?
Even if it is not a requirement of your employer it may well be a requirement of various other countries on your airline's network.
As was the case with a couple of countries not permitting crew over 65, it may see some pilots having to move to a domestic fleet if they aren't prepared to be vaccinated.

dr dre 5th Dec 2020 03:07


Originally Posted by KRviator (Post 10940073)
Yeah, nah. I won't be getting it, and neither will the kidlets.
I'm certainly not an anti-vaxxer ....but, both the KRviatrix and I have concerns about the speed with which these vaccines have progressed from development, through testing to distribution.


Originally Posted by Joker89 (Post 10940112)
I’m not injecting my kids with a vaccine that isn’t required. Covid19 will burn out on its own accord


Originally Posted by boeinga320 (Post 10940438)
I had it about 2 months ago. Woke up with a sore throat for 4 days. Bit of a cough at night. Cup of tea in the morning and I was good to go. I couldn't believe that was the reason I went from flying a plane to delivering pizzas https://www.pprune.org/images/smilies/cool.gif

Damn, didn't realise we had so many medical professionals posting here. Makes you wonder why anyone would bother to go to university and study science when we have geniuses here who can say with authority they know more than the "so called experts".

And people wonder why the virus is tearing through a lot of other nations.......

kingRB 5th Dec 2020 03:21


Originally Posted by morno (Post 10940638)
It’s not 1950, it’s 2020. I don’t think the speed makes one iota of difference.

There is risk with all vaccines, yet I’m guessing that you have had all those.

you might want to look at how many vaccines have gone wrong since 1950. Medical science still screws up routinely.

When the head of Pfizer admits they are not even sure if you can still transmit the virus when vaccinated and "it needs to be looked into more" - for the sake of a virus that will burn out by itself, and has negligible consequence on people with a normal, healthy metabolic system,
yeah, I think i'll pass. Just the same as I don't bother getting a flu vaccine because i'm not in any risk category that would warrant bothering.

As expected, vaccines that are used to combat serious disease / risk of being life altering or death are being conflated with this Corona virus vaccine.


I’ll do whatever I have to do to get the world back to normal.
That's also kinda the problem summed up in one sentence - the world, our economies and that thin veil of what we thought were our freedoms has been absolutely trashed and taken advantage of by Government and corporations by this very attitude.





Turnleft080 5th Dec 2020 03:41

The difference between a pro-vaccine person and a anti-vaccine person.

Pro-vaccine person believes a drug can counteract the bad bacteria that has caused the infection. This has been going on for the last 200 years.
Anti-vaccine person believes good bacteria that counteracts the bad bacteria prevents infection in the first place. This has been going on for the last 5000 years.

That's the dilemma in a nutshell not an argument. As time has evolved the chemical/physical/emotional stress has built slowly, century after century.
Don't forget the gut has trillions of bad bacteria at any one time and your gut is 80% of your immune system. The way you counteract that bacteria is your business
and no one else's.


morno 5th Dec 2020 04:00

Ohh FFS :ugh:

Better turn off all your EGPWS alerts and TCAS systems as well. They’re preventing you from dieing just like a vaccine.

God there are some paranoid people on here.

And the virus will die out will it? That’s why countries are into their 3rd and 4th waves and the US has just recorded some massive increase in the case rate.

morno 5th Dec 2020 04:02


Originally Posted by Turnleft080 (Post 10940689)
The difference between a pro-vaccine person and a anti-vaccine person.

Pro-vaccine person believes a drug can counteract the bad bacteria that has caused the infection. This has been going on for the last 200 years.
Anti-vaccine person believes good bacteria that counteracts the bad bacteria prevents infection in the first place. This has been going on for the last 5000 years.

That's the dilemma in a nutshell not an argument. As time has evolved the chemical/physical/emotional stress has built slowly, century after century.
Don't forget the gut has trillions of bad bacteria at any one time and your gut is 80% of your immune system. The way you counteract that bacteria is your business
and no one else's.

So you’d rather go through the pain and suffering of getting these diseases and the painful aftermath?

Ask someone who had polio as a kid if they would have liked a vaccine.

Green.Dot 5th Dec 2020 04:03


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 10940679)
Damn, didn't realise we had so many medical professionals posting here. Makes you wonder why anyone would bother to go to university and study science when we have geniuses here who can say with authority they know more than the "so called experts"...

Ha ha- says you!

I believe the famous dr dre wrote this yesterday...

Vaccines get the bodies immune system ready to fight off the infection the second it hits the body, instead of unvaccinated infection which allows the virus to get a foothold over several days before the bodies immune system creates antibodies to fight it off. So whilst the virus may technically infect the body, the sickness is less severe or non existent. Less severe or non existent symptoms means less likelihood of virus spread in the community
My apologies if you are actually a real medical doctor who found his/her way on to regularly posting on a pilots forum...

dr dre 5th Dec 2020 04:41


Originally Posted by Green.Dot (Post 10940695)
Ha ha- says you!
I believe the famous dr dre wrote this yesterday...
My apologies if you are actually a real medical doctor who found his/her way on to regularly posting on a pilots forum...

Nope. here's the difference.
I'm posting a paraphrased version of what 99% of medical experts (all minus the quacks) know. I sourced it from a World Health Organisation document here:
How do vaccines work?
Those who say they know more than the "so called experts" were saying Covid is going to die naturally, is not a problem as their symptoms were mild, and thought they knew more about vaccine approval than the specialists. These are not positions supported by the overwhelming bulk of medical experts.

Joker89 5th Dec 2020 04:53

And Dr Dre, 99% of what governments are doing is not backed by scientific evidence either. While they don’t look at the excess mortality, impact of masks and lockdowns etc they expect people to listen to them when they say, you must have a vaccine.

There has never been a requirement for a vaccine for a corona virus before and new technologies have been used to try and create one now in record time.

Nothing makes sense anymore but I think each individual has a right to choose, to look at the evidence and make their own mind up, not follow the scaremongers and sign their rights away even more.

Turnleft080 5th Dec 2020 05:00


Originally Posted by morno (Post 10940694)
So you’d rather go through the pain and suffering of getting these diseases and the painful aftermath?

Ask someone who had polio as a kid if they would have liked a vaccine.

No their wouldn't be any pain or suffering in the first place because your immune system would counteract the bacteria.

Polio was and still is a disease invented by man by poor sanitory and poor water quality. Hence your bad bacteria has well and
truly defeated your good bacteria. That's why you get sick.

Poliomyelitis, commonly shortened to polio, is an infectious disease caused by the poliovirus.[1] In about 0.5 percent of cases, it moves from the gut to affect the central nervous system and there is muscle weaknessresulting in a flaccid Poliovirus is usually spread from person to person through infected fecal matter entering the mouth.[1] It may also be spread by food or water containing human feces and less commonly from infected saliva.[1][3

Thank's wikipedia and note the word gut.

dr dre 5th Dec 2020 05:32


Originally Posted by Joker89 (Post 10940708)
And Dr Dre, 99% of what governments are doing is not backed by scientific evidence either.

Although there’s indifvidual state differences I think most scientists, experts and the governments would agree (some more begrudgingly than others) that masks work, lockdowns help reduce spread and vaccines will be safe and distributed ASAP amongst the masses. Who are you to say what is behind the stopping of the spread is not backed by scientific evidence?

Joker89 5th Dec 2020 05:51


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 10940716)
Although there’s indifvidual state differences I think most scientists, experts and the governments would agree (some more begrudgingly than others) that masks work, lockdowns help reduce spread and vaccines will be safe and distributed ASAP amongst the masses. Who are you to say what is behind the stopping of the spread is not backed by scientific evidence?


dr dre 5th Dec 2020 07:06

Ahh, Ivor Cummins, the Chemical engineer turned Diet and health food book swindler who’s now decided, with no public health qualifications or experience, that he knows far more than the “so called experts”.

I can’t be bothered to a sit through an hour of conspiracies from someone who is not remotely qualified to talk about the subject matter. I think he, you and a whole lot of others posting here need to read this, as it explains one of the biggest problems with modern society:

The problem with thinking you know more than the experts

Joker89 5th Dec 2020 08:15

Data is fact, you can draw your own conclusions, everything else is opinions, including yours, no better than the millions of others out there.

dr dre 5th Dec 2020 08:26


Originally Posted by Joker89 (Post 10940773)
Data is fact, you can draw your own conclusions, everything else is opinions, including yours, no better than the millions of others out there.

Absolute nonsense.

My interpretation of that data has the exact same weight as your interpretation, Ivor Cummins’ interpretation and anyone who does not have sufficient qualification in public health or epidemiology’s interpretation.

Zero.

So next time you break a bone before the Doctor has a chance to look at the x-ray snatch it out of his hand and tell him his mere “opinion” on it has the same weight as the receptionist or the practice cleaner. Or your own.

It doesn’t matter how persuasive or confident charlatans like Ivor Cummins are. If he’s not influencing opinions of the ones who matter (public health experts and epidemiologists) then his words are nothing more than PR designed for clicks and YouTube views to attract gullible types to his brand to buy his Keto Diet books.

The country that was going for a herd immunity approach (Sweden) failed and have now changed course to what the rest of the world is doing.

FFS how did society become so f*cking stupid......

currawong 5th Dec 2020 08:46

UK commentary as to what works does not really apply to the Australian experience.

https://ourworldindata.org/coronavir...pickerSort=asc

unexplained blip 5th Dec 2020 09:40


Originally Posted by kingRB (Post 10940685)
... and has negligible consequence on people with a normal, healthy metabolic system

I accept Boris Johnson is abnormal, and for that reason he needed ventilation to keep living. I accept Tim Brooke Taylor was gonna die anyway, yada yada.

Where I am currently sitting in my man cave, there are three people who had COVID within 50m of me. Diagonally-opposite neighbour to the NW was a fit ex-navy type in his 50s. One of the initial batch of infectees in the state. Still several kg too light, still not near pre-COVID fitness. Couple in house to the SW, husband is mid 40s in aviation, was a keen cyclist, fitness now shattered. Wife early 40s, also was in good shape, and is only now shaking off recurrent waves of anxiety and again fitness is way off. So don't spout uninformed bull**** about COVID-19 being inconsequential. It is at minimum equivalent to glandular fever for many, with an R value exceeding 1.0 by a big margin, so every ******** will get if it runs free.

Just because some government reactions are over the top fanatical, and causing equivalent damage as the virus, does not make it right to spout rubbish about COVID-19 being nothing to write home about.

And to anyone posting malarkey about COVID not killing too many more people than the flu etc, please show a little bit of common sense and consider what might happen if we were not actively shutting the virus spread down by throwing everything else under bus. FFS.




morno 5th Dec 2020 11:22

Why don’t those who are talking it down, actually go and get infected if they’re so confident, then tell us how you go afterwards.

Perhaps this is natural selection at play, off you all go

SOPS 5th Dec 2020 11:23

And in breaking news..

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-12-...ntine/12954384

More people who think the rules don’t apply to them.. there goes the borders!!!

JustinHeywood 5th Dec 2020 11:36


Originally Posted by Turnleft080 (Post 10940689)
The difference between a pro-vaccine person and a anti-vaccine person.

Pro-vaccine person believes a drug can counteract the bad bacteria that has caused the infection. This has been going on for the last 200 years.
Anti-vaccine person believes good bacteria that counteracts the bad bacteria prevents infection in the first place. This has been going on for the last 5000 years.

That's the dilemma in a nutshell not an argument. As time has evolved the chemical/physical/emotional stress has built slowly, century after century.
Don't forget the gut has trillions of bad bacteria at any one time and your gut is 80% of your immune system. The way you counteract that bacteria is your business
and no one else's.

I’m increasing suspicious that you’re just trolling turnleft.

You DO know that we are talking about a virus here, don’t you? And that a bacteria is not a virus?

boeinga320 5th Dec 2020 12:38


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 10940679)
Damn, didn't realise we had so many medical professionals posting here. Makes you wonder why anyone would bother to go to university and study science when we have geniuses here who can say with authority they know more than the "so called experts".

And people wonder why the virus is tearing through a lot of other nations.......

Haha mate woah. I didn't claim to be a medical expert. Just giving my experience of how the virus felt. I'm certainly not anti-vax or anything like that. Real science cannot be disputed. I think what it comes down to more, is that we're entitled to our core beliefs. Some people believe that death is unacceptable. Others believe that birth and death is the most natural thing in the world. And before you say that's insensitive of me, I am fully aware that my death is also inevitable. Nature suggests "survival of the fittest, to the benefit of the herd". You can have the opinion that we haven't been strict enough with lockdowns. I can have the opinion that we have been too strict and it may possibly have a lasting affect on young peoples lives for decades to come. But to say right now that either of us knows for certain is a naive point of view.

wheels_down 5th Dec 2020 13:37


Originally Posted by SOPS (Post 10940892)
And in breaking news..

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-12-...ntine/12954384

More people who think the rules don’t apply to them.. there goes the borders!!!

This and hotels are just ticking time bombs until the next cluster surfaces as a result. Whoever is responsible for the process breakdowns with these people need to be charged.

Still have people working multiple jobs at Hotels.

The Premiers have said they will not close the borders unless a significant outbreak is created, however I don’t think they will hesitate one bit if they can sniff a hotel or airport leakage problem about to surface. She normally gives Sydney a 48hr threat so you might be able to just get home in time.







Ragnor 5th Dec 2020 18:33

How is it possible his late in the game, that international travelers are able to skip hotel quarantine. Australia needs to grow a set and start criminally charging these ppl.

This is the ticking time bomb that needs to be addressed by not allowing international arrivals to capital city’s anymore risk is to high to us.

Turnleft080 5th Dec 2020 23:19


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10941123)
How is it possible his late in the game, that international travelers are able to skip hotel quarantine. Australia needs to grow a set and start criminally charging these ppl.

This is the ticking time bomb that needs to be addressed by not allowing international arrivals to capital city’s anymore risk is to high to us.

They (the 2 German tourists I think ) not only escaped quarantine, they escaped officials at SYD International then had to either train it, or bus it, to the
domestic side to catch the Virgin flight. Problem identified at MEL airport the last piece of swiss cheese blocked. All pax and flight crew texted. Wow.
What about those on the train or bus?

neville_nobody 6th Dec 2020 01:13

Looks like the security/quarantine theater show is on again. What on earth are these government officials doing to allow two foreign nationals to literally walk straight into Australia? What is the point of all the restrictions, the economic damage etc when you can just walk straight in? Lets not forget all the other stuff ups that seem to be at the hand of the government officials this year too. This year has seen the vast majority of the population do the right thing only to have the government at one level or another screw it up.

Ragnor 6th Dec 2020 01:28

NSW has done very well through out this, but, this latest is almost unforgivable. Yes there will be outbreaks and cases but this should never have happens. NSW police let these two escape, as news is coming in its apparent it could of been lining up in the line for the bus when the two told police they had exemption to on travel, luckily to the diligent airport staff in ML this was picked up and reported.
This whole not wanting to hurt anyone’s feelings give them a pat on the back tell them to try harder next time etc is rubbish. This virus has killed caused economic damage and heartache. Ppl need to be held accountable over this or stop the international arrivals.

josephfeatherweight 6th Dec 2020 01:42


Originally Posted by unexplained blip (Post 10940815)
I accept Boris Johnson is abnormal, and for that reason he needed ventilation to keep living. I accept Tim Brooke Taylor was gonna die anyway, yada yada.

Where I am currently sitting in my man cave, there are three people who had COVID within 50m of me. Diagonally-opposite neighbour to the NW was a fit ex-navy type in his 50s. One of the initial batch of infectees in the state. Still several kg too light, still not near pre-COVID fitness. Couple in house to the SW, husband is mid 40s in aviation, was a keen cyclist, fitness now shattered. Wife early 40s, also was in good shape, and is only now shaking off recurrent waves of anxiety and again fitness is way off. So don't spout uninformed bull**** about COVID-19 being inconsequential. It is at minimum equivalent to glandular fever for many, with an R value exceeding 1.0 by a big margin, so every ******** will get if it runs free.

Just because some government reactions are over the top fanatical, and causing equivalent damage as the virus, does not make it right to spout rubbish about COVID-19 being nothing to write home about.

And to anyone posting malarkey about COVID not killing too many more people than the flu etc, please show a little bit of common sense and consider what might happen if we were not actively shutting the virus spread down by throwing everything else under bus. FFS.

Well said and interesting to get this perspective from someone who has witnessed it, first hand. I don't know anyone who has had it, so I appreciate your view and agree with everything you've said.

dr dre 6th Dec 2020 03:11


Originally Posted by Turnleft080 (Post 10941270)
They (the 2 German tourists I think ) not only escaped quarantine, they escaped officials at SYD International then had to either train it, or bus it, to the
domestic side to catch the Virgin flight. Problem identified at MEL airport the last piece of swiss cheese blocked.

Again the common denominator.

Sydney Airport International terminal, city train or city bus to Domestic terminal, Melbourne airport terminal. All staff and passengers using those transport hubs then move all over those cities, potentially spreading it in every direction.

Solution? Fly them direct to Curtin, Christmas Island, Alice Springs, Woomera, etc. Problem solved.

glekichi 6th Dec 2020 03:59


Originally Posted by unexplained blip (Post 10940815)
Where I am currently sitting in my man cave, there are three people who had COVID within 50m of me. Diagonally-opposite neighbour to the NW was a fit ex-navy type in his 50s. One of the initial batch of infectees in the state. Still several kg too light, still not near pre-COVID fitness. Couple in house to the SW, husband is mid 40s in aviation, was a keen cyclist, fitness now shattered. Wife early 40s, also was in good shape, and is only now shaking off recurrent waves of anxiety and again fitness is way off. So don't spout uninformed bull**** about COVID-19 being inconsequential.

Amazing to have so many people so close when only one in just under a million Australians have been infected.
Stats show COVID-19 is inconsequential to the vast, vast, majority of those infected.
Your anecdotal evidence is weak.

BTW I do not oppose the vaccine rollout; quite the opposite. No need to be sprouting uninformed anecdotal bull**** though.

SOPS 6th Dec 2020 04:19

Australians can’t get flights home. How do German tourists get in?

Fonz121 6th Dec 2020 04:25


Amazing to have so many people so close when only one in just under a million Australians have been infected.
One in just under a million have been infected?! I’m not great at math, but maybe rethink that.

chookcooker 6th Dec 2020 04:44


Originally Posted by Fonz121 (Post 10941346)
One in just under a million have been infected?! I’m not great at math, but maybe rethink that.

ha ha. But pilots are experts at everything dontchya know

wheels_down 6th Dec 2020 04:50


Originally Posted by SOPS (Post 10941345)
Australians can’t get flights home. How do German tourists get in?

They need to be sent back if they are tourists.

The Car Rental clerk in Melbourne was the person that apparently raised the concern and called the authorities.

They purchased the Virgin tickets while on the train between terminals. They most certainly had this planned and we need to drop the book hard on these two big time.


SOPS 6th Dec 2020 06:20

ABC and The West Australian are both reporting them as German nationals. I ask again.. how did they get here in the first place?

Ragnor 6th Dec 2020 06:50


Originally Posted by SOPS (Post 10941372)
ABC and The West Australian are both reporting them as German nationals. I ask again.. how did they get here in the first place?

They're German nationals but Australian residents. It was a security guard (not car rental) that raised the alarm. They asked directions for the car rentals then the security guard probed them thats when they (the Germans) requested directions to hotel quarantine. NSW police are owning the f@#k up saying it was a veteran cop but only this cop second day doing hotel quarantine seems they gave him a pat on the back and told him to try harder next time. This guy needs to be disciplined its been going on long enough they should know what to do by now.

1A_Please 6th Dec 2020 07:18


Originally Posted by SOPS (Post 10941345)
Australians can’t get flights home. How do German tourists get in?

I was a bit confused by that too.


michigan j 6th Dec 2020 09:44


Originally Posted by 1A_Please (Post 10941389)
I was a bit confused by that too.

About 30% of people getting in arent citizens or permanent residents. 19 000 new visas have been issued since the caps started.


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:46.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.