PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

langleybaston 28th Feb 2022 20:59


Originally Posted by SLXOwft (Post 11192362)
I believe the BL755s dropped by SHARs during the Falklands War were referred to as Custard Bombs, at least by 800 RNAS.

Oh! I think I understand .... even if fleetingly.

Tartiflette Fan 28th Feb 2022 20:59


Originally Posted by pr00ne (Post 11192422)
NLAW is only part of what is being delivered, in huge numbers. At least 6 nations are supplying Javelin, other ATGW systems are being supplied by many other nations, plus Stinger and other hand held SAM's.

I was very surprised to read that part of the German contribution is supplies of Panzerfaust 3: I didn't know they had kept on the name from WW II, though having said that, the appearance is not radically different.

ORAC 28th Feb 2022 21:40

For the first time, more than half of Finns are in favour of their country joining NATO, according to a poll commissioned by public broadcasting company Yle.


cynicalint 28th Feb 2022 21:53


Originally Posted by tdracer (Post 11192457)
I saw where Ukraine is trying to make the case that Russia isn't a legitimate member of the UN Security Council. Basically, the UN charter specifies the Soviet Union - a collection of 13 states - and when the Soviet Union fell apart, Russia wasn't entitled to unilaterally take its place.
I'm not optimistic that they'll win, but it might be good for some popcorn.

Pr00ne,
What is your professional take on that? I feel that if there were mileage in it it would have been addressed before now?

ORAC 28th Feb 2022 21:53

The last texts of a Russian conscript to his mother before he was killed.


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....2d7610c9b.jpeg

Lonewolf_50 28th Feb 2022 22:45


Originally Posted by NAROBS (Post 11192388)
one wonders how many of the provisions of the UN Charter and associated conventions have to be broken before they exclude Russia from the Security Council ?

Sorry, you can't, they are a charter member of the club. Without the protections of veto, they don't join. This isn't rocket science. UN is not a matter of equality in membership. Some members are more equal than others. Russia is one such member.

Your appeal to "just war theory" will probably evoke sniggers in Moscow, and a few other places.

@tdracer:
Uh, no, that one isn't gonna go anywhere.
Republic of China (that would be the government that went into exile on Taiwan, Kuomintang), was the original UN Member, but eventually People Republic of China replaced them. You can thank Henry Kissinger and Richard Nixon for getting the ball rolling on that.
The Russians were not dumb enough not to ensure that they were the replacement for Soviet Union when CCCP became CIS after the Wall fell.

Mind you, I grinned in empathetic support the other day, about an hour after Putin launched "Operation let's go get Ukraine" when the Ukrainian (was watching this on CSPAN) ambassador addressed the Security Council and said to the sitting president of that body (the Russian gent) "you should vacate your chair, since your country started this war."

Hey, may as well raise the point. :ok:

@ORAC: what are the odds that bit you posted is factual, versus "something posted on the internet of dubious provenance" in your estimation?

NutLoose 28th Feb 2022 23:51


Originally Posted by Beamr (Post 11192434)
of course there could be an addition in the answer: "fortunately Ukraine is being delivered a multitude of other weaponry that uplifts the total performance capability."
ok?

The trouble has got to be distribution across the country though, I noted the film of the guns and ammunition being supplied to the public they were using dumper trucks as opposed to military, which makes sense, less of an obvious target.

Paul C 1st Mar 2022 00:20

I was under the assumption that the S400 was the bees knees of air defence systems so am surprised that Ukraine seems able to operate their TB2s over the battle space and possibly even into Russia.

NutLoose 1st Mar 2022 01:01


At the moment, military pilots from Ukraine are in Poland. Today they receive 29 Polish MiG-29s. With full weapons and electronics. 🇵🇱
#UkraineRussiaWar #Ukraine #StopRussia #StandingWithUkraine
1st March

quite a haul :)

NutLoose 1st Mar 2022 01:19

These farmers are getting ambitious, an SA-8 Gecko system, just what you need to scare low flying birds off your crops.

Iqbal Ul khair
@lhair_ul
·
16m
If confirmed, this could be the funniest part of Russia's war with Ukraine. Today, a Ukrainian farmer stole a Russian military track using his farm tractor. Kyiv #UkraineRussiaWar Poland #UkraineRussiaWar

tartare 1st Mar 2022 01:26

That Russian convoy moving to Kyiv is now 64km long!
Oh for a couple of fully loaded A-10s... what a Turkey shoot.

NutLoose 1st Mar 2022 01:44

I would have thought with the off road mud issues that appear to be hampering the Russians, take out the front and rear of that convoy and it will be a target rich environment.

mud problems see

https://news7f.com/russian-tank-stuc...lt-on-ukraine/

RatherBeFlying 1st Mar 2022 02:48

Let's Put In a cheer for Чернoзем aka black earth aka mud.

The Finns specialised in mottis. Disable the front and back of a convoy traversing a forest, mud an effective substitute, but forest supplies better cover. Chop the convoy into pieces. Target field kitchens (and fuel tankers).

Bring in the in-laws. Thermal sights helpful in night attacks.

It may be worth noting that penetrations are close to the borders, a possible additional confirmation of fuel shortages to be added to the many reports of Russians running out of gas.

Also of note are the generous contributions of aircraft and ordinance from Poland, Czech Republic and Slovakia. Beyond Lukashenko and Xi, Putin seems short of friends.

Sue Vêtements 1st Mar 2022 03:31

Funny how General Mud and General Winter were the Soviets' friends in WWII. It looks like General Mud has changed sides now

Have to say I find it odd that nobody seems to have mentioned the similarities (and obvious differences) between these events and Operation Barbarossa

pr00ne 1st Mar 2022 03:41


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11192473)
For the first time, more than half of Finns are in favour of their country joining NATO, according to a poll commissioned by public broadcasting company Yle.

Similar situation and scenario in Sweden. Putin really has got the exact opposite of what he wanted to achieve here.

pr00ne 1st Mar 2022 03:45


Originally Posted by cynicalint (Post 11192476)
Pr00ne,
What is your professional take on that? I feel that if there were mileage in it it would have been addressed before now?

If the case was made back in 1991 then it may have had some legitimacy. The fact that it wasn't, and Russia has continued in situ as a voting member for the subsequent 21 years and been accepted as such by the rest of the permanent Security Council and indeed the entire UN membership would, I imagine, render any attempt to make such a claim now null and void.

Until the veto of the members of the Permanent security council is removed the UN will not amount to a jot in cases such as Ukraine.

pr00ne 1st Mar 2022 03:48


Originally Posted by tartare (Post 11192525)
That Russian convoy moving to Kyiv is now 64km long!
Oh for a couple of fully loaded A-10s... what a Turkey shoot.

I think their mobile SAM and gun systems would be a real issue for anything like an A-10.

Beamr 1st Mar 2022 03:51


Originally Posted by Sue Vêtements (Post 11192537)

Have to say I find it odd that nobody seems to have mentioned the similarities (and obvious differences) between these events and Operation Barbarossa

this was discussed already before the invasion started.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:16.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.