PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Iran (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/586655-iran.html)

racedo 23rd July 2019 17:03


Originally Posted by ShotOne (Post 10526061)
Repeat a lie enough times and it becomes true, racedo?Slavery was both immensely profitable and tenable, witnessed by many nations which continued to profit hugely, long after abolition. It’s not for UK to tell HK how it should be governed. But we are very much party to the 50 year joint agreement guaranteeing HK retains its own laws. Amongst other things, these outlaw Hong Kongers from being kidnapped without legal process to reappear in Chinese prisons.

UK decided Hong Kong should have democracy only when they were leaving not before. Why not ?

racedo 23rd July 2019 17:04


Originally Posted by beardy (Post 10526123)
Has nobody considered that in responding to racedo all they are doing is priming a chatbot with its next response?

Why do you feel you have to abuse people personally when you disagree with their viewpoint ?

unclenelli 23rd July 2019 17:51

QUEST1 has had it's tracker turned off since 19 May heading to Mediterranean (MEDITE)
So what was is doing at Gibraltar in July if it wasn't heading back to some clandestine delivery to a rogue nation?

beardy 23rd July 2019 19:55


Originally Posted by racedo (Post 10526227)
Why do you feel you have to abuse people personally when you disagree with their viewpoint ?

Quod erat demonstrandum

Asturias56 24th July 2019 08:37

Racedo (and the likes of Van) are useful as they stick out a foot occasionally to interrupt the group think that can settle in on here

I'm sure West Coast, SAS-less and some of the other Cold War warriors don't object to having their tails tweaked occasionally.........

NutLoose 24th July 2019 10:47

Does this not read like......It looks like we have screwed our Navy over so much we can't protect our own ships, I know. let's suggest we have an international force and get them to do it for us.


https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknew...rce/ar-AAEKfy2

Mil-26Man 24th July 2019 11:47


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 10526796)
Does this not read like......It looks like we have screwed our Navy over so much we can't protect our own ships, I know. let's suggest we have an international force and get them to do it for us.


https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknew...rce/ar-AAEKfy2



ShotOne 24th July 2019 13:26

Even if the Royal Navy was four times it’s size, it couldn’t possibly escort every single ship. But a broad coalition (no, NOT an EU Navy!) would certainly change this picture, however unpalatable Iran May find this. How ironic that the Iranian Revolutionary Guards should be succeeding where Trump failed!

West Coast 24th July 2019 13:48


Originally Posted by beardy (Post 10526369)
Quod erat demonstrandum

Van brings a ranging perspective. Racedo is like a broken record.

Mil-26Man 24th July 2019 14:51


But a broad coalition (no, NOT an EU Navy!)
Dancing on the head of a pin. The EU is there for us, unlike the US.



How ironic that the Iranian Revolutionary Guards should be succeeding where Trump failed!
Quote
There are other ironies here also (see above).

racedo 24th July 2019 18:25


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 10526704)
Racedo (and the likes of Van) are useful as they stick out a foot occasionally to interrupt the group think that can settle in on here

I'm sure West Coast, SAS-less and some of the other Cold War warriors don't object to having their tails tweaked occasionally.........

Group think brought Communism, Nazis, Vietnam, Iraq plus lots of other cases when people who could have done something early didn't and the body count went into the millions.

Some people will always do as they are told, others won't.

racedo 24th July 2019 18:27


Originally Posted by ShotOne (Post 10526927)
Even if the Royal Navy was four times it’s size, it couldn’t possibly escort every single ship. But a broad coalition (no, NOT an EU Navy!) would certainly change this picture, however unpalatable Iran May find this. How ironic that the Iranian Revolutionary Guards should be succeeding where Trump failed!

Wouldn't it be easier to stop the drums of war and ask WTF is going on and why is everybody jumping to someones tune, who is sitting back and claim not involved.

Mil-26Man 24th July 2019 19:01


Some people will always do as they are told, others won't
.

How very noble. Don't kid.yourself racedo, you're just being contrary because.you get a kick out of it.

Asturias56 25th July 2019 09:02

"Why do you choose to make a thread personal about someone ? As someone who has openly supported Trump since 2016 then your assessment kind of falls flat."

Just interested in what drives you Racdeo - for the record I'm a middle of the road, wishy washy Liberal who doesn't trust anything any politician or newspaper says

As for supporting Trump since 2016 ... how do you know?? I've only been posting on here since late 2018 ....................

In fact I think he's a disgrace - the worst ever US President - a man I wouldn't allow to be in the same room alone with any female for a start..............

racedo 25th July 2019 10:12


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 10527735)
"Why do you choose to make a thread personal about someone ? As someone who has openly supported Trump since 2016 then your assessment kind of falls flat."

Just interested in what drives you Racdeo - for the record I'm a middle of the road, wishy washy Liberal who doesn't trust anything any politician or newspaper says

As for supporting Trump since 2016 ... how do you know?? I've only been posting on here since late 2018 ....................

In fact I think he's a disgrace - the worst ever US President - a man I wouldn't allow to be in the same room alone with any female for a start..............

Who said anything about you supporting Trump ? You made the assessment on me and I showed it up as a personal attack with little knowledge as I am an open Trump supporter and have been for 3 yrs. You attempting to dig at me rather than focus on the thread.

Tashengurt 25th July 2019 12:47

Anyone care to give odds on HMS Montrose being seized next?

Asturias56 25th July 2019 12:56

"As someone who has openly supported Trump since 2016 then your assessment "

led me to believe you were referring to me

If its you that supports Trump well I apologise ... and sympathize

Capt Kremmen 26th July 2019 11:06

During a relatively short trip, a thought crossed my mind. We seem to be many frigates, carriers, submarines and support vessels short of a navy. Wouldn't it therefore make sense to approach the Yanks for a repeat of the 1940/41 WW2 agreement where GB traded territory for fifty fairly rancid WW1 American destroyers ?

The trade-off - which heralded the start of the American dismemberment of the British Empire - perhaps created a useful diplomatic and commercial precedent. Introducing the Yanks to disaffected component parts of the British Isles might attract some serious equipment offers.

The Scots are always trumpeting independence. How many frigates would that be worth ? Prestigious Scottish golf venues might raise the ante to include a few doddery aircraft carriers and so on. I'm sure you get the general idea ! Fond as I am of the Isle of Wight, I would not like to lose that amenity, although if someone dangled an entire fleet I could be tempted.

SASless 26th July 2019 11:47

Sorry Mate....we booted some disaffected Brits back in the 1700's and Trump already has a very nice Golf Venue in Scotland.

melmothtw 26th July 2019 11:59


Sorry Mate....we booted some disaffected Brits back in the 1700's...
You were some disaffected Brits back in the 1700's.

pr00ne 26th July 2019 14:28

Quote:

Sorry Mate....we booted some disaffected Brits back in the 1700's...



You were some disaffected Brits back in the 1700's.



And you all still speak English...

If it wasn't for us you'd all be speaking French now.

SASless 26th July 2019 15:24

It is because of the French that we speak English if you care to check it! we do so as Americans and not Brits.

arketip 26th July 2019 15:36


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10529019)
It is because of the French that we speak English if you care to check it! we do so as Americans and not Brits.

Well, it would be more correct to say that if it wasn't for the French, you would be speaking English now

Mil-26Man 26th July 2019 15:36


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10529019)
It is because of the French that we speak English if you care to check it! we do so as Americans and not Brits.

Uh? That just makes no sense.

SASless 26th July 2019 15:58

For the not knowing of France's role in the successful outcome of the American Revolutionary War.

Short version....the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

https://www.thoughtco.com/france-ame...ry-war-1222026

ShotOne 27th July 2019 01:53

Successful for who? The French didn’t do it for your benefit! Their military support was purely a stick with which to poke the British. Much good it did them; following the revolutionary example the French king’s head was in a basket only a few years later.

Mil-26Man 27th July 2019 17:28


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10529044)
For the not knowing of France's role in the successful outcome of the American Revolutionary War.

Short version....the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

https://www.thoughtco.com/france-ame...ry-war-1222026

I know of France's role, but I don't understand how France's support specifically means Americans today speak English. If the British has won, you'd effectively be Candaians...speaking English.

Anyway, epic thread drift.

ShotOne 27th July 2019 19:23

They may have meant the French and Indian War which ended in a decisive British victory. So decisive, in fact, that the British colonists no longer had an enemy from which to need British protection. Leading to the rebellion to which Sasless referred. Yes: impressive thread drift!

Fortissimo 27th July 2019 23:47

I have it on good authority (The Donald) that the French sold the Exocets to the Americans that helped them win the War of Independence! You just can’t trust them!

Rant over...

West Coast 28th July 2019 04:36


Originally Posted by Fortissimo (Post 10530134)
I have it on good authority (The Donald) that the French sold the Exocets to the Americans that helped them win the War of Independence! You just can’t trust them!

Rant over...


Don't answer the knock at the door...

Asturias56 28th July 2019 07:37

If Leif Eriksson had been half the salesman his father was ("Greenland" indeed..............) you'd all be speaking Icelandic...............

SASless 28th July 2019 14:42

Mil.....you overlook the small fact that Canada is a Bi-Lingual Nation with all of their signage and such in both English and French.

But they shall be joining the coalition to protect UK Flagged Vessels in the Hormuz Straits area I am sure no matter past events between the UK and what is now Canada.

They and their American neighbors to the south are alike in that regard.



https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...alstopsign.jpg

BEagle 28th July 2019 16:35

SASless wrote:

Mil.....you overlook the small fact that Canada is a Bi-Lingual Nation with all of their signage and such in both English and French.
Indeed:


slack 28th July 2019 16:49


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10530615)
Mil.....you overlook the small fact that Canada is a Bi-Lingual Nation with all of their signage and such in both English and French.

But they shall be joining the coalition to protect UK Flagged Vessels in the Hormuz Straits area I am sure no matter past events between the UK and what is now Canada.

They and their American neighbors to the south are alike in that regard.



https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...alstopsign.jpg

Not really In quebeq english signs are illegal. They have language cops. The rest of Canada is about 80% English speeking.


Asturias56 28th July 2019 17:59

That sign is REALLY annoying - in France they just use STOP

pr00ne 28th July 2019 22:04

BEagle,

Brilliant!

Imagegear 29th July 2019 14:27

In the middle of the night, in Montreal, English street names are torn down and replaced with French names.

The city is well sectioned into English and French speaking suburbs, and in general the English are being squeezed out of Quebec by Quebecois nationalists.

There is no prospect of integration since the Quebecois are increasingly supporting independence from the rest of Canada. TODAY.

IG.

Asturias56 29th July 2019 14:40

My God! and there was me thinking the PQ were in favour of assimilation all these years

TBH I've never understood the PQ & friends - they have all the protections they could want in Canada - how many do they think they'll get if they're a small independent country between Anglophone Canada & the USA...........

Professor Plum 29th July 2019 15:09

Wow!

Epic thread drift!

This thread started talking about Iran, and we’re now talking about Canadian road signs.

Imagegear 29th July 2019 15:28

Apologies, thread drift is down to my bad, following the trail into the weeds of allies who are prepared to look past historical differences. However, since a considerable number of politicians at the top of the Canadian Government are of Quebecois origin, and there is more than a hint of French sympathy floating around, supporting an English initiative is less of a driver than you might think.

By the way, there is nothing small about Quebec, take a look at a world map.

Get the drift?

I'm done,

IG

,


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:20.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.