PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

unmanned_droid 14th Jan 2022 17:59

All this is doing is creating the narrative for the home nation that Russia simply had no choice but to act. I think its been decided that an invasion will happen, they're just trying to make themselves look like the good guys to the neighbours and locals.

If they do go to war in Ukraine, how will that affect the countries bordering Russia then? more or less likely to look to move away from Russia? and who's next?

NutLoose 14th Jan 2022 18:36


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11170081)
Logistics, logistics and logistics……

Forget attacking the tanks - go for the trucks and the fuel bowsers….

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidax...em-in-ukraine/

The Russian Army Depends On Civilians to Keep It Supplied. This Could Be A Problem In Ukraine.

And his bridge into the Crimea.

ORAC 15th Jan 2022 12:37

https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zon...e-disintegrate

Russia Orders Snap Drills Of Its Eastern Units As Negotiations Over Ukraine Disintegrate

The Russian military has launched a series of snap drills in the far east of the country, leading to speculation that additional forces could be being prepared to move west, closer to the border with Ukraine, where Moscow has been steadily massing troops and equipment as fears of a potential invasion of that country grow.

These military maneuvers in the far east of Russia come after talks between Russian and Western officials to address the worsening security situation ended in a stalemate. At the same time, a large-scale cyberattack targeting Ukrainian government websites has occurred.

The Russian Ministry of Defense today released footage of the snap drills in the Eastern Military District, including armored vehicles and other military equipment being loaded onto trains as part of what it described as an inspection drill to practice deploying over long distances.

“Some formations and units are being transferred to unfamiliar training grounds at a considerable distance from their points of permanent deployment,” Russia’s state-owned RIA Novosti news agency reported. “Particular attention will be paid to the possibilities of transport infrastructure for the movement of military personnel and equipment.”.....



blind pew 16th Jan 2022 07:51

Spent several hours trekking in the mountains to paraglide with a mate from Dresden…he mentioned what the Ukrainians did helping his countrymen during the war and said they deserve it..from a man who grew up under the Russians.

Recc 16th Jan 2022 08:29


Originally Posted by blind pew (Post 11170630)
Spent several hours trekking in the mountains to paraglide with a mate from Dresden…he mentioned what the Ukrainians did helping his countrymen during the war and said they deserve it..from a man who grew up under the Russians.

What a ridiculous thing to say. Only a tiny percentage of Ukrainians alive today were old enough to have taken part in WWII and of those that did, the majority fought for the red army. Your mate really thinks that indiscriminately killing their great-grandchildren is deserved? Or does he believe in the sins of the fathers? Presumably, in that case, he deserves "it" too.

squawking 7700 16th Jan 2022 11:49

As I understand it, from a Ukrainian relative, he had two 'choices' during WW2, conscription in to the German army or conscription in to to the Russian army - his words were, the German army was the lesser of two evils.

etudiant 16th Jan 2022 19:26


Originally Posted by blind pew (Post 11170630)
Spent several hours trekking in the mountains to paraglide with a mate from Dresden…he mentioned what the Ukrainians did helping his countrymen during the war and said they deserve it..from a man who grew up under the Russians.

Think one can multiply this one example by hundreds of thousands, the local history is full of hideous actions and war crimes.
That is why it is so dumb to separate Ukrainians by ethnicity, it is the same idiocy that caused the US to lose Iraq, focusing on religious affiliation rather than actual effectiveness.
Categorization just divides people who are all in one tent and who should be, in the words of the late LBJ, pi**ing out rather than getting cast a out and doing the opposite.

Asturias56 17th Jan 2022 09:06

Etudiant - are you suggesting that people should all be in one large country rather than a lot of smaller ones?

All those Canadians might disagree.

etudiant 17th Jan 2022 14:09


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11171072)
Etudiant - are you suggesting that people should all be in one large country rather than a lot of smaller ones?

All those Canadians might disagree.

Canada is a fair example of making a country work, despite huge cultural and geographic challenges to national cohesion.
Ukraine had its borders shifted west after WW2, so it has lots of minorities that need to be tied into the national consciousness. That's a tough job, did not work for Tito's successors in Yugoslavia.
It sure won't work if the minorities are treated as second class citizens, a situation that almost broke up Canada because the Francophone community felt marginalized.

henra 17th Jan 2022 14:31


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11170071)
https://english.pravda.ru/news/world...a_usa_nuclear/
I wonder what he has been sniffing? I doubt many on any side would survive, the blokes a cocking idiot.

Maybe just wiped out his Brain with too much Vodka?!
Even the dumbest id**t must be aware what >7000 Nuclear Warheads -each between 10 and 500 times the Oompf of the Hiroshima Bomb- will leave of our nice Blue Plant.

etudiant 17th Jan 2022 18:13


Originally Posted by henra (Post 11171215)
Maybe just wiped out his Brain with too much Vodka?!
Even the dumbest id**t must be aware what >7000 Nuclear Warheads -each between 10 and 500 times the Oompf of the Hiroshima Bomb- will leave of our nice Blue Plant.

Stupidity is always with us.
Surprised though that this kind of silliness: 'your rubble will bounce higher than ours:, can pass even minimal editorial review.

ORAC 17th Jan 2022 19:32

Defence Minister made a statement about providing support to Ukraine in the HoC this afternoon as flights were taking place.

Flights avoiding German airspace.


henra 18th Jan 2022 08:20


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11171303)
Stupidity is always with us.
Surprised though that this kind of silliness: 'your rubble will bounce higher than ours:, can pass even minimal editorial review.

Indeed!
4000 Warheads would be sufficient to even honor small Russian Villages individually with their personal Hiroshima Bomb.
The 400 - 450 British and French Nuclear warheads alone would be enough to wipe out all Russian cities with more than 50.000 Inhabitants with more than half of the Russian population.
This Guy should maybe do a reality check.

ORAC 18th Jan 2022 09:15

Well there’s good news and bad news.

The good news, if you go back a few posts, is that the one th8ng that Russia and the USA agreed is tha5 neither side would use nukes over any war in Europe.

The bad news is that that gets rid of the escalation ladder that was implicit in Flexible Response with battlefield nukes under battalion level control. And, whilst forces on both sides are far lower than during the Cold War, NATO forces, as revealed in war games, would be obliterated in attempt to defend the Baltic States, and possibly well beyond.

No one is asserting NATO would go to war over Kiev, but it is committed to d9 so over Tallinn, Riga and Vilnius.

Going back to the Yes Prime Minister deterrent scenario. Would the UK or France go nuclear in defence of any or all of them?

Which, of course, is why the Baltic states and Poland are so insistent they want more NATO troops deployed forward to where they would be a5 risk and provide a deterrent to attack.

Beamr 18th Jan 2022 12:11

NYT: Russia emptying its embassy in Kiev

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/17/u...v-embassy.html

NutLoose 18th Jan 2022 15:00

Nothing like folding your hand in a game of poker....They didn't object to US and UK troops defending their country at the height of the Cold War though did they..

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world...d=winp1taskbar


The German government briefed that threats to exclude Russia from the Swift system are to be dropped over fears it could destabilise international markets, according to Handelsblatt newspaper.

But the US pushed back against the claim, insisting “no option is off the table” in the event of Russian aggression.

The signs of division come amid reports Anthony Blinken, the US secretary of state, is to fly to Berlin on Thursday for urgent talks with Olaf Scholz, the German chancellor.

Annalena Baerbock, the German foreign minister, is set for talks with the Russian government in Moscow on Tuesday.

The West has threatened to block Russia from the Swift system, effectively cutting it off from international payments, if it attacks Ukraine.

ORAC 18th Jan 2022 17:32

Pretty close to the border…


Toadstool 18th Jan 2022 18:00


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11171749)

Given it’s role, the nearer the better. As long as it doesn’t cross.

ORAC 18th Jan 2022 18:30

I’d be a bit twitchy bum hoping the Russians are a bit more weapons tight with their SAM systems these days…

ORAC 19th Jan 2022 09:31

Interesting article explaining Russian motives - and possible target of an6 attack….


“….Seizing and occupying territory could be a means of raising pressure on Kyiv, but occupying terrain would not be the ultimate objective. If Russia had sought to occupy more territory, the past few weeks of public ultimatums would have been counterproductive, simply giving Ukraine and NATO more time to prepare. Some analyses have mentioned potential options to seize a land bridge between the Donbas and Crimea, an operation in Odessa, or even an attempt at occupying Western Ukraine. If the purpose is to compel Ukraine’s leadership, then a ground invasion only makes sense if it puts Ukraine in a more untenable or threatened position. Neither a land bridge nor an operation in Odessa would likely achieve that result, but an offensive towards Kyiv could.

The current posture of Russian forces points to a ground invasion towards the Ukrainian capital as a more likely option. Compared to the spring, when many of the reinforcements were sent to Crimea, Russia has now deployed a significant share of its forces, primarily the 41st Combined Arms Army, to Yelnya, to the north of Ukraine. These are in addition to the 1st Tank Army units deployed to Pogonovo, 100 miles to the northeast of Ukraine’s border. Kyiv is approximately 110 miles from the northern border with Russia, and Moscow is deploying its reinforcements in the regions where they could launch offensives from Ukraine’s northern and northeastern borders. Russia has also begun moving equipment to smaller encampments near the border in the Bryansk, Belgorod, and Kursk regions. The transfer of Russian units to Belarus for the upcoming exercise increases the threat posed along Ukraine’s northern border.

The most likely ground offensive option is that the Russian military would focus on destroying Ukrainian military units east of the Dnieper River, inflicting casualties, taking prisoners of war, destroying military equipment, and degrading defense capabilities. This could include a planned withdrawal — a punitive raid —possibly after one or two weeks. It could also involve occupying terrain outside Kyiv and threatening the capital unless Russia’s demands are met. Such an operation would more closely resemble a more aggressive version of Russia’s war in Georgia in 2008 than its annexation of Crimea. By inflicting heavy losses on the Ukrainian military, taking prisoners of war, and degrading Kyiv’s defense capabilities, Russia could potentially alter Zelensky’s incentive structure sufficiently to induce painful concessions. An additional benefit of such an operation is that it would likely be less costly and would not require Russian forces to enter cities, which would increase the risk of civilian casualties and make an insurgency more effective…..”


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:02.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.