PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   All borders to reopen. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/632861-all-borders-reopen.html)

Lezzeno 4th Jan 2021 06:42

Sunfish is correct

As for Covid19, the danger comes not from lethality but logistics.
According to the World Food Program covid lockdowns affecting the food supply chain will push an extra 60 to 70 million people to the brink of starvation. But hey at least they have been saved from the virus.

currawong 4th Jan 2021 10:49

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b4cd909848.png
Hmmm, lets see now.

What works and what does not....

Bodie1 4th Jan 2021 12:02

So what are you trying to say?

There are about 33 deaths per million cases in Australia?

So that death rate is about .000033%

If that's the case, why are there border closures? Shouldn't we be dancing in the streets? Hugging and Kissing? Because the death rate is so insignificantly small?

Potsie Weber 4th Jan 2021 12:29

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ba24e0834e.png
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....4cceeccce.jpeg

blubak 4th Jan 2021 18:39


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10959915)
the Victorian Gov is a disgrace, get yourself sorted and hire resources.

Coronavirus Australia live news: Swamped testing sites turn away thousands

COVID-19 testing sites across Melbourne closed within an hour of opening on Sunday, swamped by thousands of Victorians requiring tests after returning from NSW and further stressed by health staff taking holiday leave.

Despite the temporary closures and lack of staff, Victorian health authorities processed more tests than their NSW colleagues on Saturday — 22,477 samples compared to 18,923 — although that remains far short of the more than 40,000 daily tests undertaken at the height of the second coronavirus wave.

By 9.30am on Sunday, the Department of Health and Human Services listed drive-through sites in Darebin, Keysborough and West Footscray as “over capacity, no further accepted”. Cars were also turned away from the Melbourne Sports and Aquatic Centre in Albert Park, which was listed as a three-hour wait, and sites in Chadstone, St Albans and Broadmeadows had waiting times of more than two hours.But Jeroen Weimar, who is co-ordinating Victoria’s COVID-19 response, defended the long waiting times for testing.

“There was a 35 per cent uplift in the total number of tests delivered in the south and southeastern suburbs yesterday compared to the day before so we are getting the numbers through,” he said. “Our frontline staff have been working phenomenally hard for that entire period and we have seen a significant number of people rightly take some well-*deserved leave as we see across the wider sector, so we have had to gear up and mobilise,” he said.

“The choice we faced before Christmas was, do you hold people over and not let them go on leave after absolutely flogging themselves for nine months (or) do you say, ‘no, you have to stand around the testing stations on the off chance’ … we took a view that we needed to have the right balance of resources.”

The DHHS has identified a number of new exposure sites, with the number of infections in the state reaching 50.

New locations on Sunday included Brighton Beach on December 29 between midday and 3pm, Angus and Cootes Jeweller at Southland Shopping Centre on December 28 between 2.30pm and 2.50pm and the Costco Moorabbin on December 30 between 4pm and 5.50pm.

Queensland Chief Health Officer Jeannette Young said there would not be any border restriction on Melbourne or Victoria “at this stage”. “But we’re keeping a very, very close eye on that,” she said on Sunday, after Victoria reported three new local cases.

Another Melbourne location, Grape & Grain in Moorabbin, which had yet to appear in DHHS warnings, said it would remain closed after staff tested positive.

The DHHS plans to boost testing capacity by extending hours, recalling staff, bringing on board agency staff and opening more pop-up and drive-through sites.

The Victorian branch of the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation posted a message on Facebook seeking “urgent support” from nurses and midwives to work in testing sites across the state on behalf of Torrens Health and the health department: “Shift lengths will vary from between six and 10 hours; travel and meal allowances are available in some circumstances.”

“I think 60,000 people made the right decision … to come back; I am confident the vast majority will follow through and say, right, I need to make sure I get tested because I don’t want to put myself at risk,” Mr Weimar said.

There were 32000+ tests in vic on sunday,in reality how many do you think they should be able to do & how many testers the govt should have on standby in case there is an outbreak?
I am not being smart but really curious as to how they should do it in your opinion.
I dont know if you agree with the small time frame given re the border closing but for the amount of people really angry at how quick it happened there are just as many slamming the govt for not closing it as soon as the sydney outbreak happened.
Im not suggesting the vic govt is perfect by any means but to me i believe they are doing a fairly good job right now however i may be just plain silly for doing so!

Ladloy 4th Jan 2021 18:55


Originally Posted by Bodie1 (Post 10960341)
So what are you trying to say?

There are about 33 deaths per million cases in Australia?

So that death rate is about .000033%

If that's the case, why are there border closures? Shouldn't we be dancing in the streets? Hugging and Kissing? Because the death rate is so insignificantly small?

He's saying border closures work and if we don't limit movement during outbreaks our death rate will follow Sweden, US and UK

Ragnor 4th Jan 2021 19:22

NSW were able to test over 50,000 a week without missing a beat. They were not expecting those numbers they were as always prepared. I still don’t understand why Vic, QLD and other states are not prepared.

blubak 4th Jan 2021 19:35


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960595)
NSW were able to test over 50,000 a week without missing a beat. They were not expecting those numbers they were as always prepared. I still don’t understand why Vic, QLD and other states are not prepared.

50000 a week is a bit different to 32000 in 1 day.

Ragnor 4th Jan 2021 19:40

Are you that much of an idiot? They were averaging over 50,000 a day did over 60,000 in one day Xmas eve.

Ladloy 4th Jan 2021 19:48


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960609)
Are you that much of an idiot? They were averaging over 50,000 a day did over 60,000 in one day Xmas eve.

You didn't say that, you said 50k a week.

Ragnor 4th Jan 2021 20:13

I know, but he/she could not recognise a typo was made. Guess that’s why Vic is in such a mess.

WhisprSYD 4th Jan 2021 20:20


Originally Posted by blubak (Post 10960608)
50000 a week is a bit different to 32000 in 1 day.

obviously it was a mis-type on his behalf with NSW testing 60,000-70,000 a day over Xmas

blubak 4th Jan 2021 20:20


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960621)
I know, but he/she could not recognise a typo was made. Guess that’s why Vic is in such a mess.

The average testing numbers in nsw are 22000 a DAY right now,they want it to go to 50000.
Vic in a mess,ok sounds like you know everything & have all the answers,you should be pm.

blubak 4th Jan 2021 20:25


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960621)
I know, but he/she could not recognise a typo was made. Guess that’s why Vic is in such a mess.

Guess another 32000+ tests in vic yesterday is not a good number,even if it was 132000 it would not be enough for you.

WingNut60 4th Jan 2021 20:40


Originally Posted by blubak (Post 10960625)
Guess another 32000+ tests in vic yesterday is not a good number,even if it was 132000 it would not be enough for you.

Yep. The correct number is whatever NSW does. Always.
Never mind that in the early stages of the Northern Beaches F/U the queues were just as long, if not longer, with Oz-wide coverage of nasal whining from occupants of vehicles complaining that they'd been in the queue for 5 - 7 hours with no food or access to toilet facilities.
But that is "gold standard" Covid control policy, apparently. Impeccable planning. The world's best.

Ragnor 4th Jan 2021 21:09

That is a good number credit when credit is due hopefully Sydney matches it.

I said NSW has had long lines never said they were quick, northern beaches line up were long and my hat goes off to those residents the did a brilliant job sticking it out but NSW never turned anyone away due to having to shut up shop at 21:30. They got the job done.

Let’s not forget how this outbreak in Avalon and Western Sydney started in December the giant hole in this is international arrivals.

novice110 4th Jan 2021 21:47

The more testing that goes on the better it is, yes.

Is there really much difference though between 20k and 90k out of 5 million people ?

Bodie1 5th Jan 2021 02:26


He's saying border closures work and if we don't limit movement during outbreaks our death rate will follow Sweden, US and UK
Oh my gawd.........that graph proves that lockdowns work? :} So you're using Chairman Dan or Sunfish evidence now?

It must be Sunfish evidence because only a moron would present such stupidity as evidence.

De_flieger 5th Jan 2021 03:30


Originally Posted by Bodie1 (Post 10960341)
So what are you trying to say?

There are about 33 deaths per million cases in Australia?

So that death rate is about .000033%

You shouldn’t be criticising the statistics presented by others when you get your own so egregiously wrong. There have been 909 deaths in Australia from covid-19 as of todays date, so if there were 33 per million cases as you state, that would imply Australia had approx 27.5 million cases of covid-19 - that every single person in Australia had been infected, which is clearly not the case. There have been 909 deaths and 28504 cases as of today, giving a death rate of 3.18% of confirmed infections. Entirely different to your statement, which is off by a factor of around 100,000.

thisishardtochoose 5th Jan 2021 03:48

Well people on this thread should be happy, Qantas started taking bookings for International Travel July onwards, AJ must know something the general public doesn't

Buster Hyman 5th Jan 2021 03:49

The state of this thread. :rolleyes:

Turnleft080 5th Jan 2021 04:01


Originally Posted by De_flieger (Post 10960791)
You shouldn’t be criticising the statistics presented by others when you get your own so egregiously wrong. There have been 909 deaths in Australia from covid-19 as of todays date, so if there were 33 per million cases as you state, that would imply Australia had approx 27.5 million cases of covid-19 - that every single person in Australia had been infected, which is clearly not the case. There have been 909 deaths and 28504 cases as of today, giving a death rate of 3.18% of confirmed infections. Entirely different to your statement, which is off by a factor of around 100,000.

The only alteration I would change in your paragraph is, with covid-19 not from covid-19.

601 5th Jan 2021 04:14


with covid-19 not from covid-19.
Correct. I would like to know the numbers who have died FROM Covid-19 not with it.
A lot older blokes die with prostate cancer not from it.
There is a difference. I have not seen an explanation as to why testing positive with Covid would automatically infer that you died from Covid.

andrewr 5th Jan 2021 04:34


Originally Posted by Bodie1 (Post 10960026)
At no stage prior were Victorians warned that if they leave the state they may be subject to this type of action.

There were very clear warnings on the 20th December or earlier that:
  • The situation in NSW was unpredictable
  • The red zone was likely to expand
  • If you travel to NSW there was a risk you would not be able to return home.
Many people ignored the warnings, but the idea that there were no warnings is false.

Ragnor 5th Jan 2021 04:34

Well the last Covid-19 death in NSW in the last week or so they put it down to Covid as the gentleman had it in March. So that would mean if you die from any respiratory illness moving forward it could be a covid death.

blubak 5th Jan 2021 05:43


Originally Posted by andrewr (Post 10960810)
There were very clear warnings on the 20th December or earlier that:
  • The situation in NSW was unpredictable
  • The red zone was likely to expand
  • If you travel to NSW there was a risk you would not be able to return home.
Many people ignored the warnings, but the idea that there were no warnings is false.

100% correct,people were advised against going to nsw.
If the choice is made to go well so be it,if the circumstances or the risk changes well also so be it but if you take a risk well often the consequences are not what you expect.
Of course its very hard on the affected people but like i mentioned in a previous post there are lots of people still criticising the government now for not closing the border quickly enough so as always everyone cant be pleased.

1A_Please 5th Jan 2021 05:48


Originally Posted by andrewr (Post 10960810)
There were very clear warnings on the 20th December or earlier that:
  • The situation in NSW was unpredictable
  • The red zone was likely to expand
  • If you travel to NSW there was a risk you would not be able to return home.
Many people ignored the warnings, but the idea that there were no warnings is false.

Many people were in NSW seeing friends and family they had not seen all year. They were in green zones that, even now, remain Covid-free. The Victorian government's panicked actions were just another of their stuff-ups which continued today with the bizarre announcement that residents can return from Qld by road as long as they do a mad cannonball run across NSW only stopping twice for no more than 15 minutes. Good luck with that if you have kids. I wonder what the TAC thinks of this advice given it directly contradicts what they have been advertising for years!!!

Sunfish 5th Jan 2021 06:26

1A and others, you just don't get it. This is war.

War is basically a learning situation where the side that learns and reacts fastest to new developments overpowers and destroys the opposition. This truism is encapsulated in the saying "no battle plan survives first contact with the enemy" (Helmuth Karl Bernhard von Moltke the elder).

So yes, !A,, they were in the green zone, etc. but the plan changed. Think quick! It's going to change again and again. The only constant is change.

Ever heard the old army slogan "hurry up and wait?"

Ragnor 5th Jan 2021 06:27

Who comes up with these insane rules. Drive from QLD to VIC two stops 15 minutes what about singles do they not matter? Truck drivers can not do that much driving. Hopefully ppl do not attempt this ridiculous feat wouldn’t want to have any road accidents because of it or even worse they crash into someone else. Just another Dan Andrew’s f$&k up.

Buster Hyman 5th Jan 2021 06:31


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960841)
Who comes up with these insane rules. Drive from QLD to VIC two stops 15 minutes what about singles do they not matter? Truck drivers can not do that much driving. Hopefully ppl do not attempt this ridiculous feat wouldn’t want to have any road accidents because of it or even worse they crash into someone else. Just another Dan Andrew’s f$&k up.

Good point. If your kids are thinking of a lucrative career, get them into Law. This will be the Motherload of litigation!!

601 5th Jan 2021 06:47


Many people ignored the warnings, but the idea that there were no warnings is false.
There are lots of places around the world that I would not travel to before Covid even though the official travel advice was OK.
I have now added NSW and VIC to that list.
Yes I do have relation and friends in those states.

I am part of a travelling group who are looking at our next group holiday. This year is supposed to be out next big trip. However, we have decided that this time it will be within the confines of Qld.



Ragnor 5th Jan 2021 07:18

That is your choice. There are 1000s who think different to you.

The UK and US must be pissing them self at us. I thought I was Australian not sure what we are called now. 7 cases today and it’s a state of emergency one premier having their constituents do an insane feat to get home another two premiers well one and a deputy having a war of words. I’ve lived in various parts of the world and always been defensive of Australia and how good it is to others. Never in my wildest dream I would know all the premiers names their back grounds and be so defensive about the state I live in.

SOPS 5th Jan 2021 07:39


Originally Posted by Ragnor (Post 10960868)
That is your choice. There are 1000s who think different to you.

The UK and US must be pissing them self at us. I thought I was Australian not sure what we are called now. 7 cases today and it’s a state of emergency one premier having their constituents do an insane feat to get home another two premiers well one and a deputy having a war of words. I’ve lived in various parts of the world and always been defensive of Australia and how good it is to others. Never in my wildest dream I would know all the premiers names their back grounds and be so defensive about the state I live in.

I think the US and UK are pissing themselves..but not at us. The UK is reportedly days away from their hospital system being unable to cope.

https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/amp....ticle/13031334

kingRB 5th Jan 2021 08:12


Originally Posted by Sunfish (Post 10960840)
1A and others, you just don't get it. This is war.

War is basically a learning situation where the side that learns and reacts fastest to new developments overpowers and destroys the opposition. This truism is encapsulated in the saying "no battle plan survives first contact with the enemy" (Helmuth Karl Bernhard von Moltke the elder).

So yes, !A,, they were in the green zone, etc. but the plan changed. Think quick! It's going to change again and again. The only constant is change.

Ever heard the old army slogan "hurry up and wait?"

you misspelled Government incompetence. Nice try though.

IWannaFly2020 5th Jan 2021 08:14

Why doesn’t all quarantine go to Howard Springs NT?? Isolated, run by the government. No city/urban interaction risk. QF could base 2-3 787’s there and reach 90% of requests. Crew stay in own dedicated hotel with facilities. Situation over. Fed government should take over the issue. Stand up SCOMO.

currawong 5th Jan 2021 08:38


Originally Posted by Bodie1 (Post 10960771)
Oh my gawd.........that graph proves that lockdowns work? :} So you're using Chairman Dan or Sunfish evidence now?

It must be Sunfish evidence because only a moron would present such stupidity as evidence.

I presented the graph, Bodie.

With no opinion attached, just data that people can draw their own conclusions from.

For which you call me a moron.

Nice one champ. Take a long hard look at yourself.

Aussie Bob 5th Jan 2021 08:43

I am so sad, but I think all you folk on this forum who favour these "border closures" and other draconian measures implemented buy clueless politicians should take a long hard look in the mirror. What you will see is a fearful deluded and disturbed individual unable to accept personal responsibility. How you ever made it to a PIC position eludes me. This flu has a 99.9% survival rate amongst the healthy (have you got a class 1?). The measures you support cause more harm than good.

Sorry, but with respect, that's what I think.

wheels_down 5th Jan 2021 08:43


Originally Posted by IWannaFly2020 (Post 10960894)
Why doesn’t all quarantine go to Howard Springs NT?? Isolated, run by the government. No city/urban interaction risk. QF could base 2-3 787’s there and reach 90% of requests. Crew stay in own dedicated hotel with facilities. Situation over. Fed government should take over the issue. Stand up SCOMO.

The other carriers have said they are not flying here if that’s the only option. Air Freight corridors do need to remain open and QR/EK/SQ/CX are lifting huge volumes in and out at the moment underneath.

We can’t forgo air freight. UPS/DHL/Fedex are stretched at the moment.

Most are pretty full outbound currently. CZ are filling a 380 out of a Melbourne daily.

De_flieger 5th Jan 2021 08:51


Originally Posted by SOPS (Post 10960874)
I think the US and UK are pissing themselves..but not at us. The UK is reportedly days away from their hospital system being unable to cope.

https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/amp....ticle/13031334

Yep. And Los Angeles has changed their criteria for transporting patients to hospital in the last 24 hours or so. Paramedics have been ordered that some of the most critically ill patients that would previously undergo resuscitation attempts and transport to hospital, instead are to be pronounced dead in the field, to free up hospital resources. They've also changed the criteria for oxygen administration, reducing the circumstances and amounts for administration due to the shortage of oxygen/administration supplies and bottles, and are building emergency treatment rooms in carparks. Los Angeles issues brutal letter: do not treat dying patients
They've got some pretty big problems in the UK and USA, I doubt they are looking at Victoria or NSW and saying "wow, with 8 or 10 cases today those guys have really screwed up". Or even looking at them at all.

SOPS 5th Jan 2021 08:56


Originally Posted by Aussie Bob (Post 10960909)
I am so sad, but I think all you folk on this forum who favour these "border closures" and other draconian measures implemented buy clueless politicians should take a long hard look in the mirror. What you will see is a fearful deluded and disturbed individual unable to accept personal responsibility. How you ever made it to a PIC position eludes me. This flu has a 99.9% survival rate amongst the healthy (have you got a class 1?). The measures you support cause more harm than good.

Sorry, but with respect, that's what I think.


It is not the flu

https://www.news.com.au/world/north-...010c605d45a221


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:25.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.