All borders to reopen.
I'm amazed at how some of you guys interpret the written word, If it makes any difference about percentages, we in WA already have about 70% registered for their jab and no hope in hell of getting all of us that wants it, jabbed with two doses this year. We will continue to maintain zero covid until they are, then the health system has to be ready for rising cases, before any discussion will be entered into regarding open borders date. I can't make it any clearer than that.
If the WA health system can't handle a few thousand cases, with maybe 5% of those in hospital, you've got bigger problems than Covid...Though, if reports of WA hospitals having to ramp ambulances for many hours at a time are indeed accurate, then maybe you do!
Originally Posted by Xeptu
Sounds like those outside WA are reading rubbish.
Originally Posted by PerthNow
The Premier said that despite National Cabinet agreeing that Australia would open up when an 80 per cent vaccination rate was achieved, he would retain a zero COVID policy and not tolerate any cases or deaths in WA. Source
Last I checked, Zero Covid was not mentioned anywhere in the Doherty modelling or the 4-stage roadmap - and present evidence of multiple overseas jurisdictions demonstrates it is an unattainable goal, no matter your Countries' vaccination level! That being the case, for how long are Australian Citizens expected to be denied their constitutional right to travel to WA without being penalised because of the state in which they live?
Nunc est bibendum
The muppet can keep the ‘hard border’ up for as long as wants. Once everyone else opens up to each other and Covid is everywhere there will be no stopping it from entering WA. There are 100s of truck drivers crossing the border everyday and numerous Facebook pages with hints and tips on how to get into WA undetected (plenty of bush tracks).
The muppet can keep the ‘hard border’ up for as long as wants. Once everyone else opens up to each other and Covid is everywhere there will be no stopping it from entering WA. There are 100s of truck drivers crossing the border everyday and numerous Facebook pages with hints and tips on how to get into WA undetected (plenty of bush tracks).
That being the case, for how long are Australian Citizens expected to be denied their constitutional right to travel to WA without being penalised because of the state in which they live?
That's why the protesters are double morons, if they create civil disorder they give the state further power to restrict movement.
Join Date: Sep 1998
Location: The Swan Downunder
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
10 Posts
We know it will come into the state, we know we will have to live with it, we must maintain zero until the state is ready, it won't be this year. The Premier is entitled to stick it up the liberals any way he likes, it won't change the plan.
Join Date: Sep 1998
Location: The Swan Downunder
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
10 Posts
As long as the WA government can prove there is a threat to public health restriction of movement is perfectly legal. If you can prove otherwise you can force them to allow freedom of movement. International law on human rights and our constitution allows restriction of movement for public health, public order or to protect others rights. No point quoting constitutional rights if they don't apply in current circumstance. It does not even have to be a public health emergency, that just makes the case stronger for the rules.
A state of emergency must be declared, it's not forever and we don't want it to be forever, nor will it be.
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Australia
Posts: 328
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
you don’t need to be clear. You will have as much say in what happens with the borders as I do.
The Premier said that despite National Cabinet agreeing that Australia would open up when an 80 per cent vaccination rate was achieved, he would retain a zero COVID policy and not tolerate any cases or deaths in WA. Source
“If you imagine we get to 80 per cent vaccination, and Aboriginal communities, remote communities, some country towns are at much lower levels, we may have to lock those down at some point in time for whatever reason – I think that makes total sense and that was what was agreed,” Mr McGowan said.
“I’m just keen to have minimal or no COVID”
So a lot of nuance and media putting their own spin on quotes - not a “zero Covid policy and No cases or deaths”, just “keen to have minimal or no Covid”.
Not full lockdowns at 80%, targeted lockdowns for specific areas like indigenous communities.
And nowhere had the cabinet agreed to a plan where Australia “opens up” at 80%, we move to Phase C at 80% which still involves some restrictions, Phase D is more open but still there’s some countermeasures.
Everything isn’t going back to normal the day we hit 80%, it’ll be better but it’ll also be gradual and phased.
Join Date: Sep 1998
Location: The Swan Downunder
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
10 Posts
Here’s an example of where the media twists a quote to get a headline where the real quote wasn’t exactly what was said:
“If you imagine we get to 80 per cent vaccination, and Aboriginal communities, remote communities, some country towns are at much lower levels, we may have to lock those down at some point in time for whatever reason – I think that makes total sense and that was what was agreed,” Mr McGowan said.
“I’m just keen to have minimal or no COVID”
So a lot of nuance and media putting their own spin on quotes - not a “zero Covid policy and No cases or deaths”, just “keen to have minimal or no Covid”.
Not full lockdowns at 80%, targeted lockdowns for specific areas like indigenous communities.
And nowhere had the cabinet agreed to a plan where Australia “opens up” at 80%, we move to Phase C at 80% which still involves some restrictions, Phase D is more open but still there’s some countermeasures.
Everything isn’t going back to normal the day we hit 80%, it’ll be better but it’ll also be gradual and phased.
“If you imagine we get to 80 per cent vaccination, and Aboriginal communities, remote communities, some country towns are at much lower levels, we may have to lock those down at some point in time for whatever reason – I think that makes total sense and that was what was agreed,” Mr McGowan said.
“I’m just keen to have minimal or no COVID”
So a lot of nuance and media putting their own spin on quotes - not a “zero Covid policy and No cases or deaths”, just “keen to have minimal or no Covid”.
Not full lockdowns at 80%, targeted lockdowns for specific areas like indigenous communities.
And nowhere had the cabinet agreed to a plan where Australia “opens up” at 80%, we move to Phase C at 80% which still involves some restrictions, Phase D is more open but still there’s some countermeasures.
Everything isn’t going back to normal the day we hit 80%, it’ll be better but it’ll also be gradual and phased.
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Perth, WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Age: 71
Posts: 875
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
McGowan is also quoted saying:
What other conclusion are people supposed to make from that?
"Our preferred option is zero COVID obviously and that's what we'll attempt to do,"
Mr McGowan on Sunday said WA's "preferred option is zero COVID-19" and he would not tolerate any cases or deaths in his state.
"We don't want to have deaths and we don't want to have spread of the virus, but there can be some easing of some of the rules," he told Sky News Australia.
"We don't want to have deaths and we don't want to have spread of the virus, but there can be some easing of some of the rules," he told Sky News Australia.
What other conclusion are people supposed to make from that?
Last edited by ExtraShot; 25th Aug 2021 at 11:32.
Originally Posted by dr dre
“I’m just keen to have minimal or no COVID”
Isn't "No Covid" (Your words...) the same as "Zero Covid"?
Originally Posted by The West
Mark McGowan says his “preferred position is that we don’t have COVID” He said the lockdown of NSW showed it’s “better not to have COVID” and he would only abandon borders and lockdowns as virus suppression weapons when Australia reaches the last phase of National Cabinet’s four-step plan out of the pandemic.
"Obviously, if we get cases in here certainly we will have to deal with it but we're doing everything we can to keep it out."
“(Zero COVID) is now the accepted position,. People will criticise, I just want to say, ‘Look at our life, look at all this’. People out having lunch, having fun, people at work, the office blocks have got the highest staffing levels back of anywhere in Australia, our schools are operating, our economy is going the strongest in Australia of anywhere in the world — isn’t a good thing?Source
"Obviously, if we get cases in here certainly we will have to deal with it but we're doing everything we can to keep it out."
“(Zero COVID) is now the accepted position,. People will criticise, I just want to say, ‘Look at our life, look at all this’. People out having lunch, having fun, people at work, the office blocks have got the highest staffing levels back of anywhere in Australia, our schools are operating, our economy is going the strongest in Australia of anywhere in the world — isn’t a good thing?Source
He conveniently forgets to mention that NSW handles the majority of both, yet seems content for everyone to reap the benefits of it...
Join Date: Sep 1998
Location: The Swan Downunder
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
10 Posts
I think people are just frustrated with the whole Covid issue and want it to be over. I think everyone will pull their heads in as NSW deteriorates and has the entire nations undivided attention.
Correct - as the agreement allows.
Actually at Phase C, post 80% vaccination it says:"Exempt vaccinated residents from all domestic restrictions..." - happy to be corrected but I assumed this meant domestic travel restrictions.
Reading far too much into it it could even be a comment about the “Disease” of Covid-19, rather than case numbers of the virus. And having “minimal” Covid may mean minimising the amount of disease affecting the health system. But I think that’s reading too much into it and honestly at this stage we’re reading too much into any comments about what’s going to happen post Phase A.
"Obviously, if we get cases in here certainly we will have to deal with it but we're doing everything we can to keep it out."
“(Zero COVID) is now the accepted position,
“(Zero COVID) is now the accepted position,
There’s some info out there saying that going from Phase C to D would only be a matter of weeks.
and there’s the problem. The fool is so focussed on political posturing. If federal labor were in, there’s no way he’d be such a recalcitrant prick. Each way albo even says he supports the reopening plan. Mcgoose will just change the ‘best health advice’ to suit his political agenda.
you don’t need to be clear. You will have as much say in what happens with the borders as I do.
you don’t need to be clear. You will have as much say in what happens with the borders as I do.
