PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

Tartiflette Fan 23rd Mar 2023 12:32

Seaborne attack on Sebastopol
 

The above is from Denys Davydov, a civilian pilot who is blogging most days on the war The first seven minutes concern the seaborne drone attack with more video than already shown on here: Denys is a native of Sevastopol, so he can add intelligent guesswork - and background material - on which major ship may have been hit. A good channel to drop in on - lots of detail particularly on all movements on the front-line ( 15 mins on if interested ).

NutLoose 23rd Mar 2023 12:34

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fp63mH6W...jpg&name=largeRemember this?


https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....5f4ca7935e.png

Look at it now..


https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a29213f3e2.png


https://www.dezeen.com/2023/02/28/ba...p-ukraine-war/

Sfojimbo 23rd Mar 2023 12:47


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11407229)
Another reason is that it’s much easier to get new builds through Congress...........

But would taking them out of the reserve fleet even been an issue? Here's 2,000 of them sitting in the sun: 40°12'9.01"N 120° 8'54.50"W (Wikipedia says that there's a total of 20,000 armored vehicles there).

The US military's response to Ukraine's need for armor remains incomprehensible to me. Why would the US, which has given or pledged over 100 billion dollars to Ukraine, be so chintzy about giving armor to Ukraine? It defies logic. This stuff has no reason to be rusting in the California outback, everything that is salvageable should be given to Ukraine, Poland and the Baltics etc.

I don't believe this 'secret armor' line, we know that much of it includes a layer of DU, and a layer or layers of the British Chobham or Dorchester pottery (or its US equivalent). Big deal, maybe they have arranged it so it's 3% or 7% more effective than the Challengers or the Leopards, but that's a big nothing when you compare even an Abraham's M1, rev 1 to a T-72 or whatever the Russians are scraping up for their army. The 'secret armor' argument is pure hokum.

Why aren't we giving Ukraine all our old Stryker vehicles? We're parking over 4,000 of them; why aren't they being shipped to Eastern Europe where they're needed? Why are we only sending 60 Bradleys to Ukraine, we should be sending 600 of them.

None of this makes any sense at all.

NutLoose 23rd Mar 2023 12:55

Says it all really.


Approach to Bahkmut


Tartiflette Fan 23rd Mar 2023 13:44


Originally Posted by Sfojimbo (Post 11407259)

The US military's response to Ukraine's need for armor remains incomprehensible to me. Why would the US, which has given or pledged over 100 billion dollars to Ukraine, be so chintzy about giving armor to Ukraine? It defies logic. This stuff has no reason to be rusting in the California outback, everything that is salvageable should be given to Ukraine, Poland and the Baltics etc.

.

Pretty certain that's wrong. That is about 12% of the military budget and I remember from an earlier post listing lots of detail per country that the aid is at the 4-5% level.

EDIT: Since January 2021, the United States has invested more than $33.2 billion in security assistance to demonstrate our enduring and steadfast commitment to Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity.

https://www.state.gov/u-s-security-c...al%20integrity.

Sfojimbo 23rd Mar 2023 13:50


Originally Posted by Tartiflette Fan (Post 11407302)
Pretty certain that's wrong. That is about 12% of the military budget and I remember from an earlier post listing lots of detail per country that the aid is at the 4-5% level.

Here's a site that gives a 75 billion number.

Since the war began, the Biden administration and the U.S. Congress have directed more than $75 billion
https://www.cfr.org/article/how-much...are-six-charts
I have seen a site that said the US had pledged $112 billion but I'm not going to waste time tracking it down again.

This is just quibbling about numbers and misses the point of my post.
The point is that the US has invested a huge sum in Ukraine but is being chintzy about donating what is essentially scrap iron.

Pali 23rd Mar 2023 14:57

Slovak Minister of defence J. Naď announced that first 4 Migs were safely delivered to Ukraine.


https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....62cf469c9.jpeg

NutLoose 23rd Mar 2023 17:45

Well Boris… that nobody, and Zelensky may be closet gays according to the latest propogansh*t, talk about scrapping the bottom…..erm, of the barrel…

​​​​​​​

B Fraser 23rd Mar 2023 17:51

Wow.........just wow.

VIDEO | In daylight and among their own. Zelenskyy, who went to coffee at the gas station with the soldiers, once again showed Putin how to make propaganda - Delfi

NutLoose 23rd Mar 2023 18:03

Interesting that Solovyov is talking about hoping China as part of the Russian Chinese “strategic partnership" will get US Nukes removed from the likes of Turkey. That is tantamount to admitting Russia is now subservient to China in this new relationship and Russia has lost its standing it had pre war.

​​​​​​​

Pali 23rd Mar 2023 18:49

Ukrainian pilots took over our Migs (probably the only serviceable) at AFB Sliač and headed home. Good hunting, brothers.
Footage provided by our DoD.


melmothtw 23rd Mar 2023 18:53


Originally Posted by Pali (Post 11407480)
Ukrainian pilots took over our Migs (probably the only serviceable) at AFB Sliač and headed home. Good hunting, brothers.
Footage provided by our DoD.

https://twitter.com/bayraktar_1love/...69512568696833

Do we know they are Ukrainian pilots? Genuine question - I can't find that reference in the link.

Sfojimbo 23rd Mar 2023 18:57


Originally Posted by Pali (Post 11407480)
Ukrainian pilots took over our Migs (probably the only serviceable) at AFB Sliač and headed home. Good hunting, brothers.

Are these planes upgraded to a NATO standard?
Many months ago that was supposedly an issue with the Polish MIG-29s.

Wokkafans 23rd Mar 2023 23:45

​​​​​​​

Wokkafans 23rd Mar 2023 23:52

​​​​​​​

Wokkafans 23rd Mar 2023 23:53

​​​​​​​

NutLoose 24th Mar 2023 00:23

Wow….

NutLoose 24th Mar 2023 01:43

Interesting focus on some things that Ukraine needs to address.


To counter evolving tactics used by Russia and Wagner, troops require resources such as drones, radios and internet, night sights, 60mm mortars, grenades and grenade launchers for platoons, a full 81/82mm mortar company for each battalion, short-range missiles, AFAKs, uniform and safety equipment for every soldier. It is essential to prioritize discussions about these "enablers" in Ramstein meetings, not just larger equipment.

- Policy changes are necessary to modernize the military system, which still relies on outdated Soviet-style rules, and regulations. For example, drones purchased abroad needed a signature for release from MOD to the unit that purchased them. This was not done for 4 weeks. This delay means that soldiers die from a lack of drones. Activities like this should have a turnaround time of 12 hours maximum

- A new policy of creating mobile training teams near the front to update units out of battle with the latest lessons learned should be considered. It's wise to use those who have been injured in the war and cannot fight.

​​​​​​​
​​​​​​​

T28B 24th Mar 2023 01:52


Originally Posted by Baldeep Inminj (Post 11407695)
My posts have all just disappeared- every one of them. I did not remove them.

You are correct. It unfortunately turned into a bickerfest that added no value to the topic at hand. The FOD was removed from the runway.

Anyone doubt that I am telling the truth that the US want to prolong the conflict?
You've stated your opinion, you've received feedback ... and you want to try again?
Right, TOGA button pushed, trying for a stabilized approach.

Notice to all: play the ball not the man, or the FOD sweeper will come again.

How about all of you put the first P back into PPRuNe: Professional.

NutLoose 24th Mar 2023 02:28

Brave woman, those still resisting.. one hope she is freed.



All times are GMT. The time now is 22:31.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.