BALPA and BA talks breakdown
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Singapore
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Most people these days think Luddite is short hand for obstructive labour objecting to innovative ways to improve productivity. To those who say productivity will not increase then why do BA want to do this?
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: London
Age: 81
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I believe I bothered to post (when I've never bothered to post before although I've been a long time lurker mostly for the humour!) because I have been (about 10 years ago) in a position similar to the one that BACC find themselves in now.
My colleagues and I (I'm talking about a sector of the financial services industry - not the airline industry) were faced with outsouring and a threat (as we saw it) to our future terms and conditions. I can't tell you how much I hated the employer at that time (I still feel bitterness now if I'm honest) and we were fully engaged with our union (a company endorsed section of the TUC) in trying to ensure that the proposed changes were withdrawn.
Suffice to say that our small victory was a pyrrhic one - we didn't get to strike as the management agreed so some (not all) demands. I ended up redundant just under 3 years later as did many of my colleagues (it wasn't lost on us exactly WHO was made redundant)
I suppose I see reflections of that time in the tone and bitterness of many of the posts here. I don't know if I would do anything differently if I had the time again (perhaps I would have sought alternative emploment earlier?) but I do know that after my own experience I would simply ask anyone is the service sector (which can be so easily outsourced) to think long and hard about what life is like post strike. You may feel bad now but what about after a strike? What if, a year from now EU legislation makes what BA want to do perfectly legal and acceptable - what will your strike achieve?
This is an honest question for anyone here - if you do strike, do you expect BA to capitulate? If so, what happens then? I believe they could simply adapt their proposals and get what they want at a later date (rather like the re-appearance of the EU 'treaty' which looks and smells like the old one but apparently isn't...
)
I do NOT have any affiliations with BA or BAA or any airline (apart from owning a silver BAEC card). But I am interested in labour relations and transport in general...
My colleagues and I (I'm talking about a sector of the financial services industry - not the airline industry) were faced with outsouring and a threat (as we saw it) to our future terms and conditions. I can't tell you how much I hated the employer at that time (I still feel bitterness now if I'm honest) and we were fully engaged with our union (a company endorsed section of the TUC) in trying to ensure that the proposed changes were withdrawn.
Suffice to say that our small victory was a pyrrhic one - we didn't get to strike as the management agreed so some (not all) demands. I ended up redundant just under 3 years later as did many of my colleagues (it wasn't lost on us exactly WHO was made redundant)
I suppose I see reflections of that time in the tone and bitterness of many of the posts here. I don't know if I would do anything differently if I had the time again (perhaps I would have sought alternative emploment earlier?) but I do know that after my own experience I would simply ask anyone is the service sector (which can be so easily outsourced) to think long and hard about what life is like post strike. You may feel bad now but what about after a strike? What if, a year from now EU legislation makes what BA want to do perfectly legal and acceptable - what will your strike achieve?
This is an honest question for anyone here - if you do strike, do you expect BA to capitulate? If so, what happens then? I believe they could simply adapt their proposals and get what they want at a later date (rather like the re-appearance of the EU 'treaty' which looks and smells like the old one but apparently isn't...
)I do NOT have any affiliations with BA or BAA or any airline (apart from owning a silver BAEC card). But I am interested in labour relations and transport in general...
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: London
Posts: 1,907
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I take no position on either side of the argument, all I would say is that both sides need to step back and think of the end user of the product, the customer.
He has a choice of airlines, a customer lost sometimes never returns. A lost customer means a lower profit, a lower profit leads to loss of jobs.
He has a choice of airlines, a customer lost sometimes never returns. A lost customer means a lower profit, a lower profit leads to loss of jobs.
Join Date: May 2003
Location: uk
Posts: 713
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am all for the BA pilots going on strike. Cabin crew as well. May be then a sh*t airline will go out of business at long last opening the way for other carriers to move in and take over. They cannot be any worse.
I am with the pilots. I hate BA too.
I am with the pilots. I hate BA too.
Guest
Posts: n/a
So the mainline pilots want the 'open skies' pilots on the seniority list. And BA management don't.
Is that really worth striking about?
From my point of view, I guess that management must think so- otherwise they'd simply agree to the mainline pilots' demand and the threat of industrial action would recede.
The fact that they refuse to allow the OS pilots on the list proves they're up to something.
Is that really worth striking about?
From my point of view, I guess that management must think so- otherwise they'd simply agree to the mainline pilots' demand and the threat of industrial action would recede.
The fact that they refuse to allow the OS pilots on the list proves they're up to something.
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Camp X-Ray
Posts: 2,135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by SQC
Most people these days think Luddite is short hand for obstructive labour objecting to innovative ways to improve productivity. To those who say productivity will not increase then why do BA want to do this?
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: NW
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
nice one Chrisbl.
If there is a strike, let's hope that it is long term, none of this 48 hour stuff (that only hurts the passengers).
While BA is shutdown for weeks on end, lets get some decent competition in. I can just imagine Ryanair's 737s with their new logo BYE BYE BA. Richard's Virgins must be loving every moment of this (more work for them).
I am not management, I don't care which side is in the wrong. All I do know is that a strike will end in tears for the staff in the long run.
If there is a strike, let's hope that it is long term, none of this 48 hour stuff (that only hurts the passengers).
While BA is shutdown for weeks on end, lets get some decent competition in. I can just imagine Ryanair's 737s with their new logo BYE BYE BA. Richard's Virgins must be loving every moment of this (more work for them).
I am not management, I don't care which side is in the wrong. All I do know is that a strike will end in tears for the staff in the long run.
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: London
Age: 81
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Personally I would hate to see the National Carrier go to the wall. I have always enjoyed flying BA and am sometimes lucky enough to fly Club which is about the best business seat out of Heathrow.
I don't know any pilots but the cabin crew I've had on my flights have been fantastic - and I wouldn't wish loss of job on ANYONE!
Let's hope a resolution can be found before it's too late.
Everyone has the right to strike - I would defend that to my dying day. All I would say is that you have to think about the longer term consequences - and there ARE always consequences some of which sadly cannot be forseen
Good luck to all those fighting for what they want - please remember to be kind to your families and don't take out your frustrations on them (as I did on mine many years ago)
I don't know any pilots but the cabin crew I've had on my flights have been fantastic - and I wouldn't wish loss of job on ANYONE!
Let's hope a resolution can be found before it's too late.
Everyone has the right to strike - I would defend that to my dying day. All I would say is that you have to think about the longer term consequences - and there ARE always consequences some of which sadly cannot be forseen
Good luck to all those fighting for what they want - please remember to be kind to your families and don't take out your frustrations on them (as I did on mine many years ago)
PPRuNe Person
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: see roster
Posts: 1,268
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SCQ you are like a stuck record.
BA pilots have been benchmarked as amongst the most productive in the world. You clearly do not know your subject, alternatively you know exactly what you are doing and are happy to peddle lies on this forum.
Most people these days think Luddite is short hand for obstructive labour objecting to innovative ways to improve productivity. To those who say productivity will not increase then why do BA want to do this?
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: All around the World
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BA pilots have been benchmarked as amongst the most productive in the world
Now, that is 'management speak' if ever I heard it
just shows that the pilots and the managers are not as far apart as they think, and a mutually satisfactory resolution may be just around the corner.
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's pretty predictable that every 6-12 months one group or another in BA threatens strike action. Last time it was the cabin crew, now its the pilots.
The arrogance that goes hand in hand with the militant, outdated, and scargilesque belief that walking out somehow achieves any form of victory is quite overwhelming.
I was a BA gold card member - I suspect to most of the vocal minority of pilots in this current dispute that means I was just an irritant who got spoken about in the galley for ordering a second glass of wine with my meal. However, to the company that employs you it meant I and my company spent many thousands of pounds contributing to your profits.
the last time a BA group threatened strike action I made a new arrangement with my travel department and a new deal with myself - the deal meant I would only ever travel with BA as a last resort. It hasn't happened yet. i have become an extremely happy and loyal customer of Lufthansa and regularly make the short trip to Germany to connect further afield in the name of avoiding the risk that flying with BA poses.
I am ashamed to look at BA and to consider what has happened - you have some of the best working conditions of any airline and still you threaten for more. You have lost me and countless others like me. I am not throwing my toys out of the pram, just stating a fact. You need to grow up, focus on flying planes, and stop p*****g off your customers with pathetic and indefensible threats.
I suspect this note will just be greeted with a torrent of abuse for having the audacity to challenge the greater wisdom within the flying ranks...please, feel free, because maybe when you have driven enough good and honest custom away, you will realise there is nobody sitting the seats on your aircraft who actually cares any more.
Please wake up, remember why you joined the national carrier, look at the oil price, think of the shareholders, and maybe have half a thought about your pension should the worst actually happen and you put yourselves out of business...I guess that will just be someone elses fault.
Good luck.
The arrogance that goes hand in hand with the militant, outdated, and scargilesque belief that walking out somehow achieves any form of victory is quite overwhelming.
I was a BA gold card member - I suspect to most of the vocal minority of pilots in this current dispute that means I was just an irritant who got spoken about in the galley for ordering a second glass of wine with my meal. However, to the company that employs you it meant I and my company spent many thousands of pounds contributing to your profits.
the last time a BA group threatened strike action I made a new arrangement with my travel department and a new deal with myself - the deal meant I would only ever travel with BA as a last resort. It hasn't happened yet. i have become an extremely happy and loyal customer of Lufthansa and regularly make the short trip to Germany to connect further afield in the name of avoiding the risk that flying with BA poses.
I am ashamed to look at BA and to consider what has happened - you have some of the best working conditions of any airline and still you threaten for more. You have lost me and countless others like me. I am not throwing my toys out of the pram, just stating a fact. You need to grow up, focus on flying planes, and stop p*****g off your customers with pathetic and indefensible threats.
I suspect this note will just be greeted with a torrent of abuse for having the audacity to challenge the greater wisdom within the flying ranks...please, feel free, because maybe when you have driven enough good and honest custom away, you will realise there is nobody sitting the seats on your aircraft who actually cares any more.
Please wake up, remember why you joined the national carrier, look at the oil price, think of the shareholders, and maybe have half a thought about your pension should the worst actually happen and you put yourselves out of business...I guess that will just be someone elses fault.
Good luck.
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: SE Asia
Age: 39
Posts: 137
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whilst on strike ...why not take a 'crash' course in Chinese? i guess we will all be working for them in the not too distant future.deep joy....tin hat on for laughter and incoming!
ps:me no joking.
ps:me no joking.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: where ever i wake up!!!!
Posts: 608
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
it is such a sad indicment of this country that a company can only be deemed succesful by how much profit it makes and not by how it treats its workforce, a pity that a few more people didnt stand up for what they believed in ,this country as a whole might be better off. Thebaxfactor is the sort of guy that we have running companies in this country .
PPRuNe Person
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: see roster
Posts: 1,268
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's pretty predictable that every 6-12 months one group or another in BA threatens strike action. Last time it was the cabin crew, now its the pilots.
PS we are not "asking for more" - if you took the trouble to actually understand the issue before jumping in here with both feet you will see why you are being flamed.
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Manchester
Age: 45
Posts: 615
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Bravo to BALPA,
It's about time someone stuck it to the incompetent chimps that masquerade as BA senior "managers".
I'm travelling from London on BA in Mid-March and hope it coincides with the strike, as I'd happily man the picket line with the pilots. Having been a TU rep and having to deal with these idiots, I can understand how the senior BALPA reps are banging their heads against a brick wall.
I'm sure anyone who is anti this strike is either;
a) BA management
or
b) has never had to cope with the sheer arrogance, belligerence and sub-human intelligence that constitute BA mangement.
Good Luck and God Speed Gentlemen
Ex-BA and completely shafted in the regions by them.
It's about time someone stuck it to the incompetent chimps that masquerade as BA senior "managers".
I'm travelling from London on BA in Mid-March and hope it coincides with the strike, as I'd happily man the picket line with the pilots. Having been a TU rep and having to deal with these idiots, I can understand how the senior BALPA reps are banging their heads against a brick wall.
I'm sure anyone who is anti this strike is either;
a) BA management
or
b) has never had to cope with the sheer arrogance, belligerence and sub-human intelligence that constitute BA mangement.
Good Luck and God Speed Gentlemen
Ex-BA and completely shafted in the regions by them.
Last edited by Ex Cargo Clown; 8th Mar 2008 at 18:40.
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: London
Age: 81
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I used to think that if more people stood up for their rights companies would have to think twice about employment terms and conditions etc. I believed it was that simple! Unfortunately the 70s showed us that people who took this route (striking) won small victories but eventually lost the war to the global market place - steel, ,mining and coal. Less trouble with labour relations and lower costs.
I don't like it anymore than anyone else but the reality is that for everyone here who wants to see better prospects, bonuses, share options, job security for life etc etc - there are literally thousands of others both in this country and around the world who are only too happy to do the job without any of the above guarantees and perks.
If anything we are seeing it happen all over again in the service industry - outsourcing technology jobs, call centres and manufacturing all oversees.
In my own job (Technology project work for banking) I am surrounded by people of virtually every nationality who are all keen and happy just to be working.
The sad fact is that the pilots may on this occasion force BA's hand but make no mistake, as I learned from bitter experience, payback will come.
Companies DO NOT care about people - once you disabuse yourself of this ideal you can start to focus on security for you and your family. Its pretty much all you can do.
I don't like it anymore than anyone else but the reality is that for everyone here who wants to see better prospects, bonuses, share options, job security for life etc etc - there are literally thousands of others both in this country and around the world who are only too happy to do the job without any of the above guarantees and perks.
If anything we are seeing it happen all over again in the service industry - outsourcing technology jobs, call centres and manufacturing all oversees.
In my own job (Technology project work for banking) I am surrounded by people of virtually every nationality who are all keen and happy just to be working.
The sad fact is that the pilots may on this occasion force BA's hand but make no mistake, as I learned from bitter experience, payback will come.
Companies DO NOT care about people - once you disabuse yourself of this ideal you can start to focus on security for you and your family. Its pretty much all you can do.
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Camp X-Ray
Posts: 2,135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well thanks for the pep talk but nobody in BA has laboured under the notion that BA gives two hoots for us. Security for me and my family is what this whole dispute is about. Furthermore whilst it's easy to outsource IT jobs it's rather more difficult with flying. There aren't enough pilots in India. Or China. Or Australia. Or the Middle East. Where are all these people willing to do my job for peanuts?
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: U.K.
Posts: 6
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For those who would actually like to understand the issues, take a good look at.. www.baplane.bapilot.org