PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Iran (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/586655-iran.html)

Tashengurt 17th June 2025 17:33

Trump demanding Iran's "Unconditional surrender"
Can you demand the surrender of a state you aren't at war with?
Has Trump just declared war with Iran?

MPN11 17th June 2025 17:50


Originally Posted by Tashengurt (Post 11904499)
Trump demanding Iran's "Unconditional surrender"
Can you demand the surrender of a state you aren't at war with?
Has Trump just declared war with Iran?

He seems to be considering it, which I find deeply concerning.

Gnadenburg 17th June 2025 18:10


Originally Posted by Marcantilan (Post 11904477)
What happened? Does anyone know?

Was wondering the same thing. All I found at this stage was this article on fleeing Iranian fighters.

https://www.ynetnews.com/article/bjyzjx07eg

RAFEngO74to09 17th June 2025 18:25

US State Dept brief live now on Fox News

tdracer 17th June 2025 18:41

Iran has claimed to have shot down 3 F35's so far, and having captured one (female) pilot.
Has anything resembling 'proof' of these claims been released (e.g. photos of downed aircraft, interview with the captured pilot, etc.)?
Or is this more Bagdad Bob type stuff?

GlobalNav 17th June 2025 18:44


Originally Posted by tdracer (Post 11904551)
Iran has claimed to have shot down 3 F35's so far, and having captured one (female) pilot.
Has anything resembling 'proof' of these claims been released (e.g. photos of downed aircraft, interview with the captured pilot, etc.)?
Or is this more Bagdad Bob type stuff?

Tehran Tommy, you mean?

NutLoose 17th June 2025 18:53

I’ll believe it when I see them paraded in badly fitting suits.

NutLoose 17th June 2025 19:19

Fancy telling the Iranian leadership that they know where he is, talk about poor OP SEC.

Lonewolf_50 17th June 2025 20:12

Interesting commentary from 13 years ago about Israel vs Iran ... possibly applies today?
(OK, did a little digging, he tends to be a contributor to the Telegraph, leans more conservative in the UK)

Originally Posted by USA Today
WASHINGTON − President Donald Trump threatened Iran's supreme leader as he pushed Tehran to end its retaliatory airstrikes on Israel and warned against any threats to U.S. service members in the region.
"We know exactly where the so-called 'Supreme Leader' is hiding," Trump wrote on Truth Social. "He is an easy target, but is safe there."

"We are not going to take him out (kill!), at least not for now," the president said on June 17. "But we don’t want missiles shot at civilians, or American soldiers. Our patience is wearing thin." There was no immediate response from the Iranian government.

The Reality TV show continues. :ugh:

As to the Iranian Air Force:

In recent days, Iranian media claimed that Israeli pilots were shot down or captured, and that dogfights had taken place.
“It’s funny—of course that didn’t happen,” says Maj N “Every pilot dreams of downing an enemy aircraft, and we were ready for that. But during the opening wave, when we entered Iranian airspace, we saw their pilots take off—and then flee. They flew inward, toward central Iran, literally running away from us and disappearing.”
34 years ago, didn't a bunch of Iraqi pilots fly to Iran to avoid the Coalition (Desert Storm)?
Self preservation is a thing.

West Coast 17th June 2025 20:17


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11904580)
Fancy telling the Iranian leadership that they know where he is, talk about poor OP SEC.

Or it could flush him out where the Intel folks can track him.

macmp419 17th June 2025 21:10


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11904329)

dozens of aerial tankers have arrived in Europe.

Tankers Deploy to Europe as US Weighs Options in Israel-Iran War

Would this be the same Europe that is not pulling its weight and the one that "The Donald" wants to withdraw from?


RAFEngO74to09 17th June 2025 21:21

4 more KC-135R/Ts heading out from the USA + a B-1B which turned its transponder off.

Also, French E-3F + its own supporting C-135FR tanker heading to the area - by Greece at present.

dead_pan 17th June 2025 21:29

Anyone else getting this ad on this thread?...(see spoiler)


CurlyB 17th June 2025 21:44


Very good video by ex army special forces regarding some of the recent strikes in Iran

Mod Note: Start at minute 1:58. The first two minutes are fluff/noise.
T28B

NutLoose 17th June 2025 22:25

Congress on both sides are trying to limit Trumps war powers, as Congress can only declare war. SMO anyone?


Washington — Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are looking to limit President Trump's ability to order U.S. strikes on Iran amid its ongoing war with Israel, emphasizing that only Congress has the power to declare war under the Constitution.

"This is not our war," Republican Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky said in a post on X Tuesday announcing that he had introduced a measure under the 1973 War Powers Resolution to block U.S. strikes. "Even if it were, Congress must decide such matters according to our Constitution."

The Constitution grants Congress the sole power to declare war, and the extent of the president's authority to wade into conflict abroad without the approval of the legislative branch has been challenged in recent years. In 2020, Mr. Trump faced criticism for his decision to strike Iranian military leader Qassem Soleimani without notifying congressional leaders.

Massie's resolution aims to force the president to seek congressional approval before entering a war with Iran and would terminate the use of U.S. armed forces against Iran without Congress' expressed approval. It's cosponsored by Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna of California, who urged "every member to go on record" in a post on X on Monday.

"Are you with the neocons who led us into Iraq or do you stand with the American people?" Khanna said.

ORAC 17th June 2025 22:25

BREAKING:

Iranian Crown Prince @PahlaviReza just gave a speech to the nation:

“All it takes now is a nation-wide uprising to put this nightmare to and end (…) may I be with you soon”

ENGLISH SUBTITLES

NutLoose 17th June 2025 22:36

Ahhh, but further to that ORAC, please read Pakistan’s Defence Minister’s tweet to Reza Pahlavi 🤔


https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b92981321.jpeg

tartare 18th June 2025 00:36

I think a few posters are missing a point on the `Congress seeking to limit Trump's war powers' angle.
Who says he's looking to go to war? A few MOPs dropped on Fordo and Natanz is not war. He doesn't need Congressional approval to do so - just needs to tell them within two days of doing it and wrap it up within 60 days.

I think the positioning of US forces in the region may be to help shoot down a furious Iranian ballistic missile response if he does so, and to protect US bases from any retaliation.
Were he to want to respond medium term if Iran does target US forces and bases in the region - might be a different story - that's looking more like war.

Anyways, I think we'll see TACO rather than any decisive action - I hope I'm wrong.
He's just loving the drama and being the centre of attention - but this isn't an episode of The Apprentice.

13 others 18th June 2025 01:20


Originally Posted by tartare (Post 11904798)
I think a few posters are missing a point on the `Congress seeking to limit Trump's war powers' angle.
Who says he's looking to go to war? A few MOPs dropped on Fordo and Natanz is not war. He doesn't need Congressional approval to do so - just needs to tell them within two days of doing it and wrap it up within 60 days.
I think the positioning of US forces in the region may be to help shoot down a furious Iranian ballistic missile response if he does so, and to protect US bases from any retaliation.
Were he to want to respond medium term if Iran does target US forces and bases in the region - might be a different story - that's looking more like war.
Anyways, I think we'll see TACO rather than any decisive action - I hope I'm wrong.
He's just loving the drama and being the centre of attention - but this isn't an episode of The Apprentice.

Instead, it's another episode of The Prince. Here's your Machiavelli:
Jan 24, 2025
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b34da70a1d.jpg
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ec72803822.jpg

From a purely selfish point of view - one of my great regrets is that I cannot yet visit Iran to learn more about the country and culture, and may not be able to for another 10-15 years at least, because it is so dangerous for westerners.
Tehran looks fascinating, surrounded by beautiful mountains, great food, literature, history. And a vibrant society, elements of which still defy the despots who rule them.
I suppose the best fitting response is almost literally that you can't have your cake and eat it too. That is, we will never enjoy what Iran has to offer if we subscribe (submit) to Machiavellianism.

I fully believe that you genuinely wish the best for the Iranian people, and that we share a similar ordinary understanding of Iranian history. The thing is, I cannot ignore that, if/when the Iranian regime topples, either a new bad regime will take over, or Iran will be greatly weakened. With a new bad regime, practically nothing changes. If a weakened Iran emerges, what will happen to Iran is what happens to every other weak country on the globe, what has happened for centuries: pilots (boats, airplanes, spaceships, whatever) will deliver those with deep pockets to Iran to gain "rights" to as much of Iran's resources as can be had. Rinse and repeat.

Taking a step back, in the big picture, it is deficit spending outside Iran that afforded military buildup outside Iran that first threatened Iran and later is being used to topple Iran, deficit spending that causes leaders of debt-ladened nations to seek money from whomever . Those profiting from the deficit spending are the ones with deep pockets in the first place. Thus, all along those in the military are tools of, and subservient to, those in the banking/finance industry. Right out of a wealthy prince's play book.

Winemaker 18th June 2025 02:47


He's just loving the drama and being the centre of attention - but this isn't an episode of The Apprentice.
I agree, this isn't an episode of The Apprentice. Unfortunately, for Trump it actually is.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:52.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.