PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

NutLoose 8th Apr 2022 20:38

We’ve sent Harpoons.


Ninthace 8th Apr 2022 21:13


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11212695)

I wonder how they are going to operate them?

NutLoose 8th Apr 2022 21:37

I don’t know, there are land based launchers, but did the U.K. ever invest in them? Or are we providing the missiles and someone else the launcher, or have they cobbled up a system to mount it somehow on a truck?

langleybaston 8th Apr 2022 21:45


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11212708)
I don’t know, there are land based launchers, but did the U.K. ever invest in them? Or are we providing the missiles and someone else the launcher, or have they cobbled up a system to mount it somehow on a truck?

Where there's a will there's a way. the Falklands taught as that: What SHOULD have taken months took days. And that was for both sides. Exocet land-launched for example.
Going right back to Mafeking, necessity is the mother of invention, and defenders get very good at it.

SATCOS WHIPPING BOY 8th Apr 2022 22:48


Originally Posted by Darkmouse (Post 11212611)
​​​​​​I can enlighten you! There is no way on earth that FJ pilots recently out of the training system are in their early twenties. Even if they joined at 18, I'd estimate them to be in their mid-twenties at best. And for most, probably early-thirties.

Correct to a degree. I know an fj pilot who completed Valley aged 23 1/2. Had he then gone straight to fj frontline as planned he would have been 24 1/2 doing the stuff fj pilots do. A short instructor tour post-valley slowed that path but he still was frontline fj on Q and shader aged 26 and a bit.

For what it's worth, he loves it.




MAINJAFAD 8th Apr 2022 22:52


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11212708)
I don’t know, there are land based launchers, but did the U.K. ever invest in them? Or are we providing the missiles and someone else the launcher, or have they cobbled up a system to mount it somehow on a truck?

Seeing that nobody currently operates Harpoon as a Land based system (the Danes binned theirs nearly 20 years ago and Taiwan have only just ordered such a system in the last month). It is got to be a Lash up system if the British are giving it. Argies managed to do it with Exocet in 1982.

etudiant 9th Apr 2022 00:26


Originally Posted by MAINJAFAD (Post 11212733)
Seeing that nobody currently operates Harpoon as a Land based system (the Danes binned theirs nearly 20 years ago and Taiwan have only just ordered such a system in the last month). It is got to be a Lash up system if the British are giving it. Argies managed to do it with Exocet in 1982.

Afaik, the Harpoon can update its waypoints while en route, so the launch modality should be non critical. Satellite surveillance should allow targeting anywhere within the effective range of the missile.

BATCO 9th Apr 2022 06:37


Originally Posted by Timelord (Post 11212668)
Does anyone know what the “ precision munitions capable of lingering in the sky until directed to a target” that the PM has promised to Ukraine are?....

Switchblade?

Batco

dead_pan 9th Apr 2022 07:14


Originally Posted by MAINJAFAD (Post 11212733)
Seeing that nobody currently operates Harpoon as a Land based system (the Danes binned theirs nearly 20 years ago and Taiwan have only just ordered such a system in the last month). It is got to be a Lash up system if the British are giving it. Argies managed to do it with Exocet in 1982.

I've been informed that Babcock maintained a land-based 'reference system' to support the RN's capability and that it may be this that has been made available to the Ukrainians. But no official confirmation as far as I'm aware.

Mentioned here:

https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news...he-royal-navy/

skridlov 9th Apr 2022 08:03

Re: Kramatorsk station attack.
I'm puzzled as to what type of warhead this missile was carrying. Widely reported to be cluster munitions yet no obvious evidence even in footage taken just after the incident of unexploded sub-munitions or flechettes.

SRMman 9th Apr 2022 08:46

Kramatorsk station attack
 
I'm also puzzled by the video of what is said to be the actual missile (with the message written on the side). It seems strange to me that the device is still relatively intact, one would have thought that with the combination of the HE warhead and supersonic flight it would have been completely obliterated?

jolihokistix 9th Apr 2022 09:14

Just watched a Japanese TV crew interviewing a spokesman who said the deaths and injuries were cause by ‘flying fragments’ whatever that means.

Imagegear 9th Apr 2022 09:30

I suspect that they mean Shrapnel

IG

MAINJAFAD 9th Apr 2022 09:34


Originally Posted by dead_pan (Post 11212860)
I've been informed that Babcock maintained a land-based 'reference system' to support the RN's capability and that it may be this that has been made available to the Ukrainians. But no official confirmation as far as I'm aware.

Mentioned here:

https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news...he-royal-navy/

Makes sense and such systems do exist just north of Portsmouth (Type 42 and Type 45 systems on a Hill!!!). No requirement for jury rigging if a containerised system already exists,

NutLoose 9th Apr 2022 09:38


Originally Posted by SRMman (Post 11212889)
I'm also puzzled by the video of what is said to be the actual missile (with the message written on the side). It seems strange to me that the device is still relatively intact, one would have thought that with the combination of the HE warhead and supersonic flight it would have been completely obliterated?

I thought they said there was more than one missile, possibly three? So the one on the grass was possibly a dud. Or the delivery section.

Mogwi 9th Apr 2022 09:46


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11212708)
I don’t know, there are land based launchers, but did the U.K. ever invest in them? Or are we providing the missiles and someone else the launcher, or have they cobbled up a system to mount it somehow on a truck?


https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....035b3bccc5.jpg
Here is one they prepared earlier! Wheelbarrow mounted Exocet in the Falklands 1982.
Mog

MAINJAFAD 9th Apr 2022 10:05


Originally Posted by jolihokistix (Post 11212901)
Just watched a Japanese TV crew interviewing a spokesman who said the deaths and injuries were cause by ‘flying fragments’ whatever that means.

This missile has a Cluster Munition warhead which deploys said warheads around 2500 Metres from the target. As soon as it deploys those warheads, the rest of the airframe tumbles and decelerates rapidly (most likely breaking up in flight as it does so). Remains that don't go bang hit the ground at quite low velocities. The bomblets are Blast Frag.

https://armamentresearch.com/9n123k-...ions-in-syria/

dead_pan 9th Apr 2022 10:53


Originally Posted by MAINJAFAD (Post 11212928)
This missile has a Cluster Munition warhead which deploys said warheads around 2500 Metres from the target. As soon as it deploys those warheads, the rest of the airframe tumbles and decelerates rapidly (most likely breaking up in flight as it does so). Remains that don't go bang hit the ground at quite low velocities. The bomblets are Blast Frag.

https://armamentresearch.com/9n123k-...ions-in-syria/

If this was the weapon used it was clearly was a deliberate attempt to kill as civilians as possible. Given the numbers said to be present at the station when it hit its a miracle more were not killed or injured.

ACW342 9th Apr 2022 12:20

Hope anyone tanking from RAFAIR 9916 have got their sun visors down!!

NutLoose 9th Apr 2022 12:33

So having a Harpoon set up delivered, I take it the Russian fleet will need to pull right back where they will be pretty none effective? And the suspected possible combined land and sea invasion of the ports is now out of the question?

Usertim 9th Apr 2022 13:39


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11212978)
So having a Harpoon set up delivered, I take it the Russian fleet will need to pull right back where they will be pretty none effective? And the suspected possible combined land and sea invasion of the ports is now out of the question?

Kalibr has a reported range something in the area of 1500km , compared to harpoon (if they are there) in the region of 150km. I doubt that any harpoon has been delivered , but it could be true rumor and perhaps makes sure that the russian navy keeps a good distance (negating their intelligence and anti-air role).

If by ports you mean Odesa that is simply not gonna happen , it is pretty much surrounded by marshland with land and sea access very limited. Rus forces cannot really launch any serious amphibious attack since two of their 'landing' ships are sunk\damaged. For the land the only real appoach is over the Bug river , hence the big push on Mikoliev that failed , leaving really no easy access.

Indeed there is a lot of chatter on UKR telegram channels that UAF will attempt to liberate Kherson in the next days, I think that is optimistic, and not sure even that it is sensible, Kahkova ( next Dnipr bridge) is more strategic, and much smaller , plus Kherson is tying down a ton of rus occupation troops for no real effect right now.

**edited to add** Kakova is much more important as the bridge there is part of the Dnipr dam, the russians cannot really blow the bridge without a lot of trouble, and catastrophe, and essentially destroying the 'crimea water channel' which they want so much and orginates there. Attack kherson and the 2 or 3 BTGs there will withdraw over the river, blow the bridge, and be available to reinforce eastwards. What would you do ...

Geriaviator 9th Apr 2022 14:11

Let's agree Harpoon is obsolete and useless, and other missiles are not available. When (hopefully) the RF loses another ship there can be no doubt it was hit by one of their own missiles, just as the Ukrainians are shelling their own cities ...

NutLoose 9th Apr 2022 16:28

Slovakia has delivered a complete S3100 battery to Ukraine, it’s got to be getting dodgy flying over Ukraine for the Russians.


Tartiflette Fan 9th Apr 2022 18:38


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11213052)
Slovenia has delivered a complete S3100 battery to Ukraine, it’s got to be getting dodgy flying over Ukraine for the Russians.

https://twitter.com/UAWeapons/status...01106072178696

According to Forbes:

" Ukraine had around 100 active batteries of S-300 long-range air-defense systems with as many as 300 launchers when Russia widened its war in the country starting the night of Feb. 23.Seven weeks later, the Russians have knocked out at least 21 of the S-300 launchers that outside analysts have confirmed with photos or videos. Even if the actual total of destroyed launchers is higher—and it almost certainly is—it’s not hard to understand why the Russian air force still is losing a startling number of aircraft."

so although useful, it's probably more of a symbol than anything.

ICATQ 9th Apr 2022 19:07

Multinationalism at its best!

NutLoose 9th Apr 2022 19:08

Reports of NATO jets possibly shadowing Air Serbian jets possibly into Russian airspace but cannot verify.

https://www.exyuaviation.com/2022/04...y-fighter.html

SATCOS WHIPPING BOY 9th Apr 2022 19:29


Originally Posted by ACW342 (Post 11212972)
Hope anyone tanking from RAFAIR 9916 have got their sun visors down!!

What do you mean by this ?

macmp419 9th Apr 2022 20:01


Originally Posted by SATCOS WHIPPING BOY (Post 11213107)
What do you mean by this ?

Possibly a reference to it being ZZ336, pure guess on my behalf though.

SATCOS WHIPPING BOY 9th Apr 2022 20:33

Good guess macmp419, but no idea of the relevance.

Pali 10th Apr 2022 04:43

Beside S-300 we are sending 16 howitzers "Zuzana" they will be needed for the oncoming counteroffensive. The war enters the key phase. Stopping the Russian advance and making the guerrilla type of ambushes on armour columns is one thing but retaking the territory will be a different type of game.


MAINJAFAD 10th Apr 2022 10:56

Not just Starstreak that has entered the game, The missile being fired in this video is the new Martlet Light Multi-mode Missile. (uses Starstreak launcher control unit but has a different missile tube).




Timelord 10th Apr 2022 17:09

Given the amount of tanker hours revealed on FR24, Does anyone know if the extra airframes in the surge capacity of the AirTanker contract have been activated, or are they still doing bucket and spade runs?

NutLoose 10th Apr 2022 18:45

Russians take looting to a whole new level……. Shame :ugh:


These ‘heroes’ will take Darwin's prizes even from those doomed racists who inhaled the dust of the Red Forest while in it,” Ukraine’s state-run nuclear company, Energoatom, said via a Telegram statement Saturday.

Energoatom also stated that Russian forces “unauthorizedly entered a repository of ionizing radiation sources” and “stole and damaged 133 sources with a total activity of about 7 million becquerels,” which is “comparable to 700 kg of radioactive waste with the presence of beta and gamma radiation.”

The "deadly" items were taken as “souvenirs,” Energoatom said, citing Ukraine’s state zone management agency. The company warned, however, that Russian troops may be in for a surprise, because “carrying such a souvenir with you for two weeks will inevitably lead to radiation burns, radiation sickness and irreversible processes in the body.”


https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/n...obyl-souvenirs

[email protected] 10th Apr 2022 18:49

Let's hope they send some of their war trophies directly to Vlad..........

NutLoose 10th Apr 2022 22:44

Possible location of the Russian air assets that are operating over the Ukraine.


Ninthace 10th Apr 2022 23:14

Has the destruction of this convoy been confirmed?


NutLoose 11th Apr 2022 00:18

He also says


A column of #Russian equipment heading for #Kharkiv was destroyed. Witnesses report 2,000 bodies and lots and lots of equipment.

We are providing info as we receive it. There will not be any confirmation tonight, so we will all have to wait for an official statement from #ZSU. Russians are pushing towards #Kharkiv and #Donbass, so many more columns like this one are expected

jolihokistix 11th Apr 2022 00:39

Having just read the 'full conversation' it sounds as if the poor Russian grunts are getting hammered, left right and centre. They have never been able to see any viable targets, right from the beginning of this war, except for village and city buildings. They themselves are the targets, sitting ducks, and there is no friend in the air.

With unsustainable losses of men, morale and equipment, what can Putin salvage from all of this, even sending in his new general, the alleged Butcher of Aleppo?

tartare 11th Apr 2022 03:36

Was reading about the Battle of Kursk last night.
A lot of the action took place near Kharkiv... and in July.
It's looking like this spring and summer may also be a meat-grinder of dreadful proportions.

Obba 11th Apr 2022 06:00

Wrong post.





All times are GMT. The time now is 10:02.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.