PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   All borders to reopen. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/632861-all-borders-reopen.html)

Turnleft080 13th Jan 2021 07:36

[QUOTE=Sunfish;10966804]Some of you don't seem to understand logistics and especially supply chains, let alone complex systems.
Covid 19 is not directly lethal, we hope, to the majority of humans. It is indirectly lethal to everyone because it has the capacity to destroy the healthcare system.



Just to throw some numbers with your statement Sunfish worldwide their have been 93,000,000 cases, 66,000,000 recoveries, 2,000,000 deaths.
Looking at those figures it's not lethal, it's not a death sentence, however it's lethal if you have heart disease, diabetes 2, cancer, COPD, emphysema. Why? Your immune system is
exhausted and depleted to defend a covid strain. A covid strain loves any of these conditions it's free to duplicate and multiply. Also don't forget if you have these
conditions you still have a 98% chance of recovery. State/federal governments will scare the crap out of you that it's a death sentence. Remember the Dan show he
really liked to emphasis the death ages and that's it.

The healthier you are the less chance of flooding the health system.
I really think the WHO, CDC come clean and give us more information about this virus.
We only know so much, though I reckon their is more info out their they can educate us on.

WingNut60 13th Jan 2021 09:16


Originally Posted by Icarus2001 (Post 10966770)
..............Later this year lets look at the suicide statistics for 2020 in Australia.

Yes. Definitely worth follow up.
I guess that you're tipping an increase and you may be correct.
But the AIHW warns about interpreting trends in suicide rates in Australia because of the very low overall rate and the impact that small yearly variation can have on the rate.

What I am interested in is why, in the USA, without discernible COVID controls, the suicide rate (with firearms) has remained stable for several years through to and including 2020 but the homicide rate has increased dramatically - something like a 20 - 25% increase in just one year.



Sunfish 13th Jan 2021 09:25

turnleft, where are your statistics for hospitalisation, ICU occupancy and deaths and illness among health care workers?

You obviously don't understand the problem.

Chronic Snoozer 13th Jan 2021 11:07

We can survive COVID but we can't survive all having COVID at the same time.

Turnleft080 13th Jan 2021 11:34


Originally Posted by Sunfish (Post 10966891)
turnleft, where are your statistics for hospitalisation, ICU occupancy and deaths and illness among health care workers?

You obviously don't understand the problem.

Worst case scenario USA, --------- against Australia
Population 330,000,000 -----------------25,000,000

Total cases 23,400,000 ------------------ 28,647
Deaths 389,900 -------------------------------- 909
Total recoveries 13,800,000 ------------- 25,860
Active cases with covid 9,200,000 ------- 1,878
IN ICU 29,222 ------------------------------------ 1
Deaths per 1,000,000 = 1173 ----------------- 35

Haven't got health care workers though you reckon they would be healthy in the first place if their dealing with sick people
as their profession. As you can see the Aus numbers are influenced with harsh lockdowns, curfews, international air restrictions.
The USA hardly did any of that plus their diet is crap they all live on top of each other hence the large numbers.
I understand the problem, people should not be scared of the virus you should be scared of your own immune system.

Planet earth is located at the right temperature from the sun to sustain life. Provided is O2 and H2O and they alone
will produce fungi, moulds, viruses, germs. The bloke upstairs then decided to invent humans, and he provided them
with a immune system to fight them off. I believe that's been going on for the last 10,000 years.
Guess what, it will continue for the next 10,000 and 10,000 after that. What are we scared of?

Transition Layer 13th Jan 2021 11:38

Does the average age of death ‘with COVID’, still exceed the average life expectancy in the western world?

I know this was definitely the case earlier in the pandemic, and I’d expect it was still the case as treatment strategies improve.

dr dre 13th Jan 2021 12:17


Originally Posted by Transition Layer (Post 10966985)
Does the average age of death ‘with COVID’, still exceed the average life expectancy in the western world?

Sorry, do we have an attitude that those above average life expectancy aren’t worth saving?

Even if you don’t care about those above average life expectancy look at the pandemic’s toll on some who are below average life expectancy:

Average age of Covid ICU patient in UK: 60

25% of Covid dead in US below 65, another 25% between 65-74

3000 US Healthcare worker Covid deaths, majority under 60

20% of US under 35’s admitted to hospital needed intensive care, 20% reported long term complications

Over 75% of German patients with average age of 49 reported cardiac issues post Covid

Joker89 13th Jan 2021 12:42

As expected more hyperbole, sample size 100

dr dre 13th Jan 2021 13:34


Originally Posted by Joker89 (Post 10967030)
As expected more hyperbole, sample size 100

Small sample but a random selection, still indicates high degree of post Covid complications for a group of people average age well under 65 in a first world country.

Hardly hyperbole. For a profession where good cardiac health is essential to be fit to fly I wouldn’t want to be taking too many chances.

Joker89 13th Jan 2021 13:38

Mate you wrote a new headline for your linked article to try and make it sound more dire. More like 78 individuals, even the writer says all it proves is that further investigation is warranted.

dr dre 13th Jan 2021 13:57


Originally Posted by Joker89 (Post 10967068)
Mate you wrote a new headline for your linked article to try and make it sound more dire. More like 78 individuals, even the writer says all it proves is that further investigation is warranted.

Exact text from the study:


this study of a cohort of German patients recently recovered from COVID-19 infection, CMR revealed cardiac involvement in 78 patients (78%) and ongoing myocardial inflammation in 60 patients (60%), independent of preexisting conditions, severity and overall course of the acute illness, and time from the original diagnosis.
So over 75% of the patients in that study (unselected Btw, that’s the key) with a mean age of 49 had cardiac issues.

I agree further investigations need to be done, but you can hardly dismiss any risk of cardiac issues in the non elderly after Covid infection after reading that study.

wheels_down 13th Jan 2021 19:56

Effective immediately McGoose will fine you $50,000 if your in Perth Airport minus a face mask.

Green.Dot 13th Jan 2021 21:00


Originally Posted by Bodie1 (Post 10967301)
McGowan is a #### ####### ####

He may have had great success with the voters but watching him talk recently he is nothing but a power hungry psychopath. Must have been picked on during his Navy career I reckon.

Wait until COVID gets out in WA- he will make Dan look like a Saint.

WingNut60 13th Jan 2021 21:03


Originally Posted by wheels_down (Post 10967286)
Effective immediately McGoose will fine you $50,000 if your in Perth Airport minus a face mask.

That's one way to improve the compliance rate.

Transition Layer 13th Jan 2021 21:07


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 10967007)
Sorry, do we have an attitude that those above average life expectancy aren’t worth saving?

Never said that. I just posed the question. It’s called average life expectancy for a reason. We can’t live forever.

neville_nobody 13th Jan 2021 21:32

Aren't airports a federal jurisdiction?

dr dre 13th Jan 2021 22:01

It’s pretty easy to not cop that massive fine. Just wear a mask in airports and on aircraft. As airline staff we’re mandated to wear one anyway as part of our employment. If we refused to we’d cop a bigger fine than $50k, it’s called being sacked.

I’d say fines towards the extreme end would be for those who are being disruptive, like refusing to wear one after being directed to by police.


dr dre 13th Jan 2021 23:02

Eliminate it from community spread until the population is properly immunised.

In other news it’s good to see some progress is being made on the hotel quarantine front, with measures that epidemiologists have been wanting for months now are being considered, although it would’ve been better had the federal government taken the responsibility for quarantine as constitutionally mandated to them in the first place.

If these ideas are implemented across the nation then basically there’ll be very little risk of a major city hotel outbreak so life can return to best as normal until the population is immunised to herd immunity. Probably better for the quarantiners too as they can have some fresh air instead of being cooped up in sealed hotel room:

The Queensland Government will consider using mining camps to quarantine international travellers as the state grapples with a cluster of the highly-contagious UK strain of coronavirus.

Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said she would raise the matter with the Federal Government when national cabinet meets next Friday.

"We are going to look at all options and one of those options is to look at some of the mining camps that we have in Queensland," she said.

"Now, for a start, some of these mining camps are four-star.”

"My understanding is most of them, the ones we're looking at, have balconies so there's a lot of fresh air for guests and also, too, there's the capacity for all of the staff and the cleaners and everyone to also be based on those sites as well.

"I think this is a rational option and if we are dealing with a strain which is up to 70 per cent more infectious, I think we need to be really serious about it."

Queensland considers mining camps for quarantining travellers - ABC News

WingNut60 14th Jan 2021 00:06


Originally Posted by wheels_down (Post 10967286)
Effective immediately McGoose will fine you $50,000 if your in Perth Airport minus a face mask.

I believe that the penalty mentioned arises from this :

“Breaching directions made under the Emergency Management Act may result in on-the-spot fines of $1,000 for individuals, or where a matter is deemed serious and dealt with under formal criminal charges penalties of up to $50,000 or imprisonment for 12 months may be imposed by the courts.”
The last significant penalty imposed under the WA state regs was a young man who was fined following numerous, flagrant breaches of his self-quarantine directions and subsequently pleaded guilty to 5 counts of Fail to Comply with an Emergency Management Act Direction
He was fined a total of $13,000. (Very lenient in my opinion).

A WA Police spokesperson said that “Breaching directions made under the Emergency Management Act may result in on-the-spot fines of $1,000 for individuals, or where a matter is deemed serious and dealt with under formal criminal charges penalties of up to $50,000 or imprisonment for 12 months may be imposed by the courts.”

In other words, the state law and penalties have not changed. The only change is the adoption of the requirement to wear the mask at all times in airports which is a federal directive arising from a National Cabinet decision.
It applies to NSW as well, though the penalty may vary from state to state.

As far as I can tell, in NSW the penalties which would apply would be for breaches of the Public Health Act 2010.
In the case of an individual, the maximum penalty is $11,000, or imprisonment for 6 months, or both and a further $5500 penalty may apply for each day the offence continues.
The NSW Police may also issue on-the-spot fines of $1000 for an offence.
In the case of any corporation, the maximum penalty is $55,000 and a further $27,500 penalty may apply for each day the offence continues.

Funny though that the papers aren't also saying "Beryl will fine you $11,000 AND stick you in gaol for six months if you don't wear a mask at the airport".

Bodie1 14th Jan 2021 01:36


Eliminate it from community spread until the population is properly immunised.
That's not what he said or intimated.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:28.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.