PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Airlines, Airports & Routes (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes-85/)
-   -   Loganair-2 (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes/600131-loganair-2-a.html)

fjencl 5th Dec 2018 11:04

How many seats does a brand new 42-600 have, or is that carrier specific

lfc84 5th Dec 2018 11:26

up to 48 i belive

4567 5th Dec 2018 14:42

Great to hear as the interior of new ATR is much improved on earlier models to the benefit of staff and customers!

BAladdy 8th Dec 2018 03:30

Any word on when LM are going to announce there new European routes from GLA?.

TartinTon 8th Dec 2018 16:49


Originally Posted by BAladdy (Post 10330788)
Any word on when LM are going to announce there new European routes from GLA?.

I suspect that they may have issues getting decent slots at any of the major cities that have been mentioned as they are simply full at peak hours whether you have new entrant status or not.
This *could* be a reason for the delay in announcing. Otherwise you would want to get on sale as early as possible to give yourself the longest lead time to sell.

tibbs87 9th Dec 2018 14:12


Originally Posted by Jerbourg (Post 10326759)
Embraer stopped building Brasilias in 2001!

True, they ceased main production of the aircraft in 2001, but they do build new Brasilia's on request, as the Angolan Air Force received newly built EMB 120s in 2007.

davidjohnson6 9th Dec 2018 17:04

If main production ended 17 years ago, would you really want to place a new order ? Yes I'm sure all the paperwork is in place, I would be wondering if the tooling, factory process and organisational knowledge / experience that sits in emoyees heads is really as good as it needs to be to produce aircraft which don't end up being hangar queens. If I was an airline CEO, the idea of manufacturer employees having to essentially relearn things they/their colleagues hadn't done for years to be a bit of a concern

mullac30 9th Dec 2018 19:05

The only possible reason for LM to want a dodgy brand new Brazillia is commonality with the ERJs. ATR family makes much more sense.

virginblue 10th Dec 2018 07:59


Originally Posted by tibbs87 (Post 10331782)
True, they ceased main production of the aircraft in 2001, but they do build new Brasilia's on request, as the Angolan Air Force received newly built EMB 120s in 2007.

Why would you go from 34 seat Saab 340s to 28 seat Embraer 120s? Despite them being availble as built to order, apparently nobody in the past 17 years has ordered any. Must be for some reason.

The 30seater market simply is a non-starter and even the 50seat market is struggling, given the small number of orders for the only available 50 seater turborprop. The ATR42 more or less has become a niche application for those who cannot make use of ATR72s on short runways (like in the Bahamas, the Caribbean etc.) I understand that the operating costs for both ATRs are more or less the same so it appears to be a non-brainer to have an additional 25 seats to toy around with if acquisition costs for ATR72 are not much higher than for ATR42s.

Arctic Circle 10th Dec 2018 18:02

Operating costs are very similar. The 42 only requies one cabin attendant. More importantly for Loganair, the 42 has better crosswind capabilities than the 72.


Rob Royston 12th Dec 2018 10:24

The ATR has a much poorer safety record than the Saab 340. I'm basing this on 2014 data. Should this be a concern for Loganair?

The Listener 12th Dec 2018 12:15

Seems a bit like comparing apples with oranges so to speak....
When you were basing this how many ATR (42 and/or 72) against how many SAAB 340's? Hundreds against dozen(s)?

Just asking :-)

Arctic Circle 12th Dec 2018 17:26


Consider to which parts of the world many newer ATRs have been sold. The safety record here in Europe is very good.

scr1 12th Dec 2018 19:25

According to their twitter feed their will be a announcement in the new year

https://twitter.com/FlyLoganair

Rob Royston 12th Dec 2018 22:19


Originally Posted by The Listener (Post 10333944)
Seems a bit like comparing apples with oranges so to speak....
When you were basing this how many ATR (42 and/or 72) against how many SAAB 340's? Hundreds against dozen(s)?

Just asking :-)

I can't find it now, but it was fatalities per one million take offs. The ATR's were at 0.44 and the Saab 340 was on 0.19. It was based on data of all incidents up to 2014.

Flightrider 13th Dec 2018 06:31

I’ve never known an airline evaluation of a new type to be conducted in internet search statistics, to be honest. But if they did - as A 42/72 would on average be carrying about double the number of passengers of a 340, you’d expect this metric to be about double if the accident rates themselves were the same, surely?

Rob Royston 13th Dec 2018 13:57


Originally Posted by TangoAlphad (Post 10334530)
It is more complicated than that. How may of those ATR accidents came down to pilot error or being operated in inherently more dangerous areas? If you look at Saabs that have a serious failure leading to a loss of life vs ATR etc and came up with those numbers you can maybe have an argument to say they aren't as safe but there are a lot of cowboy outfits in ATR's that could really skew that number.

I found where I got it from, maybe I'm reading it incorrectly. There was a problem with icing on the ATR's in the earlier models. If you click on the FLE link it makes you to another page.

http://www.airsafe.com/events/models/rate_mod.htm

rhutch28 19th Dec 2018 12:57


Originally Posted by BAladdy (Post 10330788)
Any word on when LM are going to announce there new European routes from GLA?.

Glasgow to Dusseldorf flight start on 31 March 2019, Taking over from Eurowings
https://www.eveningtimes.co.uk/news/...y-in-new-year/

Fly757X 19th Dec 2018 16:51

G-SAJC (Ex G-RJXF) entered service today which relieved G-SAJB from Inverness for maintainence at Aberdeen.

DND delivery 20th Dec 2018 09:41


Originally Posted by Rob Royston (Post 10334877)
I found where I got it from, maybe I'm reading it incorrectly. There was a problem with icing on the ATR's in the earlier models. If you click on the FLE link it makes you to another page.

There was an American Eagle ATR72 crash in 1994 (Roselawn), a combination of icing and pilot error. They modified the de-icing boots after that accident.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.