PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Is Ukraine about to have a war? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/639666-ukraine-about-have-war.html)

Thud_and_Blunder 19th Aug 2022 15:42

Meanwhile, a redditor found this linky from Twatter (you'll have to quote this post to see the link):
..a Russian drone was downed, within which was found an SD card with video showing the base from which it was launched and the operator who made the recording.

fitliker 19th Aug 2022 16:02


Originally Posted by BlankBox (Post 11281430)
https://www.reddit.com/r/UkraineWarV...fireball_near/

DAMN!! ...what was that boy carrying?

The turret went really , is that the record or have there been greater heights reached. It got lost in the expanding smoke at about 250 feet so it may have went higher in the smoke . Are there any more videos showing reasons to avoid tank regiments ?

BANANASBANANAS 19th Aug 2022 16:21


Originally Posted by safetypee (Post 11281416)
If power station is attacked then;

Remove the restriction on NATO (US) supplied long range weapons for use only within Ukraine

As much as that might provide some short term satisfaction it would all but guarantee such an escalation that we would have a full on NATO v Russia conflict very quickly. That said, I think that is getting more and more likely anyway. Vlad is getting his butt kicked and he knows it even if his people haven't been told yet. He can't/won't back down and fairly soon either his own people will have to take him out or he will behave like a cornered wild animal. A wild animal with a finger on a nuclear trigger.

Usertim 19th Aug 2022 16:37


Originally Posted by BANANASBANANAS (Post 11281464)
As much as that might provide some short term satisfaction it would all but guarantee such an escalation that we would have a full on NATO v Russia conflict very quickly. That said, I think that is getting more and more likely anyway. Vlad is getting his butt kicked and he knows it even if his people haven't been told yet. He can't/won't back down and fairly soon either his own people will have to take him out or he will behave like a cornered wild animal. A wild animal with a finger on a nuclear trigger.

At the point where someone blows up 6 reactor cores and knowingly dumps millions of bequerels of radiation over western europe do you not think that is already full conflict?
I would definitely expect Art.5 activation to be requested by all those NATO eastern europe countries.
Let us hope it does not come to that.

NutLoose 19th Aug 2022 16:44

The guys gone one hundred percent fruity loops… I do wonder if the Russian population has a clue as to what will happen, it’s ok those dickheads on Russian State TV saying the we can nuke them, one missile and the U.K. is gone crap, but they fail to mention that it is a two sided sword. And a sword that will be difficult to put back in its scabbard.

albatross 19th Aug 2022 17:22

I assume the SD card would also have very good video and GPS position information of its flight path to the location it was downed. Such information could be most useful. Perhaps the SD stands for Sudden Death if any useful targets it overflew can be identified and taken out.


Originally Posted by Thud_and_Blunder (Post 11281439)
Meanwhile, a redditor found this linky from Twatter (you'll have to quote this post to see the link):
https://twitter.com/PaulJawin/status...16212383162373
..a Russian drone was downed, within which was found an SD card with video showing the base from which it was launched and the operator who made the recording.


MPN11 19th Aug 2022 17:40

BBC ...

  • Russia's President Putin has agreed in a call with France's President Macron on the need for a visit to the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant by inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). the Kremlin says
  • A visit to the facility could take place in September, a Russian diplomat has said

Don't stand down, but perhaps breathe more easily this weekend?

NutLoose 19th Aug 2022 17:46

Footage just released from way back in May of the fight for Snake Island


Lonewolf_50 19th Aug 2022 17:56

As to nuclear weapons (not the plant) I think Putin's bluffing, and using the various talking heads to trumpet that about is a smoke screen.

Originally Posted by Usertim (Post 11281469)
At the point where someone blows up 6 reactor cores and knowingly dumps millions of bequerels of radiation over western europe do you not think that is already full conflict? I would definitely expect Art.5 activation to be requested by all those NATO eastern europe countries. Let us hope it does not come to that.

Indeed, let's hope not. You have an interesting take on applying Article V, and I think it probably fits within the intent. *tips cap*

Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11281474)
... it’s ok those dickheads on Russian State TV saying the we can nuke them, one missile and the U.K. is gone crap, but they fail to mention that it is a two sided sword. And a sword that will be difficult to put back in its scabbard.

Difficult indeed, it's one of those irreversible decisions.

Originally Posted by MPN11 (Post 11281509)
Don't stand down, but perhaps breathe more easily this weekend?

Glad to see that a few level headed suggestions are being considered.

FUMR 19th Aug 2022 18:02

Glad to see that a few level headed suggestions are being considered.

The only problem I have is that I no longer believe ANYTHING that Putin says!

Tartiflette Fan 19th Aug 2022 18:06

Surprisingly there has been no discussion of the explosions that happened close to/on the Belbek airfield last night. This is one of the last remaining major airfields in Crimea, therefore of major significance for the Russkis, with a good number of fighter aircraft based there ( can't recall where I read that ) and therefore likely aircraft losses

Has no one seen/read anything ?

etudiant 19th Aug 2022 18:14


Originally Posted by Usertim (Post 11281469)
At the point where someone blows up 6 reactor cores and knowingly dumps millions of bequerels of radiation over western europe do you not think that is already full conflict?
I would definitely expect Art.5 activation to be requested by all
those NATO eastern europe countries.
Let us hope it does not come to that.


With the winds as currently blowing, the radioactivity would mostly impact Odessa, Turkey and maybe Crimea, rather than western Europe..
Highly recommend this site https://earth.nullschool.net/ to see the local winds, it was useful during the Fukushima disaster.

It seems obvious that Russia, which controls the site, wants to unplug this facility from the Ukraine grid.
That would be damaging to Ukraine, so they are pointing out forcibly that the site is very vulnerable and that any accidents there would mostly impact Russia.
So there is a method to the madness, while both sides blame each other for events both provoke.

Tartiflette Fan 19th Aug 2022 18:15


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 11281519)
As to nuclear weapons (not the plant) I
Indeed, let's hope not. You have an interesting take on applying Article V, and I think it probably fits within the intent. *tips cap*
Difficult indeed, it's one of those irreversible decisions..

I'm not interested to make this a political discussion, but Britain is currently shackled with a cretin as a PM ( speaking as a conservative supporter ) and I really wouldn't want him to be involved in any such existential decisions.

langleybaston 19th Aug 2022 18:18


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11281530)
With the winds as currently blowing, the radioactivity would mostly impact Odessa, Turkey and maybe Crimea, rather than western Europe..
Highly recommend this site https://earth.nullschool.net/ to see the local winds, it was useful during the Fukushima disaster.

It seems obvious that Russia, which controls the site, wants to unplug this facility from the Ukraine grid.
That would be damaging to Ukraine, so they are pointing out forcibly that the site is very vulnerable and that any accidents there would mostly impact Russia.
So there is a method to the madness, while both sides blame each other for events both provoke.

A straight short answer to a straight short question please:

WHICH EVENTS DID UKRAINE PROVOKE?

Video Mixdown 19th Aug 2022 19:31


Originally Posted by Tartiflette Fan (Post 11281533)
I'm not interested to make this a political discussion.

Why do it then? For the record It is due in no small part to UK government decisions that Ukraine is still in the fight at all - an opinion freely acknowledged by Ukraine itself.

ORAC 19th Aug 2022 20:33

https://www.defensenews.com/pentagon...ian-artillery/

Seek and destroy’: New US aid to Ukraine targets Russian artillery

WASHINGTON ― A new $775 million military aid package for Ukraine marks the first time the U.S. is sending ScanEagle drones, for targeting artillery, as well as 105mm howitzers and anti-tank rounds for the Carl Gustaf rifle to the fight against Russia, the Pentagon announced Friday.

The latest package of U.S. aid to Ukraine also includes the AGM-88 high-speed anti-radiation missile, which will allow Ukrainian forces to target Russian radars in the artillery-focused war. The disclosure marks the first time the Pentagon has discussed its provision of high-speed anti-radiation missiles to Ukraine in detail.

“Ukraine has successfully employed these missiles. They have successfully integrated them onto Ukrainian aircraft. And this enables Ukraine to seek and destroy Russian radars,” a senior defense official told reporters. The Pentagon provided the official for comment on condition of anonymity.

The Pentagon is sending 15 ScanEagles ― a small, long-endurance, low-altitude drone made by Insitu and used for reconnaissance, which is intended to help guide targeting for Ukrainian artillery. Other firsts include 16 105mm howitzers (with 36,000 artillery rounds) as well as 1,000, tube-launched, optically tracked anti-tank missiles for Carl Gustaf weapons sent by other allies.

The aid also includes 40 mine-resistant, ambush-protected vehicles for mine-clearing, 50 Humvees and 1,000 Javelin anti-tank weapons….

ORAC 19th Aug 2022 20:55

"80% of Wagner recruits will not come back from Ukraine", says Evgeny Prigozhin, Wagner owner (and Putin's chief recruiter for Ukraine invasion)

Wokkafans 19th Aug 2022 21:21


etudiant 19th Aug 2022 21:45


Originally Posted by langleybaston (Post 11281535)
A straight short answer to a straight short question please:

WHICH EVENTS DID UKRAINE PROVOKE?

For the plant, shelling items near it.
Seriously, we had the video yesterday of Excaliburs plinking individual towing trucks in shelters, looked like under 10 feet error.
So Ukraine has the means to hit any target near the plant without damaging the facility itself. If they don't, it is to send a message.

meleagertoo 19th Aug 2022 22:24

This is looking like a resort to nuclear blackmail.

Putain is militarily stuck and hugely embarrassed verging on humiliated and being a 'little man' he can't accept that.

Occupying a nuc plant gives him several advantages.

Tactically, a safe place to amass weapons and troops as the other side daren't retaliate.
Strategically, a guaranteed way to utterly and globally discredit the other side if they do.
Plus he opportunity to do that 'false flag' even if they don't.
An unanswerable bargaining chip to ensure any 'negotiation' towards ending the conflict goes his way.

I can see no disadvantages to Russia in doing this - at least, no disadvantages that they care about - and as massive radiological disaster is not one that much bothers them they hold all the cards here.

I can't see what anyone can do in the face of this.

Low average 19th Aug 2022 22:30

Of course it's blackmail. The Russians have held the nuclear gun to the World's head numerous times since this all started. As per normal, combined with their lying/distortion/blaming the innocent. Pretty simple really.

cynicalint 19th Aug 2022 22:48


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11281632)
For the plant, shelling items near it.
Seriously, we had the video yesterday of Excaliburs plinking individual towing trucks in shelters, looked like under 10 feet error.
So Ukraine has the means to hit any target near the plant without damaging the facility itself. If they don't, it is to send a message.

Provocation
noun [ C or U ]
UK /ˌprɒv.əˈkeɪ.ʃən/ US /ˌprɑː.vəˈkeɪ.ʃən/ an action or statement that is intended to make someone angry:

I would suggest that invading a sovereign country and placing 'targets' near a Nuclear plant fits well within that definition.
Russia is the provocateur here, NOT Ukraine!

T28B 20th Aug 2022 00:37

If I may make an appeal for a bit more aviation content.
Asking for a friend. ;)

fdr 20th Aug 2022 00:40


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11281530)
So there is a method to the madness, while both sides blame each other for events both provoke.


Etu, do you think about facts at all before you send, or just hit send? What provocation did Ukraine make to you Russians, other than the discovery of more hydrocarbons under Donbas?

1. Russia had access to Sevastopol by Ukraine in accordance with the aggreement that Ukraine entered into with Russia, Ukraine kept their word. Russia lied, as always;
2. Russia formented unrest in Luhansk, and Donetysk, and gave specious arguments for Crimea, in direct breach of the Alma-Ata protocol that was binding, Russia, lied, as always;
3. Russia invaded Ukraine under the pretext of
(i) de-nazification Russia being the fascist state
(ii) protection of the "Russian's" in Luhansk and Donetsk, that is the ones they gave passports to post hoc. The same people that they conscripted into their illegal war, and the same people that Russian troops raped, murdered, and had their microwaves, TV's, cars, tractors, combine harvesters swapped for T-72's (slightly used, fixer uppers). Russia lied, as always;
(iii) Russia attacked a NPP at Chernobyl...
(iv) Russia has attacked ZNPP....

Russia is a terrorist state, under the august leadership of the dear leader, as a consequence of the lack of moral fortitude that the masses of Russia exhibit in great volume. Those that speak out against the wholesale criminalisation of Russia under its leaders end up glowing in the dark, smelling of Novochok and other responses, such as falling out of closed windows, accidentally shooting themselves 12 times, and otherwise meeting unpleasant ends.

Please stop defending the indefensible. At some point in time, you will look in a mirror and you will not be able to stand what you see. Your country needs patriots to return the country to the people and get it out of the road to ruin that Putin and the rest of the excrement that exudes from the crimlin represent.


You are purportedly in a free country, so the hypocrisy of your words should be called out for what they are. If you like what Putin has done to the Russians, then go home, enjoy. Please send a message to your dear leader though, that he is not welcome in his neighbouring countries, from Chechnya, Ukraine, Moldova, Belorus, Kazakhstan, Siberia, etc.... go home, please go home now.

:)

In response to T28B's appeal for aviation content, please fly home, take Aeroflot, or whatever else is still flying in Russia other than missiles.

rattman 20th Aug 2022 00:46

These could be very interesting for the a SOF in crimea / russia


Beamr 20th Aug 2022 01:05

Not your ordinary supermarket drone:

Payload 8 x 60mm mortar grenade.
MTOW 43kg
endurance 20-40min
Range 20km

If 800 is accurate figure, it is a lot.


etudiant 20th Aug 2022 01:16


Originally Posted by fdr (Post 11281676)
Etu, do you think about facts at all before you send, or just hit send? What provocation did Ukraine make to you Russians, other than the discovery of more hydrocarbons under Donbas?

1. Russia had access to Sevastopol by Ukraine in accordance with the aggreement that Ukraine entered into with Russia, Ukraine kept their word. Russia lied, as always;
2. Russia formented unrest in Luhansk, and Donetysk, and gave specious arguments for Crimea, in direct breach of the Alma-Ata protocol that was binding, Russia, lied, as always;
3. Russia invaded Ukraine under the pretext of
(i) de-nazification Russia being the fascist state
(ii) protection of the "Russian's" in Luhansk and Donetsk, that is the ones they gave passports to post hoc. The same people that they conscripted into their illegal war, and the same people that Russian troops raped, murdered, and had their microwaves, TV's, cars, tractors, combine harvesters swapped for T-72's (slightly used, fixer uppers). Russia lied, as always;
(iii) Russia attacked a NPP at Chernobyl...
(iv) Russia has attacked ZNPP....

Russia is a terrorist state, under the august leadership of the dear leader, as a consequence of the lack of moral fortitude that the masses of Russia exhibit in great volume. Those that speak out against the wholesale criminalisation of Russia under its leaders end up glowing in the dark, smelling of Novochok and other responses, such as falling out of closed windows, accidentally shooting themselves 12 times, and otherwise meeting unpleasant ends.

Please stop defending the indefensible. At some point in time, you will look in a mirror and you will not be able to stand what you see. Your country needs patriots to return the country to the people and get it out of the road to ruin that Putin and the rest of the excrement that exudes from the crimlin represent.


You are purportedly in a free country, so the hypocrisy of your words should be called out for what they are. If you like what Putin has done to the Russians, then go home, enjoy. Please send a message to your dear leader though, that he is not welcome in his neighbouring countries, from Chechnya, Ukraine, Moldova, Belorus, Kazakhstan, Siberia, etc.... go home, please go home now.

:)

In response to T28B's appeal for aviation content, please fly home, take Aeroflot, or whatever else is still flying in Russia other than missiles.

fdr,

Imho, the Maidan revolution transformed the situation for Russia, a previously friendly country became hostile. When the facts change, countries adjust their policies, else they fail, gradually or rapidly.
Russia's reaction was entirely predictable and was in fact predicted by most of the US foreign policy veterans who had experience in Russia. Unfortunately they were ignored.
The disaster we now face was entirely avoidable, a little sense of putting yourself into the other guy's shoes would have done the trick.

Pontificating about the unprovoked assault on Ukraine while ignoring the post Maidan civil war in Donbas is rewriting history.
Likewise, claiming all the responsibility was from Putin's 'little green men' is convenient, but unsupported by the evidence from independent observers.

Now we are in a war, bullish for the MIC, which has its testing ground for modern weapons and massive replacement demand, but a horror show that is worsening for everyone who lives in the region.
Worse, we have stupidly allowed our client state to decide what conditions it will accept to make peace. That kind of blank check worked out badly in 1914, it seems we have not learned anything.
Meanwhile, bellicose war nerds cheer the death of masses of 'orcs' here on PPRN, as though the Russians were not likewise human beings. I don't see the situation in Ukraine that way

Low average 20th Aug 2022 02:14

Nope. Ukraine's conditions are simple and reasonable. All they want is for the Russians to stop killing them, stealing their resources and get out! So do it.

megan 20th Aug 2022 02:16


as though the Russians were not likewise human beings
Their conduct is not one associated with human beings, decapitations, castrations, murder of civilians, rape, I'd say that's why folk cheer.

we have stupidly allowed our client state to decide what conditions it will accept to make peace
It aint your client state, haven't you got the memo? It's you who started this fraca, so they have every right to make the rules.

NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 02:43

US has confirmed the Ukrainian MIG 29 have been equipped with the AGM88 HARM missile, I suppose some of the reported drone shoot downs of late might be attempts to get the Russian AD radars to revel their locations and some of the reported explosions around the likes of Kherson, Kerch and Sevastopol?


The Pentagon has now officially confirmed that it has transferred AGM-88 High-speed Anti-Radiation Missiles, or HARMs, to the Ukrainian Air Force. This comes nearly two weeks after U.S. Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Colin Kahl had confirmed the delivery of unspecified anti-radiation missiles to Ukraine's armed forces. The evidence of HARM usage in Ukraine had first appeared on social media just days before Kahl's comments, and more had subsequently emerged online.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world...es/ar-AA10QDWj

NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 02:54

Additional helicopters transferred to Ukraine from Latvia.
To put that in context, they only have 4 helicopters in service, 4 MI17. So that is 50% of their active helicopter fleet. Superb effort and kudos to them :D

https://twitter.com/UAWeapons/status/1559235188114194433

https://mezha.media/en/2022/08/16/latvia-for-ukraine-6-m109a5-self-propelled-guns-4-helicopters-and-fundraising-for-bayraktar-tb2/


..

magyarflyer 20th Aug 2022 03:34


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11281632)
For the plant, shelling items near it.
Seriously, we had the video yesterday of Excaliburs plinking individual towing trucks in shelters, looked like under 10 feet error.
So Ukraine has the means to hit any target near the plant without damaging the facility itself. If they don't, it is to send a message.

plinking the trucks in a nuclear power plant? Did you see the video from inside the power plant showing the military material stored inside? Are you serious?
reality has become a fiction to you

NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 03:35

Who put that bloody cellar there..


NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 03:37


Originally Posted by magyarflyer (Post 11281717)
plinking the trucks in a nuclear power plant? Did you see the video from inside the power plant showing the military material stored inside? Are you serious?
reality has become a fiction to you

Especially as they are reported to be full of explosive.

tartare 20th Aug 2022 04:09

I fort the nuclear plant was designed to be so strong as to be able to be hit by an airliner and still hold it's structural integrity.
Am I missing something here?

NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 04:11


The fact that explosions in Crimea - a place previously considered to be well beyond the reach of any Ukrainian attack - were watched by thousands of Russian tourists, many of whom have since fled Crimea back into Russia, has had a psychological effect in Moscow, officials told the media.

That reads like the Ukrainians chose the time to attack not just to hit the airbase, but to coordinate it with the height of the holiday season to cause the maximum effect at home when the shocked fleeing tourists would return to the likes of Moscow, there was no way of controlling nor keeping a lid on that story, all their false stories being shown on the Russian news channels would be shown for what they are.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world...bef336a0bd9826

NutLoose 20th Aug 2022 04:15


Originally Posted by tartare (Post 11281722)
I fort the nuclear plant was designed to be so strong as to be able to be hit by an airliner and still hold it's structural integrity.
Am I missing something here?

The Twin Towers were designed to withstand a 707 direct hit, says it all really.

It all depends on what is hit and where, take out the reactor cooling and you have problems, containment integrity or not. Plus you also have the stored waste in water tanks.

says it all really


BANANASBANANAS 20th Aug 2022 04:48


Originally Posted by Usertim (Post 11281469)
At the point where someone blows up 6 reactor cores and knowingly dumps millions of bequerels of radiation over western europe do you not think that is already full conflict?
I would definitely expect Art.5 activation to be requested by all those NATO eastern europe countries.
Let us hope it does not come to that.

If 6 reactor cores are blown then, yes, I would agree. But Putin is sly and I would suspect something much smaller but which still carried a great threat and which Putin would then try to use as some form of negotiating lever.

ORAC 20th Aug 2022 06:12

A UAV struck the Black Sea Fleet’s headquarters in Sevastopol, according to Crimean officials.

Pali 20th Aug 2022 06:40


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11281690)
fdr,

Imho, the Maidan revolution transformed the situation for Russia, a previously friendly country became hostile. When the facts change, countries adjust their policies, else they fail, gradually or rapidly.
Russia's reaction was entirely predictable and was in fact predicted by most of the US foreign policy veterans who had experience in Russia. Unfortunately they were ignored.

You simply ignore the fact that nations want freedom. In your logic the bloody crushing of Hungary in 1956 was "predictable". In your logic the invasion to Czechoslovakia in 1968 was "predictable". Chechnya, Transnistria, Georgia, Ukraine all of them are supposed to be raped and subdued because Putin wants to be like tzar and no nation in the Russian zone of interest has any right to be independent and allied to defend itself from Russian aggression.

So I translate your thinking to the rest of the forum – anyone resisting Russian imperialism needs "denazification" and Russia has every right to invade, kill, rape and turn cities into rubble.

The time when Stalin and Hitler (and other dictators alike) agreed on marking the lands which they grabbed under their rule is over. We are lucky that your "foreign policy veterans" were ignored, now is the time to teach Russians a lesson.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:11.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.