What are your pet hate non-standard phraseologies?
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 16
Likes: 0
From: Zürich
I have used "Tango Romeo Alpha" instead of "Trasadingen". But when i give "Tange Romeo Alpha" most time (about 97%) reply was "Roger direct Trasadingen" (even foreign pilots Air China, Korean Air, Ryan Air)...
And if the pilot have a problem reading back "Trasadingen" my next message will be "direct Trasadingen Tango Romeo Alpha"...
cheers
Johannes
And if the pilot have a problem reading back "Trasadingen" my next message will be "direct Trasadingen Tango Romeo Alpha"...
cheers
Johannes

Joined: Jul 2001
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 185
Likes: 0
From: Ultima Thule
I have used "Tango Romeo Alpha" instead of "Trasadingen". But when i give "Tange Romeo Alpha" most time (about 97%) reply was "Roger direct Trasadingen" (even foreign pilots Air China, Korean Air, Ryan Air)...
And if the pilot have a problem reading back "Trasadingen" my next message will be "direct Trasadingen Tango Romeo Alpha"...
cheers
Johannes
And if the pilot have a problem reading back "Trasadingen" my next message will be "direct Trasadingen Tango Romeo Alpha"...
cheers
Johannes
That's good to hear that at least ATC is understandable that not everyone has years of experience and knows the names of each and every VOR. I guess it also depends on how fast it is read out and degree of accent. Believe my most of us are all trying to improve every aspect of our professionalism each time we fly, ATC is just one of those things.
Regards,
Proxus
the lunatic fringe

Joined: May 2001
Posts: 621
Likes: 5
From: Everywhere
"ABC123, fully ready"
Is this everyones pet gripe? Come on TRE's, get it sorted. Or maybe it's a flying school issue, it seems particularly prevalent in airlines with a younger pilot age profile.
Is this everyones pet gripe? Come on TRE's, get it sorted. Or maybe it's a flying school issue, it seems particularly prevalent in airlines with a younger pilot age profile.
ATC: "ABC123, is MAG/Omelo/GMH etc on your flightplan?"
ABC123: "stand-by" (or just silence).
Next time why not read your flightplan in advance and know where you're going?
ABC123: "stand-by" (or just silence).
Next time why not read your flightplan in advance and know where you're going?
"Hello London, ABC123 FL360 direct STU"
Whatever about non-locals to London ATC, can't at least the locals read the AIP about what/what not to correctly transmit?
Whatever about non-locals to London ATC, can't at least the locals read the AIP about what/what not to correctly transmit?
"ABC123 request"
Oooh, a puzzle this one as always. Do you want a new FL, runway infomation or airplay of "Danger Zone" by Kenny Loggins? Must be a lot of shy pilots out there, but don't be, just ask for what you want.
Oooh, a puzzle this one as always. Do you want a new FL, runway infomation or airplay of "Danger Zone" by Kenny Loggins? Must be a lot of shy pilots out there, but don't be, just ask for what you want.
ATIS: "Initial contact with approach with callsign only"
"Approach, ABC123, good morning to you, descending to 3000ft on qnh 1010, heading 100 degrees, speed 180 kts"
Is reading the bloody ATIS so difficult? In the mean time, as you spout forth your ignorance, I've been left high as the g/s disappears below.
"Approach, ABC123, good morning to you, descending to 3000ft on qnh 1010, heading 100 degrees, speed 180 kts"
Is reading the bloody ATIS so difficult? In the mean time, as you spout forth your ignorance, I've been left high as the g/s disappears below.
Tiny England is just that, tiny. The world is a big place and it happens differently everywhere, and everywhere is different from everywhere else. Sometimes that nasty foreign stuff impinges on your tiny world and irritates the life out of you.
I will try harder, if you agree to go to counselling.
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 73
Likes: 0
From: EHAA
You are correct, but in defence of others, that "Initial contact with approach with callsign only" request, is only ever made at LHR. Nowhere I have ever been, all round the world, does ATC made that request except at LHR going to 126.9. It is a UK thing.
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
From: Australia
All,
May I suggest a list of standard, "non-standard" phraseologies...then we can talk about the "non-standard", standard "non standard phraseologies!"
It's a big world. That is the beauty of it.
Anyway, if this is your major problem...controllers or pilots, then you have more than that to worry about!!!
TB.
May I suggest a list of standard, "non-standard" phraseologies...then we can talk about the "non-standard", standard "non standard phraseologies!"
It's a big world. That is the beauty of it.
Anyway, if this is your major problem...controllers or pilots, then you have more than that to worry about!!!
TB.

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 159
Likes: 9
From: Euroland
And I witnessed a trainee perform the following exchange which made me cringe.
"Thai XXX, expect a couple of spins at XYZ, bring back the speed now"
"Say again"
"Thai XXX expect a couple of spins at XYZ bring back your speed"
"Thai XXX not understand, say again"
Trainee now getting a bit irate... "Thai XXX, bring back the speed, you're going to hold!!"
Long pause....
I take the RT.
"Thai XXX hold at XYZ, reduce to minimum clean speed"
"Hold at XYZ reduce minimum clean, Thai XXX"
"Thai XXX, expect a couple of spins at XYZ, bring back the speed now"
"Say again"
"Thai XXX expect a couple of spins at XYZ bring back your speed"
"Thai XXX not understand, say again"
Trainee now getting a bit irate... "Thai XXX, bring back the speed, you're going to hold!!"
Long pause....
I take the RT.
"Thai XXX hold at XYZ, reduce to minimum clean speed"
"Hold at XYZ reduce minimum clean, Thai XXX"

Show this page to the trainee Spin (flight) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia)
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 4,563
Likes: 33
From: I wouldn't know.
You are correct, but in defence of others, that "Initial contact with approach with callsign only" request, is only ever made at LHR. Nowhere I have ever been, all round the world, does ATC made that request except at LHR going to 126.9. It is a UK thing.
More than just an ATCO
Joined: Jul 1999
Posts: 1,773
Likes: 1
From: Up someone's nose
Not non-standard, but pilots who request descent then, a minute later,when several aircraft below have been vectored out their way, say, "We'll call you leaving." 
Big temptation to say, "Descent clearance cancelled , maintain FL360 to the hold." and put everyone back on own nav.

There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamed of in your philosophy

Big temptation to say, "Descent clearance cancelled , maintain FL360 to the hold." and put everyone back on own nav.
I will try harder, if you agree to go to counselling
There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamed of in your philosophy
Last edited by Lon More; 25th August 2010 at 11:43.
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
From: in the middle
to bArt2
i never met any *a couple of spins *or *bring the speed down*in the phraseology-sounds like a James Bond talking on the frequency.Not professionally,let alone saying you were talking to a crew that probably only has ICAO English level 4.
Ur trainee was getting irritated?Show him the documents.
And you probably noticed-was no problem at all for the crew to understand what he was saying when started to use aviation language.
i never met any *a couple of spins *or *bring the speed down*in the phraseology-sounds like a James Bond talking on the frequency.Not professionally,let alone saying you were talking to a crew that probably only has ICAO English level 4.
Ur trainee was getting irritated?Show him the documents.
And you probably noticed-was no problem at all for the crew to understand what he was saying when started to use aviation language.




