PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   EC notice on BREXIT issued, licenses/certificates invalid (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/607757-ec-notice-brexit-issued-licenses-certificates-invalid.html)

777JRM 1st Aug 2019 19:38

Remember that EASA is not the EU.

Further, the CAA was independent once before; if they pull their finger out, they can be so again!

The UK does have a choice, and should not be weak when faced with such scaremongering!

By your patronising reckoning, I must be an ‘idiot’.

How other non-EU airlines somehow work it out, is beyond my feeble, idiotic brain cells, but all is not lost.

Tom Sawyer 2nd Aug 2019 03:57


Originally Posted by 777JRM (Post 105343)
How other non-EU airlines somehow work it out, is beyond my feeble, idiotic brain cells, but all is not lost.

Probably because they operate under their NAA with approved regulations and Licences already in place that have no doubt taken years to develop and evolve. Come 1st November, in event of a hard exit, what approved and legislated regulations and Licences will the CAA have in place? As yet I have not seen anything issued by them as a standalone NAA, or advice that they have all this in place ready to go.

DaveReidUK 2nd Aug 2019 06:33


Originally Posted by 777JRM (Post 10534311)
Further, the CAA was independent once before; if they pull their finger out, they can be so again!

Yes, all the CAA needs to do is to have started the transition process about 10 years ago ...


If continued UK membership of EASA cannot be agreed, the UK could empower the UK CAA to discharge all the UK’s ICAO responsibilities. This would require the UK CAA to rebuild its competence in the many areas of an NAA’s remit which are currently delegated to EASA. Given the large number [around 300] of additional specialist staff needed, and the new systems and processes that would need to be put in place and used by industry, this could not be achieved by March 2019. Most of the specialists who carried out these tasks in the CAA prior to EASA taking them over have gone to EASA, taken on other work at the CAA, or retired. Based on the UK’s experience of transference of regulatory responsibility to the European level back in 2002, there is no evidence to suggest that a ‘reverse transfer’ back to the UK would be less challenging.

Under this scenario, a multi-year transition would be needed, during which activities would gradually move under the CAA’s direction. If suitable transition measures were not put in place there would be disruption of services following Brexit, increased costs to business, and almost certainly loss of business to UK companies. The reasons for this have been covered in the section on how the system works today with EASA above. Indeed, if this scenario appears likely during 2018 it is likely that the uncertainty will already cause UK industry to lose business. Businesses which have operations in multiple countries might decide to move some activities out of the UK and other businesses might move out of the UK. Clearly this would not be an option in every case. In any event, such moves would not be beneficial to the UK economy.

A transition period with high levels of change is not good for product safety assurance, as it takes the focus away from assuring every task is done correctly and from continuous improvement requiring additional work that does not add to safety. This situation would be worse if the transition period was badly managed, or indeed if there was an attempt to manage with no transition period and all the competent resources and system were not in place at Brexit.
Civil Aviation Regulation: What Future after Brexit?

Speed of Sound 2nd Aug 2019 09:33


Originally Posted by 777JRM (Post 10534311)
Remember that EASA is not the EU.

Further, the CAA was independent once before; if they pull their finger out, they can be so again!

The UK does have a choice, and should not be weak when faced with such scaremongering!

EASA is part of the EU and as such, is ultimately subject to the European Court of Justice. Non-EU European countries have associate membership of EASA and are also ultimately subject to the ECJ.

If you identify with the ‘idiots’ I referred to earlier, maybe you could tell me what choices the UK has to remain flying on 1 November. If you are saying that this is simply scaremongering, you really do need to come up with a realistic alternative within three months.

Your move!



robin 2nd Aug 2019 10:25

Given the quite scathing summary Andrew Haines described in the paper - it basically says there is little benefit in not remaining a full EASA member and a whole load of serious issues if not - I can sort of understand for certain sectors, there will be big problems.

My CAMO has already stated that if they have to go through a reregistration process, they will be retiring. They've had more than enough problems and cost over recent years dealing with EASA changes. They won't be doing that again.

But the CAA has been VERY quiet over recent months so we don't know where they are at with preparations. Still now we have Grant Shapps/Michael Green as SoS for Transport, all will be well ....!

Mickey Kaye 2nd Aug 2019 13:24

And what about if a post brexit CAA say from now on we approve the individual not the organisation?

Maintainance would suddenly become a whole lot easier.

ExDubai 2nd Aug 2019 16:53


Originally Posted by Mickey Kaye (Post 10534924)
And what about if a post brexit CAA say from now on we approve the individual not the organisation?

Maintainance would suddenly become a whole lot easier.

It looks like a lot of companies believe it’s better to stay under EASA rules.
https://amp.theguardian.com/business...eave-regulator

His dudeness 2nd Aug 2019 17:14


Why would the EU offer an EASA membership for a third country that just destroyed a peace treaty they have signed, does not fulfill its past obligations and seriously disrupts EU commerce? Answer: It wouldn't. Easy as that. The EU has already done its homework with its unilateral no deal legislation that it can withdraw without prior notice at any time, just protecting its own interests. And Airlines, workers, shareholders in a third country are not an interest to the EU.
Whilst I think you are right, I guess we all know that the owner of the UK and the EU (big business) will make it clear to their respective Governments that they have to work something out.

BTW, there is a training company in the UK just changing all their licenses to the Austrian authority - whilst staying on their premises close to London.

radiosutch 4th Aug 2019 09:47


Originally Posted by Denti (Post 10533956)
Why would the EU offer an EASA membership for a third country that just destroyed a peace treaty they have signed, does not fulfill its past obligations and seriously disrupts EU commerce? Answer: It wouldn't. Easy as that. The EU has already done its homework with its unilateral no deal legislation that it can withdraw without prior notice at any time, just protecting its own interests. And Airlines, workers, shareholders in a third country are not an interest to the EU.

Light on facts here
1) How is the WA a peace treaty? Are we at war with the EU ? War of words maybe, but not guns and bullets . Poor choice of words
2) How has the UK 'destroyed' anything ? The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. I don't think the UK has actually destroyed anything at present
3) How has the UK 'not fulfil' past obligations. The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed. I don't think the UK has actually failed to fulfill any obligation at present
4) How "disrupts EU commerce" This is getting repetitive, The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. I don't think the UK has actually disrupted anything at present

Wow, what an easy post to demolish !

lilpilot 5th Aug 2019 19:33

Denti is referring to the Good Friday Agreement/Belfast Agreement as the peace treaty, not the WA.

pr00ne 6th Aug 2019 17:58

radiosutch,

​​​​​​"The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. "

No, they are not. They are not in ANY kind of negotiation. THAT is the very worrying point in all this.

jjohn 6th Aug 2019 19:41


Originally Posted by radiosutch (Post 10536281)
Light on facts here
1) How is the WA a peace treaty? Are we at war with the EU ? War of words maybe, but not guns and bullets . Poor choice of words
2) How has the UK 'destroyed' anything ? The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. I don't think the UK has actually destroyed anything at present
3) How has the UK 'not fulfil' past obligations. The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed. I don't think the UK has actually failed to fulfill any obligation at present
4) How "disrupts EU commerce" This is getting repetitive, The UK and the EU are in a negotiation. I don't think the UK has actually disrupted anything at present

Wow, what an easy post to demolish !

What negotiations are you talking about? The EU has dismantled its negotiation team and the BoJo is leading the UK to a no-deal exit unless the EU agrees to remove the backstop from the WA they have signed with TM.

Say again s l o w l y 7th Aug 2019 13:00


Originally Posted by 777JRM (Post 10534311)
Remember that EASA is not the EU.

Further, the CAA was independent once before; if they pull their finger out, they can be so again!

The UK does have a choice, and should not be weak when faced with such scaremongering!

By your patronising reckoning, I must be an ‘idiot’.

How other non-EU airlines somehow work it out, is beyond my feeble, idiotic brain cells, but all is not lost.

Errr. How do you expect the CAA to suddenly pick it all up on the 1st November? They have few staff in comparison to ye olden days and would suddenly have to adopt responsibility for the whole regulatory shooting match from a standstill.

I'm not going to call you an idiot, just someone who has absolutely no idea what they are talking about yet has a strong opinion anyway.

Pinuz89 7th Aug 2019 18:13

My question is: why should a UK licence issued under EASA, not be valid after brexit (I mean in EU).
I can understand for licences issued AFTER brexit, but in mine I can read in capital letters EASA.

I'm afraid that the conversion period will go beyond the deadline.

Alex Whittingham 7th Aug 2019 18:18

There's been a fair bit of disinformation around but the answer to your question might be "because the licensing records are no longer held by an EASA state". To avoid this possibility you could transfer your State Of Licence Issue now. Several other EASA States (Austria at least) take the view that a transfer of SOLI process started before a hard Brexit can be completed even after the event.

Pinuz89 7th Aug 2019 18:28


Originally Posted by Alex Whittingham (Post 10539328)
There's been a fair bit of disinformation around but the answer to your question might be "because the licensing records are no longer held by an EASA state". To avoid this possibility you could transfer your State Of Licence Issue now. Several other EASA States (Austria at least) take the view that a transfer of SOLI process started before a hard Brexit can be completed even after the event.

thanks for the suggestion, I will do asap.
So, just to recap, right now in case of a hard brexit, any UK issued licences would not be reckognised outside UK anymore, and, in order to, I should retake all the ATPL examinations, is it correct ?
I mean, if the scenario does not change.

Alex Whittingham 7th Aug 2019 22:43

Why would you assume that? If you have a UK issued EASA licence (by which I think you mean your EASA licence records are currently held by the UK) and there is a hard brexit then worst case other EASA States may not recognise the licence because (arguably) the records are not held by a member State. On the other hand they may recognise it, no-one knows. In order to avoid the possibility just transfer your SOLI. No-one mentioned retaking your ATPL exams, or flight tests, or ratings.

Pinuz89 8th Aug 2019 09:07


Originally Posted by Alex Whittingham (Post 10539513)
Why would you assume that? If you have a UK issued EASA licence (by which I think you mean your EASA licence records are currently held by the UK) and there is a hard brexit then worst case other EASA States may not recognise the licence because (arguably) the records are not held by a member State. On the other hand they may recognise it, no-one knows. In order to avoid the possibility just transfer your SOLI. No-one mentioned retaking your ATPL exams, or flight tests, or ratings.

Yes, you are right, but I was meaning, in case of a Hard Brexit, and in case my licence will not be converted within the deadline, it will be a "third-country" licence in EU.
So I suppose the process will be, in this case, more complicated, and I'll need to resit everything again.
Of course this is gonna be the worst case scenario, and I'm gonna start the conversion asap.

hunterboy 8th Aug 2019 09:37

I suppose it rather depends how much pressure the EU wants to apply on the UK to get its money.

Pinuz89 8th Aug 2019 09:41


Originally Posted by Raski (Post 10539922)


It will never happen.
Worst case scenario, UK CAA like Swiss.
External member of EASA.

So, in case of External EASA member, what will change from the present scenario ?
Will the licence still be reckognised in any other EASA state ?

Pinuz89 8th Aug 2019 09:43

In other words, am I still able to work in the EU as a commercial pilot with a UK CAA licence (issued before brexit) ?

Fly Aiprt 8th Aug 2019 11:36


Originally Posted by Raski (Post 10539922)


It will never happen.
Worst case scenario, UK CAA like Swiss.
External member of EASA.

Isn't it the CAA's job to tell its stakeholders what it devised/negociated/organized for the event that is supposed to take place in less than 100 days from now ?
What does the CAA say concerning licenses, certification etc. ? They should be very busy by now, implementing whatever plan they have prepared.
That is, if they have prepared something...

Denti 8th Aug 2019 16:35


Originally Posted by Raski (Post 10539922)
It will never happen.
Worst case scenario, UK CAA like Swiss.
External member of EASA.

After a hard BREXIT? Not really a chance to be honest. After the UK has paid its dues, has agreed to the backstop in Ireland, guaranteed in law (and not only politicians words) the rights of all EU citizens in the UK, not only those that fit in an arbitrarily designed settlement process only available on Android devices, it might be possible. After the UK has agreed, same as switzerland, to full freedom of movement and continuing to pay into the EU the full (non-discounted) membership fee for the single market which they would have to join it is pretty much a given. But only then.

Remember, the EU is there to protect the interests of its members, not those of others outside of it, especially not those of ex members that left with producing an almighty mess. And yes, switzerland has some firsthand experience of that, remember that they voted against freedom of movement in a referendum, and yet, it is still there. And the swiss stock exchange lost all access to the EU recently because switzerland didn't want to agree to certain rule changes vis a vis the EU.


In other words, am I still able to work in the EU as a commercial pilot with a UK CAA licence (issued before brexit)
If the UK will be an EASA member (and be in the single market, fall under the auspices of the European Court of Justice etc) then yes. If the UK leaves without a deal the license will not be recognised, not even a day (unlike maintenance licenses) as the EU pointed out quite pointedly. After all, there are enough pilots in the EU. In the extremely unlikely case that the UK will be still within EASA but not fall under any other EU regulations, then, no, because you do not have the right to reside and work in the EU as a UK citizen. Of course, if you have EU citizenship, then yes, that could happen. But again, that is extremely unlikely.

woptb 10th Aug 2019 19:17


Originally Posted by Mickey Kaye (Post 10534924)
And what about if a post brexit CAA say from now on we approve the individual not the organisation?

Maintainance would suddenly become a whole lot easier.

It will never happen, not least to allow us to maintain bilaterals that come after Brexit,to comply with ICAO SARPS and to maintain any form of credibility!

zondaracer 15th Aug 2019 01:39

Asking because I have no idea...
Are there any countries that do a SOLI transfer without any ratings current? The ones I contacted so far require at least one rating to be current.

PAX_Britannica 18th Aug 2019 08:56


Originally Posted by Fly Aiprt (Post 10540033)
Isn't it the CAA's job to tell its stakeholders what it devised/negociated/organized for the event that is supposed to take place in less than 100 days from now ?
What does the CAA say concerning licenses, certification etc. ?

You mean, like providing a website which discusses Brexit-related issues: https://info.caa.co.uk/brexit/ ?

Bueno Hombre 18th Aug 2019 10:29


Originally Posted by PAX_Britannica (Post 10548130)
You mean, like providing a website which discusses Brexit-related issues: https://info.caa.co.uk/brexit/ ?

Yes. Thanks for the link.

Alex Whittingham 28th Aug 2019 18:01

Well, the CAA have a sitting Brexit commitee of very senior bods. Naturally one can't actually contact them to ask questions or direct their attention to issues they may have missed because, well, you can't contact anyone in the CAA other than your designated point of contact. Reports from the shop floor indicate the committee are paralysed by fear because Grant Shapps is now Secretary of State and he, apparently, has a history of asking CAA officials difficult questions. So, although a number of strategies have been proposed by the shop floor, in many areas the 'go' decision in any direction has yet to be made by the committee and work has not gone beyond vague statements of intent. There may well not be enough time remaining to actually complete it. Meanwhile in EASA land the EC have told the officials not to give any help to the UK and so they too sit paralysed by fear, wishing to be helpful, but not wanting to risk their jobs. I'm sure it will turn out fine.

Fly Aiprt 28th Aug 2019 18:54


Originally Posted by PAX_Britannica (Post 10548130)
You mean, like providing a website which discusses Brexit-related issues: https://info.caa.co.uk/brexit/ ?

Thanks for the link.
As a quick recap, in case of no-deal, the CAA would recognize EU approvals and licenses for "up to 2 years".
Not sure of who will decide the actual duration of this transition period. Maybe the PM ?
They confirm that UK commercial pilots could (should ?) change the state of issue of their EASA license prior to Brexit...

Alex Whittingham 28th Aug 2019 21:08

TBH the SOLI question appears to be no brainer. If you transfer your SOLI the UK will recognise everything for up to two years and on application issue you a parallel UK PART-FCL licence (no details available). If you keep the UK as your SOLI you get only the UK PART-FCL licence (no details available)

Kak Klaxon 29th Aug 2019 16:03

Thanks Alex, I have asked for a validation to fly G REG on my SOLI license. They don’t know how that’s going to work yet. I am flying on a Far East trip 31 into 1st.

Happy days.......may write my own validation in crayon on the back of the plog.


kontrolor 29th Aug 2019 22:04

it is simple - if there hard brexit, UK licence will not be valid in EU. It may well be in the USA on the other hand....

SJH1 4th Sep 2019 21:15

I feel I was a bit late to the party with the state of licence issue advice unfortunately. Having read the advice though, it seems like the wisest thing to do. Especially with the potential delay bill being passed through parliament tonight, which would extend the deadline for the state of licence issue process to be completed.


Just a question though. Should we leave No Deal on October 31st, as a holder of what would then become a UK Part-FCL PPL (with insufficient time between now and then to change states), what would be the likely process be to change states post Brexit??


Hopefully there's a delay which allows for my change of state, but asking just in case there's not.

RedDragonFlyer 18th Oct 2019 12:49

Does anyone know this current Johnson deal affects pilots and student in regards to EASA/ CAA?

Will the UK remain in EASA during the transition period?

International treaties are not really in my realm of expertise and I've seen no articles online about it.

Gertrude the Wombat 18th Oct 2019 14:45


Originally Posted by RedDragonFlyer (Post 10597537)
Does anyone know this current Johnson deal affects pilots and student in regards to EASA/ CAA?.

No.

(Plenty of people will speculate, and some claim inside information, but nobody knows.)

Skyjob 18th Oct 2019 16:47


what would be the likely process be to change states post Brexit??
You will require a full application from the like of any third country status applicant, as intra-EASA transfer of licence will not be able to change anymore.
See it a s full initial each time...

Pinuz89 18th Oct 2019 18:19


Originally Posted by Skyjob (Post 10597697)
You will require a full application from the like of any third country status applicant, as intra-EASA transfer of licence will not be able to change anymore.
See it a s full initial each time...

This scenario is only in case of a no-deal, in case of a deal, depend on the deal itself.

rwm 4th Apr 2020 16:20

I am currently writing the Part 66 exams in the UK via the CAA. I already have Canadian AME M1 & M2, and FAA A&P licenses. I hope to have these exams complete before the end of the year. I have not seen anything that states that it won't be an EASA part 66 license, only that:

"EU exit
Please note that, in the event of UK participation in EASA and mutual recognition of licences and certificates ceasing, some CAA website content and application forms may continue to carry the EASA logo or reference the EU or EASA rather than the UK CAA in the short term. These will be updated in due course following the outcome of the transition period negotiations on the long-term aviation relationship between the UK and the EU. In the meantime, the guidance provided and the application forms accessed via the CAA website portal will continue to be valid."


I have read other places that nothing will change until 31 Dec 2020 and therefore a license issued in the UK will still be an EASA part 66. Does anyone know if this is still true?

Is there an easier place to write the exams that I won't need to worry about having to convert or write a different license again? I'm a bit concerned as this covid-19 issue has caused some concerns with how long travel will be restricted making it difficult for me to complete the license before the door closes.

W Smith 4th Apr 2020 17:32

rwm - You seem to have missed the fundamemtal point here. An EASA licence is only an EASA licence if it is issued and administered by the competent authority of a Member State. The UK government has said that the UK CAA will cease to be a part of the EASA system in December. That will mean that every licence that the CAA HAS EVER ISSUED WILL CEASE TO BE A VALID EASA LICENCE on that date. It makes no difference what it says on the licence, it will not be valid for working on EASA aircraft, any more than a licence issued by Russia, Australia, or the USA with "EASA" printed on it would be an EASA licence.
If you get an EASA Part 66 licence (or a Part-FCLpilot licence) issued by the CAA before it leaves EASA you will be an "existing holder of a UK issued EASA licence". The only way to preserve the EU privileges of an EASA licence issued by the UK CAA is to have it reissued by another EASA State before it ceases to be a valid EASA licence. That is why there is so much stuff on the CAA website telling people how to move their licences to other countries - in the jargon 'change the State of Licence Issue (SOLI)"
On the CAA website is a section specific to Brexit -
i.e. The page 'Our-work - About-us - Brexit'
Halfway down that page there is a bullet point which reads:
  • UK-issued licences and approvals (issued when the UK was an EASA member) will continue to have validity under UK law but only those contained in EU Regulation 2019/494 will continue to have validity within the EU system, as defined by that regulation.
If you look up EU Regulation 2019/494 you will find that in the Annex to the Regulation it lists the UK issued licences and approvals that will remain valid for a limited period. If you refer to that Annex you will find that it DOES NOT include Part 66 licences nor does it include Part-FCL pilot licences. They will all cease to be valid in the EU.
That is why thousands of UK licensed pilots and engineers have made sure they have had their UK EASA licences re-issued by other countries - such as the Republic of Ireland and Austria (because Easyjet is changing from a British to an Austrian airline because of Brexit).
That same page on the CAA website says:
  • All licences issued by the CAA under EU legislation, and all type approval certificates and third country approvals issued by EASA under EU legislation, will continue to have validity under UK law, provided they were effective immediately before 1 January 2021.
This is consistent with the reality that an EASA Part 66 licence issued by the UK CAA will become a UK national licence, still valid for G registered aircraft, but ONLY valid for G registered aircraft. These licences will not be valid for aircraft registered outside the UK unless other countries sign new agreements to make UK national licences valid for aircraft on their registers. Probably not a priority for anyone in the current crisis.
The advice is simple (and you will find it implied on the UK CAA website if you look hard enough).
If you want to work on or fly aircraft that are registered in EASA Member States after this year, get yourself a licence issued by an EU Member State, not the UK CAA.





covec 4th Apr 2020 20:58

Icelanta.

Sorry that an exercise in Democracy should upset you so.

Yep. Consequences. Big Boys Rules.

For where I live...may be a moot point. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

In any case, my FI work is on G registered aircraft.

Red Dragon Flyer: train and get examined in non-UK EU States.

Curious though. All this talk of “if no deal” no UK licensed pilot can fly in EU countries begs the question: and what of EASA licensed pilots flying in the UK?


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:59.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.