PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Bristow S92 down west of Bergen Norway (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/657874-bristow-s92-down-west-bergen-norway.html)

Smokeyboy 28th Feb 2024 19:07

Bristow S92 down west of Bergen Norway
 
Latest reports 5 persons hoisted up. Unknown conditions.

Update: SAR version, 6 POB, all 6 flown to hospital. Unknown conditions.

212man 28th Feb 2024 19:44


Originally Posted by Smokeyboy (Post 11605815)
Latest reports 5 persons hoisted up. Unknown conditions.

Update: SAR version, 6 POB, all 6 flown to hospital. Unknown conditions.

Bristow SAR in Norway?

Very best wishes to all involved.

Lonewolf_50 28th Feb 2024 20:17

If flown to hospital, hopefully that means still alive.

Windblade 28th Feb 2024 20:25

Reuters - February 28, 20249:17 PM GMT

Helicopter crash lands in ocean off Norway, all 6 aboard rescued

(Sorry, can't post links yet :) )

HeliComparator 28th Feb 2024 20:48

https://www.flightglobal.com/helicop...157174.article

OttoRotate 28th Feb 2024 21:30

ADSB Track
 
https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao...28&trackLabels

Looks like a normal training run, maybe they settled into the water unintentionally?

212man 28th Feb 2024 21:46


Originally Posted by OttoRotate (Post 11605895)
https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao...28&trackLabels

Looks like a normal training run, maybe they settled into the water unintentionally?

as opposed to intentionally?

GenuineHoverBug 28th Feb 2024 22:43

Sadly, it was just confirmed that there is one fatality. The other five have varying degrees of injuries.

Update 29.2.24: One is critically injured, one has serious injuries and three have minor injuries.

hargreaves99 29th Feb 2024 08:25

https://www.offshore-energy.biz/trag...s-in-fatality/

TowerDog 29th Feb 2024 10:36


Originally Posted by GenuineHoverBug (Post 11605926)
Sadly, it was just confirmed that there is one fatality. The other five have varying degrees of injuries.

Update 29.2.24: One is critically injured, one has serious injuries and three have minor injuries.

The fatality was a female nurse in her 60s.


malabo 29th Feb 2024 11:51

Same operator as the S-92 loss of control incident a week back. Coincidence or systemic shortcomings? Wonder if the crew will allow accident investigators access to CVR or FDM data on this one.

hargreaves99 29th Feb 2024 11:53

That "loss of control incident" was 4 years ago. Feb 2020

https://www.nsia.no/Aviation/Published-reports/2024-03

Mitchaa 29th Feb 2024 12:29

Not sure this design flaw has ever been fixed by Sikorsky other than increased monitoring -

https://skybrary.aero/accidents-and-...north-sea-2016

https://www.offshore-technology.com/...60853/?cf-view

I believe there were a handful of identical issues going back previously also as they issued an emergency AD just before that accident above.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-n...2-emergency-ad

Just a post to highlight previous loss of control events. Most likely unrelated to this event but you never know.

albatross 29th Feb 2024 13:02

Considering the events you write of occurred in 2016 do you think your speculation is appropriate in this case?


Originally Posted by Mitchaa (Post 11606246)
Not sure this design flaw has ever been fixed by Sikorsky other than increased monitoring -

https://skybrary.aero/accidents-and-...north-sea-2016

https://www.offshore-technology.com/...60853/?cf-view

I believe there were a handful of identical issues going back previously also as they issued an emergency AD just before that accident above.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-n...2-emergency-ad

Just a post to highlight previous loss of control events. Most likely unrelated to this event but you never know.


Mitchaa 29th Feb 2024 13:10


Originally Posted by albatross (Post 11606264)
Considering the events you write of occurred in 2016 do you think your speculation is appropriate in this case?

I believe the TRPCS issue has never been redesigned so yes. They are protecting it with increased monitoring.

G-REDL happened in 2009 with Bond (16 fatal). The exact same failure mode happened again in 2016 with CHC (13 fatal)

Time apart 7yrs there. I don’t think time has any bearing on faulty design personally.

Chances of this accident being related to the same issue as the 2016 issue highlighted then it’s unlikely but they will be looking at all avenues and previous design related issues.

They likely already know the cause as they will have survivor feedback. Speculation therefore shouldn’t last too long.


ChristopherRobin 29th Feb 2024 13:42


Originally Posted by Mitchaa (Post 11606271)
G-REDL happened in 2009 with Bond (16 fatal). The exact same failure mode happened again in 2016 with CHC (13 fatal)

G-REDL was a puma as was the CHC aircraft in 2016. This thread is about an S-92 🙄

Mitchaa 29th Feb 2024 14:03


Originally Posted by ChristopherRobin (Post 11606295)
G-REDL was a puma as was the CHC aircraft in 2016. This thread is about an S-92 🙄

Thanks for that Captain obvious :rolleyes:

What does an S92 and a Super Puma have in common? What do design faults have in common? What do aviation accidents have in common?

My point was about design flaws that have a habit of coming back to bite. Time is no measure. It’s not just on Super Pumas, S92’s, it happens across the whole of aviation whether that be whirly birds or fixed wing (B737 max for example)

This thread will naturally be open to speculation until something more formal comes out. Human nature my friend.

Chill out and relax :)

212man 29th Feb 2024 14:03


Originally Posted by ChristopherRobin (Post 11606295)
G-REDL was a puma as was the CHC aircraft in 2016. This thread is about an S-92 🙄

I think everyone knows that - Mitchaa's point was about unresolved design 'flaws'

ChristopherRobin 29th Feb 2024 14:31


Originally Posted by Mitchaa (Post 11606307)
Thanks for that Captain obvious :rolleyes:

my pleasure, Captain Irrelevant

HeliComparator 29th Feb 2024 14:37

Someone dies, this creates an opportunity for some childish bickering and point scoring. Rather sad.


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:50.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.