Go Back  PPRuNe Forums > Aircrew Forums > Rotorheads
Reload this Page >

Helicopter Crash In Bettystown Ireland

Rotorheads A haven for helicopter professionals to discuss the things that affect them

Helicopter Crash In Bettystown Ireland

Old 20th Sep 2008, 14:26
  #81 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: uk
Posts: 1,638
Yes farrell, it will be interesting to see what the full story is.
So, no external signs of fire from the footage we have seen so far. Maybe there is some out there that can back up a fire theory. Maybe it was a fire indication.
Why would anyone land a 76 in such a small place in the first place.
He was initially over a beach. So between dropping off the pax then repositioning he had a fire indication, then he hovered for a while over a car park instead of staying out clear of built up areas. ???wtf????
A/C clips something which causes it to yaw and spin out of control with the obvious result.
Lets just wait and see what the truth is about it all.
We all have our own opinions. After all, this is a 'rumour' network', is it not?

PS, quite a few of us spend a lot of our working days in the 76, not playing flight sim!
helimutt is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 16:18
  #82 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: West of Greenwich
Posts: 117
Originally Posted by Coatesy
just like to let you all know that the pilot is prob one of the most experienced in ireland , just for all you speculators, which you will find out in the report.!! that was not the intended landing site were the cctv footage was.!! he was trying to deal with the engine fire were he was, couldnt move forward because there was a woman standing there looking at him.!! tail clipped something and the rest is the rest. you will notice that the wheels are not even down in the footage, he tried to make the beach but couldnt, cockpit filled with smoke very quickly ..!!
The landing gear might not look like it's down in the video footage, but it certainly looks like it is down in some of the still shoots,including the photo on the front page of yesterdays Irish Independent.
Pink Panther is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 16:22
  #83 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: London, UK
Posts: 226
cockpit filled with smoke very quickly ..!!
Is that a feature of the S76? With the small stuff i've flown, i've assumed to date that anything in the cockpit would be a slow evolving fire of electrical origin and that you'd never have to rapid loss of sight and breathing difficulties?
FairWeatherFlyer is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 16:24
  #84 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 343
In common with others I'll await the official report. Lots of factors I'd like to hear the final viewpoint on (most of which have been highlighted already).

HM, I don't recall the FSI sim yawing for a fire indication real or spurious, do you

And considering the previous comments, with a substantial engine firewall and masses of power even OEI in a B model (especially a light one), it sadly doesn't look too clever

FWF - No it's not a 76 feature. Must have been a major engine fire for the smoke to have not been visible from the outside, but so fierce that it breached the firewall, filled the MRGB compartment, crossed the overhead bay containing the mixing unit and then filled the cockpit before confirmation of a fire or a safe landing could be made Possible electrical fire in the cockpit????? But then those in the know have stated it was an engine fire

FW

Last edited by Flingingwings; 20th Sep 2008 at 17:12.
Flingingwings is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 16:31
  #85 (permalink)  
RotorHead
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,007
Sorry fellas but i couldn't help but laugh at this..

couldnt move forward because there was a woman standing there looking at him.!!
206Fan is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 18:55
  #86 (permalink)  

Just Dropped In
 
Join Date: May 2001
Location: um....er.....
Posts: 130
Seriously glad no-one was hurt!

Have to say....fantastic to see the passer-bys running to help!

Did anyone notice the CCTV footage jumps from 16:41:13 to 16:41:36??

When I first watched it I was truly horrified the fire caught so quickly, on realising there was 24 seconds missing.....whilst still horrified, it explained the pilot's escape! & explained the severity of the fire seen on the tape!
Reminded me of the Bristows S-61 near Portland.......scarey stuff!

Again.....I'll wait for the report. Glad no-one was hurt!
Roofus is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 19:01
  #87 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Ireland
Posts: 85
davy o7 how is this funny .stand near an s76 rotors running and see how long you stay in the one place.if he moved to close to a lady and the down wash hit her, she may have got hurt.He was correct by not trying to move her away from the landing site by moving close to her.I will wait for the report before making further comment.

To many experts with to few hours on this network.
Choppersquad is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 19:29
  #88 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Ireland
Posts: 30
Wow.. arrogant AND intelligent.. you're on a winner!

It looks like the topic isn't open to conversation, lets get a moderator in here to close this thread down, might as well, the opinions of us people are no longer tolerated, however it seems there's a double standard here, we're not entitled to question the events of the accident yet you're able to make a "fully informed" attack on other members, arrogance is obviously flavour of the day.. for what it's worth, if thats the result of your many years of flying I'd rather quit now while I'm still ahead. What happened to the topic of conversation BEFORE the slating of other members started, or is that all you're capable of doing with YOUR 19 inch monitor? Why don't you instead, set a good example to us small fry instead of painting a bitter picture. We're only discussing the accident.

I believe we were discussing the theories and causes of the helicopter crash in Bettystown - just like you, we are all anticipating the AAIU report, we're not out to slate the pilot. I'm not trying to slate you either but it appears you want to have a go at people..

I don't see any mention of an R44 (R22 would be more appropriate) but regardless of that I think you're missing the point, nobody is comparing them, rather it was more a question about even attempting to land a robbie in such a spot, not to mention an S76.. but as some have already mentioned, there may have been governing factors that led to him to end up where he did.

I can see this conversation getting heated so lets just get back to the discussion of the sequence of events, possible causes and what other information has emerged about the accident, that's what we're here for, right?

I believe you'll find flight simmers hanging out in other forums, I wouldn't know, I guess I can only assume it seeing as I know so little about the rest of you, and visa versa.
highonsnow is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 19:35
  #89 (permalink)  
RotorHead
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,007
I wasn't laughing at the situation, just that comment!

Anyway, as you say il wait to hear what the report says also.
206Fan is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 20:11
  #90 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Near the Mountains
Age: 63
Posts: 345
Firstly, best wishes to the pilot and those others who received injuries of any kind, including having the life frightened out of them. He was very lucky to get out of it in one piece!

Disregarding all the speculation and comment, but .......

.........has anybody spoken to the man and actually heard him say there was a fire or fire indication, or even a problem of any kind in those moments before going down?

And no, I don't mean " heard it from a mate of his neighbour" stuff.

22
heliski22 is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 20:44
  #91 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Ireland
Posts: 30
I hate to dwell on the past.. but Farrell, you clearly have anger issues:

http://www.pprune.org/jet-blast/3431...ml#post4395477

Perhaps take a moment and get some fresh air, you've got quite a lot of posting done on PPRuNe (1,207 from last count), hang up the keyboard mate and stick to the aviation if that's what you're really into, all you seem to do is hop from thread to thread looking for arguments.

So far you have not mentioned one relevant piece of information about the actual event itself, all you have done is ranted. Go annoy another thread
highonsnow is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 21:05
  #92 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: An Irish dude in Houston, TX. I miss home!!!
Age: 39
Posts: 231
It must be that time of the month for a lot of ppruners or something! There's quite a few topics with cranky and snide comments at the moment!

Relax da kaks lads or take a chill pill or something!
darrenphughes is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 23:01
  #93 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: An Irish dude in Houston, TX. I miss home!!!
Age: 39
Posts: 231
Quote:
I don't see any mention of an R44 (R22 would be more appropriate)
What the are you talking about?
Why would it be more appropriate? Who ARE you????
If you actually read the context of the statement instead of jumping in feet first screaming at people, you'd see that they were saying that there was barely room for a little R22, never mind a helo the size of a S76.

If you talk to people in the real world like this I can guarantee you now that nobody, and I mean nobody ever actually listen to you. They probably just stand around saying, "ooh here comes Farrell with his big crazy head"!!!

What causes are you talking about? Do you want to head off to Bettystown and tell the investigation team about that?
Third time: YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT THE CAUSE IS!

With regards to theories.....who gives a toss about them? They are irrelevant and a waste of bandwidth - especially if they are so far out there that I can watch them heading off for days.

The pilot doesn't need your theories, the investigators don't need them, the people paying for this site don't need them - Jesus, you don't even have a personal title - you get to spout off for free!
Nobody on here are claiming to have all the answers, but their informed theories and educated guesses(aided by researching certain things like google earth for example) can give some insight into what happened. Why do we all want to know what happened?? I'll answer for myself here; Because, as a pilot I feel that knowledge is power. It gives me the tools to apply the last guys mistakes to my equation when it comes to my own flying, hence reducing my own risk and making the skies a little safer.

I think a certain amount of speculation is healthy in this realm. Since I joined here and VR 2 years ago as a student pilot working to become a CFI and Professional Pilot I have used these sort of topics to enhance my knowlege by taking into account informed speculatory posts and discarding the posts that do not add up. I have listened to many Professional Pilots from both the Civilian world and the Military and learned from their stories and mistakes. I have also learned from people discrediting both my own & other peoples theories using sensible language and statements, and not just coming out swinging.

If you have a problem with speculation then thats your problem, as this industry is rife with it, be it a good thing or a bad thing. Even the top guys use speculation based on their prior knowledge. Take for example, Greg White who wrote Fatal Traps for Helicopter Pilots. While almost all his case studies show just the facts, there are quite a few where he or others speculate as to the events running up to the accidents in question. This is how we learn.

Some of the people on here may be Sim fliers and many are Professional Pilots. I suggest you show some respect to all of them, as you'll find that most of them have a great deal more experience and knowlege than you.
darrenphughes is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 23:07
  #94 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Ireland
Posts: 30
Great response though, you have very valid points - without the contributions of everyone and making an open minded analysis of the information available it's hard to learn from others accidents, actions, or otherwise.
highonsnow is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 23:21
  #95 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: No where
Posts: 54
Well said Darren, healthy conversation is the only way forward. As whatsarunway points out, this is not a place for mud-slinging.
I think this trend should be closed and let the AAIU / NTSB do there jobs and publish a preliminary report, then it should be discussed further. We are gaining nothing here and risk the media miss quoting replies and harming the image of this very delicate industry further.
Ketchup
ketchup is offline  
Old 20th Sep 2008, 23:46
  #96 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: uk
Age: 44
Posts: 56
We are gaining nothing here and risk the media miss quoting replies and harming the image of this very delicate industry further.....

wise words ketchup.

Pilot will have enough knives out for him not to mention the demons in his own head. IF it is determined as a poor judgement call it will have a serious effect on the guy. Experience is relative, I think it naive to say he one of the most experienced in ireland although he is a nice chap.

NB
noblades is offline  
Old 21st Sep 2008, 10:11
  #97 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Italy
Posts: 14
It certainly looks like the gear is down, contrary to Coatesy's spin on the events, (Coatesy should hire a PR spin expert of you want to change the story ref your pilot) even when the CCTV fottage is enhanced, and from the still footage of the heli burning on its side it certainly looks like its down, if he only took off a few short moments before, why would he bother to pull the gear up

The pilot is a very nice individual, and as good a pilot as anyone, however if a mistake was made on the day, we are all prone to making bad judgements and most times only ourselves will ever know,
We do however need to support our friend and fellow pilot in times like this, The one who thinks they will never make a mistake or misjudgement will themselves be the next to do so
swisstony is offline  
Old 21st Sep 2008, 11:23
  #98 (permalink)  

Just Dropped In
 
Join Date: May 2001
Location: um....er.....
Posts: 130
Does anyone know who was in the Blue (appeared blue anyway) 407 circling overhead at the time of the crash?
Obviously a birds eye view would shed alot of light & prevent speculation!

Noblades Absolutely spot on to state experience is relative!

'Prob one of the most experienced pilots in Ireland' is a very bold claim!!

Because without wishing to mud-sling.......I'd suggest that was not the best place to try & land at anytime (What is it......50yds from an open beach!?) & certainly not IF there was a problem with the aircraft.
Roofus is offline  
Old 21st Sep 2008, 12:23
  #99 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: europe
Posts: 85
From the aerial shot of the scene i am struck by how close the crash site was to the beach, even if my head was on fire i would maneouvre the machine over a few yards and land on the beach... i am amazed nobody was seriously hurt. Was there an engine/electrical/xmsn fire? From the footage it apears quite clear cut...pilot trys to land in a (very?)confined area, clips his tail and crashes. Thank god the Pilot is ok and will hopefully return to fly in the future (a little more cautious of his landing sites). I await the AAIU interim report with interest.
eurocopter beans is offline  
Old 21st Sep 2008, 13:19
  #100 (permalink)  
 
Join Date: May 2002
Location: "Deplorable but happy as a drunken Monkey!
Age: 71
Posts: 16,615
Whats that old saying...."Even Monkey's fall out of trees every now and then!"

This will all be sorted at the conclusion of the many investigations that are on-going. After the reports are published then we can properly sit as a jury and make our verdicts known.

Until then....is it just not a bit presumptious of us to take a definitive view of things?

EB,

Unless you have had your "head" on fire before....there is no telling what you would do if it really happened.

I have sat in a cockpit full of fire (in flight) and I can assure you it alters your normal line of thinking and there is no training that will prepare you for the event. We might like to assume what we would do....but until you smell yourself burning it is only hypothetical thinking at best.
SASless is offline  

Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service - Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.