PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Professional Pilot Training (includes ground studies) (https://www.pprune.org/professional-pilot-training-includes-ground-studies-14/)
-   -   Modular V Integrated (Merged) - Look here before starting a new thread! (https://www.pprune.org/professional-pilot-training-includes-ground-studies/403410-modular-v-integrated-merged-look-here-before-starting-new-thread.html)

rudestuff 5th May 2023 20:39

You mention three well-trodden routes:
Modular, Integrated and USA.
Integrated is the most expensive by far. Modular in the UK can be done for £45-£50k and gives exactly the same licence. Then there's the US route, which is by far the cheapest - if you know what you are doing. The US route makes the most sense of you commit to it - meaning get FAA certificates and work as a flight instructor to 1500 hours. The advantage of the FAA system is that you only need 100 hours in powered aircraft, which opens the door to a lot of cross crediting and some very very cheap flying.

pilotmanpilot 11th May 2023 20:37

What does modular training consist of?
 
I understand that first you need to attain your PPL, then you must hour build in order to attain your CPL. There are so many websites that say the order of your modules but they all say different things.

So my question is, what is the order of and what are the modules called that are NECESSARY to become a commercial airline pilot [for BA or easyJet etc].

​​​​​​Thank you

mystify2431 12th May 2023 11:36

I've been trying to calculate a more recent/relevant cost for going the modular route and I'm finding it will be a lot more expensive than the £50k to £60k that is usually estimated. My training for the PPL and most of the subsequent hour building would be based around London, which I appreciate is not the cheapest place to fly and perhaps I will look to get it done cheaper elsewhere, but is there anything in there that looks wildly wrong?

Training
PPL (45 hours) 12,000
Night Rating (5 hours) 1,300
Hour building (25 hours) 5,000
IRR/IMC (15 hours) 3,750
Hours (35 hours) 7,000
CBIR (15 hours) 8,000
MEP (6 hours) 4,000
MEIR (5 hours) 18,000
Hours (22 hours) 4,400
CPL (SEP) ( 15 hours) 6,000
MCC APS 5,000
JOC 1,000
TOTAL 75,450

Examinations and Tests
PPL Test 200
PPL Exams 450
ATPL Exams 1,000
Austro Exams 1,300 (probably won't go for EASA anyway)
IR Skills 850
ME Skills 150
ME Paper 35
ATPL Theory Course 2,500

CAA License Fees
PPL 202
RT License 79
ME Class Rating 131
IR Rating 131
CPL 263

Misc
Headset 200
Memberships 400
Medical+renewals 1,000
ATPL books 600
PPL Books/Equipment 250

GRAND TOTAL 85,191

So that's looking like it'll be around £85k when all is said and done. It does not include accomodation/travel for exams, longer to get PPL etc either. I can certainly see why some might choose Integrated in this position. Having said that, the ability to work full time alongside still makes modular far more compelling for me.

rudestuff 12th May 2023 17:34

If you're paying £3,600 per hour for MEIR training you might want to consider something smaller!
Also, you're paying £200 per hour for hour building when you could get it for half that.
And for some reason you want to pay £500 per hour for SEIR training. You're getting screwed and you're pushing back. I can see £25,000 of savings straight away...

mystify2431 13th May 2023 09:38


Originally Posted by rudestuff (Post 11433926)
If you're paying £3,600 per hour for MEIR training you might want to consider something smaller!
Also, you're paying £200 per hour for hour building when you could get it for half that.
And for some reason you want to pay £500 per hour for SEIR training. You're getting screwed and you're pushing back. I can see £25,000 of savings straight away...

Thanks. Well that's encouraging to hear that I probably have some of those costs wrong then. I was taking quotes that I'd seen for those respective packages but hadn't figured that a per-hour rate would probably be better. For the hour-building, I can't find anything that much cheaper in my area though, but I'll hopefully be able to take a chunk off in a package somewhere sunnier.

rleungz 27th Jul 2023 13:13

Hi - please may someone lay out why doing the CBIR is better .e.g. getting your PPL and doing a IMC (IR)?

rudestuff 27th Jul 2023 13:21


Originally Posted by rleungz (Post 11474810)
Hi - please may someone lay out why doing the CBIR is better .e.g. getting your PPL and doing a IMC (IR)?

Look up what you need for an IR course, then look up what you need doing it via CBIR. You'll have your answer.

rudestuff 27th Jul 2023 14:00


Originally Posted by mystify2431 (Post 11434178)
Thanks. Well that's encouraging to hear that I probably have some of those costs wrong then. I was taking quotes that I'd seen for those respective packages but hadn't figured that a per-hour rate would probably be better. For the hour-building, I can't find anything that much cheaper in my area though, but I'll hopefully be able to take a chunk off in a package somewhere sunnier.

Where are you based?
The easiest option if you're working full time is a two week package holiday to Florida and fly 50 hours. Do that twice and you've covered your hour building. The IRR is a bit on the high side, you should be able to get it for £3000. The simplest option for CBIR is 40 hours and is essentially the same course but longer, so expect it to cost £8000, but you wouldn't need the IRR in that case. Or you can choose to do the 15 hours IRR then 10 hours by yourself, then finish with another 15 hours instruction to upgrade from IRR to IR. That should be slightly cheaper at £6000 plus the extra 10 hours.
The MEP is 6 hours. The SEIR to MEIR is 5 hours (3 of which can be SIM) so it should cost less than the MEP but budget about the same and you'll be covered.
After PPL and Night (50 hours) your aircraft hire should be:
IRR>CBIR 40 hours, £7500
MEP 6 hours, £3000-3500
MEIR 5 hours, £2500-3000
CPL 15 hours, £4500
Hour Building 84 hours, £8400
Total: 150 hours, £25900-26900. Based on normal UK prices. Plus of course all the incidentals you mentioned like tests, exams, licence and landing fees etc, but still definitely a reasonable figure.


fredddyfred 2nd Aug 2023 19:52

Hey guys!
I've been following this thread for quite some time, very insightful!

A short background : Currently 30 years old working full time in London and planning to switch career as an airline pilot, but due to visa restrictions I'd only be able to join integrated course in 7 months at least ( March 2024 )

I initially thought to do an integrated course just because I want to start my career as a pilot as soon as possible, which if I were to take the integrated course it will probably be the end of 2025, if Im lucky enough to secure a job right after

But then I thought, I could probably start a modular route by doing part time for the next 7 months for PPL, then convert to full-time modular student. Which seems to be about the same time to get the ATPL license and potentially saving quite a lot of money?

I will need to get a loan and help from my family anyways so just weighing out the two options. Thanks in advance!

fredddyfred 3rd Aug 2023 21:08

Following up on my thread above.

I saw this article about a modular student getting into Easyjet and his final stages of modular was done with L3Harris : http://www.pilotcareernews.com/toms-...-with-easyjet/
Also this one saying that the British Airways Whitetail programme will select potential candidates from 5 major ATOs during/after their training ( integrated and modular ) : http://www.*****************/2023/07...lified-pilots/
Basically from what I understood, these airlines tend to 'like' students from these schools anyways?

So after some rough calculations, if I were to do my PPL, ATPL and Hour building with a local, more affordable flight school, then go to the big ones to do the rest of the training. The price difference seems quite small around 10-15k, especially if I want to do dual license.

I guess 10-15k is still quite a lot of money and will take some time to pay back?

belugaInBroughton 31st Aug 2023 23:31

Modular is better
 

Originally Posted by G-FATTY (Post 5470287)
Hi checkxp,
I did my training all modular and came out with the same pieces of paper in the end as any intergrated fATPL holder, for less than 1/2 the price (if it costs £100,000!! above)

2 years! - PPL for £6200, 45hrs
6months - ATPL groundschool fulltime Cabair £2250 + living exp. = £3,200 (good name, would recommend groundschool @ Bournemouth).
5months - Hour building @ £70ph + landing fees etc = £8500 - UK based
3months - Multi CPL/IR at PAT, Bournemouth = £26,000inc exams - (great name, instructors) + living exp.£1,600
1 week - MCC @ European = £1,900 living exp £120

Modular route......priceless!
(Total: £48,170)

under 15months taken out from completing PPL.
200.1 hours total.

I think my training was picking the best of each stage in my view. The level of training was as high as I believe it can get and I feel that each training organisation above was providing a tailor made course to suit my needs.
At the end of the day though I am not guaranteed an interview, as I believe some intergrated course offer, but I would prefer to go to an interview saying I managed my training on both cost and a hight level of training, than to turn up to an interview that was included in a package.

In answer to your question, I would have £51,830 left for a Type Rating until im evens with a intergrated students price.
If only I had that money left over!

Thought this may be of some interest. Good luck with the training.

I think modular is better mate,

Zembla82 8th Sep 2023 13:35

Hello everyone. Following on from some of the points above, what would those with experience say is a realistic Modular cost in the UK?

I'm currently looking to start an Integrated in Greece as it's much cheaper than UK Integrated courses. I've phoned a few UK flight schools (Aeros, L3, ACS) and getting a clear answer for even a ballpark figure has been impossible for Modular routes. Each just says, their Integrated course would be better.

I would prefer to do joint CAA and EASA licences but let's even say for the UK licence, any ballpark figures to go zero to fATPL via modular?

Much obliged folks and thanks for taking the time to read.

flyaviation15 5th Oct 2023 16:17

Does anyone know any info in regards to finishing a UK CAA PPL, and doing the rest of the license modular abroad in Europe?
I enquired at certain flight schools, but they require you to do you're hour building in a UK registered aircraft, and do the EASA ATPL's, then complete the rest of the license off with them.
Can you do hour building at different flights schools? which are not in the UK, e.g. in Florida or somewhere in Europe. Which might workout to be cheaper than UK to do hour building.

rudestuff 6th Oct 2023 04:53


Originally Posted by Zembla82 (Post 11499361)
I would prefer to do joint CAA and EASA licences but let's even say for the UK licence, any ballpark figures to go zero to fATPL via modular?

In the UK at typical prices about £45,000-£50,000 is achievable if you do everything in the optimal order. It's relatively easy to price it up using any flight schools rate-sheet. To finish your fATPL with the CPL test you need at least 200 hours total (with a minimum of 12 hours multi engine) and 77 hours of dual instruction. Plus the cost of medical, ATPL theory, exams, flight tests and licence and landing fees.

Using £175ph (SEP), £450ph (MEP) and £60(Instructor) as an example:
(188x175)+(12×450)+(77*60) = £42,920.

That's doing it all in the UK at school rates. If you split your hour building into 2 blocks of 2 weeks of 50 hours and do it in Florida at £100 per hour (probably cheaper) then even if you spend £2000 each time on flights and hotels you'll save £3500 which brings the cost of aircraft and instructor below £40,000. Plus you'll get the hours a lot quicker.






rudestuff 6th Oct 2023 04:54


Originally Posted by flyaviation15 (Post 11514946)
Can you do hour building at different flights schools? which are not in the UK, e.g. in Florida or somewhere in Europe. Which might workout to be cheaper than UK to do hour building.

Yes you can, its called modular for that reason.

cede 8th Oct 2023 13:04


Originally Posted by rudestuff (Post 11515229)
In the UK at typical prices about £45,000-£50,000 is achievable if you do everything in the optimal order. It's relatively easy to price it up using any flight schools rate-sheet. To finish your fATPL with the CPL test you need at least 200 hours total (with a minimum of 12 hours multi engine) and 77 hours of dual instruction. Plus the cost of medical, ATPL theory, exams, flight tests and licence and landing fees.

Using £175ph (SEP), £450ph (MEP) and £60(Instructor) as an example:
(188x175)+(12×450)+(77*60) = £42,920.

That's doing it all in the UK at school rates. If you split your hour building into 2 blocks of 2 weeks of 50 hours and do it in Florida at £100 per hour (probably cheaper) then even if you spend £2000 each time on flights and hotels you'll save £3500 which brings the cost of aircraft and instructor below £40,000. Plus you'll get the hours a lot quicker.

Hey rudestuff,

Currently in a similarish career to airlines, just via a different medium....

I've seen you say that now has never been better than to go for the training. I've seen others say that even taking out a loan to part fund is an option worth considering (sorry I can't remember who).

My day job pays well. However it will take me a year or two to save up the figures quoted for modular. There are a few options I have been thinking about;

1. Take as big a loan as I can get, and save up the remaining difference = less time to fATPL and more chances of employment "quicker" in this market, and thus total career earnings. However more debt and first job could be on regional carrier with low pay and high repayments...

2. Save up everything I need including living expenses and then do it all off my own back = will take 2/3 years to save up properly and may have missed my "chance" in the market. However no debt and if I get first job with regional, I'll not be struggling with repayments. Though final career earnings could be less??

3. A balance of the two options. Save up half and loan the other half = best of both worlds or worst of both worlds?

Any thoughts on the above?

Cheers

ynceeaa 10th Oct 2023 10:09

Hello everyone!

I am interested in pursuing an EASA ATPL course in Europe. However, being a Russian citizen, I have encountered difficulties finding schools that accept students from my country. Among the options, I am particularly considering FlyBy in Burgos. Could you please provide some insights on the feasibility of completing an integrated course within 14 months, successfully passing all requirements, fulfilling the required flight hours, and avoiding any unnecessary expenses?

WindyTurtle 10th Oct 2023 19:10

So FlyBy said that it is do-able within 14 months (and I met someone who was going to finihs within 14 months when I visted) however most students apparnetly complete it in 16-18 months. So actually it's the advertised EUR75000 + EUR3700 per additional month I believe. For a small school, you may be better off spending the money elsewhere that's better known and with less presure to get it done super quickly. Having said that, it looks like a great price and the staff there were really passionate about the school when I visited.

Do you think you would be accepted in Poland? BartoliniAir have a Lauda-mentored and RyanAir-mentored ATPL for EUR60000 at the moment.

http://www.pprune.org/professional-p...hool-leon.html

rudestuff 11th Oct 2023 00:01


Originally Posted by cede (Post 11516771)
Hey rudestuff,

Currently in a similarish career to airlines, just via a different medium....

I've seen you say that now has never been better than to go for the training. I've seen others say that even taking out a loan to part fund is an option worth considering (sorry I can't remember who).

My day job pays well. However it will take me a year or two to save up the figures quoted for modular. There are a few options I have been thinking about;

1. Take as big a loan as I can get, and save up the remaining difference = less time to fATPL and more chances of employment "quicker" in this market, and thus total career earnings. However more debt and first job could be on regional carrier with low pay and high repayments...

2. Save up everything I need including living expenses and then do it all off my own back = will take 2/3 years to save up properly and may have missed my "chance" in the market. However no debt and if I get first job with regional, I'll not be struggling with repayments. Though final career earnings could be less??

3. A balance of the two options. Save up half and loan the other half = best of both worlds or worst of both worlds?

Any thoughts on the above?

Cheers

You mentioned career earnings - which means you understand the importance of getting into the industry sooner rather than later. Don't be afraid of unsecured debt (in the UK at least.) The worst that can happen is that you get a black mark against your name. Work out the largest repayments you could comfortably afford and multiply that by the longest loan period to find out hour much you could borrow and save the rest.

modularlover11 24th Oct 2023 19:31


Originally Posted by rudestuff (Post 11515229)
In the UK at typical prices about £45,000-£50,000 is achievable if you do everything in the optimal order. It's relatively easy to price it up using any flight schools rate-sheet. To finish your fATPL with the CPL test you need at least 200 hours total (with a minimum of 12 hours multi engine) and 77 hours of dual instruction. Plus the cost of medical, ATPL theory, exams, flight tests and licence and landing fees.

Using £175ph (SEP), £450ph (MEP) and £60(Instructor) as an example:
(188x175)+(12×450)+(77*60) = £42,920.

That's doing it all in the UK at school rates. If you split your hour building into 2 blocks of 2 weeks of 50 hours and do it in Florida at £100 per hour (probably cheaper) then even if you spend £2000 each time on flights and hotels you'll save £3500 which brings the cost of aircraft and instructor below £40,000. Plus you'll get the hours a lot quicker.

I'm confused how you got £42,920 for zero to fATPL, why is instructor £60? Getting a PPL itself needs 45 hours of minimum hours, at stapleford its £210 per hour in a cessna 152. £210*45 for the ppl + landing fees + test fee it would set you back more than £12k, and thats just the PPL.

It's similar for Redhill aviation centre, even with their discounted training they totaled the cost of a PPL to £12k. It's on their website on the prices page.


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:49.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.