PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Iran (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/586655-iran.html)

BEagle 29th July 2019 15:54

Perhaps then, Les Quebecois might influence the RCAF's future fighter programme office towards the excellent Dassault Rafale? The Polaris crews with whom I've worked were hugely impressed by the Rafale's capabilities during the Libyan campaign.

SASless 29th July 2019 16:50


By the way, there is nothing small about Quebec, take a look at a world map.
Caution....you just walked off into a Minefield.


Lets compare Quebec to the UK for instance......by land area.

OverlapMaps - Instantly compare any two places on Earth!

Select Country, Province (Canada/Quebec) and United Kingdom and check the results.

Capt Kremmen 29th July 2019 17:24

I'm left wondering why Wolfe bothered.

Lonewolf_50 29th July 2019 18:13

The mistake made was in the treaty in 1763. Wolfe bothered because it was a key strategic objective of the campaign.

tdracer 29th July 2019 18:40


Originally Posted by Imagegear (Post 10531322)
There is no prospect of integration since the Quebecois are increasingly supporting independence from the rest of Canada. TODAY.

If my Canadian friends in BC are in any way representative, the rest of Canada would be happy to see them go...
Before I visited Montreal the first time, I was warned to speak English with a distinctly American accent, if they thought I was Canadian speaking English they would ignore me. Absolutely correct - and quite obvious.


t43562 29th July 2019 20:19


Originally Posted by tdracer (Post 10531494)
If my Canadian friends in BC are in any way representative, the rest of Canada would be happy to see them go...
Before I visited Montreal the first time, I was warned to speak English with a distinctly American accent, if they thought I was Canadian speaking English they would ignore me. Absolutely correct - and quite obvious.

That's sometimes true in South Africa. It is useful to be foreign and not British because then some Afrikaners will then talk to you in English.

Personally I think it's totally incredible that these enormously arrogant people don't get with the program and speak English like everyone in the world should for our convenience.

tdracer 29th July 2019 20:39


Originally Posted by t43562 (Post 10531565)
Personally I think it's totally incredible that these enormously arrogant people don't get with the program and speak English like everyone in the world should for our convenience.

The vast majority of people in Quebec speak English quite well - I've been there a few times and never came across anyone who didn't speak English fluently (I also found it mildly amazing how quickly and seamlessly they could switch between French and English).
They just think everyone should speak French (at least other Canadians).


havoc 29th July 2019 23:40

Speaking of Thread drift France end of WWI
 
https://yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/...ys-middle-east

Lessons From Versailles for Today’s Middle East



Imagegear 30th July 2019 05:09

SASLESS

I think we are in agreement, there is nothing small about Quebec...:ok:

IG

ericsson16 4th August 2019 09:58

Another Tanker Seized
 
https://www.theguardian.com/world/20...to-arab-states

SASless 4th August 2019 11:45

That article says nothing useful.

Which ship, where was it loaded, who owned the cargo, where was it too unload?

Was it Iranian Oil from an Iranian Port or was it from a non-Iranian Port headed to an Non-Iranian port?


From a better source.....at least there is some detail and background info in this article.

https://www.foxnews.com/world/iran-s...l-persian-gulf

ericsson16 4th August 2019 12:26


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10536369)
That article says nothing useful.

Which ship, where was it loaded, who owned the cargo, where was it too unload?

Was it Iranian Oil from an Iranian Port or was it from a non-Iranian Port headed to an Non-Iranian port?

If true,what it does say is that the International community is pretty hopeless.

ericsson16 5th August 2019 10:03

https://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-G...sian-Gulf.html

racedo 7th August 2019 10:44


Originally Posted by ericsson16 (Post 10536390)
If true,what it does say is that the International community is pretty hopeless.

Ambivalent is a better word.

Asturias56 7th August 2019 11:18

Yes - its fine for the USA and the UK to have bases there but Really Bad when the Russians do................

Pot, kettle, black...................................

Capt Kremmen 7th August 2019 11:18

If the British navy again caves in as pathetically as it did during the last interception by armed Iranian fast RIBs in 2007 then the correct description is 'hopeless'.

Risk aversion carried to the nth. Nelson must be quivering with rage !

ORAC 7th August 2019 13:45

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/bu...t-hormuz-71661

Iran and Russia: Getting Ready to Hold Joint-Naval Drills in the Strait of Hormuz

https://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/ori...ounter-us.html

WE Branch Fanatic 7th August 2019 22:51

Capt Kremmen

Just a question - what would you have done, in a RIB and armed with a SA80 and a 9mm pistol, when IRGCN boats armed with 12.7mm and 14.5mm Heavy Machine Guns surround you?

If you are interested - the Fulton report was released under the Freedom of Information Act.

Capt Kremmen 8th August 2019 10:20

I'm not exactly an 'armchair warrior'. I'm a former member of No. 40 Commando and my actions would not have included the pathetic act of surrender that, when it became known, was so damaging to the international reputation of specifically our navy and generally our armed forces.

Resolution, linked to a clear cut extraction plan appeared to be lacking. Thank you for the link.

SASless 8th August 2019 12:51

My t thoughts go towards how did the RIB crew(s) come to find themselves in that predicament to begin with.

It is plain....they did not have the back-up support needed to ensure their safety.

Considering the situation, past conduct by the Iranians....going down with the ship with guns ablaze certainly was not the ending this situation demanded or would be be expected.

I did like the comment in the Report about "overly complex SOP's".

For the Captain....taking a hard line begins at 10 Downing Street and not on the Deck of a RIB in contested waters with a small boat crew with no backup.



All times are GMT. The time now is 05:02.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.