PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Moskva down (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/646198-moskva-down.html)

dead_pan 14th Apr 2022 15:48


Originally Posted by Xeptu (Post 11215324)
Ethical Question for you military people, is it still OK to fire upon an enemy warship even though it may be conducting a rescue operation.

Chris Wreford-Brown apparently generated a firing solution for one of the Argentinian vessels picking up survivors from Belgrano, but opted not to prosecute an attack.

Personally I'd have no problem finishing off a capital ship like Moskva, get rid of it forever.

On which note, I wonder it will have pickets to protect it while it is under tow? They would make a tempting target too...

1771 DELETE 14th Apr 2022 16:10

Moskva down
 
The ship i knew as a Slava in the old days has been seriously damaged by missile attack.
Seems like they were a bit quick to abandon ship if its still afloat.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-61103927

Mogwi 14th Apr 2022 16:16

The wheelbarrows still work!

Mog

Lonewolf_50 14th Apr 2022 17:00

Presuming that this was in fact a cruise missile attack and not an on board fire as the Russian news release asserts:
The aviation, or perhaps aerospace, question I have is how Ukraine's missile system (allegedly Neptun) got cueing and targeting information on a ship at sea when their own maritime assets are in poor shape.
I'll toss out a guess: drone/UAV got a good enough "AoP" for the Moskva and they let loose with a few Neptun's.
There, we have aviation content related to the OP. :}

Nostalgia moment: when we were doing FoN ops in the black sea back in '85, we were, shadowed/escorted by three Soviet Navy ships as we did our "right on the 12 mile limit" transits.
A Krivak frigate, a Udaloy destroyer, and the Slava (CG). She was fairly new then, and was a real beauty to behold.
Our helicopter detachment was not allowed to fly during that transit. We had to stay on the ship for various political reasons. We took a lot of pictures of our escorts, which were of course all turned into the ship's INT officer.
Our little flotilla was overflown by a Backfire at fairly low altitude. Loud, that was.

SpazSinbad 14th Apr 2022 17:06

Some guesswork? Dunno: Loss of Russian Cruiser Moskva: What we know so far - Naval News 14 Apr 2022

Orestes 14th Apr 2022 18:02

Even if it was still afloat, if an on-board fire was threatening the ship's magazine(s), abandoning ship may very well have been the most prudent thing to do, lest the ship go boom like HMS Hood.

Imagegear 14th Apr 2022 18:16

Well if only 55 were taken off the hull by the Turkish ship in the area as is being suggested, that still leaves around 450 trying to prevent the "boom".

IG

Orestes 14th Apr 2022 18:27

As always in war, info is often sketchy. I was going by the RIA Novosti report that the ship was completely evacuated. Whatever the case, the truth will make itself known eventually.

https://ria-ru.translate.goog/202204..._x_tr_pto=wapp


Mariner9 14th Apr 2022 18:41


Originally Posted by Imagegear (Post 11215447)
Well if only 55 were taken off the hull by the Turkish ship in the area as is being suggested, that still leaves around 450 trying to prevent the "boom".

IG

I believe the Turks have denied that any of their vessels were involved in a rescue

etudiant 14th Apr 2022 19:12


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 11215427)
Presuming that this was in fact a cruise missile attack and not an on board fire as the Russian news release asserts:
The aviation, or perhaps aerospace, question I have is how Ukraine's missile system (allegedly Neptun) got cueing and targeting information on a ship at sea when their own maritime assets are in poor shape.
I'll toss out a guess: drone/UAV got a good enough "AoP" for the Moskva and they let loose with a few Neptun's.
There, we have aviation content related to the OP. :}
.



The US has spoken of 'unprecedented intelligence sharing', which suggests that satellite surveillance cuing data might have been supplied to the Ukraine.
Separately, does the 'Neptune' not look rather like a 'Harpoon' at launch?

NutLoose 14th Apr 2022 19:16


Lonewolf_50 14th Apr 2022 19:39


Originally Posted by etudiant (Post 11215470)
Separately, does the 'Neptune' not look rather like a 'Harpoon' at launch?

To me it does, yes.
The Russian missile upon which it is based (KH-35) was dubbed Harpoonski by some Western wags when it came out. :p

dead_pan 14th Apr 2022 20:08

It's sunk!! Just been confirmed by the Russian defence ministry.

Wokkafans 14th Apr 2022 20:15



Original TASS post:


T28B 14th Apr 2022 20:17

In support of dead_pan's posts:

langleybaston 14th Apr 2022 20:22

That's a Gotcha for the tabloids tomorrow then.

Gordon Brown 14th Apr 2022 20:30

Oh dear. How sad. Never mind.

NutLoose 14th Apr 2022 20:30

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ab949a4d1.jpeg

I do feel a slight sadness for the crew, most of them will not be involved with shelling anyone, nor raping or looting, and it will be a blow to a close community in their home port, but it did need taking out and that will reverberate all the way to the top while making the Navy now back right off.

Ninthace 14th Apr 2022 20:31


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 11215484)
To me it does, yes.
The Russian missile upon which it is based (KH-35) was dubbed Harpoonski by some Western wags when it came out. :p

Flys further though does it not?

Ninthace 14th Apr 2022 20:32


Originally Posted by T28B (Post 11215508)

Any word on casualties?


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.