Lossie saved, Leuchars to the Army
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Edinburgh, Scotland
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hope 2011 RAF Leuchars Air Show is safe at least
Hope 2011 RAF Leuchars Air Show is safe at least
Life would be dull just relegated to the comparatively tame East Fortune show.
Life would be dull just relegated to the comparatively tame East Fortune show.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 1,515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Glad Rag,
You post a suggestion that the public sector (of which the armed forces are part) and then in support you post an a part of a BBC article on private sector outsourcing???
The two things are only very tenuously related. Public sector outsourcing to the private sector (which is already a massive industry) is just one means of achieving cuts, but is politically sensitive because it is seen to replace public sector jobs with private sector profit (in my eyes, a very good thing). Hence the soft shoe shuffle by Cameron (a sign of weakness).
To support your argument you need to post an article that suggests that the public sectors cuts are being scaled back, except for defence related cuts which are being scaled up.
Good luck with that.
PS Not a tory, nor a labour. I can't stand politics or politicians of any flavour.
You post a suggestion that the public sector (of which the armed forces are part) and then in support you post an a part of a BBC article on private sector outsourcing???
The two things are only very tenuously related. Public sector outsourcing to the private sector (which is already a massive industry) is just one means of achieving cuts, but is politically sensitive because it is seen to replace public sector jobs with private sector profit (in my eyes, a very good thing). Hence the soft shoe shuffle by Cameron (a sign of weakness).
To support your argument you need to post an article that suggests that the public sectors cuts are being scaled back, except for defence related cuts which are being scaled up.
Good luck with that.
PS Not a tory, nor a labour. I can't stand politics or politicians of any flavour.
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: uk
Age: 55
Posts: 117
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Think you are all missing the point.
Now Salmond and his lot are in power with a majority the whole way of looking at this needs to change.
The SNP are committed to spending minimal amounts on defence (in effect creating a defence force not available for overseas deployment on anything other than "peacekeeping" duties and then only for short periods) and are also commited to withdrawing from NATO (I have this from the horses mouth as I know Angus Robertson their defence spokesman unfortunately for me).
So bases need to close, would you keep them open in Scotland where in all likelyhood in a few years you will need to close them and relocate everything south of the border? personally im surprised they are talking of moving the army in.
Lets face it the SNP are in a win win situation they are jumping up and down screaming about base closures (which they will do anyway) should they close they will shout "London dont care about Scotland etc etc etc" if they keep the bases open "we beat London - they dance to the tartan tune"
Interesting times ahead.
Now Salmond and his lot are in power with a majority the whole way of looking at this needs to change.
The SNP are committed to spending minimal amounts on defence (in effect creating a defence force not available for overseas deployment on anything other than "peacekeeping" duties and then only for short periods) and are also commited to withdrawing from NATO (I have this from the horses mouth as I know Angus Robertson their defence spokesman unfortunately for me).
So bases need to close, would you keep them open in Scotland where in all likelyhood in a few years you will need to close them and relocate everything south of the border? personally im surprised they are talking of moving the army in.
Lets face it the SNP are in a win win situation they are jumping up and down screaming about base closures (which they will do anyway) should they close they will shout "London dont care about Scotland etc etc etc" if they keep the bases open "we beat London - they dance to the tartan tune"
Interesting times ahead.
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Kilmarnock,United Kingdom
Age: 68
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The SNP "policy" on Defence is, in effect, to have only Eire style Defence Forces. In fact Eire was one possible Model for the Scottish Economy too until the Celtic Tiger went pfutt!
From a practical point of view the SNP now has a problem! Scotland has thousands of workers at various Air Force, Army and Naval Establishments as well as a key role in buiding the aircraft carriers and future frigates which would only be put at risk by them talking up the need for a Referendum. The SNP has no intention of doing this and will instead seek more devolved powers in certain areas, for example some aspects of Taxation. Keep an eye on the Scotland Bill passing through Westminster!
Spectacular growth in the SNP vote, if reflected in a Westminster Election, (it never has) might suggest moving Trident to the Thames but I would not get too excited at the prospect yet.
From a practical point of view the SNP now has a problem! Scotland has thousands of workers at various Air Force, Army and Naval Establishments as well as a key role in buiding the aircraft carriers and future frigates which would only be put at risk by them talking up the need for a Referendum. The SNP has no intention of doing this and will instead seek more devolved powers in certain areas, for example some aspects of Taxation. Keep an eye on the Scotland Bill passing through Westminster!
Spectacular growth in the SNP vote, if reflected in a Westminster Election, (it never has) might suggest moving Trident to the Thames but I would not get too excited at the prospect yet.
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: GLASGOW
Posts: 1,289
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Salmond is one of the brightest and politically astute politicians we have. He knows exactly how to play the Westminster playground. However......
The Catch 22 here is that Scotland, to keep employment, local economies surviving, etc etc, requires the bases to be protected. Their (SNP)defense manifesto, states minimal defense. A problem.
We also know that these bases, within reason, can be anywhere on the UK mainland. We also know that we appear to have too many UK bases, as per the review. A problem.
Add in the mix the ''coalition'', and frankly you have one almighty mess, which will come as no surprise to anyone.
Salmond from the Scottish perspective will have to play this one very carefully, as will Cameron, and something will have to give. My view is that the good old compromise may surface, where nothing happens, except doubt and uncertainty, until the cards fall, and that may take some time.
The Catch 22 here is that Scotland, to keep employment, local economies surviving, etc etc, requires the bases to be protected. Their (SNP)defense manifesto, states minimal defense. A problem.
We also know that these bases, within reason, can be anywhere on the UK mainland. We also know that we appear to have too many UK bases, as per the review. A problem.
Add in the mix the ''coalition'', and frankly you have one almighty mess, which will come as no surprise to anyone.
Salmond from the Scottish perspective will have to play this one very carefully, as will Cameron, and something will have to give. My view is that the good old compromise may surface, where nothing happens, except doubt and uncertainty, until the cards fall, and that may take some time.
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: London
Age: 54
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
@ pr00ne.
You are completely right that Defence took a smaller hit in the Comprehensive Spending Review but a little bit of context is appropriate. Defence has had little growth in its real budget in the last 20 years and the growth it has had has not kept pace with inflation in Defence costs. Consequently there have been cuts in every Planning Round as far back as I can remember. By contrast both Health and Education have benefitted from very significant expansion in their budgets - much of which has not translated into increased output; take a look at the budgets of Defence, Education, Health and Social Services in 1989 and take another look at them in 2010 to see the point. The output of the Armed Forces has undeniably increased very significantly over the last 20 years but we are now at the point where resources and commitments don't match.
There is plenty which could still be done to cut costs but the areas to look at are the business costs imposed by Government in the form of 'red tape'. This is an area which has undeniably expanded massively especially over the last decade and could be radically cut back. The answer then is to take another look at what is important and what is not - and stop doing that which we can't afford any more. If the government were cutting costs in that way - there would I think be some logic to the cuts, and they might even be welcomed. Instead we are focussed on cutting the means of output without actually cutting the commitment (indeed our commitments just got bigger, again). It is here that criticism should lie.
You are completely right that Defence took a smaller hit in the Comprehensive Spending Review but a little bit of context is appropriate. Defence has had little growth in its real budget in the last 20 years and the growth it has had has not kept pace with inflation in Defence costs. Consequently there have been cuts in every Planning Round as far back as I can remember. By contrast both Health and Education have benefitted from very significant expansion in their budgets - much of which has not translated into increased output; take a look at the budgets of Defence, Education, Health and Social Services in 1989 and take another look at them in 2010 to see the point. The output of the Armed Forces has undeniably increased very significantly over the last 20 years but we are now at the point where resources and commitments don't match.
There is plenty which could still be done to cut costs but the areas to look at are the business costs imposed by Government in the form of 'red tape'. This is an area which has undeniably expanded massively especially over the last decade and could be radically cut back. The answer then is to take another look at what is important and what is not - and stop doing that which we can't afford any more. If the government were cutting costs in that way - there would I think be some logic to the cuts, and they might even be welcomed. Instead we are focussed on cutting the means of output without actually cutting the commitment (indeed our commitments just got bigger, again). It is here that criticism should lie.
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Wight
Age: 63
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd like Glad-rag to explain the 530 local government redundancies in my local council over the next 3 years, and the reduction of the Connexions service from 36 people to 7 last month? Figment of my imagination I suppose. Along with the reduction in my education job to term time only in September (an immediate reduction of 14% in my salary) I'm probably making it up as I am Tory Boy or something... Tool.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 1,515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just for clarity....
If the argument is that the government is not doing enough to reign in the excessives of our bloated, inefficient and wasteful public sector (all of it), I completely agree.
If the argument is that the government is (relatively) favouring health, education etc at the expense of defence, I completely disagree.
If the argument is that the government is not doing enough to reign in the excessives of our bloated, inefficient and wasteful public sector (all of it), I completely agree.
If the argument is that the government is (relatively) favouring health, education etc at the expense of defence, I completely disagree.
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: London, New York, Paris, Moscow.
Posts: 3,632
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
@Benjaminw1
explain the 530 local government redundancies in my local council over the next 3 years
Go read the Telegraph article again.
It does give the apperance of a U turn and it's now all about staying in power not "doing the right thing".
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: UK
Age: 67
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Close all the bases in Scotland? That's a vote winner - NOT.
Salmond is a yap o' ****e - he would risk 1000's of Scots becoming unemployed and millions of pounds removed from local economies? I doubt it somehow. He's riding high on a tartan wave right now, and so can get away with the current nationalistic posturing, but he best tread very carefully over the subject of base closures. Witness the recent marches by residents of Lossiemouth against the threatened closure - multiply that by all the folk working on the bases and the locals 'supporting' the bases across Scotland...
I suspect if he has a referendum on leaving the Union he might be as disappointed as the LibDems were with the Yes To AV vote...
Salmond is a yap o' ****e - he would risk 1000's of Scots becoming unemployed and millions of pounds removed from local economies? I doubt it somehow. He's riding high on a tartan wave right now, and so can get away with the current nationalistic posturing, but he best tread very carefully over the subject of base closures. Witness the recent marches by residents of Lossiemouth against the threatened closure - multiply that by all the folk working on the bases and the locals 'supporting' the bases across Scotland...
I suspect if he has a referendum on leaving the Union he might be as disappointed as the LibDems were with the Yes To AV vote...
Last edited by Trogger; 11th May 2011 at 12:17.
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: S England
Age: 54
Posts: 320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Personally, I go with the idea that a much larger number of Infantry personnel suddenly descending on St. Andrews would be like a Hells Angel Gang turning up and setting up Headquarters in Tunbridge Wells. If its true the whole idea will prove a fool hardy one regarding the impact on the local area, thinking particularly of St. Andrews!
Go on then, I'll bite. Explain your concerns.
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Kilmarnock,United Kingdom
Age: 68
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"Explain your concerns."
Well to do University Town (William and Kate et al) and the home of golf plus a few thousand squaddies in town each weekend = potential issue for Ming the Mighty as sitting Liberal MP
!
Well to do University Town (William and Kate et al) and the home of golf plus a few thousand squaddies in town each weekend = potential issue for Ming the Mighty as sitting Liberal MP
!
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Tennessee - Smoky Mountains
Age: 55
Posts: 1,602
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Utter BS. Salisbury, a well-to-do Cathedral City has done alright with a few thousand squaddies (and crabs) right next door for a few centuries now (well Army anyway).
If one thinks that airmen make better neighbours than soldiers, one only has to look as far as Carterton for a shining example of how untrue that is.
If one thinks that airmen make better neighbours than soldiers, one only has to look as far as Carterton for a shining example of how untrue that is.
It may well be a Cathedral City Roadster, but it is as you say, a long established Garrison town. The character of St. Andrews though, is still far more likely to have a hefty culture chock visited on it. I understand the inhabitants around Abingdon and Oxford weren't too happy about the Army moving into Abingdon (Dalton Barracks), whether their fears were unfounded is entirely possible I'm sure. But the Army by nature employs a lot more young men, who by nature of the kind of service environment and culture they are brought up in, means at the very least, local perceptions aside, there will be an increased likelihood of larger groups of young men with "attitude" shall we say, looking for a good time on Friday and Saturday night. No doubt St. Andrews would cop its share of young soldiers thronging into Ma Belles and the West Port, just looking for a good time chatting up the young students. When I was stationed at Gatow (although just one particular regiment) the Black Watch billeted a hundred yards or two down the road at Montgomery Barracks were banned from entering the R.A.F. Station, by the Station Commander. This was following an incident involving a knife being pulled at the Naafi Disco one night. Then there was another incident in which a Sergeant from my own unit, charged a small gang from said Regiment who were drunk on the Bus returning from a night out, they allegedly had been making luid remarks to a young girl on the Bus. She was the Group Captain's Daughter. However, upon arrival at Monty Barracks, said Sergeant, Gerry Flanagan, got a culture shock of his own when he saw how the Guardroom RMPs/RPs dealt with the matter in short order. I think he ended up feeling sorry for them afterwards and wishing he'd said nothing on that score alone.
FB
FB
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Closer than you think...
Age: 65
Posts: 390
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ahh Leuchars, St Andrews, Cupar (ok, cut Cupar out) nice peacefull places, spent a happy 3 years at Leuchars with DCRE.
The chicken was nice on the bbq btw... once it was de-feathered, as to how it got there? Anyway I degress from the matter in hand.
Stick a few regiments of Squaddies in Leuchars? No probs, I wouldnt worry about it, the place will be as peacefull as ever. For about a week that is, month max by then all the kit will have been put away...
Meantime recces to find what pubs/clubs the local 'attractions' use will have been done and dusted. And the old beer token pot topped up in the bank ready....
Then, one not so quiet Friday night.... mayhem will spread Life will never be quite the same again as the area slowly transforms into.... the Scottish version of Aldershot
The chicken was nice on the bbq btw... once it was de-feathered, as to how it got there? Anyway I degress from the matter in hand.
Stick a few regiments of Squaddies in Leuchars? No probs, I wouldnt worry about it, the place will be as peacefull as ever. For about a week that is, month max by then all the kit will have been put away...
Meantime recces to find what pubs/clubs the local 'attractions' use will have been done and dusted. And the old beer token pot topped up in the bank ready....
Then, one not so quiet Friday night.... mayhem will spread
Life will never be quite the same again as the area slowly transforms into.... the Scottish version of Aldershot
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Closer than you think...
Age: 65
Posts: 390
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is one good thing though... Todays squaddie is nothing like the beast inflicted on the local populations back in the late 70's through to the 90's.
Todays squaddie is much more civilised, come to that, you could almost describe them as being partly house trained....
Todays squaddie is much more civilised, come to that, you could almost describe them as being partly house trained....
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: London, New York, Paris, Moscow.
Posts: 3,632
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And their is ALWAYS the Irish question. Would the good people of NE Fife be understanding of going from Medium to High? from "over the water"
Oh did I say Irish? Sorry wrong decade or so.
SACC | Special Branch Terror Unit
or not.
Oh did I say Irish? Sorry wrong decade or so.
SACC | Special Branch Terror Unit
or not.
Nemo Me Impune Lacessit
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Derbyshire, England.
Posts: 4,091
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As a one time member of the Royal Engineers, stationed at Ripon, Yorkshire, among other places, I think you may find that some of the locals may not appreciate the lads letting their hair down at the weekends but all is forgiven, on a regular basis, when the lousy weather comes and we were able to rebuild roads, bridges etc. get fodder to animals, pull stuck vehicles out of snow drifts, get stranded people to safety, get sick people to hospital etc. etc. etc.
A regiment of Royal Engineers and a regiment of Army Air Corps would probably brighten the place up a bit and give it some class!
A regiment of Royal Engineers and a regiment of Army Air Corps would probably brighten the place up a bit and give it some class!
As a one time member of the Royal Engineers, stationed at Ripon, Yorkshire, among other places, I think you may find that some of the locals may not appreciate the lads letting their hair down at the weekends but all is forgiven, on a regular basis, when the lousy weather comes and we were able to rebuild roads, bridges etc. get fodder to animals, pull stuck vehicles out of snow drifts, get stranded people to safety, get sick people to hospital etc. etc. etc.
A regiment of Royal Engineers and a regiment of Army Air Corps would probably brighten the place up a bit and give it some class!
A regiment of Royal Engineers and a regiment of Army Air Corps would probably brighten the place up a bit and give it some class!
FB