PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   Which Aerodrome Mk III (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/459713-aerodrome-mk-iii.html)

India Four Two 23rd Sep 2013 04:55

Dora-9,

Thanks for expanding my knowledge of Aussie slang. ;)

Furphy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dora-9 23rd Sep 2013 16:54

TD:

Correct ID of both aircraft and owner unit -not Fenton though (which was a much more heavily timbered location), nor is it Garbutt.

Dora-9 23rd Sep 2013 18:48

On the basis that "a fast game is a good game", here's another clue (different location on the same airfield, almost two years later):

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a1...psd6ad5082.gif

Terry Dactil 23rd Sep 2013 22:44

That escarpment to the East makes me think it could be Adelaide or Perth. However as the black swan is a Western Australia icon it could be a significant clue, so I'll go for Perth.
(It is only 1600 nm from their main base in the NT, but in 1945 I guess their navigation wasn't all that great). :E

Lordflasheart 23rd Sep 2013 23:34

Wild guess - Corunna Downs in the Pilbara ?

dubbleyew eight 24th Sep 2013 00:01

just a guess. Gawler in South Australia.

Dora-9 24th Sep 2013 01:29

LFH has it! Well done, that man - it is Corunna Downs, Australia's "secret air base". Over to you!

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a1...pse2ced8de.jpg

That distinct ridge is immediately south of the main runway - the domestic site lay immediately to the west of this.

Also Terry D - the black swan indicated 25 (City of Perth) Squadron - the connection is obvious - who were based at Cunderdin, east of the Perth, and not in the NT. The remainder of the RAAF force, 82 Wing, comprising 21, 23 & 24 Sqns, were based in the NT. All these units, plus earlier the USAAF's 380th BG, used Corunna to stage through to attack targets in Java. History waffle ends....

Terry Dactil 24th Sep 2013 01:51

What a desolate place!
No wonder it was a "secret" airfield.
http://mw2.google.com/mw-panoramio/p...um/8860200.jpg
Thanks for the incentive to embark on a great history lesson.
(Just finished looking up the details of when the later version nose turrets were fitted to the B-24 as in the second photo).

Dora-9 24th Sep 2013 02:35


What a desolate place!
Yes, and it was 15 miles from Marble Bar, statistically the hottest town in Australia. What a great place to be posted!

I flew into here regularly in the late 1960's, despite being closed in 1945 it was then quite well preserved. The revetments were impressively huge and in a much better state than they are now - then they still looked exactly like the three you can see in the background to my 25 Sqn photo....

There is another airfield at Noonkanbah (then called Nookanbah), ESE from Derby, with similarly enormous revetments (positioned even further away from the airfield) obviously intended for the same purpose, although it doesn't seem to have seen much use in fact.

Lordflasheart 24th Sep 2013 08:26

Thanks Chaps for eliminating all the obvious airfields. Interesting to see how many of these obscure places got bombed - in addition to the well known raids such as on Darwin and Broome. No wonder they staged through. Apparently the livestock got strafed on occasion too - mistaken for troops in the open.

Here's the next - LFH

http://i1271.photobucket.com/albums/...g?t=1380009917

Dora-9 24th Sep 2013 10:56

LFH, I think that Corunna was never located by the Japanese - however there was a nocturnal raid by a "Mavis" on Anna Plains (on the coast south of Broome), it's thought that while the Japanese were aware of a large staging airfield somewhere in the Pilbara, they located and subsequently attacked the prominent airfield at Anna Plains in error.

Terry Dactil 24th Sep 2013 23:16

Yes. It appears that the Japanese never found the place.
When I was searching for "Corunna Downs" to find out where the hell it was, I came across an entry that seemed to imply that the only casualty there was some poor sod who was killed when he fell off a truck when they were all leaving.

Lordflasheart 25th Sep 2013 09:30

Clue: It's not Australia. ;). LFH

Dora-9 25th Sep 2013 11:16

LFH - a ranging shot. Germany?

Lordflasheart 25th Sep 2013 11:31

A lot warmer and a lot further East than Germany, Dora.

Lordflasheart 25th Sep 2013 22:42

Looks like I'm flogging a dead duck here. SE Asia - ca 1948. LFH

Cubs2jets 25th Sep 2013 23:06

San bay Gia Lam, Ha Noi, Vietnam

C2j

Lordflasheart 26th Sep 2013 00:44

Not Hanoi Cubs - but you're in the right territory - (then and now - but not in between) LFH

Terry Dactil 26th Sep 2013 04:04

As I am a newcomer to this thread, can someone explain to me what strategy I should use in locating the current challenge.

I came in on the previous B-24 challenge because there were several clues in that photo.
B-24 & nose art = aircraft and squadron = unit history. Date clue = operational area. Background terrain = possible locations etc.

The current challenge is such low resolution that there is not much detail to work with. There is an airfield and some buildings, some trees, a river and a road. That eliminates places in the desert or snow, but that is about all.

I can nail the location in 30 seconds using Google images, but that method seems to be frowned upon. :=

Help.

India Four Two 26th Sep 2013 04:17


I can nail the location in 30 seconds using Google images, but that method seems to be frowned upon.
Welcome to the thread, Terry. More and more participants are now aware of GI and try to post pictures not already on the web, or obfuscate ones that are.

What is really "frowned on" by most here, is a technique employed by some posters of immediately going to GI and then posting a series of questions, giving the appearance of clever research, while narrowing down the choices to the "correct answer". What's the point?

The only time I look at GI in connection with these threads, is to check an image I want to post.

Terry Dactil 26th Sep 2013 06:56

Thanks India Four Two.

I liked the idea of some details in the photo giving clues to research.
With the B-24 challenge I learned something about:
  • The 380Th BG operations in Australia
  • How to fly the B-24 and operate a Norden bombsight
  • Some history of RAAF 25 squadron
Then about the "secret" Corunna Downs airfield in Western Australia

There are good recent hi-res photos of Corunna Downs here
Code:

http://dandjr.wordpress.com/2009/08/21/secret-airbase-revealed-corunna-downs/
and some rare photos when the base was operational
Code:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFcIrvpcSO4
This all made a great little history lesson that I thoroughly enjoyed.
In contrast, using Google images or the "I guess a country" then "I guess a place" and "no - a bit further east etc," shotgun approach does not appeal so much.

India Four Two 26th Sep 2013 07:08


the "I guess a country" then "I guess a place" and "no - a bit further east etc," shotgun approach
However, sometimes other poster's guesses help me zero-in on a geographic area, that perhaps hadn't occurred to me.

LFH's most recent cryptic comment seems to indicate this airfield is "in my back yard" but I still cannot think of a likely location.

Dora-9 26th Sep 2013 07:25

Good sleuthing TD! Thanks for posting the links.

Looking at those recent hi-res photos makes me realize just how much the revetments have deteriorated in the 45 years (gulp) since I was there.

Lordflasheart 26th Sep 2013 07:57

Good morning Terry and Ifor. (And Dora.) I agree with all your remarks including about the low res. I did check the pic against GI and it came out nil, so considering its history, I was quite pleased with it. I tried GI again after Terry's remarks and now see that there's not a lot escapes the magic eye if you persevere. I haven't time or skill for "obfuscation" and suitable non-internet photos (such as personal or book sourced) are few and far. A lot of the good book stuff finds its way onto the net anyway.


"giving the appearance of clever research, while narrowing down the choices to the "correct answer". What's the point ?"
- and then say "Open House" rather too often .....


What we are currently discussing has given rise to a bit of mild aggro here in the last year or so. I am not sure if I have any suggestions. I'm off for a couple of days so I shall probably have to terminate this challenge in a couple of hours anyway. LFH


PS see three more posts since I started drafting this - -



LFH's most recent cryptic comment
.... ;)

Lordflasheart 26th Sep 2013 09:18

OK - shan't be around for a couple of days - If I may, I'll put this challenge on ice and declare Open House. LFH

Background Noise 26th Sep 2013 13:09

Been done before but an interesting historic pic - taken about 40 years ago,

http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a2...r/DSC_0435.jpg

Lightning Mate 26th Sep 2013 13:22

Ahh - camouflaged Frightnings.

Gutersloh ?

Issa Mk F2As innit.

Background Noise 26th Sep 2013 13:26

Absolutely.

Not a clue on the Mk, it was a teenage snap shot.

Lightning Mate 26th Sep 2013 14:01

Youngster. :E

92 Squadron.

The F2A was the only version in Germany.

Some called it the interim Mk6, but it had the old AI23 radar and Firestreaks.

At least it had GUNS.

Open house I'm afraid.

chevvron 26th Sep 2013 15:55

3 of the old 92 Sqdn aircraft were 'disposed of' to RAE Farnborough. They still had a 'bite' though. When the wings were being cut off one of them, some residual fuel vapour ignited causing an explosion which injured the person doing the cutting up.
I was tower controller at the time and my 60 year old assistant was so quick with the crash alarm that the fire service said they heard the klaxon before they heard the bang.

LFT 30th Sep 2013 19:20

Try this -

http://i43.tinypic.com/2sb7ivs.jpg

Terry Dactil 30th Sep 2013 23:45

OK. I'll bite.
I can't see any passenger terminal with aerobridges, so it does not look like a major domestic or international airport. The small and medium sized hangars suggest private and business aircraft based there, and there is an industrial area in the foreground.
Is it in the UK?

Terry Dactil 1st Oct 2013 01:19

Cancel that UK question.
I see non-ICAO single digit runway designators.
And a what looks like a baseball playing field.
I'll go for North America now.

LFT 1st Oct 2013 16:16

Scheduled air services started just this year and that's 3 x C-130's top right.

Terry Dactil 1st Oct 2013 23:21

Aha. I had my suspicions that the cleanest bit of concrete with grey aircraft on it could have been military, but there was not enough detail to be sure.
Knowing they were C-130s and finding a list of their bases to check runway diagrams soon got a match with 142nd Airlift Squadron, Delaware ANG.

So it is:
New Castle Airport (KILG)
Wilmington Delaware USA

Interesting to know that Delaware was the only state in the USA that did not have a scheduled airline service until very recently.

LFT 2nd Oct 2013 04:50

Well done, New Castle it is, over to you.

Terry Dactil 2nd Oct 2013 08:34

OK. Let's have a bit of history then with this very old photo where the airfield has been tinted green.

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...0s-overlay.jpg

Some clues to start with:
  • This airfield was opened in the 1920's and the land cost just over 5000 pounds.
  • The sale conditions allowed the original owner to graze horses on the land overnight.

evansb 2nd Oct 2013 16:27

Essendon Aerodrome, Melbourne, Australia ?

Terry Dactil 2nd Oct 2013 20:00

That is it. Well done evansb -You have control.
I had several more hints ready, but you were too good. I guess the area reserved for the water tanks was a dead giveaway.
  • The fenced off area was kept by a water supply authority and now contains several large water tanks.
  • The airfield was expanded to the south in 1935 and 1943, and to the north in 1947.
  • Housing development has surrounded the airfield now and, as usual, residents are clamoring for the airfield to be closed, even though it was there first!
Here is what it looks like now.
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...6/Essendon.JPG

evansb 3rd Oct 2013 14:43

Here is another mystery aerodrome:
http://i1047.photobucket.com/albums/...that_dromo.jpg


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:47.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.