PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Project Winton- Airbus (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/644222-project-winton-airbus.html)

itsnotthatbloodyhard 24th Jun 2022 04:47


Originally Posted by Fujiroll76 (Post 11250799)
Anyone want to do the sums on a 2 year wage freeze, over the course of a 20-30 year career.

$5000…shove it

And it’s about the fourth wage freeze the company’s demanded in the last couple of decades, each of which has been followed by handsome profits and tasty bonuses for senior management. On top of a couple of years’ unpaid standdown, rapidly increasing cost of living, and the company’s continuing belligerent, ultimatum-style approach to new aircraft - yep, shove it.

blubak 24th Jun 2022 04:52


Originally Posted by Fujiroll76 (Post 11250799)
Anyone want to do the sums on a 2 year wage freeze, over the course of a 20-30 year career.

$5000…shove it

Love how he says in recognition of the sacrifices that have been made,bet they account for a lot more than $5k per employee. Of course the exec & management 1 off bonus will never be revealed,the deceit rolls on.

SHVC 24th Jun 2022 05:35

Is this online with the shares offering or additional?

blubak 24th Jun 2022 05:57


Originally Posted by SHVC (Post 11250814)
Is this online with the shares offering or additional?

I believe its additional BUT an eba has to be signed to become eligible which if im correct contains an 18 month(could be 24,not sure) wage freeze.
Not hard to figure out who is making the sacrifices & who is the big beneficiary.

Blue Ruin 24th Jun 2022 10:13

Rooing the day: Qantas passengers and crew taken for a ride by the board - Michael West

blubak 24th Jun 2022 21:31

Dont think there was ever much doubt about the mates club,this shows even more why little ol AL never gets questioned.

Ladloy 25th Jun 2022 05:15

never thought I'd see Michael West on pprune.

regitaekilthgiwt 25th Jun 2022 13:16


Originally Posted by Fonz121 (Post 11250748)
A two year pay freeze at the next LH EBA is the hill I will die on while inflation is what it is. I don't care what they threaten.

Agree 1000%

Ollie Onion 25th Jun 2022 22:52


Originally Posted by regitaekilthgiwt (Post 11251525)
Agree 1000%

Good luck, I hope you are successful.

thisishomebrand 28th Jun 2022 10:56


Originally Posted by Fujiroll76 (Post 11250799)
Anyone want to do the sums on a 2 year wage freeze, over the course of a 20-30 year career.

$5000…shove it

While I agree the 2 year pay freeze is ridiculous, the 2 year pay freeze is a relatively smaller loss over longer periods of time, i.e. 20-30 year career, than the lost income as a result of 2% annual increases (previously 3%). For individuals with a shorter timeframes however, the wage freeze will will be much more costly.

ExtraShot 28th Jun 2022 12:17


Originally Posted by thisishomebrand (Post 11252861)
While I agree the 2 year pay freeze is ridiculous, the 2 year pay freeze is a relatively smaller loss over longer periods of time, i.e. 20-30 year career, than the lost income as a result of 2% annual increases (previously 3%). For individuals with a shorter timeframes however, the wage freeze will will be much more costly.

The two year pay freeze is actually a massive loss over a career. That’s over 6% for those two years based on previous increases, the forgone value of which is compounded every pay increase going forward, forever.

The ongoing two percent is just insulting salt in the wound, repeatedly, every year going forward.

TimmyTee 28th Jun 2022 18:51


Originally Posted by thisishomebrand (Post 11252861)
While I agree the 2 year pay freeze is ridiculous, the 2 year pay freeze is a relatively smaller loss over longer periods of time, i.e. 20-30 year career, than the lost income as a result of 2% annual increases (previously 3%). For individuals with a shorter timeframes however, the wage freeze will will be much more costly.

Compounding interest says this is wrong. The longer remaining in your career, the more a wage "freeze" (really a pay cut) impacts you

thisishomebrand 29th Jun 2022 03:04


Originally Posted by ExtraShot (Post 11252901)
The two year pay freeze is actually a massive loss over a career. That’s over 6% for those two years based on previous increases, the forgone value of which is compounded every pay increase going forward, forever.

The ongoing two percent is just insulting salt in the wound, repeatedly, every year going forward.

I was trying to say that while the freeze is costly, the cost of 1% lower salary increases dwarfs that two years of zero, particularly over the longer term.

ExtraShot 29th Jun 2022 05:21


Originally Posted by thisishomebrand (Post 11253223)
I was trying to say that while the freeze is costly, the cost of 1% lower salary increases dwarfs that two years of zero, particularly over the longer term.


I see what you’re saying, but don’t forget the two years of zero increase is there, baked in, forever. It’s compounded every year that you ‘might’ get a pay increase forever, increasing the amount you’re not getting anymore.

Do the maths on that two year pay freeze compounded at the company’s desired 2% annually for a decade, or more! Eye watering.
Then add the ongoing losses of the 1% annually that the company doesn’t think you’re worth.

And don’t get me wrong, 2% is a joke as well. Especially at current rates of inflation.

noclue 29th Jun 2022 08:02

The inflation rate has only been above 3% 3 times in the last 20yrs.


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d67f80969.jpeg

https://www.macrotrends.net/countrie...ation-rate-cpi

tossbag 29th Jun 2022 12:04

Too late now.

TimmyTee 29th Jun 2022 12:22


Originally Posted by noclue (Post 11253304)

putting aside the flawed logic of comparing wages to inflation rate as opposed to cost of living, the above resulted in an average inflation rate of about 2.7%
- which group of pilots in Australia has achieved that year on year? (And due to compounding factor, for every year it wasn’t achieved ie “group wage freezes” etc, the following year would have required a slightly higher wage rise to offset that loss)

SHVC 29th Jun 2022 19:43

Why do we have to accept a 2 yr pay freeze! No other industry that I can find is imposing such draconian measures on their employees. 2% and 2yrs is just a number AJ thought of whilst sitting on the can one morning. There is still one group left to sign off, actually even to start negotiations.

Ollie Onion 29th Jun 2022 23:39

You don’t have to accept it. Fact is though most know that they will be taking it one way or another as Alan has played a blinder by splitting the workers up into so many competing entities that they can play off against each other.

neville_nobody 30th Jun 2022 01:08


The inflation rate has only been above 3% 3 times in the last 20yrs
Except that is looking backwards and it sure ain’t going to be 3% end of next FY.

dr dre 30th Jun 2022 02:20

Both EBAs don’t expire for another 12-18 months, and then negotiations usually take a year, so finalised deals won’t be voted on for another 2-3 years. A different environment will exist then.

Plus a smart negotiating team can technically comply with a wage freeze policy but find smart ways to reach a deal the pilot group can find palatable. Just requires some time.

kiwi grey 30th Jun 2022 02:42

And you're only looking back 20 years.
If you go back to the 1970s & 1980s, inflation was much, much higher than recently

Hawk Circle 1st Jul 2022 01:45


Originally Posted by dr dre (Post 11253837)
Plus a smart negotiating team can technically comply with a wage freeze policy but find smart ways to reach a deal the pilot group can find palatable. Just requires some time.

Meanwhile in 2022:
United (Mainline) Pilots get 14.5% pay raise - Business Insider
American Airlines (Mainline) Pilots offered nearly 17% pay raise - CNBC

Pedalz 1st Jul 2022 05:14

CPI dosen't take into account the sky rocketing real estate market (existing dwellings) either... take a look at 1900-1980 vs 2000-2020 for the J curve. And the shortage of rentals for the younger ones near most bases is becoming an issue.

Thumb War 1st Jul 2022 05:17


Originally Posted by Hawk Circle (Post 11254370)
Meanwhile in 2022:
United (Mainline) Pilots get 14.5% pay raise - Business Insider
American Airlines (Mainline) Pilots offered nearly 17% pay raise - CNBC


I hear the United union aren’t pleased with 14.5% in light of the better offer made to AA

SHVC 4th Jul 2022 09:11

QF and group better pick their act up quick smart otherwise there will be no punters left to fly on them. Pi$$ing so many ppl off each day the latest, knowingly departing Sydney for Wellington then diverting to Christchurch because of curfew. Telling lax to grab a couch and get comfy. Hope AJ holiday is most excellent.

Not hearing such from VA pax must be running smoothly there.

dr dre 4th Jul 2022 11:55


Originally Posted by SHVC (Post 11255903)

Not hearing such from VA pax must be running smoothly there.

BITRE on time departure data for May had VA group at 64% OTP vs QF group at 61.5%. Not ideal and should be doing better but VA had a similar fall in OTP compare to QF.

Photos from Sydney T2, pretty chaotic and it mostly seems to be at the VA check in. A quick perusal of the VA FB page shows lots of angry comments regarding flight delays, cancellations, baggage issues, call centre wait times, overbooking etc.

And a perusal of news sites shows cancellations and delays all across the northern hemisphere this summer. This isn’t making any excuses for what’s happening atm, I think all airlines need to do better, but it’s not a problem confined to just one airline in one country.

I remember in 2011 everyone was saying that would be the end of QF too, everyone would flock to VA. What ended up happening?


JoeTripodi 4th Jul 2022 13:02

Not only the punters are leaving Qantas, there is currently a max exodus of pilots from the group headed to the USA.

Thumb War 4th Jul 2022 15:07


Originally Posted by JoeTripodi (Post 11256064)
Not only the punters are leaving Qantas, there is currently a max exodus of pilots from the group headed to the USA.

They should all be applauded. Employees voting with their feet is the only thing that makes airline management think about coughing up a few more dollars

gordonfvckingramsay 5th Jul 2022 03:41


Originally Posted by Thumb War (Post 11256125)
They should all be applauded. Employees voting with their feet is the only thing that makes airline management think about coughing up a few more dollars

A few more dollars? When companies like Atlas are throwing numbers around that would give AJ heartburn, it’s clear that there will need to be HUUUUGE incentives.

tossbag 5th Jul 2022 04:05

Huge numbers leaving? Really?

C441 5th Jul 2022 07:27


Originally Posted by JoeTripodi (Post 11256064)
Not only the punters are leaving Qantas, there is currently a max exodus of pilots from the group headed to the USA.

Would I be right in guessing that's mainly from non-mainline group entities with a few less-senior S/O's from Longhaul?

I believe most US operators wont take an ex-Qantas group pilot unless they resign; that is not acceptable if on LWOP.

dr dre 5th Jul 2022 14:01


Originally Posted by C441 (Post 11256464)
Would I be right in guessing that's mainly from non-mainline group entities with a few less-senior S/O's from Longhaul?

I believe most US operators wont take an ex-Qantas group pilot unless they resign; that is not acceptable if on LWOP.

I haven’t heard of a single current mainline pilot resigning to go to a US regional (legacy carriers only on offer for those with green cards). Even if there were it would be a single digit number only.

I suspect a few who took VR may have taken up a contract to fly for Atlas for a couple of years, but only after a VR package, and pretty much everyone who took VR had less than 5 years to go to retirement anyway. There’s certainly no “exodus”.

Thumb War 5th Jul 2022 14:57

Know of 1 mainline S/O currently going through the process. I think as said by a previous poster it would more likely be from other group companies.

LostWanderer 6th Jul 2022 02:42


Originally Posted by Thumb War (Post 11256680)
Know of 1 mainline S/O currently going through the process. I think as said by a previous poster it would more likely be from other group companies.

Have heard from buddies over there now that there are indeed a number of QF S/Os jumping from the rat to a few different US regionals, I guess they like to actually fly airplanes. Wouldn't be shocked if a bunch of expats are bouncing back to oz as well though.

Vindiesel 6th Jul 2022 02:57


Originally Posted by LostWanderer (Post 11256961)
Have heard from buddies over there now that there are indeed a number of QF S/Os jumping from the rat to a few different US regionals, I guess they like to actually fly airplanes. Wouldn't be shocked if a bunch of expats are bouncing back to oz as well though.

If they want to "actually fly airlplaes" then it's a very quick path to becoming a 737 F/O in mainline and able to make ~180-200k on comfortable hours. Seems a lot better than flogging around for a second tier US carrier.

stillcallozhome 6th Jul 2022 03:08


Originally Posted by Vindiesel (Post 11256963)
If they want to "actually fly airlplaes" then it's a very quick path to becoming a 737 F/O in mainline and able to make ~180-200k on comfortable hours. Seems a lot better than flogging around for a second tier US carrier.

Nope. They’ll make more at the regionals over there and have better conditions than Qf 737. Cancellation pay - you’re paid a minimum of what your initial roster is published at. Duty and trip rigs. Four hotels a month if you commute. Bonuses. Better flying. More destinations. Far better atc and procedures. List goes on….

But this is probably more appropriate on the thread for US regionals.

SIDS N STARS 6th Jul 2022 05:43

A220/B717 CPT @ DL on $350K/AUD... maybe $100K more than what QF will pay NJS?? Multiplied by X number of years... that's a lot of beer

https://www.airlinepilotcentral.com/...lta_air_lines#

stillcallozhome 6th Jul 2022 06:34


Originally Posted by SIDS N STARS (Post 11256992)
A220/B717 CPT @ DL on $350K/AUD... maybe $100K more than what QF will pay NJS?? Multiplied by X number of years... that's a lot of beer

https://www.airlinepilotcentral.com/...lta_air_lines#

Not really applicable as that’s a legacy and won’t take E3 applicants. Speaking more to the regionals that are offering over $150p/h for 1st year FO with huge bonuses up to 60k on top. I believe these were introduced with an August 2024 expiry so would suit well to go for a brief period. Regionals over there are rarely career destinations anymore. More a stepping stone to legacy or fedex/ups etc.

bazza stub 6th Jul 2022 07:13


Originally Posted by SIDS N STARS (Post 11256992)
A220/B717 CPT @ DL on $350K/AUD... maybe $100K more than what QF will pay NJS?? Multiplied by X number of years... that's a lot of beer

https://www.airlinepilotcentral.com/...lta_air_lines#


I believe the data on the NJS salary is incorrect. NJS pilots are not on $100k less than $350k. They don’t even crack $200k


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:08.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.