Most idiotic things you've seen from a tower?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: London
Posts: 48
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Most idiotic things you've seen from a tower?
Just wondered if ATCOs would mind sharing stories about the most stupid things they've observed from their towers? Be it pilots or ground crew etc.
One particular favourite of mine:
Manchester dual runway ops, quite a significant queue had built up for 24L. Jet2 737 gets crossing clearance from F1 to V5 for departure from VA1. The aircraft began crossing 24R (arrival RWY) but then proceded to slow half way across, and then stop with its tail end halfway over the runway edge.
Controller: Channex 890 do you have a problem?
Aircraft: Negative
Controller: Well you're infringing the landing runway. Expedite to V5!
Aircraft: Well we were just biding our time to see if we preferred Tango 1
Controller: There's landing traffic 1 mile, move now!
Aircraft: Oh, roger, wilco
Controller: Channex 890 you were given V5, so you're expected to go to V5
Aircraft: Apologies
...
Controller: Channex 890 via VA1 line up and wait 24L
Aircraft: Line up 24L
Controller: Channex 890 24L clear takeoff ...
Aircraft: Er, we're not quite ready ma'am
Controller: [many expletives to colleagues in tower!!!]
How ridiculous! Possibly didn't like being given instructions from a lady controller. Anyone observed anything similiar?
One particular favourite of mine:
Manchester dual runway ops, quite a significant queue had built up for 24L. Jet2 737 gets crossing clearance from F1 to V5 for departure from VA1. The aircraft began crossing 24R (arrival RWY) but then proceded to slow half way across, and then stop with its tail end halfway over the runway edge.
Controller: Channex 890 do you have a problem?
Aircraft: Negative
Controller: Well you're infringing the landing runway. Expedite to V5!
Aircraft: Well we were just biding our time to see if we preferred Tango 1
Controller: There's landing traffic 1 mile, move now!
Aircraft: Oh, roger, wilco
Controller: Channex 890 you were given V5, so you're expected to go to V5
Aircraft: Apologies
...
Controller: Channex 890 via VA1 line up and wait 24L
Aircraft: Line up 24L
Controller: Channex 890 24L clear takeoff ...
Aircraft: Er, we're not quite ready ma'am
Controller: [many expletives to colleagues in tower!!!]
How ridiculous! Possibly didn't like being given instructions from a lady controller. Anyone observed anything similiar?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Controller: Channex 890 via VA1 line up and wait 24L
Aircraft: Line up 24L
Controller: Channex 890 24L clear takeoff ...
Aircraft: Er, we're not quite ready ma'am
Controller: [many expletives to colleagues in tower!!!]
Aircraft: Line up 24L
Controller: Channex 890 24L clear takeoff ...
Aircraft: Er, we're not quite ready ma'am
Controller: [many expletives to colleagues in tower!!!]
Possibly didn't like being given instructions from a lady controller.
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: 59°45'36N 10°27'59E
Posts: 1,032
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Early January morning, it's fallen approx 1 ft of snow during the night. Snow clearance team has cleared the runway, but only 2 taxiways from the apron. (The parallel is closed)
First departure calls for taxi, and is given via one of the 2 open ones, and onto the rwy via backtrack. As the kind soul I am, only the lights on the cleared twys are lit, to avoid the 737 going off the reservation.
When the 737 reaches the parallel, they turn 90 degrees to the left and goes full steam down the dark parallel twy in 1 foot of snow........only to get stuck in a drift right away.
It was hard to find something appropriate to say!
----------------------------------------
Female collage of mine experienced this:
Helicopter doing hover, 1 engine flyaways etc on the parallel TWY is told to land due tfc on final for the RWY. (To close for independent ops)
TWR: "Lynx land on Y, remain on GND"
Lynx: " WHY?"
TWR: "Trafiic on 2 mile final, land now"
Lynx: "Yeah, we can se him, he's no factor"
TWR: "Lynx, land IMMEDIATELY, you need to be on GND before he lands"
(Female collage is about to blow all the fuses at this point, feisty redhead and all!)
Lynx: "That is not necessary, we will keep clear"
Que 737 going missed at 0.5 miles for another 50nm of vectors.
She eventually kicked the Lynx over to the hangar pan and refused further flight, and gave a very graphic debrief on the phone with the pilot of the Lynx later in the day!
First departure calls for taxi, and is given via one of the 2 open ones, and onto the rwy via backtrack. As the kind soul I am, only the lights on the cleared twys are lit, to avoid the 737 going off the reservation.
When the 737 reaches the parallel, they turn 90 degrees to the left and goes full steam down the dark parallel twy in 1 foot of snow........only to get stuck in a drift right away.
It was hard to find something appropriate to say!
----------------------------------------
Female collage of mine experienced this:
Helicopter doing hover, 1 engine flyaways etc on the parallel TWY is told to land due tfc on final for the RWY. (To close for independent ops)
TWR: "Lynx land on Y, remain on GND"
Lynx: " WHY?"
TWR: "Trafiic on 2 mile final, land now"
Lynx: "Yeah, we can se him, he's no factor"
TWR: "Lynx, land IMMEDIATELY, you need to be on GND before he lands"
(Female collage is about to blow all the fuses at this point, feisty redhead and all!)
Lynx: "That is not necessary, we will keep clear"
Que 737 going missed at 0.5 miles for another 50nm of vectors.
She eventually kicked the Lynx over to the hangar pan and refused further flight, and gave a very graphic debrief on the phone with the pilot of the Lynx later in the day!
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Apa, apo ndi kulikonse!
Posts: 1,757
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Some of the most idiotic things I have seen in a tower have come from fellow ATCOs!!
(including an "airmiss" between a G4 crossing the piano keys in the flare vs a model aircraft (a spitfire) - someone who forgot to ground the model flyers!???)
(including an "airmiss" between a G4 crossing the piano keys in the flare vs a model aircraft (a spitfire) - someone who forgot to ground the model flyers!???)
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: London
Posts: 48
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flower, Vintage and Spitoon. This actually happened, the lady atco part was to say that the controller this happened to was a highly experienced lady atco, (who was sitting next to me at the time !!) and the pilot was extremely cocky. Just a possible 'reason' for his behaviour. Not that I implied that myself whatsoever!
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: UK
Posts: 1,294
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I as a lady ATCO have never had an issue with male or female pilots, if anything they tend to respond better to you.
We all of us make mistakes everyday , I am quite sure we wouldn't appreciate if pilots started up a thread on stupid things ATCOs do.
We all of us make mistakes everyday , I am quite sure we wouldn't appreciate if pilots started up a thread on stupid things ATCOs do.
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: cheshire
Posts: 208
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SPITOON
what are you talking about.I clear you to cross an active rwy, you cross , why should I need another plan . Regarding your comment about understanding acft performance , as far as I was concerned when given a cleareance to cross an active rwy you advance the throttles and get across asap ,dont stop half way across and think where you will be departing from , do that when you are clear. I think its called airmanship
what are you talking about.I clear you to cross an active rwy, you cross , why should I need another plan . Regarding your comment about understanding acft performance , as far as I was concerned when given a cleareance to cross an active rwy you advance the throttles and get across asap ,dont stop half way across and think where you will be departing from , do that when you are clear. I think its called airmanship
Guest
Posts: n/a
opnot, my comments were about the second example cited but don't you have another plan for when something doesn't happen as planned - but I suppose just to be ready to bawl the pilot out on the RTF could be called a plan.
Yup, airmanship is a good thing for a crew to have but sadly we're not all perfect all of the time. It's a bit like professionalism on the RTF for controllers.
And I didn't make any comment about aircraft performance in my post but, rather, about how an aircraft is operated. My point was that there are a good many things that might be cause for unexpected query just before take-off. But on reflection I guess you're probably right, it's obviously just a crew who really shouldn't be flying a proper aeroplane from a busy airport.
And, yes, you're also right that I don't work CC so I cannot understand what a real busy place is like. But I guess it's just as well because I probably couldn't come up to your high standards!
Yup, airmanship is a good thing for a crew to have but sadly we're not all perfect all of the time. It's a bit like professionalism on the RTF for controllers.
And I didn't make any comment about aircraft performance in my post but, rather, about how an aircraft is operated. My point was that there are a good many things that might be cause for unexpected query just before take-off. But on reflection I guess you're probably right, it's obviously just a crew who really shouldn't be flying a proper aeroplane from a busy airport.
And, yes, you're also right that I don't work CC so I cannot understand what a real busy place is like. But I guess it's just as well because I probably couldn't come up to your high standards!
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Deepest darkest Inbredland....
Posts: 606
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Actually Spitoon to line up and when cleared for take-off say you're not ready yet is incredibly un-professional. If you are not ready don't line up. Simple. On single runway ops it's really exciting then telling another aircraft to go around and then the aircraft on the runway to report ready. Bit late!!!
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: The Grim North
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Spitoon
Yup, airmanship is a good thing for a crew to have but sadly we're not all perfect all of the time.
I don't want sound like I'm having a go Spitoon, but safety will always come first where ATC are concerned. Comercial interests are not ignored but will always be second place to safety.
Guest
Posts: n/a
terrain and ayr, thanks for your comments - it's always good to feel talked down to. Despite your suggestions to the contrary, I do know a bit about ATC. I also know a little about how modern aircraft are operated - I find it helps when I am controlling. There's always at least two sides to every situation.
Yup, runways are dangerous places. Sadly, the point I was trying to make is clearly lost on you and others. But hey, Manchester's clearly a safe place from the ATC point of view - all the incident reports must come about because of those idiot pilots.
Professionalism is not simply about shifting more aircraft on your runway(s) safely - I can't help feeling that it's about doing it smoothly....for all concerned.
But, you know, I really don't know why I'm bothering......
Yup, runways are dangerous places. Sadly, the point I was trying to make is clearly lost on you and others. But hey, Manchester's clearly a safe place from the ATC point of view - all the incident reports must come about because of those idiot pilots.
Professionalism is not simply about shifting more aircraft on your runway(s) safely - I can't help feeling that it's about doing it smoothly....for all concerned.
But, you know, I really don't know why I'm bothering......
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Apa, apo ndi kulikonse!
Posts: 1,757
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well you're infringing the landing runway. Expedite
StandupfortheUlstermen
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Peoples' Democratic Republic of Wurzelsetshire
Age: 53
Posts: 1,182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
mmm, shall I say - I have seen many stupid things from a tower but I decline to comment on the grounds that I may incriminate myself?
Or that most of the stupid things I have seen have been managers?
Did once tell a light twin that subject the one pushing back on to the taxiway, he could taxi to stand xx. Light twin didn't stop but instead executed what can only be described as an 'over taking' manouevre twixt the push back and the apron and continued to his stand!
And no, it wasn't at Ooh-arr International.
Or that most of the stupid things I have seen have been managers?
Did once tell a light twin that subject the one pushing back on to the taxiway, he could taxi to stand xx. Light twin didn't stop but instead executed what can only be described as an 'over taking' manouevre twixt the push back and the apron and continued to his stand!
And no, it wasn't at Ooh-arr International.