PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Airlines, Airports & Routes (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes-85/)
-   -   Flybe-9 (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes/599822-flybe-9-a.html)

mik3bravo 14th Nov 2018 06:01


Originally Posted by toledoashley (Post 10310672)
There is also a difference in actively seeking for a merger/take over and being approached for one...

True, but shareholders run the show now, board largely irrelevant under these circumstances.

Plane.Silly 14th Nov 2018 06:44


Virgin would be another option but I think they have bigger fish to fry.
They did have their 'Little Red' operation a few years back, would certainly give then the scale and equipment necessary to kickstart that again.
Bit of an outsider though IMHO, i'd peg Stobart for the takeover. Remember when their bid was rejected earlier in the year because FlyBe though they were being undervalued?...now the company is worth around 1/10th of the price, it would seem like a steal to them

SWBKCB 14th Nov 2018 06:56

Why the assumption that the buyer will be an airline? Surely the "usual suspects" will have been approached before there was a public announcement?

rowly6339 14th Nov 2018 07:18

Can't help but think that the shareholders should be held to account here, they had the chance to save the airline when Stobart came in but they said no and thought that they could do better. Now the company is worth nowhere near what Stobart offered and so they will all be out of pocket and we could see the end of BE. If Stobart do go back in for BE it would be a steal for them however with the state the business is in would Stobart have the time and money to turn things around?

GCILover 14th Nov 2018 07:22

BA Citiflyer would be an ideal candidate. I know its a massive expansion but it would be for whoever looked at it.

22/04 14th Nov 2018 07:37

How strong are Loganair/Bmi Regional? Could they "buy" in the way that BA bought Dan Air, ( e.g. for £5) retaining some E-Jets and crews operating ex BHX, SOU and MAN. BMi could drop the regional and become British Midland once again unless BA hold the rights to that name. Stobart would take over IOM,NQY. LCY would be left to an expanded BA Cityflyer. Easy to pick up some sun routes where viable e.g. SOU and EXT.

VS won't return to domestic flying- they weren't "VS Atlanta" when they dabbled with that. LHR domestic will be BA BA BA again.

kcockayne 14th Nov 2018 07:41

Funny, but they seem to blame it all on outside factors & not attribute even only a small part of their misfortunes on “bad management”.

Planespeaking 14th Nov 2018 07:46


Originally Posted by kcockayne (Post 10310747)
Funny, but they seem to blame it all on outside factors & not attribute even only a small part of their misfortunes on “bad management”.


Well there's a surprise!!

Wycombe 14th Nov 2018 07:48


IAG it, rebrand to Aer Lingus Regional
Like most of what mik3bravo says, but why on earth brand as EI Regional? It needs to branded as BA. That would work on the trunk routes at BEE's major hubs, but a lot of peripheral flying (eg, most if not all regional France from SOU) would have to go in order to turn the operation round. Rationalisation would be needed at LCY, where they widely compete at present.

The fact that Stobart have already started flying a couple of EMB's (or are about to) for CFE could be described as interesting.

LTNman 14th Nov 2018 07:50

Maybe from an interested airlines point of view is to let Flybe fold and just grab the routes they think are profitable without taking on the liabilities of Flybe

SWBKCB 14th Nov 2018 07:52


The fact that Stobart have already started flying a couple of EMB's (or are about to) for CFE could be described as interesting.
Could it? In what way?

ATNotts 14th Nov 2018 08:04


Originally Posted by LTNman (Post 10310756)
Maybe from an interested airlines point of view is to let Flybe fold and just grab the routes they think are profitable without taking on the liabilities of Flybe

More likely a pre-pack administration, where the sale is agreed before entering administration, ensuring continuity of service, whilst the creditors are hung out to dry. Either that or a purchase by a bunch of venture capitalist sharks such as Greybull.

B Fraser 14th Nov 2018 08:06

Blaming Brexit ? I thought Flybe were taking a kicking thanks to EU261 and Brexit offered the best chance of becoming exempt. Not so long ago my family had a 5 hour delay on the way home which not only paid for all flights but made me a 4 figure profit. That has to be wrong but thank you Brussels.

Easy's share price is virtually unchanged year on year and they are in the same market so Flybe's excuses are totally bolleaux. Nothing at all to do with paying the over-rated CEO a shed load of "golden hello's" then ?

Alteagod 14th Nov 2018 08:09

Is the plan to sell as one business or hive off different departments? My monies on divide it up and sell what you can. Better that than going belly up!

Brigantee 14th Nov 2018 08:10


Originally Posted by ATNotts (Post 10310771)
More likely a pre-pack administration, where the sale is agreed before entering administration, ensuring continuity of service, whilst the creditors are hung out to dry. Either that or a purchase by a bunch of venture capitalist sharks such as Greybull.

Greybull ownership would be the worst possible outcome that’s for sure

ATNotts 14th Nov 2018 08:23


Easy's share price is virtually unchanged year on year and they are in the same market so Flybe's excuses are totally bolleaux. Nothing at all to do with paying the over-rated CEO a shed load of "golden hello's" then ?
EasyJet are in a completely different market, largely London centric in UK, and really a pan European airline.

FlyBe is suffering in the same way as most regional carriers in recent history have, too many intra regional services making too little, if any money. In the scheme of things only the major secondary trunk routes such as those between SOU / BHX / MAN / CWL and Scotland / NI, plus connections between the likes of MAN / BHX / SOU to major European business centres are truly viable with the fleet that BE operate.

Any new owner is going to drastically cut back on peripheral, marginal services which will bode badly for some UK airports.

Beanjet 14th Nov 2018 08:31

My money will be on IAG, restructure the routes, some branded to Cityflyer and some to vueling. Either way there will be a dramatic reduction of routes and expect prices to rise for passengers.

Alot of airlines have an interested in the outcome as flybe feed many passengers into their hubs for international routes etc. VS for example.

Lots of uncertainty for staff, my thoughts are with you at this unsettled time.

Planespeaking 14th Nov 2018 08:33


Originally Posted by ATNotts (Post 10310784)
EasyJet are in a completely different market, largely London centric in UK, and really a pan European airline.

FlyBe is suffering in the same way as most regional carriers in recent history have, too many intra regional services making too little, if any money. In the scheme of things only the major secondary trunk routes such as those between SOU / BHX / MAN / CWL and Scotland / NI, plus connections between the likes of MAN / BHX / SOU to major European business centres are truly viable with the fleet that BE operate.

Any new owner is going to drastically cut back on peripheral, marginal services which will bode badly for some UK airports.

Whilst I have no brief for Flybe's recent management I do feel they took over a toxic legacy from Jim (call me James) French. Under his stewardship the airline vastly expanded and over ordered from Embraer, and it has been reported that terms of acquisition were very costly. I do hope for the sake of staff and airports such as SOU that a rescue can be arranged.


willy wombat 14th Nov 2018 08:39

In terms of a sale, Flybe management have made a bit of a rod for their own back banging on about how expensive and unprofitable the E195s are. Who'd want to take that on? I'm with ATNotts - pre-pack Administration or just insolvency with the others nipping in to pick up the "worthwhile" routes (Loganair back on GLA MAN for example).

Wycombe 14th Nov 2018 08:51


The fact that Stobart have already started flying a couple of EMB's (or are about to) for CFE could be described as interesting.
Could it? In what way?
Stobart pick-up Flybe for a snip (much cheaper than last time they tried), operate as BA under a franchise agreement having cherry-picked the routes that will work, as many have already suggested.

Even if the above happens, likely to be bad news for even the larger bases and for or Exeter in general :-(

I fly with BEE quite a bit and the people are great - sad to see this happening.

El Bunto 14th Nov 2018 09:03


Originally Posted by mik3bravo (Post 10310676)
True, but shareholders run the show now, board largely irrelevant under these circumstances.

The public shareholders, incidentally, don't have any share in the actual airline. It remains a limited company ( FlyBE Ltd ).

They do have shares in FlyBE Group Plc which is a holding company ( formerly Walker Aviation Ltd ). So they can tell that board what to do, but not the airline management.

The aircraft which are owned directly are registered to FlyBE Ltd, rather than the Group, which could make a sale of that unit quite straiightforward; own aircraft, no public shareholders.

Likewise FlyBE Aviation Services Ltd is a nice tidy little MRO package, complete with a contract for A400 work.

I forsee the individual units being sold-off and the Group fading away into nothingness.

Navpi 14th Nov 2018 09:06

If BA CITIflyer did get it I fear for the Exeter HQ.

I assume they would move the HQ to Manchester where the CF headquarters staff are based.

B Fraser 14th Nov 2018 09:24


Originally Posted by ATNotts (Post 10310784)
EasyJet are in a completely different market, largely London centric in UK, and really a pan European airline.

The market is the same regardless and both Flybe and Easy have a strong regional presence. Both are under the cosh of the same punitive Eu rules, so beloved by airline CFO's.

Anyway, good of Flybe to blame Brexit and hide the news on a day when that subject will dominate the headlines. Coincidence ? I think not.

BA318 14th Nov 2018 09:42

You have to wonder who would hire Christine Ourmieres-Widener after this. She hasn't done well at Cityjet or Flybe.

Cazza_fly 14th Nov 2018 10:01


Originally Posted by BA318 (Post 10310867)
You have to wonder who would hire Christine Ourmieres-Widener after this. She hasn't done well at Cityjet or Flybe.

Agreed. She focuses her time on far too many projects outside of the airline operation itself unfortunately. The airlines needs someone with focus and structure only for the business in hand.

Such a shame, but fingers crossed for a very positive outcome for all involved with the company. Especially its very hard working and passionate frontline staff. Flybe are a very good airline with a very good product for its market. I hope it gets the investment and leadership it needs and remains as Flybe.

Mike Flynn 14th Nov 2018 10:20


Originally Posted by El Bunto (Post 10310832)
The public shareholders, incidentally, don't have any share in the actual airline. It remains a limited company ( FlyBE Ltd ).

They do have shares in FlyBE Group Plc which is a holding company ( formerly Walker Aviation Ltd ). So they can tell that board what to do, but not the airline management.

The aircraft which are owned directly are registered to FlyBE Ltd, rather than the Group, which could make a sale of that unit quite straiightforward; own aircraft, no public shareholders.

Likewise FlyBE Aviation Services Ltd is a nice tidy little MRO package, complete with a contract for A400 work.

I forsee the individual units being sold-off and the Group fading away into nothingness.

I agree.

I remember Walker when he ran his steel company and moved to Jersey and invested in building Jersey European. Indeed the instructor who sent me solo was later employed as a pilot flying their old twin Otters..

A lot of their business has been built on routes that are just about marginal.

Norwich falls in to that arena.

With the decline in operations in the southern North Sea one has to ask how much longer the regular revenue from oil traffic will support the airport.

If we spool back a few years ago we had this fiasco.

In 2008, in order to avoid losing a £280,000 rebate from Norwich Flybe advertised for "actors", as well as offering free return flights to Dublin on its website.

Eastern,Flybe and Loganair face tough times ahead as do some of the airports they serve.

Wycombe 14th Nov 2018 10:51


You have to wonder who would hire Christine Ourmieres-Widener after this.
One suspects that at 54, and that after the best part of 10 years earning a CEO salary she probably doesn't need to work again.

Sharklet_321 14th Nov 2018 10:55

The old 'Jersey European' culture still exists to this day, probably why they're in such a spot

racedo 14th Nov 2018 11:34

Current owners are in this link https://www.marketscreener.com/FLYBE...78595/company/

Break up value is greater than value of the company on Stock Exchange which is not a good thing. This means someone can buy and break up all the parts of it................... or as they are better known as "asset strip".

Brigantee 14th Nov 2018 11:47

Heard earlier today a big middle eastern opeartor is interested if true it good be good news
Emirates maybe?

inOban 14th Nov 2018 11:48

I see that the share price has risen only a little, which suggests that the market isn't anticipating any bidding war.

Alteagod 14th Nov 2018 14:10

Probably not the best day to break the news with all the Brexit news or was it a ploy? I am sure there are more than one or two Airport commercial departments having a very reflectave and contemplatery conversation with the airport teams today.

inOban 14th Nov 2018 17:14

And by the end of day the shares were down slightly.

mik3bravo 14th Nov 2018 18:54

More I analyse this, the more I'm coming back to the same conclusion as a few of you have speculated. Potentially, administration. Asset strip constituent entities to maximise asset disposal values, reconcile debtors and creditors, leave warranties & indemnities insurance to respond to residual liabilities. That may be the optimum as opposed to a rescue package with its significant risks.

ib26uk 14th Nov 2018 21:13

Dont shoot the messenger but have just seen this story online...

https://www.ft.com/content/9d5ab702-...-04b8afea6ea3t

The story mentions the flybe LGW slots? LGW to NQY?.......

I was thinking as I read the story about easyJet acquiring flybe - Manchester slots? flybe have a big operation at MAN - Surely easyJet would be interested in MAN slots...

Tagron 14th Nov 2018 21:16

According to the FT EasyJet and Stobart are both looking at Flybe, EZY interested in parts of the business and STK the whole entity.or parts.
Stobart is not now ruling out another bid, potentially with the same structure as before — co-investment with a private equity partner and taken off Stobart’s balance sheet.

That latter statement seems quite specific so perhaps there might be more to it then the general speculation that is doing the rounds

racedo 14th Nov 2018 21:59


Originally Posted by Brigantee (Post 10310970)
Heard earlier today a big middle eastern opeartor is interested if true it good be good news
Emirates maybe?

Nope. Takeover rules prevent a Non EU Airline owning more that 49.99% of an EU Airline. Rules will still apply until formal leave occurs.

Lets face it what would Flybe offer to someone like that ?

racedo 14th Nov 2018 22:04


Originally Posted by Tagron (Post 10311470)
According to the FT EasyJet and Stobart are both looking at Flybe, EZY interested in parts of the business and STK the whole entity.or parts.
Stobart is not now ruling out another bid, potentially with the same structure as before — co-investment with a private equity partner and taken off Stobart’s balance sheet.

That latter statement seems quite specific so perhaps there might be more to it then the general speculation that is doing the rounds

PE not going to get involved unless it gets 5-6 times its investment as a return bearing in mind risk of an underperfoming airline. Slots offer some value BUT slots ultimately belong to Airport and they may take a different view on their sale. Specific routes will be of interest to airlines but aside from slots there is really no barrier from another airline starting up same route.

Navpi 14th Nov 2018 22:11


Originally Posted by ib26uk (Post 10311464)
Dont shoot the messenger but have just seen this story online...

https://www.ft.com/content/9d5ab702-...-04b8afea6ea3t

The story mentions the flybe LGW slots? LGW to NQY?.......

I was thinking as I read the story about easyJet acquiring flybe - Manchester slots? flybe have a big operation at MAN - Surely easyJet would be interested in MAN slots...


Whilst MAG might be grateful EZY take the MAN slots they will be shelll shocked if domestic air bridge disintegrates!

JobsaGoodun 14th Nov 2018 22:32

Airport slots belong to the operating airline unless there is another agreement (such as a remedy agreement) that precludes this. Without the airline, the slot doesn't effectively exist for the airport to do anything with, thus no airport can ultimately decide what an airline does with this asset.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:51.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.