indian class 1 medical nessasary for expats-DGCA
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: india
Age: 34
Posts: 54
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
indian class 1 medical nessasary for expats-DGCA
DGCA has made it mandatory for expats working in india to have a current class 1 indian medical 
DGCA tightens rules for foreign pilots - Yahoo! India News
saw that coming.....comments
DGCA tightens rules for foreign pilots - Yahoo! India Newssaw that coming.....comments
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Currently unemployed and live in my parents basement
Posts: 30
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The ONLY reason I don't like it is because I have to catch an early flight to Mumbai and then an afternoon flight back so it takes all day. If it is required for my job, than so be it. The medical itself is nothing to worry over.
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Philippines
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
More wasted time. money & paperwork
So let's get this straight.
An Indian Class 1 is superior to every other class 1 exam in the world?
By this requirement, they (Indian AME's) will uncover all the medical problems that other Aviation Medical Examiners have somehow 'missed'?
What is the point? (Or have I missed it)
An Indian Class 1 is superior to every other class 1 exam in the world?
By this requirement, they (Indian AME's) will uncover all the medical problems that other Aviation Medical Examiners have somehow 'missed'?
What is the point? (Or have I missed it)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Now at Home
Posts: 290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
indian class 1 medical nessasary for expats-DGCA
Shouldn't there be one Global Standard or is it just to make extra money.
maybe in near future we have to fly our Buses and Boeings according
Indian Standard, Sandpit Standard, German Standard,...etc, etc
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: usa
Posts: 122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Maybe the Indian pilots should have spent more time lobbying for the international medical standard and not the Indian standard. LOL..
Like two kids in the play ground who get caught fighting and the Indian kid is mad because the other kid is only going to get two spankings, instead of four. I would have asked for the same punishment as the other kid. Maybe you should think about what the outcome of your battle will be. Instead of a less invasive medical like other countries, you have the same one.. Good job boys, way to stick it to the expats.
Like two kids in the play ground who get caught fighting and the Indian kid is mad because the other kid is only going to get two spankings, instead of four. I would have asked for the same punishment as the other kid. Maybe you should think about what the outcome of your battle will be. Instead of a less invasive medical like other countries, you have the same one.. Good job boys, way to stick it to the expats.
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: US
Posts: 285
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Aren't the DGCA a bit inconsistent??
They wont give an Indian licence to a non Indian national and now by this latest BS, they are not recognising any other ICAO issued licence.
We can all be sure though, if they go ahead then there will be no more accidents incidents in Indian registered aircraft.
When does the medical have to be carried out BTW? I guess before another FATA is issued.
I think the fighter pilot medical is not tough enough. It should be up to astronaut standard at the very least. A medical so stringent, only a world class athlete would have any hope at getting through.
Old story, get rid of the expats, upgrade the inexperienced and then you will see more smoking holes. What a bunch of baffoons.
They wont give an Indian licence to a non Indian national and now by this latest BS, they are not recognising any other ICAO issued licence.
We can all be sure though, if they go ahead then there will be no more accidents incidents in Indian registered aircraft.
When does the medical have to be carried out BTW? I guess before another FATA is issued.
I think the fighter pilot medical is not tough enough. It should be up to astronaut standard at the very least. A medical so stringent, only a world class athlete would have any hope at getting through.
Old story, get rid of the expats, upgrade the inexperienced and then you will see more smoking holes. What a bunch of baffoons.
Last edited by weido_salt; 19th Jun 2010 at 12:28.
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Well thats a big volcano...
Posts: 369
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Come on , can anyone read:
From the dgca website...
Amendment to CAR Section 7 Series 'G' Part I I - Validation Of Foreign Licences Of Flight Crew Comments required by 16th July 2010. Mail to: Shri Arvind Sardana, Director (T&L), Email: [email protected] / [email protected] Comments on revision highlighted in Para 3.5 and Para 9 may be provided.
Anyone that believes an Indian press release is a fool, how can it be law when its still in draft??
From the dgca website...
Amendment to CAR Section 7 Series 'G' Part I I - Validation Of Foreign Licences Of Flight Crew Comments required by 16th July 2010. Mail to: Shri Arvind Sardana, Director (T&L), Email: [email protected] / [email protected] Comments on revision highlighted in Para 3.5 and Para 9 may be provided.
Anyone that believes an Indian press release is a fool, how can it be law when its still in draft??
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: OMAA
Posts: 253
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
this topic is already in discussion in another thread (3 days ago)
http://www.pprune.org/south-asia-far...ml#post5761164
http://www.pprune.org/south-asia-far...ml#post5761164
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Birthplace of Aviation
Posts: 462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Come on , can anyone read:
From the dgca website...
Amendment to CAR Section 7 Series 'G' Part I I - Validation Of Foreign Licences Of Flight Crew Comments required by 16th July 2010
From the dgca website...
Amendment to CAR Section 7 Series 'G' Part I I - Validation Of Foreign Licences Of Flight Crew Comments required by 16th July 2010
Here is the amended regulation
http://dgca.nic.in/cars/D7G-G2.pdf
Please note:
1. Date of Ammendment 8th June 2010
2. Date of publication of article referenced in post # 1 18th June 2010
3. Date of your post 19th June 2010
Not everything can be googled.
Aren't the DGCA a bit inconsistent??
They wont give an Indian licence to a non Indian national and now by this latest BS, they are not recognising any other ICAO issued licence.
They wont give an Indian licence to a non Indian national and now by this latest BS, they are not recognising any other ICAO issued licence.
You will also need security clearance, which the Indian national also needs to fly.
You can get the Indian CPL without any company sponsoring you. Yes work permit is a different story.
Old story, get rid of the expats, upgrade the inexperienced and then you will see more smoking holes. What a bunch of baffoons.
Expats will be needed but only as TRE/TRI not as line captains, so if you fit the bill get here, for a short stint.
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: US
Posts: 285
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Jolly good.
Now tell me of one expat who holds a full Indian ATPL? There are none. You know why? Because the DGCA wont let them have one.
I know people who came in with a 5 year work-permit. As they were being obstructed in the FATA application process they enquired as to the possibility of getting an Indian licence. They were given the "1 fingered salute".
So get your facts straight and admit India does not play a fair game.
As far as incorrect spelling is concerned, you are correct. As i dont feel the need to use the word baboon often i slipped up. However in the above situation words began to fail me, as it appears spelling did too.
Now tell me of one expat who holds a full Indian ATPL? There are none. You know why? Because the DGCA wont let them have one.
I know people who came in with a 5 year work-permit. As they were being obstructed in the FATA application process they enquired as to the possibility of getting an Indian licence. They were given the "1 fingered salute".
So get your facts straight and admit India does not play a fair game.
As far as incorrect spelling is concerned, you are correct. As i dont feel the need to use the word baboon often i slipped up. However in the above situation words began to fail me, as it appears spelling did too.
Last edited by weido_salt; 26th Jun 2010 at 16:11.
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Birthplace of Aviation
Posts: 462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Jolly good.
Now tell me of one expat who holds a full Indian ATPL? There are none. You know why? Because the DGCA wont let them have one.
Now tell me of one expat who holds a full Indian ATPL? There are none. You know why? Because the DGCA wont let them have one.
Getting a full Indian ATPL will entail
1. Getting the Indian Class 1 Initial Medical, waitlist runs in months.
2. He will have to get the Indian RTR(A), not easy to pass..
3. He will have to clear at least 4 ATPL level DGCA exams conducted only every quarter.
4. Getting a morse code proficiency certificate
5. Security clearance
and many more things...
Since this is going to be a personal affair, he will not be assisted by his company staff in getting this done... Ask any expat if he would like to go through this, especially when an Indian ATPL doesn't guarantee work rights in India. The Indian ATPL to an expat has no commercial value attached to it.
I know people who came in with a 5 year work-permit. As they were being obstructed in the FATA application process they enquired as to the possibility of getting an Indian licence. They were given the "1 fingered salute".
If they were obstructed in FATA, they will be obstructed in regular ATPL too, but mind you the Indian applicants also face these obstructions.
The fact is that any individual of any nationality can get Indian flying licenses as long as he/she can get a security clearance, which for your information is not handled by DGCA.
Remember facts are not folklores.
So get your facts straight and admit India does not play a fair game.
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: US
Posts: 285
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Jimmy
We are all very well aware of the Indian ability to complicate issues. Your post is further proof. Ever heard of K.I.S?
I didn't enquire what the whole curriculum of the long drawn out Indian licence process was. (What relevance Morse has in this day and age defies logic). Yes I am able to read Morse at 20 WPM, BTW. I stated the expat is not allowed to hold an Indian license, period. You have given me no proof to the contrary.
Over kill in the class room and the books will do very little to reduce the accident rates. Experience will. Experience that cant be learnt in the classroom. Experience that comes from actually doing the job, year in and year out and learning from our mistakes and that of others.
We are all very well aware of the Indian ability to complicate issues. Your post is further proof. Ever heard of K.I.S?
I didn't enquire what the whole curriculum of the long drawn out Indian licence process was. (What relevance Morse has in this day and age defies logic). Yes I am able to read Morse at 20 WPM, BTW. I stated the expat is not allowed to hold an Indian license, period. You have given me no proof to the contrary.
Over kill in the class room and the books will do very little to reduce the accident rates. Experience will. Experience that cant be learnt in the classroom. Experience that comes from actually doing the job, year in and year out and learning from our mistakes and that of others.
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Well thats a big volcano...
Posts: 369
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey jimmy doesnt this just show you the level of incompetence of ones own 'worldclass' aviation authority when they have a draft with comments by July prior to implementation posted on their site, but then 1 month before the comment period closes the new rule is implemented!!
Now thats a fine organization we have here isnt it !.
Someone better run around and ground all the expats flying !!
Now thats a fine organization we have here isnt it !.
Someone better run around and ground all the expats flying !!
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Birthplace of Aviation
Posts: 462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We are all very well aware of the Indian ability to complicate issues. Your post is further proof. Ever heard of K.I.S?
I didn't enquire what the whole curriculum of the long drawn out Indian licence process was. (What relevance Morse has in this day and age defies logic). Yes I am able to read Morse at 20 WPM, BTW. I stated the expat is not allowed to hold an Indian license, period. You have given me no proof to the contrary.
I didn't enquire what the whole curriculum of the long drawn out Indian licence process was. (What relevance Morse has in this day and age defies logic). Yes I am able to read Morse at 20 WPM, BTW. I stated the expat is not allowed to hold an Indian license, period. You have given me no proof to the contrary.
You stated
1. Expats are not allowed to have Indian Licenses ( I disagreed)
2. Now tell me of one expat who holds a full [sic]* Indian ATPL? There are none.
That there does not exist even a single expat with Indian ATPL is not a proof that they are not allowed to have an Indian ATPL.
Or to make it a bit easier for you. The fact that there is not a single Martian staying in city of New York, doesn't imply that City of New York has any policy against Martians residing in New York.
One way to provide a proof that NY doesn't have any policy against Martians residing in NY, is actually listing all the NY City codes and policies and point towards the absence of any such policy.
Another way is to actually find a Martian legally residing in Manhattan.
Legal presence of a Martian in Manhattan may prove that NY doesn't have any Martians-not-allowed policy.
But Martian's absence cannot be considered a proof of existence of alleged policy.
You say Unicorns exist.
You want me to prove that they don't.
Why don't you just show me a Unicorn and I will believe you?
Show me an Indian policy which states that only Indian nationals are allowed to hold DGCA issued pilot licenses and I will believe you, and I will put an apology in the forum. And trust me, I will start working towards removing that policy.
Over kill in the class room and the books will do very little to reduce the accident rates. Experience will. Experience that cant be learnt in the classroom. Experience that comes from actually doing the job, year in and year out and learning from our mistakes and that of others.
Remember the Wright Brothers had no planes to get experience before the first fight.
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Birthplace of Aviation
Posts: 462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey jimmy doesnt this just show you the level of incompetence of ones own 'worldclass' aviation authority when they have a draft with comments by July prior to implementation posted on their site, but then 1 month before the comment period closes the new rule is implemented!!
Now thats a fine organization we have here isnt it !.
Someone better run around and ground all the expats flying !!
Now thats a fine organization we have here isnt it !.
Someone better run around and ground all the expats flying !!
Yes it does show their level of incompetence. But any one who had would have searched for para 3.5 and para 9 would have come across the error as the said draft didn't have any Para 3.5 or Para 3.5. The webmaster did correct the error, but just like you didn't apologise for it or made a notice of the error.
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: OMAA
Posts: 253
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
@jimmygill
R u talking abt the following paragraph? Rev 8th June.
2.4 viii c
R u talking abt the following paragraph? Rev 8th June.
2.4 viii c
c) Valid Class-I medical :-
a. From Contracting state for keeping the Foreign License Current; and
b. Issued by DGCA India to ensure the medical fitness in accordance to
the Aircraft Rules 1937 equivalent to class-I renewal medical
standards as per Rule 39B of the Aircraft Rules 1937 and the period of
validity of medical fitness Assessment shall be as per Rule 39C of the
Aircraft Rules 1937.
a. From Contracting state for keeping the Foreign License Current; and
b. Issued by DGCA India to ensure the medical fitness in accordance to
the Aircraft Rules 1937 equivalent to class-I renewal medical
standards as per Rule 39B of the Aircraft Rules 1937 and the period of
validity of medical fitness Assessment shall be as per Rule 39C of the
Aircraft Rules 1937.