VFR On Top
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 4,631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
VFR On Top
I know for a PPL without ratings VFR on top of an under cast is prohibited in the UK but has I think always been permitted in France for French PPlers.(obviously so long as the descent is not IMC). This was in the days of our respective national licenses. Of course all new licenses here and in France are JAA licenses. I am therefore intrigued as to whether we Brits are now permitted to fly VFR on top in France, whether the French continue to remain able to do so, or whether we have managed to embody some restrictions in our ANO that cunningly restrict a JAA license issued in the UK to prohibit VFR on top. If not, does it make any difference if you have not converted your old national license to a JAA one?
If the restriction is in place so much presumably for a set of common regulations, always assuming the flying syllabus for a JAA PPL in France is much the same as here. Is this yet another JAA anomaly or are the French just better at navigation than us?
Is it too much to hope that our national IMC rating should be recognised in Europe. There was talk of this.
If the restriction is in place so much presumably for a set of common regulations, always assuming the flying syllabus for a JAA PPL in France is much the same as here. Is this yet another JAA anomaly or are the French just better at navigation than us?
Is it too much to hope that our national IMC rating should be recognised in Europe. There was talk of this.
PPruNaholic!
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Buckinghamshire
Age: 61
Posts: 1,615
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi Fuji,
I don't know the answer - VFR on top was discussed in one of the mags this month (Flyer) but I don't think it addressed whether or how JAA licenses changed things. [I think they haven't, and that we are restricted to "in sight of the surface" at all times if we hold a UK issued JAA PPL.]
But what I'd like to know from anyone who's done it is: how safe/dangerous is it to tyravel VFR on top anyway?
From the perspective of someone without an IMC, the thought of relying on a hole in the clouds for a let-down at the destination is a bit of a worry. I guess you have to be extra careful when assessing the forecast for the destination!
There have been a few horror stories published - I recall several from the US, and a mate of mine based in Connecticut once confessed to me that he had once nearly come to grief this way in his Vari-Eze... the destination wasn't good, so he turned back to land at another point he had overflown some way back, but when he got there it was all under cloud. He descended over a nearby lake - using GPS to fix position - and had to avoid a mast on the lake-shore. It worked out OK, but he fairly sh&t himself, and was a bit close for comfort to the mast when he broke cloud only 1000' or so above the lake, then was able to land at the airport on the shoreline.
So while it sounds like a privelege I would like to have, I wonder how they get on with it in practice e.g. in Northern France?
Andy
I don't know the answer - VFR on top was discussed in one of the mags this month (Flyer) but I don't think it addressed whether or how JAA licenses changed things. [I think they haven't, and that we are restricted to "in sight of the surface" at all times if we hold a UK issued JAA PPL.]
But what I'd like to know from anyone who's done it is: how safe/dangerous is it to tyravel VFR on top anyway?
From the perspective of someone without an IMC, the thought of relying on a hole in the clouds for a let-down at the destination is a bit of a worry. I guess you have to be extra careful when assessing the forecast for the destination!
There have been a few horror stories published - I recall several from the US, and a mate of mine based in Connecticut once confessed to me that he had once nearly come to grief this way in his Vari-Eze... the destination wasn't good, so he turned back to land at another point he had overflown some way back, but when he got there it was all under cloud. He descended over a nearby lake - using GPS to fix position - and had to avoid a mast on the lake-shore. It worked out OK, but he fairly sh&t himself, and was a bit close for comfort to the mast when he broke cloud only 1000' or so above the lake, then was able to land at the airport on the shoreline.
So while it sounds like a privelege I would like to have, I wonder how they get on with it in practice e.g. in Northern France?
Andy
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: London, England
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The answer is the same as the one that is always given when this question is raised (about weekly). Your CAA issued licence is governed by the ANO wherever you fly. So the French version of the ANO might let them fly VFR on top, but not you.
Sorry
See http://www.higherplane.flyer.co.uk/faq.htm no 5
Sorry
See http://www.higherplane.flyer.co.uk/faq.htm no 5
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 4,631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ah well your weeks must be longer than mine!
I have not previously seen this specific answer given. Makes me wonder quite how it all works legally as I do not have a copy of the ANO to hand. Presumably the JAA establishes the JAA privileges of the PPL or maybe it is just the syllabus. Presumably also the national authorities then seek to enact national legislation to define or modify the JAA privileges.
As to whether it is safe I personally agree with the previous correspondent - flying VFR on top without an IMC or IR is potentially courting disaster. However, with even an IMC we Brits cannot legally fly "on top" in France. It would be useful to at least have this privilege had our national authority not felt otherwise. Maybe the answer is to seek recognition of the IMC in Europe.
Still seems strange to me that we sign up to a piece of legislation on the premise it provides common mutuality throughout Europe (which makes sense) and then seek to impose national differences whatever the virtues or disadvantages.
I have not previously seen this specific answer given. Makes me wonder quite how it all works legally as I do not have a copy of the ANO to hand. Presumably the JAA establishes the JAA privileges of the PPL or maybe it is just the syllabus. Presumably also the national authorities then seek to enact national legislation to define or modify the JAA privileges.
As to whether it is safe I personally agree with the previous correspondent - flying VFR on top without an IMC or IR is potentially courting disaster. However, with even an IMC we Brits cannot legally fly "on top" in France. It would be useful to at least have this privilege had our national authority not felt otherwise. Maybe the answer is to seek recognition of the IMC in Europe.
Still seems strange to me that we sign up to a piece of legislation on the premise it provides common mutuality throughout Europe (which makes sense) and then seek to impose national differences whatever the virtues or disadvantages.
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 263
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The UK ANO restricts us to 3000m Vis, in sight of the ground etc . If you have an IMC than you can fly on top and your Vis minima is down to 1500m.
A French PPL can fly on top and within 1500m vis without IMC. As the IMC is not recognized outside the UK, the minute you get out of UK airspace you are illigal to fly on top or in vis<1500m.
Oh I forgot, our French friends can.
[ 22 November 2001: Message edited by: AC-DC ]
A French PPL can fly on top and within 1500m vis without IMC. As the IMC is not recognized outside the UK, the minute you get out of UK airspace you are illigal to fly on top or in vis<1500m.
Oh I forgot, our French friends can.
[ 22 November 2001: Message edited by: AC-DC ]
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The JAA does not determine the privileges of its licences, that is a matter (one of the few remaining) on which national governments in europe legislate.
What your UK issued JAA licence entitles you to do (wherever in the world you fly) is detailed in the Air Navigation Order 2000 which, as a Statutory Instrument (SI 2000 No.1562), is the law of the land. Since ignorance of the law is not a defence in court, it might be wise to invest in/borrow/steal a copy and find out just what is legal and, more importantly, what is not.
What your UK issued JAA licence entitles you to do (wherever in the world you fly) is detailed in the Air Navigation Order 2000 which, as a Statutory Instrument (SI 2000 No.1562), is the law of the land. Since ignorance of the law is not a defence in court, it might be wise to invest in/borrow/steal a copy and find out just what is legal and, more importantly, what is not.
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: SURREY, U.K.
Posts: 214
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just a thought ladies and gentlemen,
As I understand it, to be VFR you must be in sight of the ground. In the UK it is only possible to be VMC on top. Any thoughts?
Tailwinds
As I understand it, to be VFR you must be in sight of the ground. In the UK it is only possible to be VMC on top. Any thoughts?
Tailwinds
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SKYYACHT - Not true! One may elect to fly under the Visual Flight Rules (VFR) at any time that one is in Visual Meteorological Conditions (VMC) provided that VFR flight is permitted in the prevailing Class of airspace.
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 4,631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So let me summarise
We now have a European wide JAA license
but
each national authority decides the limitiations applicable to this license.
I know it has been said before, probably weekly, but perhaps we should have stuck with our national license - or maybe we did.
We now have a European wide JAA license
but
each national authority decides the limitiations applicable to this license.
I know it has been said before, probably weekly, but perhaps we should have stuck with our national license - or maybe we did.
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: SURREY, U.K.
Posts: 214
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Rolling Circle, I sit corrected, and suitable abashed.....My only excuse - too many beers!
Tailwinds
PS - Reminds me of the adage to keep quiet and have everyone think you are an idiot, Rather than open thy gob, and leave them in no doubt!
Tailwinds
PS - Reminds me of the adage to keep quiet and have everyone think you are an idiot, Rather than open thy gob, and leave them in no doubt!
Join Date: May 2001
Location: 75N 16E
Age: 54
Posts: 4,729
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This again sums up the JAA and the CAA ! Why should our French brethren get extra privileges when they hold the same licence ! Its a bunch of b**locks if you ask me, and makes a complete mockery of the entire JAA system. Next you'll be telling me that they can fly at night becasue they don't need a night rating...oops sorry 'qualification'...Why isn't the IMC therefore part of the JAA Licence...ie. By passing the IMC you get the IMC privileges but as part of your JAR licence and not a seperate CAA thing. Couldn't the ANO be ammended to reflect this, seeing as each national government is reponsible for what your licence allows ???????????
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Leeds, UK
Posts: 103
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
sorry to confuse things further, but what if you're flying a French-reg plane?
Presumably then you get French JAR PPL priveleges, in the same way that a UK PPL with an FAA IR can fly full IFR (including incontrolled airspace) in an N-reg plane...
Anyone know about this? - I may be hiring a plane in France next year, (I have PPL/IMC), so being able to go on top of cloud, as I can here, would be great.
Presumably then you get French JAR PPL priveleges, in the same way that a UK PPL with an FAA IR can fly full IFR (including incontrolled airspace) in an N-reg plane...
Anyone know about this? - I may be hiring a plane in France next year, (I have PPL/IMC), so being able to go on top of cloud, as I can here, would be great.
I say there boy
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 1,065
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
englishal,
It's worse than that - night VFR is allowed in some JAA countries, night VFR is banned in others where you must fly IFR and have an IR.
In the UK we have the loophole that you are allowed to fly at night under IFR in VMC with just a night rating!
foggy.
It's worse than that - night VFR is allowed in some JAA countries, night VFR is banned in others where you must fly IFR and have an IR.
In the UK we have the loophole that you are allowed to fly at night under IFR in VMC with just a night rating!
foggy.
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just to re-iterate - If you are flying an aircraft on the basis of your UK issued JAA PPL (or, indeed, UK national PPL), the privileges of that licence are detailed in the ANO. This applies no matter where in the world you are flying nor in what state the aircraft is registered. If, however, your UK issued PPL has been validated in another state (or 'converted' if you speak american) then it is as though you held a licence issued by that state and the privileges are those laid down in the validating state's legislation.
The JAA PPL, and CPL for that matter, are VFR licences. The privileges do not entitle the holder to fly in a visibility of less than 3km or out of sight of the surface. The privileges of a CPL are, essentially, those of a PPL with night qualification (leaving aside the matters of remuneration and public transport).
In order to fly IFR it is necessary to hold an Instrument Rating or (in the UK only) an IMC rating. However, the IMC rating is not recognised by any other country and, therefore, its privileges do not extend outside UK airspace. No credit will be given for holding a FAA Instrument Rating in any JAA member state other than the UK as there is no equivalent to the IMC rating.
The JAA PPL, and CPL for that matter, are VFR licences. The privileges do not entitle the holder to fly in a visibility of less than 3km or out of sight of the surface. The privileges of a CPL are, essentially, those of a PPL with night qualification (leaving aside the matters of remuneration and public transport).
In order to fly IFR it is necessary to hold an Instrument Rating or (in the UK only) an IMC rating. However, the IMC rating is not recognised by any other country and, therefore, its privileges do not extend outside UK airspace. No credit will be given for holding a FAA Instrument Rating in any JAA member state other than the UK as there is no equivalent to the IMC rating.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: London, England
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I thought that if you convert your JAA licence to FAA, and get an FAA IR you will abe able to: (a) get an automatic IMC rating from the CAA to fly G reg planes in IMC in the UK FIR and (b) be entitled to exercise the priviliges of your FAA IR in N reg planes anywhere in the world.
If so, this sounds like a sensible approach to getting a proper instrument rating without the roadblocks put in place by the JAA/CAA
If so, this sounds like a sensible approach to getting a proper instrument rating without the roadblocks put in place by the JAA/CAA
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 4,631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So to add to the confusion presumably the French will validate your JAA / CAA license for a JAA / French license granting you the full priviliges of a JAA / French license.
I guess you can then fly French aircraft applying their VFR ANO rules - but G reg. aircraft?
Strange in all this that it is the same pilot, same training, same experience, same aircraft, same community, but different rules.
I suppose it is a sort of opt in, opt out.
I guess you can then fly French aircraft applying their VFR ANO rules - but G reg. aircraft?
Strange in all this that it is the same pilot, same training, same experience, same aircraft, same community, but different rules.
I suppose it is a sort of opt in, opt out.
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 135
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
PhilD - The validation certificate you get from the FAA states:
XIII LIMITATIONS
Issued on the basis of and valid only when accompanied by United Kingdom pilot license number(s) xxxxxxx. All limitations and restrictions on the United Kingdom pilot license apply.
That being the case, you cannot apply a FAA IR to a UK licence. You can, however, gain a FAA licence and apply a FAA IR to it and that will get you an IMC rating attached to your UK issued PPL.
Fuji Abound - The french do not need to validate a JAA licence issued in the UK. By definition, a JAA licence issued in the UK is valid throughout the member states of the JAA, without formality. Except, of course, if the training for that licence has been conducted outside of the JAA (e.g. USA) in which case the licence has not been issued in accordance with the requirements of JAR-FCL and any member state (e.g. france) may decide not to recognise it.
If, however, your UK national PPL is validated by the DGAC then the priveleges are as laid down in french law.
englishal - You may think that, I could not possibly comment!
XIII LIMITATIONS
Issued on the basis of and valid only when accompanied by United Kingdom pilot license number(s) xxxxxxx. All limitations and restrictions on the United Kingdom pilot license apply.
That being the case, you cannot apply a FAA IR to a UK licence. You can, however, gain a FAA licence and apply a FAA IR to it and that will get you an IMC rating attached to your UK issued PPL.
Fuji Abound - The french do not need to validate a JAA licence issued in the UK. By definition, a JAA licence issued in the UK is valid throughout the member states of the JAA, without formality. Except, of course, if the training for that licence has been conducted outside of the JAA (e.g. USA) in which case the licence has not been issued in accordance with the requirements of JAR-FCL and any member state (e.g. france) may decide not to recognise it.
If, however, your UK national PPL is validated by the DGAC then the priveleges are as laid down in french law.
englishal - You may think that, I could not possibly comment!
Join Date: May 2001
Location: 75N 16E
Age: 54
Posts: 4,729
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
...or fly IFR in an N Reg plane ANYWHERE in the world with the FAA IR.......Even on the FAA Licence issued on the basis of the JAA licence so long as you have passed the FAA IR....
[ 27 November 2001: Message edited by: englishal ]
[ 27 November 2001: Message edited by: englishal ]