Deletion of quote boxes?
Thread Starter
Deletion of quote boxes?
Please could PPRuNe policy be explained.
I recently seem to be having quite a few quote boxes of just a few lines removed from my posts and replaced with the name of the poster I was quoting. Since there is no 'dear x' or 'Hi x', just the quotees name, it seems as if I am being rude, which is never my intention.
Other posters seem to be allowed to post quote boxes of many paragraphs, which spread over several pages.
I edit my quote boxes to remove superfluous content so they are as concise as possible, and only consist of a few lines. What am I doing wrong?
I recently seem to be having quite a few quote boxes of just a few lines removed from my posts and replaced with the name of the poster I was quoting. Since there is no 'dear x' or 'Hi x', just the quotees name, it seems as if I am being rude, which is never my intention.
Other posters seem to be allowed to post quote boxes of many paragraphs, which spread over several pages.
I edit my quote boxes to remove superfluous content so they are as concise as possible, and only consist of a few lines. What am I doing wrong?
Moderator
Examples?
Are you inadvertently removing some of the Quote HTML tags when editing your quotes?
[QUOTE>] TEXT followed by [>/QUOTE] or [>QUOTE=Username;10942332] TEXT followed by [>/QUOTE] are always required for quoting previous text (note > inserted to prevent actual quotations).
Are you inadvertently removing some of the Quote HTML tags when editing your quotes?
[QUOTE>] TEXT followed by [>/QUOTE] or [>QUOTE=Username;10942332] TEXT followed by [>/QUOTE] are always required for quoting previous text (note > inserted to prevent actual quotations).
Originally Posted by Uplinker
I edit my quote boxes to remove superfluous content so they are as concise as possible, and only consist of a few lines.
Don't change anything inside the square brackets. The 8 digit number provides the little blue "View post" arrow.
Last edited by jimjim1; 8th Dec 2020 at 10:33.
Thread Starter
Ah, a misunderstanding: this is a moderation question, not a formatting question - I know how to format quotes.
What I am questioning is that a post I have written incorporating a quote from another poster - and that I have seen successfully submitted and displayed on the thread, (so the formatting was correct) - is edited a few hours or a day later by the moderator?, who removes the quote box and leaves just the name of the quotee.
This has now happened a few times. Unfortunately I cannot provide examples because I did not copy the original posts. The post initially displays with the quote box but is later seen to have had just the quote box removed. Could this be some sort of glitch rather than moderation?
What I am questioning is that a post I have written incorporating a quote from another poster - and that I have seen successfully submitted and displayed on the thread, (so the formatting was correct) - is edited a few hours or a day later by the moderator?, who removes the quote box and leaves just the name of the quotee.
This has now happened a few times. Unfortunately I cannot provide examples because I did not copy the original posts. The post initially displays with the quote box but is later seen to have had just the quote box removed. Could this be some sort of glitch rather than moderation?
Chief Bottle Washer
Originally Posted by Uplinker
Please could PPRuNe policy be explained.
I recently seem to be having quite a few quote boxes of just a few lines removed from my posts and replaced with the name of the poster I was quoting. Since there is no 'dear x' or 'Hi x', just the quotees name, it seems as if I am being rude, which is never my intention.
Other posters seem to be allowed to post quote boxes of many paragraphs, which spread over several pages.
I edit my quote boxes to remove superfluous content so they are as concise as possible, and only consist of a few lines. What am I doing wrong?
I recently seem to be having quite a few quote boxes of just a few lines removed from my posts and replaced with the name of the poster I was quoting. Since there is no 'dear x' or 'Hi x', just the quotees name, it seems as if I am being rude, which is never my intention.
Other posters seem to be allowed to post quote boxes of many paragraphs, which spread over several pages.
I edit my quote boxes to remove superfluous content so they are as concise as possible, and only consist of a few lines. What am I doing wrong?
I’ve been back through two months of your posts and there is nothing that matches your complaint here, nor any record in the thread edit history (available to Mods) to indicate any editing/moderation of any of your posts other than by yourself.
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: NA
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PPRuNe Towers
I happily delete quote boxes that simply repeat a post just above. Name of the poster referred to left in place.
These quotes are a waste of space and electrons.
These quotes are a waste of space and electrons.
A short quote is extremely helpful.
Did you just moderate me? See above link above, I won't quote it...
...and you didn't leave the poster's name, whom I was addressing.
Last edited by awair; 17th Dec 2020 at 12:27.
Moderator
Join Date: Mar 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 2,178
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Don’t need to read a complete reprint of the post above yours or part of a conversation flow. Worst cases are of the 10 paragraph diatribe followed by “ plus1” or “I agree” type thing.
Where they are cleaned up, it doesn’t usually happen in real time so it is obvious from the flow of the thread if the quote is necessary or the referred to poster. Where a reply is well out of context or possibly on another page, the quote box is often useful. Similarly where a portion of the quoted post is being used or possibly being dissected in stages for reply.
Where they are cleaned up, it doesn’t usually happen in real time so it is obvious from the flow of the thread if the quote is necessary or the referred to poster. Where a reply is well out of context or possibly on another page, the quote box is often useful. Similarly where a portion of the quoted post is being used or possibly being dissected in stages for reply.
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: EDSP
Posts: 334
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So I put some effort in reducing quotes to the one or sometimes several sentences I am refering to, replacing the content not relevant to my post by "...".
Nevertheless those quote boxes get replaced with the username by moderation regularly. A recent example is here .
While I have sympathy for replacing full quotes I find this practice where people have thoughtfully prepared their references intrusive and disrespectful!
Nevertheless those quote boxes get replaced with the username by moderation regularly. A recent example is here .
While I have sympathy for replacing full quotes I find this practice where people have thoughtfully prepared their references intrusive and disrespectful!
