PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Cirrus down Gundaroo, 06/10/23 (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/655148-cirrus-down-gundaroo-06-10-23-a.html)

KRviator 6th Oct 2023 05:46

Cirrus down Gundaroo, 06/10/23
 
From the ABC:

Emergency services responding to reported plane crash outside Gundaroo, north of Canberra
Emergency services have been called to a reported plane crash at Gundaroo, a small town north of Canberra.

NSW Police said they received a report that a plane had crashed and caught alight just before 3:00pm today.

Firefighters, police and the ambulance service are at the scene, which is close to the Federal Highway and Lake George.

It is unclear how many people were on board the plane.
Both FA & FR24 show VH-MSF, a Cirrus planned YSCB-YARM in the area at the time, and in a rapid descent from ~9,000 in the vicinity, and failing to reappear. Whoever it was, hopefully they've been able to walk away from it, but it doesn't sound promising...:(

EDIT:Added photos from onthesceneACT.
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....21356cb151.jpg

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....afb05b8f0f.jpg

Desert Flower 6th Oct 2023 06:06

Channel 10 news is saying there are no survivors.

DF

Magnetomick 6th Oct 2023 06:13

[[color=#333333]Looks like pancaked from vision I can see, could shute been deployed?
Or is there slide marks across the road?

Dick Smith 6th Oct 2023 06:31

It's about 3 km from my strip. Deepest condolences.

Squawk7700 6th Oct 2023 07:16

Very sad.

Last radio call to departures was ops normal.

FR suggests 12,000fpm descent rate at <120 knots.

It’s a G1 and they have a one piece wing.

It sounds catastrophic.

Dr1sRule 6th Oct 2023 08:26

There's nothing left to investigate . It looks like the remains of an ancient campfire.

Desert Flower 6th Oct 2023 08:31


Originally Posted by Dr1sRule (Post 11515355)
There's nothing left to investigate . It looks like the remains of an ancient campfire.

Yes. If you weren't told it was the scene of an aircraft crash it would be hard to know what it was.

DF.

TBM-Legend 6th Oct 2023 08:42

I thought they had a ballistic chute

atakacs 6th Oct 2023 08:48


Originally Posted by TBM-Legend (Post 11515363)
I thought they had a ballistic chute

They do.
Still need to deploy it in (relative) reasonable conditions.

Jenna Talia 6th Oct 2023 08:49

Icing?

KRviator 6th Oct 2023 08:54


Originally Posted by TBM-Legend (Post 11515363)
I thought they had a ballistic chute

They're supposed to! Which makes this one strange. Looking at FA and the recent flights, they've all been filed at set 1000's in altitudes, not Alt+500, indicative of routine operations under the IFR.

Latest news reports are saying a pilot + 3 kids on board, too. :mad:


Icing?
FZL per the 0500-1100Z GAF was listed as 8000'N / 5000'S for the area, with BKN CU/SC5000/10000. Possible...
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....80c55f53f5.jpg

Hammerstan 6th Oct 2023 09:26

FR shows maintaining groundspeed in low fpm descent at time 20231006 03:47 UTC after reaching top of climb, then followed by slowing groundspeed with increasingly rapid descent. Explanations?

physicus 6th Oct 2023 09:34

1 Attachment(s)
Looks like something catastrophic happened. KMZ and CSV from RealTraffic - Fly with real air traffic attached.

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....895ce9f042.png

outnabout 6th Oct 2023 10:47

Worse…..grandpa took three of the grandkids out for a School holiday blast.

https://www.news.com.au/national/at-...be08567f2f00e5


the flight profile is heartbreaking…


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....88adf11198.png

Paul O'Rourke 6th Oct 2023 10:55

Some observations:

From flightaware - Flight out of Canberra shows straight tracking upto 7800’ (1013 datum) then tracking looks handflown.



On the way down, at 7300’ (1013 datum) the ROD is 9811 at around 80° angle of depression. 18 seconds later the ROD at 3550’ (1013 datum) is reduced 41% to 5714 fpm at an 83° angle of depression.

TBM-Legend 6th Oct 2023 11:21

Maybe an evil thought…


Capt Fathom 6th Oct 2023 11:43

No mayday and no chute. Quite unusual. Incapacitation?

Mr Mossberg 6th Oct 2023 12:23


Maybe an evil thought…
Hate to think it right.

NZFlyingKiwi 6th Oct 2023 18:18

It's a bit hard to imagine incapacitation leading to that sort of flight profile unless it was a seizure or something causing a total lockup on the controls. I'd think even with someone slumped over the stick (which doesn't seem very likely with a Cirrus sidestick anyway) the aerodynamic forces involved would eventually shallow the descent out a bit. You would assume he would have shown the kids how to operate the parachute too in case he suddenly keeled over.

Checkboard 6th Oct 2023 19:37

Autopilot on VS climb. Heart attack or similar. Young children not understanding anything about the aircraft or 'chute. Stall. Descent to terrain. :(


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:35.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.