PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Hand, or rope, starting your aircraft (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/652925-hand-rope-starting-your-aircraft.html)

First_Principal 26th May 2023 07:24

Hand, or rope, starting your aircraft
 
It seems the previous thread that included some detail on hand or rope starting aircraft was deleted?

Admittedly it deviated from it's original intent, however the content was interesting, so I've found my manual on the DC-3 rope start procedure and scanned a copy of that here for anyone that may find it useful. My recollection is that the C-47 I flew was in the Pacific for WW2 and that there was some specific additional information on rope starting. Unfortunately I wasn't able to find that in the brief time I spent looking, if I do I'll update - otherwise if you've flown VH-CAN you may recall what I'm talking about...?

I also found a photo of some real-life practice rope-starting, source is DC3 Southern Skies Pioneer, Brian Lockstone and Paul Harrison, Random House, 2000. megan had a good photo too, although in that case I think they'd wrapped the rope around the prop boss:


https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....15cefde90e.jpg
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b93d2c94d9.jpg
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....32e81b61df.jpg

Mach E Avelli 26th May 2023 07:57

Thanks for that! It was a similar sketch that I referred to in the last thread that seems to have gone walkabout.
I am still sceptical that it would always work. My recollection of starting those buggers involved a fair amount of cranking, hitting spark boosters and tickling primer switches. I suppose enough persistance and a bit of luck could eventually crack it. Never tried it or witnessed it.
An alternative method suggested of wrapping a rope around the prop dome then pulling with a vehicle would impose enormous stresses, so that sounds like something you’d only do to in desperation to escape someone shooting at you.
Some of the Pommy Dakotas retained their original wartime inertia starters. These were either electrically or hand cranked to spin up a flywheel then a clutch was engaged, though I only ever used the electric system.

megan 27th May 2023 04:00

FP, the illustration and procedural text you posted is the exact word for word copy of what was posted previously, even down to the serial number and issue date. Pity the site where we got the info from didn't attribute its source, New Zealand National Airways Corporation.

Some of the Pommy Dakotas retained their original wartime inertia starters
As did some Oz variants, can't recall if they were Pratt or Wright variants, foggy memory suggests Guinea Airways in South Oz..

aerolearner 27th May 2023 05:45

In addition, the licence-built Lisunov variants of the DC-3 had a fitting for a Hucks starter on the propeller boss.

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....61bf7d2437.jpg
https://pickledwings.files.wordpress...2/img_0715.jpg

lucille 27th May 2023 06:32

Yes. I had seen photos of rope starting DC-3 / C47; luckily there were plenty of staff on hand and presumably an appropriate sling.

It was a post in a different thread (which, peculiarly, has since vanished) which stated they had rope started a fuel injected Islander in the highlands of PNG which particularly intrigued me.

Can someone explain how to rope start a BN-2 with a two bladed prop and a spinner. There’s obviously some neat trick which I’m missing.


megan 27th May 2023 07:03

Pprune has a thread with folk starting DC-3, C-46 and Shakletons using the rope trick.

https://www.pprune.org/private-flyin...ing-dc3-3.html

lucille 27th May 2023 09:00

Great thread, Megsie. Thanks for the link. Halcyon days of aviation, when flying was fun and admitting to knowing the rules was sneered at.
Old farts like us were lucky to have experienced both the dodgy, the “innovative” and imaginative little stunts of the era. There were some characters who preceded us who are now in that final holding pattern.


mustafagander 27th May 2023 10:51

Ah yes Lucille, when the sex was safe and the flying dangerous. Damn I miss those days!!

donpizmeov 27th May 2023 11:12


Originally Posted by Mach E Avelli (Post 11440750)
Thanks for that! It was a similar sketch that I referred to in the last thread that seems to have gone walkabout.
I am still sceptical that it would always work. My recollection of starting those buggers involved a fair amount of cranking, hitting spark boosters and tickling primer switches. I suppose enough persistance and a bit of luck could eventually crack it. Never tried it or witnessed it.
An alternative method suggested of wrapping a rope around the prop dome then pulling with a vehicle would impose enormous stresses, so that sounds like something you’d only do to in desperation to escape someone shooting at you.
Some of the Pommy Dakotas retained their original wartime inertia starters. These were either electrically or hand cranked to spin up a flywheel then a clutch was engaged, though I only ever used the electric system.

I can just imagine some fellas pulling the rope when the hydraulic lock happens.
Unless you have had to use three switches, starter, vibrator and prime to start an engine you have missed all the fun. Now was that 15 blades or 8? : )

Mach E Avelli 27th May 2023 11:44

15 on the Pratt, 9 on the Wright…I think, memory is dim now.

Duck Pilot 27th May 2023 12:16

****, I only made a comment on another thread about rope starting an Islander and the lapuns have got exited!

I’m impressed 👍👍

Capn Rex Havoc 27th May 2023 17:11

15 cold, 6 when warm rings a bell,

but then again I can’t remember what I had for breakfast let alone bou stuff from the 90s,

First_Principal 27th May 2023 23:44


Originally Posted by megan (Post 11441218)
FP, the illustration and procedural text you posted is the exact word for word copy of what was posted previously, even down to the serial number and issue date. Pity the site where we got the info from didn't attribute its source, New Zealand National Airways Corporation...

Quite, although to be fair to that site I'm not entirely sure that NAC hadn't copied their procedure from another operator's manual (without attribution). I suppose it may even have been part of official documentation from Douglas; I once had the complete set (de Douglas) but haven't seen the box in a long time, maybe someone else will turn up with earlier detail.

Thanks for posting that other link, I am interested in the efficacy and advisability of rope starting from the prop boss/spinner as described in the Land Rover scene. As I see it having a sock on the prop tip is reasonable (and would appear to be an approved SOP in some cases), and you'd expect it to fly off and out of the way if/when the engine started (if it hadn't already), however I see at least three issues with the boss rope:

(1) unless you're very careful and get the rope exactly orthogonal to the boss (and have a very straight boss) it will either pull off, or become entangled with the blades
(2) if you're unlucky the rope could become entangled with the blades if the engine started and said rope wasn't out of the way in time, oh la la!
(3) while it's been some time since I worked on a DC3 I don't remember the boss being all that strong, it seems to me that miss-application of force on the rope could damage it quite easily? Mach E Avelli clearly has similar thoughts (and yes, I agree they could be a chore to get going at times!).

Thus It'd be good to hear from someone that's actually done a boss rope start, if they're still here to tell the tale...

FP.


First_Principal 28th May 2023 00:02


Originally Posted by Mach E Avelli (Post 11441430)
15 on the Pratt, 9 on the Wright…I think, memory is dim now.

I'm looking at our manual now, it says 14 blades for cold start, and 9 for hot (R1830), and of course we needed to WOBBLE, none of this flash electric pump stuff :)

Here is the relevant NAC process from '68:


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....cf4e1e58bc.png

Maisk Rotum 30th May 2023 03:31


Originally Posted by lucille (Post 11441246)
Yes. I had seen photos of rope starting DC-3 / C47; luckily there were plenty of staff on hand and presumably an appropriate sling.

It was a post in a different thread (which, peculiarly, has since vanished) which stated they had rope started a fuel injected Islander in the highlands of PNG which particularly intrigued me.

Can someone explain how to rope start a BN-2 with a two bladed prop and a spinner. There’s obviously some neat trick which I’m missing.

I started an Islander with a rope. Talair, 38 years ago in PNG. Had a dummy run first with the mags off. Wrapped the rope over itself initially and then maybe 4 to six times around the spinner. Test proved the rope came away freely. Had three of us on the rope as best I can remember. Worked well. I think it was my last flight on type with Talair.

Pinky the pilot 30th May 2023 06:27

I hand started a 260HP Islander one time when the starter went U/S and I was on the other side of the Owen Stanleys late on a Friday afternoon.
AY taught me the procedure in case it was ever needed.

Had to get back to the Club Dero for the Friday night BBQ.:D

blackburn 1st Jun 2023 05:50

Started a DC3 at Bairnsdale by hand sometime in 1970. It was a hot start and the starter motor failed i.e.when selected nothing happened!.
The Captain was Mayne McKern, the SRC for JetAir, and he had the answer in his head despite no starter rope being carried. Can't remember which acft it was but they were all R1830 engined.
Co-opted several of the male passengers and after carefully priming the engine, and turning it through a number of blades, about 3 or 4 joined hands with me and with mags on, pulled it through and walked away as the engine started first go!.
All aboard and back to Essendon by just on dark.
Was something to remember!

lucille 1st Jun 2023 22:04


Originally Posted by Maisk Rotum (Post 11442778)
I started an Islander with a rope. Talair, 38 years ago in PNG. Had a dummy run first with the mags off. Wrapped the rope over itself initially and then maybe 4 to six times around the spinner. Test proved the rope came away freely. Had three of us on the rope as best I can remember. Worked well. I think it was my last flight on type with Talair.


Ah ha! Thanks for that. I would have been too afraid to wreck the spinner. Obviously they’re way stronger than I gave them credit for.

pithblot 4th Jun 2023 09:11

First Principal

My recollection is that the C-47 I flew was in the Pacific for WW2 and that there was some specific additional information on rope starting. Unfortunately I wasn't able to find that in the brief time I spent looking, if I do I'll update - otherwise if you've flown VH-CAN you may recall what I'm talking about...?
Mach E Avelli

An alternative method suggested of wrapping a rope around the prop dome then pulling with a vehicle would impose enormous stresses, so that sounds like something you’d only do to in desperation to escape someone shooting at you.
FP,
VH-MMA is possibly the -3 that you are thinking of? It was General McArthur’s transport in the Pacific for a time.

Stretching the memory a bit, the Flight Manual of Air Norths DC3s (VH-CAN being the other) had the Rope Start instructions, including rope around the prop done that Mach mentions. It also had interesting instructions on how to picket the aircraft in snow and ice. (Fun fact, the Royal Darwin Hospital has external pitched concrete structures around the building to protect it from snow over load. The building was allegedly designed for Alaska).

IIRC, Hank used the Rope about the prop dome (man powered, not car powered) to get out of Maningrida back in the day when overnighting there was considered on par with being shot at.
​​​​​​​

Fris B. Fairing 4th Jun 2023 20:53


Originally Posted by pithblot (Post 11445539)
First Principal
FP,
VH-MMA is possibly the -3 that you are thinking of? It was General McArthur’s transport in the Pacific for a time.
​​​​​​​

I'm not saying that MacArthur never flew on VH-MMA but the aircraft that was assigned to his GHQ and on which he flew to Canberra to meet with Prime Minister Curtin was later VH-ANR. This DC-3 was soon replaced by a brand new C-47 (not MMA).


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.