PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   ASIC (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/620984-asic.html)

Jabawocky 12th Jul 2017 22:18

And what is a "White ASIC"?......racist bastards :-)

No longer red?


I will take this up with my local member Peter Dutton, I am sure this is helping him keep out illegal immigrants.

But I have also realised as pilots, LAME's and any related industry staff we are screwed. There are probably at the most 100,000 affected people. 80% will be issued via their QF/VA or related employers. The rest of us, get ready for the pineapple. With 1,000,000 gun owners in this country who are equally or more pissed off with BS regulation that achieves zero, and they can't affect change against stupidity, what hope do we have in aviation?

Arizona or Texas is looking better all the time.

Lead Balloon 12th Jul 2017 22:21

If the facade makes the punters feel safe, it's a small price that the bureaucracy is happy for you to pay!

Eddie Dean 12th Jul 2017 22:45

Calm down peoples, $265 for two years is well worth it, considering all the discount coffees we get at the airport terminals.

Old Akro 13th Jul 2017 00:03


Originally Posted by Eddie Dean (Post 9828994)
Calm down peoples, $265 for two years is well worth it, considering all the discount coffees we get at the airport terminals.

Eddie

1. If you want good coffee, what are you doing buying it at airports?
2. If you want a discount on your coffee get a Starbucks discount coupon
3. Are you real? Have you figured out how many cups of coffee you need in a year to get your $265 back and for me the real cost is the day of my life I loose arranging all of the document copies, getting them signed by a JPand filling out the inane government forms.

This is a lousy ham fisted expensive to administer system where once again Australia has made more intrusive and more complex than anywhere else in the world with no proper review of the necessity for it.

Lead Balloon 13th Jul 2017 01:05

We are trapped in the Orwellian world of government.

There is a bureaucracy with 'responsibility' for aviation security. There is a bureaucracy that makes money out of police checks. There is a business that makes money out of issuing ASICs.

Somebody has to be their plaything and revenue stream.

I had considered providing a submission to the review of aviation security, but then I realised that if I pointed out the various practical scenarios that demonstrated why the ASIC system is little more than an expensive and easily-avoided facade, the only likely outcome would be further inconvenience and costs to me and other law-abiding citizens rather than the people who are hell-bent on doing harm.

The 2-yearly inconvenience and expense - even under the new system - pales into insignificance compared with what we'd pay if it weren't a facade.

Eddie Dean 13th Jul 2017 01:45


Originally Posted by Old Akro (Post 9829026)
Eddie

1. If you want good coffee, what are you doing buying it at airports?
2. If you want a discount on your coffee get a Starbucks discount coupon
3. Are you real? Have you figured out how many cups of coffee you need in a year to get your $265 back and for me the real cost is the day of my life I loose arranging all of the document copies, getting them signed by a JPand filling out the inane government forms.

This is a lousy ham fisted expensive to administer system where once again Australia has made more intrusive and more complex than anywhere else in the world with no proper review of the necessity for it.

When I want good coffee I definitely do not go to Starfvcks.
As always, you missed the satire.

Clare Prop 13th Jul 2017 01:47

I can see the point from an aerodrome security point of view, but insisting on security checks for GA pilots is just another double standard, seeing as RA-Aus people don't have to have any kind of security check.

I think this is what should be focussed on rather than ranting about the cost etc, so talk to your local Senator about Section 6.55 of the Aviation Transport Security Regulations 2005 as this is to do with OTS not CASA.

Old Akro 13th Jul 2017 03:03


As always, you missed the satire.
you mean sarcasm?

The trouble is there are people who genuinely think that the discounts you get are an advantage.

no_one 13th Jul 2017 04:46

I hope everyone who post here also sent a quick email to their local member.

Members ? Parliament of Australia

Venting on PPRUNE wont change anything. Emailing you local member may not either but it might just help when one of the aviation bodies are trying to get a meeting in the future.

Lead Balloon 13th Jul 2017 05:07

That doesn't work. These arrangements are keeping our local members 'safe'. The only way we can convince them otherwise is to point out why it's just a facade. But that's likely to merely prompt them to demand that OTS impose even more inconvenient and costly demands on us.

Jetjr 13th Jul 2017 06:18


Originally Posted by Clare Prop (Post 9829064)
seeing as RA-Aus people don't have to have any kind of security check.

Where did you get this from?
They need an ASIC like everyone else

lo_lyf 13th Jul 2017 07:25

My ASIC got me 15% off an iPhone at SY.

gerry111 13th Jul 2017 11:22


Originally Posted by no_one (Post 9829125)
Venting on PPRUNE wont change anything.

What?? :sad:

Lead Balloon 13th Jul 2017 11:29


Originally Posted by Jetjr (Post 9829154)
Where did you get this from?
They need an ASIC like everyone else

Do RA-Aus people have to get an AVID?

Cloudee 13th Jul 2017 12:29


Originally Posted by Lead Balloon (Post 9829450)
Do RA-Aus people have to get an AVID?

No. They need no form of security pass unless they want to land at a security controlled airport, and then they need an ASIC.

Lead Balloon 13th Jul 2017 13:12

Therefore Clare Prop made a valid point.

Andy_RR 13th Jul 2017 19:03

Given the recent history of terrorism in Australia, making an ASIC mandatory for ordering coffee should make the place safer!
Less important for pilots at airports...

Lead Balloon 13th Jul 2017 22:41


Originally Posted by aeropelican (Post 9829625)
But why differentiate between RAAus and CASA issued licence holders in this case? All that achieves is dividing when a united GA pilot body is imperative to having these dumb regulations and requirements repealed.

The rules at the moment are clear:

Any pilot (be it RAAus or CASA) who has or requires airside access at a security controlled aerodrome requires an ASIC. Likewise both a CASA or RAAus pilot operating out of a non-security controlled aerodrome (or ALA, or field, or whatever) doesn't require an ASIC.

But you missed the point made by Clare: A "CASA" pilot must have at least an AVID, and getting one entails a security check.

However, I agree completely with your first point.

runway16 13th Jul 2017 23:20

So do I have it right?


A few weeks to run and this new set of rules come into place.


In Victoria there appears to be only one location where you have to front to confirm your face and paperwork ?


This is a disaster for flying. What about the guys in the country? Do they have to spend bulk dollars getting to and from that location?


This is really going to be a huge negative for people wanting to get into flying.
More security barriers and work that does not appear to do anything real. If the bad guys want to get into an airport are they really going to get an ASIC?
A pair of wire cutters will be the cheap option.

Egipps 14th Jul 2017 01:33


Originally Posted by runway16 (Post 9830069)
So do I have it right?

In Victoria there appears to be only one location where you have to front to confirm your face and paperwork ?

This is a disaster for flying. What about the guys in the country? Do they have to spend bulk dollars getting to and from that location?

AviationID have assured me there will be someone at Moorabbin to do the checks. No idea re other locations. But maybe worth calling them.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.