ABC Helicopter crash near Lake Eyre
Filming perspective on reported last moments.
My comments are from an aerial filming perspective as to what the crew may have been doing and is based on the eyewitness report, so should be read with skepticism..
ABC chopper had a mechanically stabilised camera rig installed in the right hand rear door. John sat beside the camera and its angle of view is obviously restricted to the right hand side.
So one should consider that often the aircraft needs to be flown in unusual configurations when filming from a side door (compared to using a stabilised nose mount). Gary probably had more experience of flying a camera in this manner (sideways) than anyone else in Australia.
But no indication as yet if they were filming when they took off. Eyewitnesses should have been able to see if the door was open so I hope this question can be answered promptly.
Direction of the orbit is a clue, if they flew an anti clockwise obit around the camp they weren't shooting the camp as the camera would be facing the outside of the orbit.
I could imagine that a wide shot of the camp, no doubt illuminated by campfire or battery lanterns would be a good shot and at least worth a look on the way out, which may explain the orbit.
I'm not sure if their SOP was to take off and land with the door closed and then open it in flight.
This could be explained if they were shooting a departure shot of the camp and so had to crab tail to the left which can look weird to a casual observer.
Flying low would give a good shot of the reflection of the camp lights in the water (assuming that there was water near the campsite)
If the dunes were fairly close to the camp (say under 1km) Gary could have been repositioning for a "reveal" shot of the camp by setting up the chopper behind the dunes, although the dunes would have been quite dark and a night time reveal does not generally fit into the conventional editing together of a daylight sequence.
Another possibility of the cause of them going low could have been a decision to land near the dunes so John could have setup an elevated, long lens tripod shot of the camp.
A bit early for such speculation, in any case the investigators could ask if a camera battery light was in use during ground filming after sunset. Tungsten bulb versions of these battery lights have in the past started a fire when accidently bumped/switched on whilst stowed in a camera bag.
I truly hope the case is a flukey mechanical failure. In any event with the loss of such an experienced low level filming pilot, who will be hard to replace, ABC should reconsider the merits of shooting from a side door.
Mickjoebill
Loss of orientation must be relatively low on the list,
So one should consider that often the aircraft needs to be flown in unusual configurations when filming from a side door (compared to using a stabilised nose mount). Gary probably had more experience of flying a camera in this manner (sideways) than anyone else in Australia.
But no indication as yet if they were filming when they took off. Eyewitnesses should have been able to see if the door was open so I hope this question can be answered promptly.
Direction of the orbit is a clue, if they flew an anti clockwise obit around the camp they weren't shooting the camp as the camera would be facing the outside of the orbit.
I could imagine that a wide shot of the camp, no doubt illuminated by campfire or battery lanterns would be a good shot and at least worth a look on the way out, which may explain the orbit.
I'm not sure if their SOP was to take off and land with the door closed and then open it in flight.
"They took off and circled around ... it didn't appear like a normal sort of exit," Mr Ellis said
"They went pretty low and out of sight behind dunes.
If the dunes were fairly close to the camp (say under 1km) Gary could have been repositioning for a "reveal" shot of the camp by setting up the chopper behind the dunes, although the dunes would have been quite dark and a night time reveal does not generally fit into the conventional editing together of a daylight sequence.
Another possibility of the cause of them going low could have been a decision to land near the dunes so John could have setup an elevated, long lens tripod shot of the camp.
Rumor from the television side of the project is that there was some sort of mechanical failure/fire on board.
I truly hope the case is a flukey mechanical failure. In any event with the loss of such an experienced low level filming pilot, who will be hard to replace, ABC should reconsider the merits of shooting from a side door.
Mickjoebill
Last edited by mickjoebill; 20th Aug 2011 at 10:18.
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Wybacrik
Posts: 1,190
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Boys will be boys whatever their age and experience...especially out in the bush after a days work and heading off to finish the night with good friends, a meal and a bottle of wine only a short distance away.
We've all been there, done that, haven't we?
We've all been there, done that, haven't we?
Boys will be boys whatever their age and experience...especially out in the bush after a days work and heading off to finish the night with good friends, a meal and a bottle of wine only a short distance away.
We've all been there, done that, haven't we?
We've all been there, done that, haven't we?
did they camp on the cooper overnight? if so whats the possibility of rats eating wiring in the plane which could cause problems?
Come on you guys! Give it a rest.
Let's just wait for the official inquiry!
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Australia
Age: 51
Posts: 931
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Capt Fathom,
you are pretty much right.
Mickjoebill.....make up your mind son.....your mother didn't give you that many names!!!
Further to Capt Fathom above, I enjoyed reading your post. It showed some elements of the sort of things a newsie pilot would be considering pre-flight that many of us would never even contemplate. It was certainly a good read. Thankyou for taking your time to post.
Jas
you are pretty much right.
Mickjoebill.....make up your mind son.....your mother didn't give you that many names!!!
Further to Capt Fathom above, I enjoyed reading your post. It showed some elements of the sort of things a newsie pilot would be considering pre-flight that many of us would never even contemplate. It was certainly a good read. Thankyou for taking your time to post.
Jas
For the moment only one person has mentioned a possible bird-strike. I was camping over at Lake Eyre in June and I experienced two relevant incidents.
One was a bird-strike in a C208 while a pax on an afternoon scenic flight. I was in the front right seat... conditions were good, we were flying north west at about 2500 ft. when in a moment I noticed two birds in front of us and one second later there was a bang as one of them hit the leading edge of the wing. There was no obvious damage when we landed but it was amazing how quickly it happened.
The second incident might be more relevant though. We were camped near the punt on the Cooper Creek and one night I kayaked 10 kilometres from the road end of Lake Warrawarrinna back across to our camp. I left on sunset and had a full moon, perfect still conditions and a GPS to find the camp.
About 7.30 at night... in darkness except for the moonlight I encountered a large flock of pelicans and they took to the air. If a kayaker paddling in near silence is enough to get a couple of hundred pelicans into the air... what would they do with a helicopter coming towards them at 100 knots?
My condolences to the families and friends of three great men. In today's world it was just great to see three men, with the support of the ABC, committing to such a beautiful project.
One was a bird-strike in a C208 while a pax on an afternoon scenic flight. I was in the front right seat... conditions were good, we were flying north west at about 2500 ft. when in a moment I noticed two birds in front of us and one second later there was a bang as one of them hit the leading edge of the wing. There was no obvious damage when we landed but it was amazing how quickly it happened.
The second incident might be more relevant though. We were camped near the punt on the Cooper Creek and one night I kayaked 10 kilometres from the road end of Lake Warrawarrinna back across to our camp. I left on sunset and had a full moon, perfect still conditions and a GPS to find the camp.
About 7.30 at night... in darkness except for the moonlight I encountered a large flock of pelicans and they took to the air. If a kayaker paddling in near silence is enough to get a couple of hundred pelicans into the air... what would they do with a helicopter coming towards them at 100 knots?
My condolences to the families and friends of three great men. In today's world it was just great to see three men, with the support of the ABC, committing to such a beautiful project.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Enroute from Dagobah to Tatooine...!
Posts: 791
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Saw the re-run of ABC's 7:30 report tribute to these guys today. It's a shame more people on here couldn't extend some of the same empathy that these professionals were known for - irrespective of the causal factors of the crash.
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: australia
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Gary Ticehurst. A wonderful gentleman, a class act all round, and an extraordinary aviator. I didn't know the other two gentlemen, but my condolences to their families and friends. RIP Tice, say G'day to Lizard for me, and let the clowns pontificate.
The only thing we know is that the chopper flew into the ground at high speed, and that can only mean sudden and severe mechanical failure, sudden pilot incapacitation, or the pilot losing orientation.
Even in transit mode and at night, there are many reasons for laptops, PDAs and cameras to be operated and wielded around in this mobile office/TV studio.
Another (remote) possibility is compromising the pilot's night vision by the accidental activation of a TV light. Such lights are used in cockpit to illuminate the reporter and modern versions are dimmable and can be very bright to balance the shadowed interior to the high light intensity of daylight.
I'm hoping it is a bird strike.
Mickjoebill
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Usually Oz
Posts: 732
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Memorial Service - Gary
Lest you missed this in other media;
RIP
F#3
UPDATE August 24, 2011: A memorial service for Gary Ticehurst will be held in Sydney at Rushcutters Bay Park, near the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia, on Tuesday, August 30 at 11.30am. The service is open to anyone who would like to attend and is being held by the family and the ABC.
A reel of Ticehurst's feature film work is being compiled by Matt Graham and will be screened at the memorial service. He is trying to locate images (still or moving) of Gary and his work. If you have contributions, these can be sent to Matt Graham, who can be contacted on 0430 572 770.
A reel of Ticehurst's feature film work is being compiled by Matt Graham and will be screened at the memorial service. He is trying to locate images (still or moving) of Gary and his work. If you have contributions, these can be sent to Matt Graham, who can be contacted on 0430 572 770.
F#3
Memorial Service - Gary
DF.
On ROTORHEADS under the thread called -
Three killed in South Australia Helicopter crash
there's a link to a doco coverage of the memorial
service held for Gary Ticehurst. It reveals in spades
what a wonderful person he was. Viewing highly recommended.
Three killed in South Australia Helicopter crash
there's a link to a doco coverage of the memorial
service held for Gary Ticehurst. It reveals in spades
what a wonderful person he was. Viewing highly recommended.
Preliminary report
ABC reporting that preliminary investigation has not reached any conclusions.
http://www.atsb.gov.au/media/3466996...102_prelim.pdf
It has however ruled out a pre impact fire saying the reports of a glow by eyewitness are not supported by study of the wreckage.
I wonder if they have also ruled out the accidental activation of an in cockpit camera light which would have created a glow if seen from the ground.
The bureau says an examination of the artificial horizon instrument has confirmed its internal gyro was working at the time. It hit the ground at 90 degrees on right hand side.
Mickjoebill
http://www.atsb.gov.au/media/3466996...102_prelim.pdf
It has however ruled out a pre impact fire saying the reports of a glow by eyewitness are not supported by study of the wreckage.
I wonder if they have also ruled out the accidental activation of an in cockpit camera light which would have created a glow if seen from the ground.
The bureau says an examination of the artificial horizon instrument has confirmed its internal gyro was working at the time. It hit the ground at 90 degrees on right hand side.
Mickjoebill