PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Ukraine War Thread Part 2 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/652441-ukraine-war-thread-part-2-a.html)

Sfojimbo 4th Jul 2023 08:23


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 11461542)
NATO member states have differed in their respective degree of support for Ukraine since the beginning of the war.
I assume you're not suggesting that those members not at immediate risk from Russia are going to abrogate Article 5?

If things drag on too long, Poland or the Baltics may engage in activities that bring them into military engagement with Russia. In that case, would the other NATO members see article 5 as being violated? Might they try to distance themselves from actions they see as imprudent?

Tartiflette Fan 4th Jul 2023 08:44


Originally Posted by Sfojimbo (Post 11461573)
If things drag on too long, Poland or the Baltics may engage in activities that bring them into military engagement with Russia. In that case, would the other NATO members see article 5 as being violated? Might they try to distance themselves from actions they see as imprudent?

As I understand it, if any member acts unilaterally, then they do so on their own national responsibility and there would be no question of Article 5 being invoked. Obviously if this unilateral action were an immediate response to an attack, that would not be the same at all and Article 5 would , presumably, be enacted as soon as the necessary meetings/agreements were carried out. Where I am completely uncertain is how any cyber attack would be viewed, and what intensity would be required before there would be any joint action.

wondering 4th Jul 2023 09:07


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11461136)
Ominous if true and an indication of the failure of the allies to step up production.



It appears that The time windows for an attrition war against Russia was missed.

Months ago, I wrote about the three biggest Russian factories idling their production due to a shortage of electronics.

(twitter.com/pati_marins64/…)


….

This account is not 'neutral'. It has always been biased towards RU.

Sure RU won't run out of weapons any time soon. That' obviously propaganda. Since it is a war of attrition, does anybody believe RU can out-manufacture the West? The SU tried it during the Cold War. We all know how that ended.

What she totally ignores is the ramping up of weapons production in the Free World. It's not just Poland.


NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 09:30

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....0d667fc8d8.png

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 09:33

Update:

Wanted war criminal and former FSB officer Igor Girkin reports:

"Apparently, the enemy resumed the offensive on the Vremevsky ledge (south of Velyka Novosilka), heavy fighting is reported, alarming information comes from the area north of Bakhmut, just where the understaffed units of the 3rd Army Corps are deployed on our side. The enemy in that area has an advance, how deep - I can’t say, there is little information. But there urgently went reserves."

ORAC 4th Jul 2023 09:34

Arrest warrant for Prigozhin for high treason was issued on 21st June - 2 days before before his attempted coup….

​​​​​​​

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 09:35


It is reported that a warehouse was struck by the AFU in occupied Yakymivka, occupied Zaporizhzia region. This town is a logistical (railway) hub between Crimea and Melitopol and was subject to strikes earlier.

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e4433e3c3a.png


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....86be0563f8.png


NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 09:40

Test: This morning the Moscow region was attacked by unknown drones. An explosion is reported on the territory of a military unit in Kubinka, the neighboring Vnukovo airport has stopped accepting aircraft.

https://mstdn.social/@noelreports/110654348698436889

Tartiflette Fan 4th Jul 2023 09:43

https://www.focus.de/politik/ausland...198103589.html

This report contains Twitter video ( which works ) showing recovery operations for damaged armour at Mala Tokmatschka i ( Leos and Bradleys caught in artillery fire/mines on June 8th). What is interesting is both that the AFU has now advanced enough to recover them , but also the numbers involved. Total given as 25 which is many more than I believed were involved at the time.

Leopard tank repair depot in Gliwice, Poland:

This operation should have opened in May to maintain and repair Polish and German Leo's donated to Ukraine, however it hasn't.. The reason is that there is a disagreement over the price that the Polish arms manufacturer,
Bumar-Labedy, wants for the work which Germany finds far too high. It's very strange to me that this wasn't settled months ago when agreeing to set up the operation. Pistorius, the German Defence Minister, has set a deadline of 10 days to reach agreement.

The Hague: International Centre for the Prosecution of Crimes of Aggression against Ukraine https://www.dw.com/de/ukraine-aktuel...rum/a-66095756

This body has just taken up its work as part of Eurojust. It brings together prosecutors from Ukraine, the EU, the USA and the International Criminal Court who will gather evidence of crimes committed by Russia in preparation to prosecute these acts and their perpetrators.

John Marsh 4th Jul 2023 10:08


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 11461542)
NATO member states have differed in their respective degree of support for Ukraine since the beginning of the war.

I assume you're not suggesting that those members not at immediate risk from Russia are going to abrogate Article 5?

Indeed not. I can however see a situation where the more immediately threatened members adopt their own joint initiative in expanding and upgrading Ukraine's military capabilities.

Rockie_Rapier 4th Jul 2023 10:51


Originally Posted by John Marsh (Post 11461656)
Indeed not. I can however see a situation where the more immediately threatened members adopt their own joint initiative in expanding and upgrading Ukraine's military capabilities.

Hasn't that already happened?

I understand that Poland and Estonia are making significantly greater (in GDP percentage wise) than most of the other NATO partners.

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:03

Feher Junior says


In the Berdyansk direction, the Armed Forces advanced up to 2 kilometers into the depth of the enemy's defenses, — the press center of the Defense Forces of the Tavriysk direction The Ukrainian military continues to advance in the Tauriy direction. Currently, the Defense Forces are entrenched on the occupied borders.

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....7e51e108f7.png

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:05

It makes total sense.


Jens Stoltenberg remains NATO Secretary General until October 1, 2024. The decision to keep Stoltenberg in office was made in order to preserve unity and stability during Russia's war against Ukraine.

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:10

Ballcocks...


Unfortunately, today the Russians shot down "Storm Shadow" for the first time...
I tend to agree, what about you?


This was likely a malfunction as there’s no visible damage. Russian will reverse engineer this missile and incorporate its stealth technology to its own. China will pay big bucks for this trophy too.

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d0e836168a.png


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8746dcb27f.png


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....9d7e210902.png


https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....840bec1767.png


NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:21

It does not really help when you teach the Ukrainians western tactics, but one thing those tactics depend on is airpower and you then do not provide it when needed.


"Training of Ukrainians on the F-16 was supposed to begin in June" - Kuleba The training includes not only the training of pilots, but also engineers, as well as the creation of infrastructure and "making the necessary legal decisions." P.S. Was supposed to begin...

"The training did not start. There was a promise to start training in June from one of the countries, now they say that they are continuing preparations for the start of training, they made a mistake in the calculations, they need more time" - Kuleba

"The training of pilots and technical personnel, as well as the provision of logistics that can support these aircraft, will not be available until the counteroffensive is completed" - said the chairman of the NATO Military Committee, Rob Bauer.

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:26

It just amazes me what the Ukrainians can do when they put their mind to it.. Imagine this in the UK!

MAKS 23

"The construction of the main water pipelines for the territories affected by the terrorist attack at the Kakhovska HPP has begun" - the Minister of Infrastructure

The waterworks will consist of 3 links with a length of ~150 km and will be able to provide water to at least 1 million people in Dnipropetrovsk Oblast, Mykolaiv Oblast, Kherson Oblast and Zaporizhzhia.

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....cbdec6cb7f.png


https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....72f0620ddc.png


NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 11:29


At the moment, the most alarming situation for the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation is in the Orichovsky direction:
On June 28-29, the Russian counterattack, which was intended to push the Armed Forces back to the minefields north of Robotyny, failed. This had serious consequences - for the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation.
In the early morning of June 30, the Ukrainian Armed Forces entered Novopokrovka, and then attacked it at close range, forcing the Russian garrison to flee in panic. In response, the 58th ZVA transferred special forces there (probably the 45th brigade), which saved the situation so much that they still hold the southern side of the village.
However, later (on July 1) the Armed Forces penetrated the junction between BARS-3 (defended by Robotyn) and the 70th motorized rifle regiment (defended the area between Robotyn and Verbov).
Russian positions collapsed again, which allowed the Armed Forces to drive a wedge in the direction of Novoprokopivka (defended by the 1430th motorized rifle regiment). It is not known how far this offensive went, but it is clear that our actions continued for at least 48 hours without a break, exhausting the Russians as a result.
There is no doubt that as soon as the Russians threw part of the 22nd Special Forces Brigade and several tanks to block this move, the main position of the 22nd Brigade was attacked by the ZSU, this time on the eastern flank of the Russians, in the direction of Verbovoi (defended by the 417th Reconnaissance Battalion ).

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....9ab4f23869.png

fdr 4th Jul 2023 11:48


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11461637)
Test: This morning the Moscow region was attacked by unknown drones. An explosion is reported on the territory of a military unit in Kubinka, the neighboring Vnukovo airport has stopped accepting aircraft.



https://mstdn.social/@noelreports/110654348698436889

Waggoneer's revenge? Assume they know a thing or two about drones and IED's now, and they surely have an enemy, the one in the crimlin, not the Ukrainians at this time. ("Enemy of my enemy" etc....):bored:

NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 12:52

Good, at the moment there is a 13KM queue to get onto the Kerch bridge heading into Crimea, it is Russians going on holiday, a few bangs along the coast might get the old rings puckering amongst them, I did wonder if this sudden surge of "tourists" is moscow led to prevent strikes on the bridge if packed with civilians


An explosion is reported in the center of Sevastopol near Ostryakova Ave.

The traffic jam at the entrance to Crimea from the Russian main land reached 13 kilometers. The local authorities of the occupied Crimea notes that this is due to the influx of tourists. Governor Aksyonov promised to solve the problem even when the traffic jams were 5-6 km long.
Easily fixed, whistle up a couple of Ukrainian missiles and no point queuing anymore.



NutLoose 4th Jul 2023 12:55

A pair of knocked out Leopard2R mine clearers.

https://mstdn.social/@noelreports/110651322930990116


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:07.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.