PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Chinese spy balloon over US (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/651165-chinese-spy-balloon-over-us.html)

Ninthace 4th Feb 2023 16:35


Originally Posted by Low average (Post 11379845)
The timing is too much of a co-incidence to me. The US has finally started to call China out over Taiwan and the South China Sea. Called it a bigger threat than Russia, and has just struck a deal for bases in the Phillipines. Resistance to the slow coiling Chinese Dragon is growing.

This balloon, with its considerable payload hovering over the continental US, capable or not...is a message.

And the strategic significance of the balloon over Costa Rica. What are they up to?

mikeoneflying 4th Feb 2023 17:11

n Costa Rica exports account for around 40 percent of GDP. Costa Rica´s main exports are electronic components (18 percent of total exports), medical equipment (7.3 percent), pineapples (7 percent) and bananas (6 percent). Costa Rica´s main export partner is the United States (37 percent of total exports). Others include: Netherlands, Panama, Hong Kong and Nicaragua.

However, always rumours about secret US bases in S.America.

Baldeep Inminj 4th Feb 2023 17:26

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....beb5fb0fd.jpeg

RAFEngO74to09 4th Feb 2023 17:41

Biden Admin's indecisive incompetence over this all over US TV now - including comments from all the usual top commentators eg previous SecDef + various retired 3/4-stars.

Looks like they will finally be attempting a shootdown over Atlnatic.

FAA issued ground stop in area - F-22As + F-15Cs + supporting tankers scrambled


https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FoJH2UCa...name=4096x4096

RAFEngO74to09 4th Feb 2023 18:02

Live excellent quality feed on Fox News now. Probably going to be multiple 20mm gun passes by F-22A and F-15C.
Ground stop is until 1445 EST.

Ninthace 4th Feb 2023 18:10


Originally Posted by mikeoneflying (Post 11379968)
n Costa Rica exports account for around 40 percent of GDP. Costa Rica´s main exports are electronic components (18 percent of total exports), medical equipment (7.3 percent), pineapples (7 percent) and bananas (6 percent). Costa Rica´s main export partner is the United States (37 percent of total exports). Others include: Netherlands, Panama, Hong Kong and Nicaragua.

However, always rumours about secret US bases in S.America.

So nothing really

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 18:24


Originally Posted by RAFEngO74to09 (Post 11379981)
Live excellent quality feed on Fox News now. Probably going to be multiple 20mm gun passes by F-22A and F-15C.
Ground stop is until 1445 EST.



Fonsini 4th Feb 2023 18:26

F-22s spraying 20mm all over Myrtle Beach. Meh, all you need is a helicopter and a box cutter :}

pasta 4th Feb 2023 18:28

BBC News reporting that Biden "is facing intense pressure domestically to shoot the object down." What is it with the Americans, thinking that the solution to every problem is to shoot it? It's not as though the US haven't flown plenty of their own weather balloons over China...

RAFEngO74to09 4th Feb 2023 18:39

Balloon splashed 1438 ET!

pilotmike 4th Feb 2023 18:45


Originally Posted by petit plateau (Post 11379954)
More likely …. The payload is probably just …. and a wee pump. !

That would be wasted payload. Gravity could take care of matters if the Chinese just wanted to p1$$ all over the USA!

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 18:52

Looked like the payload broke away when the balloon burst - that'll hit the ground hard.

Ninthace 4th Feb 2023 18:59


Originally Posted by Wokkafans (Post 11380010)
Looked like the payload broke away when the balloon burst - that'll hit the ground hard.

I got the same impression.

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 19:02

Missile strike


MENELAUS 4th Feb 2023 19:17


Originally Posted by Brewster Buffalo (Post 11379931)
With a proper breeding techniques and a ratio of, say, ten females to each male, I would guess that we could be back to the present gross national product within, say, 20 years.:)


Thank you Dr Strangelove. It won’t be difficult mein fuhrer.

langleybaston 4th Feb 2023 19:20


Originally Posted by MENELAUS (Post 11380030)
Thank you Dr Strangelove. It won’t be difficult mein fuhrer.

Do you save wicked women? Save ne a few, pease.

NutLoose 4th Feb 2023 19:46

Probably trying to emulate Branson and be the first Chinese to circumnavigate the world in a balloon, but forgot to tell anyone. ;)

sir 4th Feb 2023 19:52

handled well IMHO, cool and collected until it was offshore then splash with a conventional regular every day weapon.

RAFEngO74to09 4th Feb 2023 20:03

F-22A used an AIM-9 to shoot down the balloon.

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 20:12

Footage from another angle.


https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFoota...eb2x&context=3

Greatman77 4th Feb 2023 20:15

I live in Charlotte, NC. This thing came over us this morning, the US airforce was clearly following and watching it closely, with multiple contrails visible around it. Absolutely surreal...

Ninthace 4th Feb 2023 20:41

All very anticlimactic, I bet it will be more spectacular when they make the movie. I wonder if there was a sweepstake for who got the honours?

Baldeep Inminj 4th Feb 2023 21:01


Originally Posted by Ninthace (Post 11380064)
All very anticlimactic, I bet it will be more spectacular when they make the movie. I wonder if there was a sweepstake for who got the honours?

Gotta be the Sqn boss - always take the glory missions…at least mine all did, particularly my 2 female bosses - never to be seen until a high-profile mission appeared and then they were all over it…🤔

True, but ducking and preparing for incoming nevertheless.

twb3 4th Feb 2023 21:02

Is this the first ever air-to-air kill for the Raptor?

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 21:09




albatross 4th Feb 2023 21:22

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....f70b72d28.jpeg
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....06c4d96a8.jpeg
Both a Poseidon and a USCG Dolphin helicopter operating in the impact area. The Helicopter appears to be in a low hover.

421dog 4th Feb 2023 22:01


Originally Posted by twb3 (Post 11380072)
Is this the first ever air-to-air kill for the Raptor?

Maybe so, but I think Willi Coppens (sorry if I am screwing up the spelling) is still number 1
(as balloon busters go)

gums 4th Feb 2023 22:06

Salute!

Actchally, If it were a Raptor, then pilot could wear a p-suit or simply pull up and gun the balloon to allow a kinder more gentle descent of the payload for recovery and analysis.

Using an AIM-9X from an F-22 seems overkill, and even an F-16 or F-15 could do a snap-up and an Aim-9. Even back in 1966 we practiced snap=ups versus high targets like U-2, B-57 and even the BOMARC interceptor doing 3.+ M and at 70,000 feet. If we were not cruising above 50,000 ft, we did not need the p-suits and the rules allowed us to go up for the shot and then pull back down to follow all the altitude/pressure rules. BFD.

Anyway, looks like one bullet, one kill. Even versus a stoopid floating balloon.

Gums sends...

421dog 4th Feb 2023 22:13

It looked like it was 60k or less when it hit the East coast. (Not really sure about the weird secrecy surrounding this event, it makes me uncomfortable. We knew exactly when where and what was going to happen to Payne Stewart and his crew when they were still buzzing along asleep for 6 hrs before they crashed in ND 10 yrs ago)

Wokkafans 4th Feb 2023 22:15


421dog 4th Feb 2023 22:19

Ok, well that even makes it look more duplicitous. What the heck am I missing?

tartare 4th Feb 2023 22:30

So presumably, F22 pilots would only wear a full pressure suit if expecting to fly at or above FL60 for a while i.e. the Armstrong line?
Otherwise it's pressure breathing etc?

NutLoose 4th Feb 2023 22:41

Of course all this is assuming it wasn’t transmitting the data home in real time and China already has what they wanted.

Less Hair 4th Feb 2023 23:05

China might try to politically use it as a bait. Now that the US shot down an overflight they might claim to be authorised to do the same to anything over "their" reefs airspace or similar? There is certainly more behind this. It's all too visible, a show piece.

Ninthace 4th Feb 2023 23:19


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11380107)
Of course all this is assuming it wasn’t transmitting the data home in real time and China already has what they wanted.

Care to speculate what they wanted as it was known it was there so any sensitive emissions should have been minimised and its track could not exactly have been controlled, so anything sensitive it flew over was pretty much random. The best they could hope for was picking up lots of cell phone calls of people asking each other if they could see it.

aox 4th Feb 2023 23:26

So if it really was a spy deice, the best thing to do is let if fly cross the whole country, then shoot it down as it leaves

One explanation was they didn't want to risk collateral damage on the ground

Now it is said they want to recover and inspect it, but it will be harder to find

Wokkafans 5th Feb 2023 00:31

​​​​​​​

albatross 5th Feb 2023 00:38


Originally Posted by aox (Post 11380121)
So if it really was a spy deice, the best thing to do is let if fly cross the whole country, then shoot it down as it leaves

One explanation was they didn't want to risk collateral damage on the ground

Now it is said they want to recover and inspect it, but it will be harder to find

I think they have a very good position on the impact point in shallow water. The USS Morehead City arrived near the area just about time of impact. No recent up date on position.Shortly after impact a Poseidon was in the area and a USCG helicopter flew a search grid and seemed to then enter a low hover. As per my previous posts.
Lots of folks not under the balloon’s flight path and in the political opposition were calling for shooting it down overland on every channel on which they could get in front of a camera. imagine these same folks outrage if it hit anything or anybody.or even came close to anything. Bringing it down as it left the coast was IMO the best option.
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....16b4bd292.jpeg


gums 5th Feb 2023 00:41

Salute!

tartare Back in the day, we only had to wear a p-suit for "sustained flight" above 50K and maybe shorter flights way up there like those NF-104 jets. I am not even sure the Streak Eagle guys wore a p-suit and they toped out aroung 100K, certainly above 90K

Our high altitude profile in the VooDoo and 106 was at 49K and go fast, then pull up for the shot. As a target, we cruised at 49K and 1,1M or so for 10 or 15 minutes in basic flying suit.

Well, guess the crew chief can paint a timny balloon on the side of the jet now.

Gums sends...

MechEngr 5th Feb 2023 01:33

One never can tell when interesting information can be gathered:


We were told to be very careful - not to buy our train ticket in Princeton, for example, because Princeton was a very small station, and if everybody bought train tickets to Albuquerque, New Mexico, in Princeton, there would be some suspicions that something was up. And so everybody bought their tickets somewhere else, except me, because I figured if everybody bought their tickets somewhere else. . .

So when I went to the train station and said, “I want to go to Albuquerque, New Mexico, “ the man says, “Oh, so all this stuff is for you!" We had been shipping out crates full of counters for weeks and expecting that they didn't notice the address was Albuquerque. So at least I explained why it was that we were shipping all those crates; I was going out to Albuquerque.
Los Alamos From Below: Reminiscences 1943-1945, by Richard Feynman

"You can observe a lot by just watching." - Yogi Berra

Meanwhile there is no good understanding on the amount and type of information being exfiltrated that the TikTok app has gathered.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:40.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.