PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Chinese spy balloon over US (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/651165-chinese-spy-balloon-over-us.html)

212man 7th Feb 2023 18:18


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11381392)
Best detailed photo released so far.


https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....5b076b029.jpeg

Anyone seen a translation? Right character appears to mean ‘center’ but can’t find the left one.

MENELAUS 7th Feb 2023 18:24

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ab44733fb.jpeg
Or close enough

MechEngr 7th Feb 2023 18:38


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11381782)
Anyone seen a translation? Right character appears to mean ‘center’ but can’t find the left one.

The left one is clearly a pictograph of a camera, indicating the world "Spy."

(I'm here all week. Try the veal.)

212man 7th Feb 2023 18:40


Originally Posted by MechEngr (Post 11381793)
The left one is clearly a pictograph of a camera, indicating the world "Spy."

(I'm here all week. Try the veal.)

Hopefully not from a crate?


SWBKCB 7th Feb 2023 19:19

The Chineses are smuggling veal reared in crates using balloons? :eek:

Wokkafans 7th Feb 2023 20:24





mike1964 7th Feb 2023 20:52

New Zealand spy balloon
 
https://scontent-akl1-1.xx.fbcdn.net...jA&oe=63E8418B

judyjudy 7th Feb 2023 21:24


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11381782)
Anyone seen a translation? Right character appears to mean ‘center’ but can’t find the left one.

”zhong gong” - abbreviation for “Chinese Communist Party”

judyjudy 7th Feb 2023 21:36

Actually, In thinking about it, “zhong gong” could mean:

CCP “zhong guo gong chan dang”

or

PRC “zhong hua ren min gong he guo”

I’ve seen it to mean both

212man 7th Feb 2023 21:38


Originally Posted by judyjudy (Post 11381880)
Actually, In thinking about it, “zhong gong” could mean:

CCP “zhong guo gong chan dang”

or

PRC “zhong hua ren min gong he guo”

I’ve seen it to mean both

makes sense. I thought the ‘center’ was probably going to get further translation

Ninthace 7th Feb 2023 23:05


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11381392)
Best detailed photo released so far.


https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....5b076b029.jpeg

is that THE balloon or a generic image?
Edit to add, I have trawled all the previous images and there is no writing visible on the envelope. The writing is not parallel to the balloon material either.

StephanKoelliker 7th Feb 2023 23:24


Originally Posted by Ninthace (Post 11381929)
is that THE balloon?

Certainly not. Look at the number of solar panels (or whatever they are):
The fake "photo" posted by ORAC shows ten "double panels", the real photos taken from the ground show only eight "double panels".

megan 8th Feb 2023 00:11


I find it funny that the “media” is reporting that 3 times during the Trump administration
From the link, why fitted with propellers and rudder?

National Security Council spokesman John Kirby told reporters Feb. 6 that the balloon had propellers and a rudder, which allowed it to change course and conduct limited maneuvers, though it mostly stayed with the jet stream. It was able to slow down and loiter over sensitive locations, he said.........................After the Pentagon announced the balloon’s presence on Feb. 2, officials said there had been at least four other intrusions in recent years—one near Hawaii earlier in the Biden administration and three during the Trump administration. All of these incidents were brief, with the overflight far shorter than the most recent incursion, Kirby says.
https://aviationweek.com/defense-spa...d77e4643d6b76e

nephx 8th Feb 2023 03:24


Originally Posted by kiwi grey (Post 11380582)
I would surmise that the attack run was made from the west, and we know it was from below the balloon.
Hence the balloon envelope would be reflecting the afternoon sun (it was ~14:40 local) and would be relatively warm against the easterly sky, also the only such object in view. Presumably the temperature difference was enough for the AIM-9X imaging infra-red sensor to resolve a 'target'

The AIM 9X Block II & II have lock-on after launch capability with a datalink. I haven't seen much on how that works but assuming the data link can be used by AWACS, P-8 or whatever was assisting them including a F-15E WSO.
I've seen one account that the AIM 9x had no warhead which could be true - no flames visible in footage made public.

nephx 8th Feb 2023 03:37


Originally Posted by Chiefttp (Post 11381478)
I find it funny that the “media” is reporting that 3 times during the Trump administration, Undetected Chinese ballon’s crossed the U.S. If they were undetected how did they know it happened 3 times.


I love this word “Undetected”. Sounds just like a Who’s On First skit..”

The Biden administration only became aware of the intrusions during the Trump prior administration by looking back after the fact using an undisclosed “forensic” process, he says. The current White House has offered briefings to Trump administration officials on this.
While officials did not specify how these prior intrusions were discovered, the Pentagon has convened a task force to investigate sightings of what it calls unexplained aerial phenomena to try to learn more about the incidents and identify what the aircraft could be. (National Security Council spokesman John Kirby Feb. 6)
The Chinese are testing undetectable low tech ways to intrude. That's not funny at all. There is always a new thing out there.

National defense should have no political aspect when the enemy is concerned.

Asturias56 8th Feb 2023 07:52

Even as we speak Boeing and MD are working on proposals for a $ 10 Bn R&D programme to shoot down these balloons

"It is a DISGRACE that these 2st century threats are being dealt with by 20th Century equipment a spokesman said."

622 8th Feb 2023 09:03


Originally Posted by judyjudy (Post 11381872)
”zhong gong” - abbreviation for “Chinese Communist Party”


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11381782)
Anyone seen a translation? Right character appears to mean ‘center’ but can’t find the left one.

..I'm pretty sure it's dry clean only or do not bleach .....but will obviously need to confirm with Mrs 622 first! :E

MechEngr 8th Feb 2023 12:13


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11381796)
Hopefully not from a crate?

Like the balloon, free range.

Flyhighfirst 8th Feb 2023 12:24


Originally Posted by mike1964 (Post 11381857)

Its just a bird isn’t it?

albatross 8th Feb 2023 17:19

After studying this footage it became obvious that destruction over land was not a viable option.
Hence the delay until the balloon left the coast.

Ninthace 8th Feb 2023 17:37


Originally Posted by Flyhighfirst (Post 11382231)
Its just a bird isn’t it?

Can't be a kiwi, they're flightless.

BBadanov 8th Feb 2023 17:47

And another balloon has been spotted, as reported on the "adf-serials" site. This one looks rather military, compared to those COMPLETELY harmless, innocent, benign Chinese ones. This was spotted snooping around Canberra at low level.
It won't find much intelligence in Canberra.

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d78fe35965.jpg

albatross 8th Feb 2023 18:01

Recent tracks of the USS Carter Hall off of Myrtle Beach. From the Marine Traffic Website.https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....485889e9f.jpeg

SASless 8th Feb 2023 19:30

Note:

The US Navy Ship offshore of Myrtle Beach, South Carolina is the USS Carter Hall, an LSD that departed Morehead City, North Carolina.

The Hall is home-ported at Little Creek, Virginia.

The ship recently returned from a deployment and probably off loaded embarked Marine Corps personnel and equipment at Morehead City.

Morehead City is used by Marine Corps units assigned to Camp Lejeune, North Carolina....home of the 2nd Marine Division and MARSOC units.

There is no USS Morehead City shown on the current US Navy list of Ships.

https://www.navysite.de/ships/lsd50.htm

The search area is in about fifty feet of water....in an area that has a generally flat sandy bottom with a current that tends to the northeast. Visibility can vary from almost nil to like a swimming pool depending upon season and sea state.

Excellent weather the past few days.....warm, slack wind, ocean is almost flat.

https://tides4fishing.com/us/south-c...ity-pier-ocean

pax britanica 8th Feb 2023 19:54

isnt this sort of mission what U2s carried out decades ago ; I can understand the US destroying it/ shooting it down but not righteous indignation since they have been doing the same thing with more sophsiticated kit since forever

albatross 8th Feb 2023 22:13

You are correct SASless.
USS Carter Hall.
My post has been edited to correct the info.
A Landing Ship, Dock.
She would have useful tech aboard.
I really should learn how to read.
Cheers
Albatross

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8e0db7495.jpeg

Originally Posted by SASless (Post 11382432)
Note:

The US Navy Ship offshore of Myrtle Beach, South Carolina is the USS Carter Hall, an LSD that departed Morehead City, North Carolina.

The Hall is home-ported at Little Creek, Virginia.

The ship recently returned from a deployment and probably off loaded embarked Marine Corps personnel and equipment at Morehead City.

Morehead City is used by Marine Corps units assigned to Camp Lejeune, North Carolina....home of the 2nd Marine Division and MARSOC units.

There is no USS Morehead City shown on the current US Navy list of Ships.

https://www.navysite.de/ships/lsd50.htm

The search area is in about fifty feet of water....in an area that has a generally flat sandy bottom with a current that tends to the northeast. Visibility can vary from almost nil to like a swimming pool depending upon season and sea state.

Excellent weather the past few days.....warm, slack wind, ocean is almost flat.

https://tides4fishing.com/us/south-c...ity-pier-ocean


Tartiflette Fan 9th Feb 2023 11:24


Originally Posted by pax britanica (Post 11382445)
isnt this sort of mission what U2s carried out decades ago ; I can understand the US destroying it/ shooting it down but not righteous indignation since they have been doing the same thing with more sophsiticated kit since forever

Seems naive to pass up a propaganda chance to poke your enemy in the eye, especially since the Chinese are always whining about capitalist expansion ( when they are busy concreting the China Sea reefs ). That apart, for the past few decades, surveillance has been carried out from outside the borders of the state concerned.

ChrisJ800 9th Feb 2023 11:46

Why is a spy balloon designed to fly in the stratosphere where there are no clouds white or silver instead of blue? And it seems to be coated in a fine powder based on the puff of dust from missile impact.

Brewster Buffalo 9th Feb 2023 11:57


Originally Posted by ChrisJ800 (Post 11382806)
Why is a spy balloon designed to fly in the stratosphere where there are no clouds white or silver instead of blue? And it seems to be coated in a fine powder based on the puff of dust from missile impact.

Well if you tried to camouflage it, in order to conceal it, then that wouldn't support your weather balloon story. After all why would you want to hide a weather balloon?

sandringham1 9th Feb 2023 12:13


Originally Posted by nephx (Post 11381999)
I've seen one account that the AIM 9x had no warhead which could be true - no flames visible in footage made public.

Just a pin!

SASless 9th Feb 2023 12:13

Albatross,

As I live near Morehead City....and pass by the Port often....seeing the reference to the USS Morehead Ctty and knowing how Amphib Ships are named.....it took a while for the doubt to fester.

I rode the USS Denver so to see and LSD with a city name seemed likely enough until I thought to check the current ships list.

So do not feel bad at all.....it took almost a week for me to check.

albatross 9th Feb 2023 13:11


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 11382824)
Albatross,

As I live near Morehead City....and pass by the Port often....seeing the reference to the USS Morehead Ctty and knowing how Amphib Ships are named.....it took a while for the doubt to fester.

I rode the USS Denver so to see and LSD with a city name seemed likely enough until I thought to check the current ships list.

So do not feel bad at all.....it took almost a week for me to check.

SASless….It was fun and easy to find it on a shipping site I should however have checked the hull pendant number 50.
The Poseidon and USCG Dolphin helicopter were also easy to find on an aviation site in position ready to pounce.

I found the media reportIng on this affair to have been on the low standard I have learned to expect. “A headline in search of a story”

I was surprised that no politician or reporter, in order to spread further fear and panic, reported that the only deaths caused in the lower 48 states by air bombardment in WW2 were caused to a church group on a picnic by bombs dropped from a Japanese balloon.
One reporter for a large US network did state in passing that a Japanese balloon had been shot down during the Pearl Harbour attack…I just about fell off the couch at that one. “If you can’t daze them with facts baffle them with bull****!”
Cheers
Albatross

Funny note on Pendant numbers: If the flagship raises a flag signal of just your pendant number “at the dip” ( about 3/4 of the way up the signal halyard ) it means “You have done something wrong and have failed to correct it.” COs must luv to see that! Almost as good as the signal “Maneuver fairly well done.”

SASless 9th Feb 2023 15:35

I recall standing on the Bridge when a vessel of the Gray Funnel Line dropped Anchor off Hong Kong.....along with every inch of the chain attached thereto......after all of the racket...smoke and dust settled and a very prolonged silence by all present.....the XO was heard to say...."Gee....That went well!".

Fortunately a Fleet Tug was in port and was able to retrieve it all within a few days.

RatherBeFlying 9th Feb 2023 17:26

Inspected by U2
 
It's reported that a U2 did a flyby and likely took pictures from the cockpit as the reconnaissance optics point at the ground.

Maybe they will fit a gun pod on the U2 so they can bring the next balloon(s) down slowly.

albatross 9th Feb 2023 17:45


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 11382930)
I recall standing on the Bridge when a vessel of the Gray Funnel Line dropped Anchor off Hong Kong.....along with every inch of the chain attached thereto......after all of the racket...smoke and dust settled and a very prolonged silence by all present.....the XO was heard to say...."Gee....That went well!".

Fortunately a Fleet Tug was in port and was able to retrieve it all within a few days.

Dark and foggy night on the Great Lakes many moons ago as told by my seafaring uncle…Ship creeps into harbour:
Capt from the bridge: “ Mate! Lower the anchor.”
Newfoundland voice: “Aye, Aye Sor.” Clank, clank, splash, clank clank clank..clank…….clank…silence.
Capt from the bridge: “Mate! Is the anchor down?”
Newfoundland voice: “Well Sor I doesn’t see it floating around anywheres!”

We had best drop the hook and stop this thread drift.
Cheers.

Obba 9th Feb 2023 17:47

Nice read:

Gen. Glen VanHerck, Commander, North American Aerospace Defense Command and United States Northern Command, Holds an Off-Camera, On-The-Record Briefing on the High-Altitude Surveillance Balloon Recovery Efforts


Gen. Glen VanHerck, Commander, North American Aerospace Defense Command and United States Northern Command, Holds an Off-Camera, On-The-Record Briefing on the High-Altitude Surveillance Balloon Recovery Efforts > U.S. Department of Defense > Transcript

Asturias56 10th Feb 2023 08:37

"an Off-Camera, On-The-Record Briefing"


I presume he was inappropriately dressed?

jolihokistix 10th Feb 2023 08:59

Meanwhile people are starting to ask questions here about past balloons hovering over Japan, and why they were not taken seriously.

Also, would the government feel legally able to make a decision to pop one, and would the armed forces even be able to perform such a feat with present equipment.

It has been noted that PLAAF pilots have practiced just such a scenario, i.e. shooting down high-altitude enemy ‘weather’ balloons.

212man 10th Feb 2023 14:11

https://www.aerosociety.com/news/chi...7J33UC,6VL8F,1

As expected really, but why let facts get in the way of a good story!

Lonewolf_50 10th Feb 2023 15:01

Not only are they sending spy balloons over America, they are attacking Hawaii with space lasers! :eek:
(Please enjoy the read at the link)
Spoiler
 


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:45.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.