PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Heads Up! Fighter Pilot: The Real Top Gun (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/624763-heads-up-fighter-pilot-real-top-gun.html)

Warmtoast 20th Aug 2019 11:21

Heads Up! Fighter Pilot: The Real Top Gun
 
Fighter Pilot: The Real Top Gun - 9pm, ITV 20th August


In the first of an exciting three-part documentary, clever camerawork and commentary relayed from in-helmet microphones combine to capture the thrills and drills of the cockpit. Three trainees at Britain’s elite fighter pilot school (including the establishment’s only female student) graduate from propeller planes to learning how to fly the F35 Lightning II, the RAF’s most advanced jet fighter, in a tough competition that involves dizzying rolls, whiplash 4G turns and hair-raising “treecutters”. And, yes, they really do quote Top Gun to each other
.

SASless 20th Aug 2019 14:11

Sounds like all the limbs on the family tree are right up there at the tip top of the stalk.

I would have thought there might be some sort of Joint Training with other F-35 users with far more experience in the aircraft.

MPN11 20th Aug 2019 14:51

Popcorn Time on ITV - 20/8/19
 
New: Fighter Pilot: The Real Top Gun

ITV (Channel 3 if you prefer), 2100-2200


This three-part documentary series spends a year inside Britain's elite Fighter Pilot School, following three recruits as they compete to become the best of the best. Ep1

charliegolf 20th Aug 2019 15:27

What's a tree cutter? In this context?

CG

unmanned_droid 20th Aug 2019 15:30

Only 4G?

UD

MPN11 20th Aug 2019 15:41

My popcorn is loaded, and we will both be glued to the small screen. Sick-bags also available if needed. ;)

MG 20th Aug 2019 20:12

Ten minutes in and I’m finding it quite painful. Plenty of whooping and hollering.

MaxR 20th Aug 2019 20:14

And calling instructors "mate" - when did that happen? Don't answer that, I'm old, I'm very old, I can tell that by how young they look. I don't even recognise the flying suits any more.

tubby linton 20th Aug 2019 20:15

Is it the same production team as the easyjet series? I felt embarrassed watching the latter and this one seems to have shared a few of its let's try and be cool cutaways.

ExAscoteer 20th Aug 2019 20:20

4G? Four ******* G? Christ on a bike, JP5A was 5.5G without a bloody G Suit!

MG 20th Aug 2019 20:38

Nope, given up after 30 minutes.

I realise that I’m not the target audience, but it seemed disjointed and far, far too much faux jeopardy. And when did formation turn calls go all Red Arrowey? Horrible.

Time for my Horlicks and bed!

MaxR 20th Aug 2019 20:54

You missed the line "strong winds could blow him off". I might be old but that doesn't mean I've grown up.

MG 20th Aug 2019 21:00

If I’d have known that it was full of smutty innuendo, I’d have stuck with it! Sadly, I suspect that it was said with an entirely straight face.

.....and lots of annoying music.

Timelord 20th Aug 2019 21:02


Originally Posted by MG (Post 10550143)
If I’d have known that it was full of smutty innuendo, I’d have stuck with it! Sadly, I suspect that it was said with an entirely straight face.

.....and lots of annoying music.

Well, it was Miss Moneypenny so it probably was innuendo!

Lima Juliet 20th Aug 2019 21:02

I quite enjoyed it actually - well done to Puppy and Butch and their respective teams. :ok::ok:

The narrator was also Moneypenny, if I’m not mistaken? Which links in nicely to the name of the new Bond film - No Time To Die... sounds like my RAF career so far! :p

sharpend 20th Aug 2019 21:05

Just watched it. As an ex TWU instructor (1980 - 83) I was amazed how much has changed. Not for the better. For a student to state 'I have a problem with authority' to calling the instructor 'mate'. My mind boggles. I suppose it is all part of the nice 'touchy feely' modern armed forces. And don't they carry maps anymore?

H Peacock 20th Aug 2019 21:06

Hmmm

Sedge - get a bloody haircut!

Doesn't the Hawk T2 look just stoopid taxing with its canopy open!

EXFIN 20th Aug 2019 21:13

Well, an Instructor saying ‘sweet’ was different. However, in his defence if when I went through Brawdy in the mid ‘80’s an Instructor had said ‘jolly good show bloggs’ I might have thought ‘that’s different’! Times change!

AR1 20th Aug 2019 21:15

Enjoyed it oneself. One thing stuck out. They played hovering like at never been done before and no mention of the "H" word.

Odanrot 20th Aug 2019 21:36

Mmmmmmm? Don’t post too much, normally wait for Beagle to tell me what I think.

Having been a stude, instructor and standards Flt Cdr at Valley, as well as spending my RAF life shifting soil I think I have some problems with what I have just watched.

I did a lot the flying for the first series back in the 80s and saw first hand how, if the story wasn’t going the way the director wanted it to go then problems ensued. Generally the RAF won the argument and “ W....k..s did not fly on your wings.” (Well done Dan)

Now, is this “Mate, touchy-feely, everybody’s name ends in “ers” bollocks for real?

This lot worried me, maybe because I’m old, but being in the front seat, now only seat, of a fast-jet hasn’t changed, less knobs and tits but with computers that talk back. However, personally, an airliner on the RT never added any stress to an IP to Tgt run. The only saving grace was when the F35 said NO and the fix was the same one I used this IPAD, switch it off, kick the s...t out of it and turn it back on.

Something has changed and IMHO not for the better.

Hope I’m wrong



Specaircrew 20th Aug 2019 21:54

As an ex graduate of No 1(Hunter) Cse I found myself reminiscing about those halcyon days of my youth. Drunken Sundays at the 'Sandymount Club' at Rhosneigr, paddling across the lake on a Sabre drop tank etc. Not sure that I remember being distracted by ATC on an IP to Tgt run or calling my instructor mate though!

The F35 stuff was interesting, I'm ex 617 too! Hopefully it'll encourage a few more millennials to give it a go......even if they do think 4G is 'awesome' !

Lima Juliet 20th Aug 2019 22:46


https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....137c425dd5.gif
Good grief...PPruNe really is the home of old fossils...

Tankertrashnav 20th Aug 2019 23:48


4G? Four ******* G? Christ on a bike, JP5A was 5.5G without a bloody G Suit!
I'm only an ex nav so what do I know but I certainly remember 6g in a JP5 when doing a low level nav course at Linton (sans G suit). As for calling your instructor "mate"!!! :*

TTN (proud to be an old fossil ;))

just another jocky 21st Aug 2019 05:10


Originally Posted by Lima Juliet (Post 10550201)

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....137c425dd5.gif
Good grief...PPruNe really is the home of old fossils...

Thank goodness none of us still serving care what they think of us.

4everAD 21st Aug 2019 06:04

So can Pruners tell m e what they expect the students to call the instructor? They were both equivalent ranks (OF2) and no doubt got on well from the bits I saw, It certainly doesn't call for a sir, maybe staff?

Bob Viking 21st Aug 2019 06:13

ITV Series
 
I haven’t seen it (and I’m not in it) so can’t and won’t comment on its content.

What strikes me as funny though is that the series that was made in the 1980s attracts much comment on how bad the instruction was (also never seen it so can’t comment). It also led to adverse affects for some of its participants. The new series has already attracted comment for how it is not like the good old days.

So my question is, are some people ever going to be happy with any documentary? Also, when exactly were the good old days? And if people don’t like what’s on show now, didn’t like what was on show 35 years ago when exactly was instruction to their liking?

Would I be right in thinking that, since this is a documentary for the masses and probably to aid recruitment, it is not targeted at long retired RAF members?

Yes I have opened myself up to yet more criticism from the usual suspects. I am beginning to care less and less though.

BV

[email protected] 21st Aug 2019 06:29

Is it me or is the course size really small nowadays - is this a MFTS thing or were they just cherry-picking the most media-friendly students?

Bleating Betty seems a big distraction at low level - isn't there an audio inhibit?

Nice to see the progress made with the F35. Harrier mates used to do a hovering course at Shawbury before the OCU, does this happen for the F 35?

Overall - some cringy bits and some good bits (the flying)

Lima Juliet 21st Aug 2019 06:42

Before this descends into Monty Python’s Yorkshireman Sketch of “Luxury...we had it tough...”

Let’s answer some of the ‘outrage bus’ questions.

1. The 4g to 5g sortie was a famil trip - no point in pulling the wings off of the jet, it’s there to familiarise the student in the aircraft before the harder stuff starts (ie. to ease them in).
2. Where are the maps and charts? You will have seen the Mission Planning Aid in the TV programme and oddly enough we plan electronically these days - colour printed maps and IP/Tgt runs are still carried in case the kit stops playing.
3. 6g in a JP? Really? I don’t recall more than 5g for most of my JP flying.
4. Calling instructors ‘Sir’ on Advanced Jet Training (AJT) - this is equivalent of a little bit of the old AFT and TWU - I don’t recall calling my instructors “Sir” on TWU or even on 4FTS. So I suspect that some folks’ memories are playing tricks on them, as I can’t recall calling any of my instructors “Sir”, unless a Sqn Ldr/Wg Cdr/Gp Capt, and I have been flying in the RAF for 30 years.

So how about looking at the positive stuff - we still have a fast jet flying training system that other countries pay good money to use, we now have a far lower ‘chop’ rate as we actually teach and test these days, it is a far healthier learning environment, we have a modernised trg aircraft that now reflects the FL type they will go to (with airborne electronic threat simulation that instructor can bring up during the sortie), we now have a fast jet trainer with a basic collision warning system and the aircraft that we are training them to fly on the FL are far more capable than any than went before - 9g Typhoons and 5th generation F35s. So let’s just enjoy the filming and the insight to a trg system that is vastly different to even the one 15 years ago. The only real criticism I have over this trg system is the fact that we didn’t plan enough capacity in it from SDSR10/SDSR15 and so now we have too little capacity/aircraft for what we really need.

Finally, the young men and women that will be the future of the RAF and FAA are still very fine individuals indeed - there are still very few “w**k*rs on your wing” - probably as many, by percentage, as there ever were. It’s just that this new breed are culturally different, but underneath they still have what it takes to do what is asked of them.

Bob Viking 21st Aug 2019 06:51

LJ
 
Great post. I must go flying now. Toodle pip.

BV

Specaircrew 21st Aug 2019 07:24


Originally Posted by just another jocky (Post 10550330)
Thank goodness none of us still serving care what they think of us.

So....are you like.....disrespecting us? Hashtag Ageist Hashtag Weeandbiscuits ;-)

Hamish 123 21st Aug 2019 07:31

NINE years into an RAF career before you even got into a Hawk??? I'm assuming the pilot quoted hadn't switched branches either. Is that length of time typical these days? 10+ years before you're combat ready?

sharpend 21st Aug 2019 08:09

Lima Juliet, Well maybe we are a bunch of old fogies, but personally I have found a sea-change in attitudes over the years caused by lack of discipline & respect for authority/elders, all across the whole spectrum of society. . The whole point of the armed forces is to fight and that means sometimes telling soldiers to do unpleasant things. Without discipline and respect for authority (one of these students said he had a problem with authority; FFS), soldiers will do as they please. Sadly, we are in a touchy-feely society today; drill Sgts cannot shout as students etc etc. I could go on mentioning the softening of rules etc... but ultimately the RAF is a fighting force; disciple, respect and standards are vital. But what do I know, I'm just an old fogie.

muppetofthenorth 21st Aug 2019 08:19


Originally Posted by sharpend (Post 10550442)
Lima Juliet, Well maybe we are a bunch of old fogies, but personally I have found a sea-change in attitudes over the years caused by lack of discipline & respect for authority/elders, all across the whole spectrum of society. . The whole point of the armed forces is to fight and that means sometimes telling soldiers to do unpleasant things. Without discipline and respect for authority (one of these students said he had a problem with authority; FFS), soldiers will do as they please. Sadly, we are in a touchy-feely society today; drill Sgts cannot shout as students etc etc. I could go on mentioning the softening of rules etc... but ultimately the RAF is a fighting force; disciple, respect and standards are vital. But what do I know, I'm just an old fogie.

Society is shaped by the people in it.
The people you bemoan are the ones your generation created. So who's to blame?

sharpend 21st Aug 2019 08:24


Originally Posted by muppetofthenorth (Post 10550450)
Society is shaped by the people in it.
The people you bemoan are the ones your generation created. So who's to blame?


Not me personally. This generation is shaped by the media, the internet and social media.

Asturias56 21st Aug 2019 08:25

"drill Sgts cannot shout at students " ... and you wonder why no-one wants to join up

these days you EXPLAIN what you want and why and hope the trainees will use their intelligence to achieve the results - in fact that approach often leads to better outcomes as they can adapt to changes in circumstances rather than blindly "Obey orders" or freeze and have to call back in for new instructions

The days of blind obedience are long gone

Nige321 21st Aug 2019 08:51


Originally Posted by sharpend (Post 10550442)
Lima Juliet, Well maybe we are a bunch of old fogies, but personally I have found a sea-change in attitudes over the years caused by lack of discipline & respect for authority/elders, all across the whole spectrum of society. . The whole point of the armed forces is to fight and that means sometimes telling soldiers to do unpleasant things. Without discipline and respect for authority (one of these students said he had a problem with authority; FFS), soldiers will do as they please. Sadly, we are in a touchy-feely society today; drill Sgts cannot shout as students etc etc. I could go on mentioning the softening of rules etc... but ultimately the RAF is a fighting force; disciple, respect and standards are vital. But what do I know, I'm just an old fogie.

Judging by Channel 5's recent documentarys on the Household Cavalry and the Paras, I'd say that's completely wrong...

Stuff 21st Aug 2019 09:14


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10550369)
Harrier mates used to do a hovering course at Shawbury before the OCU, does this happen for the F 35?

The Harrier hover course was highly entertaining but of fairly questionable value. For a start the cyclic operates in the opposite sense to the throttle (pull for up vs push for up). Much of the requirement for the Shawbury hours came from the Harrier sim's low-fidelity visuals and lag from the eye tracker. I would assume, but I don't know, that the F35 sim should be able to display everything needed for hover training, obviating the need to use a helicopter.

Tankertrashnav 21st Aug 2019 09:26


The days of blind obedience are long gone
Instant obedience has a purpose. Father in law, a REME staff sergeant, was pinned down by sniper fire in Normandy when his team were attempting a tank recovery. His corporal thought he would pop up and have a look and try and locate the sniper. FIL shouted to the corporal to get his head down. "Hang on staff, I think I can see the bugger --- bang. Corporal no longer had much of a head to get down. Shame FIL didn't have time to give the corporal detailed reasoning for his order!

Toadstool 21st Aug 2019 09:34


Originally Posted by sharpend (Post 10550442)
Lima Juliet, Well maybe we are a bunch of old fogies, but personally I have found a sea-change in attitudes over the years caused by lack of discipline & respect for authority/elders, all across the whole spectrum of society. . The whole point of the armed forces is to fight and that means sometimes telling soldiers to do unpleasant things. Without discipline and respect for authority (one of these students said he had a problem with authority; FFS), soldiers will do as they please. Sadly, we are in a touchy-feely society today; drill Sgts cannot shout as students etc etc. I could go on mentioning the softening of rules etc... but ultimately the RAF is a fighting force; disciple, respect and standards are vital. But what do I know, I'm just an old fogie.

The whole point of the armed forces is to fight and that means sometimes telling soldiers to do unpleasant things - Still happens

Without discipline and respect for authority (one of these students said he had a problem with authority; FFS), soldiers will do as they please - Soldiers and Airmen will still do as they please when they please, should they be so inclined, as they used to do when I first joined up in the 80s. Soldiers and Airmen still have respect and discipline now, as I can attest to on a daily basis.

Sadly, we are in a touchy-feely society today; drill Sgts cannot shout as students etc etc - Yes they can and yes they do. Perhaps things are slightly different, but its called Emotional Intelligence. Times change.

ultimately the RAF is a fighting force; disciple, respect and standards are vital. - Op TELIC, Op Herrick, Op Ellamy and Op SHADER proved the RAF was a fighting force and still is. If you remember AP 1, Respect, Integrity, Service and Excellence is still extant.

Happy to discuss via PM.

Regards

Timelord 21st Aug 2019 09:41

Had to laugh though when Bally couldn’t log into his jet. Who controls that database I wonder?
“You want me on the boat over Christmas? Not if you ever want your jet to start again”

I bet when the instructor asked the cameras to leave he gave Bally his own log in!


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:57.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.