Ukraine War Thread Part 2

Joined: Jul 2003
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 977
Likes: 121
From: Oz
It seems that the russians have effectively no air defence detection capability accross Russia and they could not detect a C172 sized aircraft.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.

Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 1,980
Likes: 636
From: Outer ring of HEL
It seems that the russians have effectively no air defence detection capability accross Russia and they could not detect a C172 sized aircraft.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.



Joined: Nov 2011
Aviation Qualifications: SLF
Posts: 2,881
Likes: 516
From: Japan
It seems that the russians have effectively no air defence detection capability accross Russia and they could not detect a C172 sized aircraft.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.
(As long as they are not damp.)
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...

Joined: Jul 2000
Aviation Qualifications: Spotter
Posts: 24,684
Likes: 7,368
From: Peripatetic
and crew those with al-qaeda ISIS supporters, maybe?
Here's one they did years ago.....



Joined: Apr 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Spotter
Posts: 1,505
Likes: 540
From: Rhone-Alpes


Joined: Dec 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Non-Aircrew
Posts: 1,583
Likes: 1,389
From: Over the rainbow
Trying to fly a big aircraft by remote is problematic due to the size. Lag is the problem which is why the above aircraft missed it's marks. The crash was a fail as were other remote airliner style crashes.
Small aircraft are more nimble and can be placed on target a lot easier. Also r/c is not drone tech. Drones are autonomous.
Small aircraft are more nimble and can be placed on target a lot easier. Also r/c is not drone tech. Drones are autonomous.


Joined: Jan 2019
Aviation Qualifications: LAME
Posts: 806
Likes: 645
From: Cumbria
Regardles of the technical challenges, I think part of the problem with a potential 7-drone-7 would be the PR fallout from mis-targetting. At the moment Russia, and to a lesser extent Ukraine, are suffering a percentage of missiles/artillery/bombs which are striking civiian buildings, whether due to inadequate care in targetting, deliberate intent, or premature encounters with air-defences.
However tragic the consequences for civilians receiving an unexpected Kinzhal, the outrage rarely persists in public consciousness beyond a day or 2. The image of a flak-damaged, explosive-laden, airliner flying into a high-rise however is going to remain like, well, you know .....
However tragic the consequences for civilians receiving an unexpected Kinzhal, the outrage rarely persists in public consciousness beyond a day or 2. The image of a flak-damaged, explosive-laden, airliner flying into a high-rise however is going to remain like, well, you know .....



Joined: Nov 2011
Aviation Qualifications: SLF
Posts: 2,881
Likes: 516
From: Japan
The Russians know that destroyed railway lines can be more quickly repaired on solid land as opposed to on a bridge, which is why they are pressing ahead with the rail network throughout their newly-established land bridge joining mother Russia through Mariupol, around the Azov Sea to Crimea.



Joined: Apr 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Spotter
Posts: 1,505
Likes: 540
From: Rhone-Alpes
I am not suggesting they should not take down the bridge, but that it may end up being more of a symbolic act, and a personal affront to Mr P.
The Russians know that destroyed railway lines can be more quickly repaired on solid land as opposed to on a bridge, which is why they are pressing ahead with the rail network throughout their newly-established land bridge joining mother Russia through Mariupol, around the Azov Sea to Crimea.
The Russians know that destroyed railway lines can be more quickly repaired on solid land as opposed to on a bridge, which is why they are pressing ahead with the rail network throughout their newly-established land bridge joining mother Russia through Mariupol, around the Azov Sea to Crimea.


Joined: Dec 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Non-Aircrew
Posts: 1,583
Likes: 1,389
From: Over the rainbow
Regardles of the technical challenges, I think part of the problem with a potential 7-drone-7 would be the PR fallout from mis-targetting. At the moment Russia, and to a lesser extent Ukraine, are suffering a percentage of missiles/artillery/bombs which are striking civiian buildings, whether due to inadequate care in targetting, deliberate intent, or premature encounters with air-defences.
However tragic the consequences for civilians receiving an unexpected Kinzhal, the outrage rarely persists in public consciousness beyond a day or 2. The image of a flak-damaged, explosive-laden, airliner flying into a high-rise however is going to remain like, well, you know .....
However tragic the consequences for civilians receiving an unexpected Kinzhal, the outrage rarely persists in public consciousness beyond a day or 2. The image of a flak-damaged, explosive-laden, airliner flying into a high-rise however is going to remain like, well, you know .....

Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 1,980
Likes: 636
From: Outer ring of HEL
My guess is that the orcs tried to steal the bricks and the roof sheets of some garden shed. Garden shed for I can't see no toilet seat inside.

Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 1,980
Likes: 636
From: Outer ring of HEL
Zelenskyy: "Russia is planning to mobilize additional 300k troops by June 1st"
How it started: "we have 190k men and we'll take Kyiv in three days"
How it's going: "we are on our third mobilization wave with yet another 300k men to make up for the already lost 450k troops on our third year of war and aren't any closer to Kyiv than on day 1"
How it started: "we have 190k men and we'll take Kyiv in three days"
How it's going: "we are on our third mobilization wave with yet another 300k men to make up for the already lost 450k troops on our third year of war and aren't any closer to Kyiv than on day 1"

Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 760
Likes: 34
From: Rural England, thank God.
Too late for F16s?
"Despite months of preparations and training, it seems that the western-supplied F-16 fighter jets due to arrive in Ukraine in July may be ‘no longer relevant’ in the fight against Russia. Speaking on condition of anonymity to Politico, a senior Ukrainian military official dismissed the impact that the aircraft would now have on the war effort. ‘Often, we just don’t get the weapons systems at the time we need them – they come when they’re no longer relevant,’ the high-ranking official said. ‘Every weapon has its own right time. F-16s were needed in 2023; they won’t be right for 2024.’Volodymyr Zelensky first campaigned for the West to supply his country with the US-made aircraft in the summer of 2022. In what has become a regular refrain among Kyiv’s western allies, the request caused many months of hand-wringing and infighting, notably in Germany, where politicians feared that supplying the jets could lead to an escalation in the conflict. In the end, however, around 60 F-16s were pledged by Nato members, but with training timelines adding to the delays caused by the West’s initial hesitation, which is why the first aircraft will only be delivered to Ukraine this summer.
Now reliant on sourcing weapons from Iran and North Korea, as well as dipping into supplies left over from the Cold War, Russia has consistently, but successfully, been forced to play catch up to match the western weaponry Kyiv is using. As such, the Ukrainians fear that the jets may no longer be effective as Moscow has the capability to counter them. Instead, the official said what Ukraine needs are more traditional weapons and drones: ‘We need Howitzers and shells, hundreds of thousands of shells and rockets.
Russia is expected to mount a major push in the coming months ahead of a summer offensive, after a recent surge in missile and drone strikes that have targeted Ukraine’s infrastructure. Among the weapons Ukraine wants are long-range Taurus missiles, capable of striking targets 310 miles away. With the West yet to make a conclusive decision on whether to send them, Ukraine may once again find itself in a race against the clock." [Spectator today]
All that Tutor time (taken from UASs I believe) in vain?
Now reliant on sourcing weapons from Iran and North Korea, as well as dipping into supplies left over from the Cold War, Russia has consistently, but successfully, been forced to play catch up to match the western weaponry Kyiv is using. As such, the Ukrainians fear that the jets may no longer be effective as Moscow has the capability to counter them. Instead, the official said what Ukraine needs are more traditional weapons and drones: ‘We need Howitzers and shells, hundreds of thousands of shells and rockets.
Russia is expected to mount a major push in the coming months ahead of a summer offensive, after a recent surge in missile and drone strikes that have targeted Ukraine’s infrastructure. Among the weapons Ukraine wants are long-range Taurus missiles, capable of striking targets 310 miles away. With the West yet to make a conclusive decision on whether to send them, Ukraine may once again find itself in a race against the clock." [Spectator today]
All that Tutor time (taken from UASs I believe) in vain?



Joined: Apr 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Spotter
Posts: 1,505
Likes: 540
From: Rhone-Alpes
Ukraine has no missiles capable of 1 200 km , so they obviously can't run out of them. Most likely is they were able to convert this craft to carry extra fuel for the distance and then add whatever weight of explosives was still possible.

Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 138
Likes: 119
From: Off the map

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,140
Likes: 331
From: Royal Berkshire
It seems that the russians have effectively no air defence detection capability accross Russia and they could not detect a C172 sized aircraft.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.
Now imagine if the Ukrainians could take a few clapped out airliners that were heading for the scrap yard. A 737 sized airframe could easily carry 10 tons of explosives and 50,000lbs of fuel. Now that would make one helova mess it it plowed into an oil refinery. Surely 5 or 6 barely airworthy airframes could be scrapped up around the world for one final flight.


Joined: Nov 2007
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 514
Likes: 832
From: UK
This talk of airliners being used as missiles is a little like Hitler and his Wunderwaffe.
There is no need to re-invent the modern battlefield - drones are doing that with aplomb.
What Ukraine needs is for the US to sort out its Congress nonsense and provide Bradleys, MLRS, F16s, Support Helicopters and more shells than can be fit into 10 Super Container Ships.
Its all there sitting in the desert anyway.
Mix in a few dozen Taurus missiles and the expected Russian Offensive will be a dampened to a stalemate again.
If the massing of mines worked for the Russians, I hope the Ukrainians have the same response to a Russian sojourn this summer.
There is no need to re-invent the modern battlefield - drones are doing that with aplomb.
What Ukraine needs is for the US to sort out its Congress nonsense and provide Bradleys, MLRS, F16s, Support Helicopters and more shells than can be fit into 10 Super Container Ships.
Its all there sitting in the desert anyway.
Mix in a few dozen Taurus missiles and the expected Russian Offensive will be a dampened to a stalemate again.
If the massing of mines worked for the Russians, I hope the Ukrainians have the same response to a Russian sojourn this summer.

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 286
Likes: 38
From: Peterborough
Using large aircraft was tried out in WW2. It didn’t work then and killed a possible future US president, Joe P. Kennedy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite



Joined: Apr 2020
Aviation Qualifications: Spotter
Posts: 1,505
Likes: 540
From: Rhone-Alpes
Using large aircraft was tried out in WW2. It didn’t work then and killed a possible future US president, Joe P. Kennedy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Aphrodite




