Red White and Blue Voyager
Jehovah
I’m going to go against the grain on this one. Sorry.
For large aircraft I’m not sure it makes the slightest difference what colour it is unless it plans to operate in the LL environment and even then I would take some convincing it matters that much.
In these days of high fidelity radars, live satellite uplinks, targeting pods, HMCSs etc the colour of the paint isn’t going to matter at all when anyone who wishes to do you harm can either see you anyway (think large aircraft on approach and a guy with a MANPADs) or will have a targeting system that doesn’t care what colour your aircraft is.
In fact, couldn’t we actually make a better argument nowadays for high visibility paint schemes for all of our aircraft to aid with visual acquisition for safety purposes?
If an aircraft is on the ground does the colour of the paint really make it less easy to see? I mean really? Whatever colour you paint it there is no secret about the fact it is going to be parked on an airfield.
Have I just set the cat amongst the pigeons?!
BV
For large aircraft I’m not sure it makes the slightest difference what colour it is unless it plans to operate in the LL environment and even then I would take some convincing it matters that much.
In these days of high fidelity radars, live satellite uplinks, targeting pods, HMCSs etc the colour of the paint isn’t going to matter at all when anyone who wishes to do you harm can either see you anyway (think large aircraft on approach and a guy with a MANPADs) or will have a targeting system that doesn’t care what colour your aircraft is.
In fact, couldn’t we actually make a better argument nowadays for high visibility paint schemes for all of our aircraft to aid with visual acquisition for safety purposes?
If an aircraft is on the ground does the colour of the paint really make it less easy to see? I mean really? Whatever colour you paint it there is no secret about the fact it is going to be parked on an airfield.
Have I just set the cat amongst the pigeons?!
BV
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Often in Jersey, but mainly in the past.
Age: 79
Posts: 7,698
Received 102 Likes
on
48 Posts
No problem, BV ... I'm sure you're broadly correct. And I assume the black Hawks, Tucanos etc. are so painted for high-visibility reasons.
I just have an aversion to 'party' colours on military hardware! Do the Army or RN behave in that manner?
I just have an aversion to 'party' colours on military hardware! Do the Army or RN behave in that manner?
MPN11
I’m not saying I am correct but I wonder if there is an element of painting aircraft with camouflage paint schemes because we’ve always done it that way.
Our enemies know who we are and where to find us anyway so are we just making life difficult for ourselves?!
BV
Our enemies know who we are and where to find us anyway so are we just making life difficult for ourselves?!
BV
I think you make perfect sense. Everything from airliners to delivery vans carry the operators’ colours and logos so I see it as entirely proper that an aircraft representing the UK overseas does the same. The ‘camouflage’ argument is ridiculous. If an enemy is allowed to get close enough to a strategic tanker/transport to see what colour the paint is you’ve got bigger problems. This frothing about changing the colour of an aircraft comes over as a bit loony.
Also, I don't see the same toolbags getting wound up over special Sqn tails, or 50 years of Herc tails, or WW2 commemorative paint schemes.
This forum has gone to shit, like much of the rest of the internet......let's all race to the bottom.
This forum has gone to shit, like much of the rest of the internet......let's all race to the bottom.
Join Date: Jan 2019
Location: Narfalk
Posts: 392
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No problem with a decent paint scheme. However it is a Royal Air Force operated aircraft and as such should fit into the corporate theme of the organisation. Most on this thread are ultra conservative. I am like that in regards to the way RAF aircraft look for business. Wish our display aircraft had more of the creativity of other airforces, but that is a different question and matter. As long as the A330 is not a Boris 350 million to the NHS bus.
Join Date: Jan 2019
Location: Narfalk
Posts: 392
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Democrary old boy. People like you shouted loudly about it in 2016. It doesn't end because it is something you disagree with. As for the internet, the other forum you are involved in, is a race to the bottom and that is why hardly anybody looks at it. It is like the Air Mech engineers forum that gone so low, no admins at all do anything to it. I run a FB group that is strong because it is actively administered and not allowed to be taken over from what it is there for, so I disagree on "the everything on the internet". As for my comments about Boris, I am taking the mick.
Last edited by Cat Techie; 17th Jun 2020 at 12:22.
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,939
Received 1,748 Likes
on
752 Posts
In fact, couldn’t we actually make a better argument nowadays for high visibility paint schemes for all of our aircraft to aid with visual acquisition for safety purposes?
Last edited by NutLoose; 17th Jun 2020 at 12:34.
Democrary old boy. People like you shouted loudly about it in 2016. It doesn't end because it is something you disagree with. As for the internet, the other forum you are involved in, is a race to the bottom and that is why hardly anybody looks at it. It is like the Air Mech engineers forum that gone so low, no admins at all do anything to it. I run a FB group that is strong because it is actively administered and not allowed to be taken over from what it is there for, so I disagree on "the everything on the internet". As for my comments about Boris, I am taking the mick.
I'm involved in a number of forums so not sure which one you mean anyway; Ok, maybe not everything on the internet has gone to shit, but a very large chunk of it has. You have to look hard to find anything moderate and unpolarised these days.
Paxing All Over The World
I can see Bozzer, now, as he stands at the top of the steps, waving to his admirers in some sort of military style suit and a big hat with plenty of medal ribbons on it. Sadly, Boris and his Svengali will never understand that, when they rock up to a G7 wrapped in the Union flag, everyone is only going to be thinking of the rate per million of deaths from Covid-19.
As flashy aircraft are the preserve of banana republics, we now qualify.
As flashy aircraft are the preserve of banana republics, we now qualify.
Join Date: Jan 2019
Location: Narfalk
Posts: 392
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I moaned about what in 2016? You lost me there IILKC.
I'm involved in a number of forums so not sure which one you mean anyway; Ok, maybe not everything on the internet has gone to shit, but a very large chunk of it has. You have to look hard to find anything moderate and unpolarised these days.
I'm involved in a number of forums so not sure which one you mean anyway; Ok, maybe not everything on the internet has gone to shit, but a very large chunk of it has. You have to look hard to find anything moderate and unpolarised these days.
Cunning Artificer
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: The spiritual home of DeHavilland
Age: 76
Posts: 3,127
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So the spare Voyager aircraft that Air Tanker leased to Thomas Cook is now looking for a new customer. The government decides to take it on and, since it isn't required for front-line military service, they wish to replace the Thomas Cook livery with a more patriotic one for use by Royalty and government ministers - like 32 (Royal) Sqn) for instance. Hence the anti-Boris section of the population want to use it for a bit of Boris Bashing and that's only to be expected, surely? The mainstream media are certainly unlikely to broadcast anything that would calm the fuss by reporting the facts.
Whatever the colour scheme turns out to be, it's an additional bit of mission-creep with the VIP airframe, given that there was no VIP provision when the Voyager contract was completed. There's a certain inevitability about it all, but I imagine that getting the contact signed at all was something of a triumph at the time.
So the spare Voyager aircraft that Air Tanker leased to Thomas Cook is now looking for a new customer. The government decides to take it on and, since it isn't required for front-line military service, they wish to replace the Thomas Cook livery with a more patriotic one for use by Royalty and government ministers - like 32 (Royal) Sqn) for instance. Hence the anti-Boris section of the population want to use it for a bit of Boris Bashing and that's only to be expected, surely? The mainstream media are certainly unlikely to broadcast anything that would calm the fuss by reporting the facts.
I suspect that the repainting of the TC ac and the change to the VIP frame colour scheme are unrelated. The VIP ac (336) is the only one with the posh fit ,so, unless the MOD has decided to go to another expenditure of many millions, then I suspect that what is going on at Cambridge is simply the demodification from TC livery/fit -incidentaly paid for by Air Tanker.
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Great Britain
Posts: 471
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And painting it grey does that at 35,000ft? What about contrails etc?
