Army cuts - AAC going?
Preferred Marys B&B myself
If memory serves, It was Dunne's Farm, but no-one ever referred to it as such.
CG
Purveyor of Egg Liqueur to Lucifer
I'll bet CrabAir almost rubbed their hands with glee at the thought of the end of the AAC believing they'd poach Apache.
Sorry xn mate, it just ain't going to happen and while you're at it, you wont ever be getting the Harrier back either
Sid, you and the dummy have got a really peevish chip on your shoulder re the RAF; the Apache going to the RAF is a none argument invented to have a snipe at the SHF. To my mind the AH choice should have been the upgraded Cobra as chosen by the US Marines over the Apache. The greater number of cheaper airframes should have gone to the FAA as a carrier bourne asset.
Without the AH the AAC have little to offer as the Lynx and Wildcat can carry jack sh1t; it and the Merlin were nothing more than a job creation scheme for Wastelands.
Given that, how much bayonet strength could have been saved had they got rid of the AAC?
Without the AH the AAC have little to offer as the Lynx and Wildcat can carry jack sh1t; it and the Merlin were nothing more than a job creation scheme for Wastelands.
Given that, how much bayonet strength could have been saved had they got rid of the AAC?
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 785
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sid, you and the dummy have got a really peevish chip on your shoulder re the RAF
To my mind the AH choice should have been the upgraded Cobra as chosen by the US Marines over the Apache. The greater number of cheaper airframes should have gone to the FAA as a carrier bourne asset.
Without the AH the AAC have little to offer as the Lynx and Wildcat can carry jack sh1t; it and the Merlin were nothing more than a job creation scheme for Wastelands.
Given that, how much bayonet strength could have been saved had they got rid of the AAC?
At a guess, the AAC is cheaper to run than one Puma det to Morocco and it is still seen as value for money.
We currently make up about 1.9% of Army strength. Post 2020 we'll be about 2.4% of the strength so in real terms, we're still growing
Considering that the Battle of Britain was mainly won by NCO pilots flying Hurricanes (as opposed to the myth of Officers flying Spitfires) and many of the RAF heavy bombers in WW2 were flown by an entire crew of NCOs, past history would indicate that anyone in the RAF who thinks you have to be an officer to be a pilot is either severely deluded or a very senior officer (actually those two are often one and the same in my limited experience) - and that's from a still serving crab!
The all officer thing is a throw back to the age of the "deterrent".
The all officer thing is a throw back to the age of the "deterrent".
Last edited by Biggus; 6th Jul 2012 at 16:23.
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: At the bottom of our garden
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not so, WG13 Dummy, that some crabs are irked that AAC SNCO pilots do a great job flying and operating the Apache, at least not this (ex-) Brylcreem Boy.
When I was very young (when the Earth was flat and had hair) my Dad used to bounce me on his knee and tell me war stories. He used to wear a natty khaki, hairy, tickly suit, had three odd stripes on his sleeve and wore what looked like a grubby sea gull on his chest, sometimes with dangly, jangly, shiny things. When I was still an ignorant yoof he used to take me to Glider Pilot Regimental Association Meetings and we would visit a Dutch holiday resort called Arnhem. Apparently, during WW2 he had dropped in one day...As I matured the penny dropped, and I developed a profound awe for him and his SNCO colleagues. As a result of the tales of battle, of dirt, of filth, I made it my life's ambition to join the Crabs, where I could work regular hours and sleep in a proper bed. And so it was.
After many years I retired from the jolly life of a SARboy, QHI, and CFS Examiner Ne'erdowell, to find myself working on 660 Sqn DHFS for 11 years. As a result of this latter experience my profound awe developed into a sustained respect and admiration for AAC SNCO pilots, especially as I became very aware of the contribution to Apache ops that was made - and is being made - by SNCO pilots who are, in my experience, a brave and gallant lot.
Even if you are all dirty, filthy and smell of wee.
When I was very young (when the Earth was flat and had hair) my Dad used to bounce me on his knee and tell me war stories. He used to wear a natty khaki, hairy, tickly suit, had three odd stripes on his sleeve and wore what looked like a grubby sea gull on his chest, sometimes with dangly, jangly, shiny things. When I was still an ignorant yoof he used to take me to Glider Pilot Regimental Association Meetings and we would visit a Dutch holiday resort called Arnhem. Apparently, during WW2 he had dropped in one day...As I matured the penny dropped, and I developed a profound awe for him and his SNCO colleagues. As a result of the tales of battle, of dirt, of filth, I made it my life's ambition to join the Crabs, where I could work regular hours and sleep in a proper bed. And so it was.
After many years I retired from the jolly life of a SARboy, QHI, and CFS Examiner Ne'erdowell, to find myself working on 660 Sqn DHFS for 11 years. As a result of this latter experience my profound awe developed into a sustained respect and admiration for AAC SNCO pilots, especially as I became very aware of the contribution to Apache ops that was made - and is being made - by SNCO pilots who are, in my experience, a brave and gallant lot.
Even if you are all dirty, filthy and smell of wee.
Xenolith,
I wholeheartedly agree that the Cobra Venom would've been a good AH as it came neck and neck, cheek and cheek, with the Longbow, more so for CHF's purposes. I read in the concluding chapter of Hans Halbertsadt's Army Aviation (Presidio Power series pub.1989) that there were some army aviator debated that maybe they should stick on an extra engine to the Cobras ike their Flying Leatherneck counterparts.
Then again the recent Op Ellamy ops proved the Longbow is a worthy 'feet wet' asset with the UK being the first to use it from the sea. Though read in Air Forces Monthly, last month that the Dutch were starting ship trials with their D models.
Best of luck to 1 or 9 or 19with the forging ahead who knows maybe in years to come, 9 may get redeployed to Germany if the garrisons are kept there.....
Cheers
I wholeheartedly agree that the Cobra Venom would've been a good AH as it came neck and neck, cheek and cheek, with the Longbow, more so for CHF's purposes. I read in the concluding chapter of Hans Halbertsadt's Army Aviation (Presidio Power series pub.1989) that there were some army aviator debated that maybe they should stick on an extra engine to the Cobras ike their Flying Leatherneck counterparts.
Then again the recent Op Ellamy ops proved the Longbow is a worthy 'feet wet' asset with the UK being the first to use it from the sea. Though read in Air Forces Monthly, last month that the Dutch were starting ship trials with their D models.
Best of luck to 1 or 9 or 19
with the forging ahead who knows maybe in years to come, 9 may get redeployed to Germany if the garrisons are kept there.....Cheers
Dummy
Uncalled for and just plain rude. Based on what you say should I assume that the AAC are a bunch of uncouth louts?
I’m afraid that my only experience of that is ‘Lynx 5 ‘ in NI; from that perspective your statement is totally without foundation.
There is bound to be extra cost involved but I have long believed that it is worth it, in the long term, to keep the FAA viable, as they do actually deliver a quantifiable benefit and do it well.
Nonsense! Stop guessing it makes you appear to be crass.
Perhaps if you considered quality rather than quantity, you may achieve a tad more clarity in your overall view.
Biggus
The RAF are not the only part of the British military that recruit officer only pilots. Apart from that issue your point has merit.
No chip. Just think that on the whole, crabs are a bunch of self serving cnuts.
The Lynx (more specifically the crews) has and is being used as a tac platform, C&C and as fire support as opposed to a 'troop carrier'
The argument would be similar to that raging re the Merlin going to CHF. 'It'll cost more to give it to the navy!!! etc etc'. Would it?
At a guess, the AAC is cheaper to run than one Puma det to Morocco and it is still seen as value for money.
We currently make up about 1.9% of Army strength. Post 2020 we'll be about 2.4% of the strength so in real terms, we're still growing
Biggus
The RAF are not the only part of the British military that recruit officer only pilots. Apart from that issue your point has merit.
Last edited by xenolith; 6th Jul 2012 at 16:55.
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 785
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not uncouth, just straight to the point. Sorry if it offended your Grantham Poly educated fragility...
Depends what era you witnessed Lynx 5. If it was in the latter stages of Op Banner then your comment is relevant. If was from an earlier period then maybe you were one of the crabs who felt aggrieved at a Sgt Pilot being Mission Commander/Aviation Commander of 2-4 Lynx, Gazelle, Wessex and Puma in South Armagh? Why do you think GOC NI wanted it that way?.....Because he knew his AAC chaps could do the tactical command bit and not just support the blokes on the ground but be an intrinsic part of the operation? Same can be said of current ops.
...clean up in aisle 1.....
I’m afraid that my only experience of that is ‘Lynx 5 ‘ in NI; from that perspective your statement is totally without foundation.
Nonsense! Stop guessing it makes you appear to be crass.
Ahhh Dum Dum, I fear that as you can offer little more than discourteous rhetoric our discourse is at an end but feel free to have the last word.
That said, if you are still ‘operational’ and due to go into harm’s way anytime soon I wish you a safe journey and speedy return to your loved ones. Little could diminish the respect I hold for what you do.
Lynx effect, well put
Just been to happy hour perchance?
That said, if you are still ‘operational’ and due to go into harm’s way anytime soon I wish you a safe journey and speedy return to your loved ones. Little could diminish the respect I hold for what you do.
Lynx effect, well put
Just been to happy hour perchance?
Last edited by xenolith; 6th Jul 2012 at 20:13. Reason: just spotted Lynx E's drivel.
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: S England
Age: 54
Posts: 320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Biggus
The RAF are not the only part of the British military that recruit officer only pilots. Apart from that issue your point has merit.
The RAF are not the only part of the British military that recruit officer only pilots. Apart from that issue your point has merit.
Every day an education!!
Chicken Leg,
Do grow up. Kindly tell all the descendants of the following
List of Victoria Cross recipients of the Royal Air Force - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
that their illustrious ancestors weren't in the military.....
Don't tell me, it was banter....
Do grow up. Kindly tell all the descendants of the following
List of Victoria Cross recipients of the Royal Air Force - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
that their illustrious ancestors weren't in the military.....
Don't tell me, it was banter....
At a guess, the AAC is cheaper to run than one Puma det to Morocco and it is still seen as value for money.
We currently make up about 1.9% of Army strength. Post 2020 we'll be about 2.4% of the strength so in real terms, we're still growing
We currently make up about 1.9% of Army strength. Post 2020 we'll be about 2.4% of the strength so in real terms, we're still growing
I'd love to know where the sheer venom and bile that comes from many elements of the Army towards the other service comes from. Given your parochialism and general lack of corporate knowledge of anything outside your own Regiments let alone Arms and Services (that comment from an Army instructor at Shriv) suggests it can't be based on a proper understanding or experience of working with the other services.
Nemo Me Impune Lacessit
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Derbyshire, England.
Posts: 4,094
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd love to know where the sheer venom and bile that comes from many elements of the Army towards the other service comes from.
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: London
Posts: 7,072
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
the problem is that everyone thinks they can operate aeroplanes whereas not even the Navy think they can operate tanks........................... (well in their more lucid moments anyway)
parabellum,
For I'd say, 75-80% of the Army, yes it probably is a bit strong. But there is a significant number that seem to do nothing other than taking pot shots at the RAF and generally down playing the RAF's contribution. And no, this isn't the RAF being precious or 'crying to mummy'. It's just very tedious. However, if I'm wrong, then the constant failure to learn or want to learn about anything outside of their own Regt, in some extreme cases Bn, as exemplified by some of the comments in this thread and in almost every thread on ARRSe can only be described as venom and bile. Banter is banter, but to come on PPrunE and describe the RAF as a bunch of self-serving c***s is out of order and frankly deserves such a tag.
For I'd say, 75-80% of the Army, yes it probably is a bit strong. But there is a significant number that seem to do nothing other than taking pot shots at the RAF and generally down playing the RAF's contribution. And no, this isn't the RAF being precious or 'crying to mummy'. It's just very tedious. However, if I'm wrong, then the constant failure to learn or want to learn about anything outside of their own Regt, in some extreme cases Bn, as exemplified by some of the comments in this thread and in almost every thread on ARRSe can only be described as venom and bile. Banter is banter, but to come on PPrunE and describe the RAF as a bunch of self-serving c***s is out of order and frankly deserves such a tag.
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Desert mainly, occasionally arctic and rarely jungle
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Strangely enough I've never had any complaints from the limbless army lads I, and many of my colleagues, have pulled out under heavy fire. Must be another Air Force he's talking about??
Really very sad that a small minority of AAC undermine the credibility of their organisation with such puerile and ill-informed opinion.
Really very sad that a small minority of AAC undermine the credibility of their organisation with such puerile and ill-informed opinion.