PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Biz Jets, Ag Flying, GA etc. (https://www.pprune.org/biz-jets-ag-flying-ga-etc-36/)
-   -   Citation 750 down in Egelsbach. (https://www.pprune.org/biz-jets-ag-flying-ga-etc/478763-citation-750-down-egelsbach.html)

Denti 2nd Mar 2012 08:12

We were going into frankfurt last night and low vis procedures were in force. Wonder how one can fly VFR in those conditions.

aviamark 2nd Mar 2012 08:30


Marginal VFR turned out to be a few minutes later to be IFR...
Just a few minutes after the crash weather in EDDF was following

METAR EDDF 011920Z 02005KT 0400 R07R/0750VP2000D R07C/0700V1600D R07L/1100VP2000D FG BKN001 07/07 Q1025 NOSIG=

Maybe there was some fog around at the accidentplace which was not taken into account by the
AUTO Metar from Egelsbach...

I had been do EDFE several times, tough thing to get an X in there on 1400m - again under
these conditions. Citation X minimum landing distance 1000m. EDFE LDA on 27 1166m

LINK: Area Chart EDFE, to illustrate the position of EDFE an EDDF...

http://www.egelsbach-airport.com/_img/aip/dfs_07.jpg

While I never want to criticize colleagues, this approach under these met conditions seems
to me a bit useless as you have Frankfurt a few miles to the west which has all IFR approaches
you can dream about... CAT III was in prorgess there.

My condolences to the familys who beareved. Very sad!

Liftboy 2nd Mar 2012 08:31

At least three dead in light aircraft crash - The Local

what next 2nd Mar 2012 08:36


EDDF is really close by, 15 minutes drive
Yes. But have you tried to get an airport slot there recently? On short notice maybe? At seven in the evening on a weekday? In a private aircraft?

jetopa 2nd Mar 2012 08:59

Why on earth would anyone fly to EDFE with a C750? :ugh:

jetopa 2nd Mar 2012 09:16


Yes. But have you tried to get an airport slot there recently? On short notice maybe? At seven in the evening on a weekday? In a private aircraft?
Sad but true, unfortunately. And the bad news is: it ain't going to improve in either EDDM or the new Berlin airport when they close down EDDT.

But should that motivate one to seriously consider EDFE in a C750? Definitely not the right airplane for that airfield. :ugh:

172driver 2nd Mar 2012 09:26

crew?
 
Anyone got any info re the crew? I have a very unpleasant nagging feeling....

:(

All-Ex 2nd Mar 2012 10:07

EDDF is too crowded and EDFE is only 10 km away from EDDF.

To install ILS the runway has to be extended by 270 meters (currently 1,400-by-25-metre)

Denti 2nd Mar 2012 10:53

An ILS can't even then be installed as EDDF is too close and there is no space to legally design IFR procedures to EDFE until a few rules are changed.

Anyway, with the weather during the time of accident (EDFE 011750Z AUTO 03003KT //// // /// 08/07 Q1025) it wasn't even good enough for a CAT I ILS, nevermind RNAV or other IFR procedures. And to fly VFR in that kind of weather, well....

ZeeDoktor 2nd Mar 2012 11:20

First hull loss of a 750, let's hope they didn't die for a stupid reason like some in this thread suggest (IFR -> VFR transition in insufficient conditions).

captjns 2nd Mar 2012 11:22


EDFE 011820Z AUTO 06002KT //// R27/P2000N // /// 08/08 Q1025 [18:20 UTC / 19:20 LT: Automated weather report: Wind 060 degrees at 2 knots; Runway 27, touchdown zone visual range is more than 2000 meters; temperature 8°C, dew point 8°C; QNH 1025 mb]
What are the minima for a non precision approach?

what next 2nd Mar 2012 11:40


What are the minima for a non precision approach?
Depends on a lot of factors. In Egelsbach they probably would be very close to the german VFR minima in class G airspace under which they very operating anyway: 1500m visibility, clear of clouds and not below 500ft GND unless taking off or landing.

The slashes in the Metar replacing the values for visibility and clouds stand for "cannot be determined" which can mean anything. We will have to wait for reports from other pilots and witnesses on the ground what the met conditions were like at the time of the accident.

20milesout 2nd Mar 2012 11:42

captjns:
What are the minima for a non precision approach?

There is no instrument approach in Egelsbach, therefore VFR apply here (NVFR, that is)

Denti 2nd Mar 2012 12:07

Well, EDDF right next to EDFE had at least for some time low vis procedures in progress yesterday evening. The weather in quite a few areas in western germany was pretty unpleasant, very low ceiling if any, heavy mist or fog and so on.

Hotel Tango 2nd Mar 2012 12:38

Will this turn out to be yet another pressonilitis in marginal weather (due to commercial pressures) accident?

threemiles 2nd Mar 2012 12:52


Yes. But have you tried to get an airport slot there recently? On short notice maybe? At seven in the evening on a weekday? In a private aircraft?
Things have changed. There is plenty of landing runway capacity in EDDF these days.


But should that motivate one to seriously consider EDFE in a C750? Definitely not the right airplane for that airfield.
The airfield is owned by Netjets and is promoted for exactly this purpose.

yron 2nd Mar 2012 14:42

Commercial with N registration ? or Private without AOC it wa limit with C525 , it 's a litle bit crazy no??:sad:

20milesout 2nd Mar 2012 16:41

Gettheritis?
 
Going around @ Egelsbach is no fun at all, especially not in a Citation. Remember: you had cancelled IFR prior to landing, and Langen Radar has long forgotten about you. Now you find yourself caught in a small cage of airspace, max altitude 1.500ft. (3.500ft, respectively) with only Egelsbach Info, and the big jets lingering only 2000ft. above you.

What do you do?

-Circle and wait for the wx to approve?

-Divert, including a huge workload with Langen Radar, and all the :mad: trouble after landing, because your company/boss/passengers won´t be amused?

-Close you eyes, pray, and try to make it anyway?

WestWind1950 2nd Mar 2012 16:43

not pretty....

Edit: photos removed...too many peeps reading too much into them, besides the press offers more


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:41.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.