PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   Name that Flying Machine (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/626547-name-flying-machine.html)

PPRuNe Towers 25th Nov 2020 17:21

Don't turn into the over enthusiastic hair trigger posters on this thread. 24 hour rule and same for clues.

Rob

ea200 25th Nov 2020 17:28

Sorry Rob, I forgot all about that. I have deleted my post.

Self loading bear 25th Nov 2020 20:52


Originally Posted by PPRuNe Towers (Post 10934631)
Don't turn into the over enthusiastic hair trigger posters on this thread. 24 hour rule and same for clues.

Rob

Rob,
Thank you for your message which clarifies a lot.
I understand you have been triggered by the 21 minute response of Fauteuil.
That was indeed quite fast.

Officially the 24 hour rule was lifted by the Mods some months ago.
I understand it is again in force.
I agree with your intention that this should be an international thread in which pprunes from all time zones should be enabled to contribute.

In the last month I personally have PMed one or two Quick contributors to warn them not to spoil the search for others. In these threads one does not get points for the quickest answer.
Each should obtain ones satisfaction by solving the mystery themselves.
If the challenge is so easy that one can answer it quickly, the satisfaction must also be less?
I leave those challenges for others to ponder over as they apparently have not fully understood the clues.

If you feel the urge to post a lot of challenges yourself, you do not have to answer quickly because there are lots of opportunities to post at Open House.

Quick answering and then declare Open House certainly does not help anyone.

Long time contributors will see that I learned some things myself and I apologize for having sinned.

Rob, via PMs I know Fauteuil has understood this.
I think your post above would have been enough warning.
Blocking without warning or clarification will not reach your goal.
I hope you are willing to end the blocking soon?

ea200 25th Nov 2020 23:25

24 hours have passed so I'll have another (same) go. It looks like it might be a Curtiss model D?

Senior Pilot 26th Nov 2020 00:05


Originally Posted by ea200 (Post 10934816)
24 hours have passed so I'll have another (same) go.

To repeat the discussions from earlier this year; the 24 hour rule applies to a new challenge, not to posts answering an existing challenge. The three threads were becoming a spotters game dominated by some UK based members who would turn over sometimes 3 or 4 challenges in a day, off-putting for other PPRuNers around the world.

Thanks

Self loading bear 26th Nov 2020 12:48


Originally Posted by ea200 (Post 10934816)
24 hours have passed so I'll have another (same) go. It looks like it might be a Curtiss model D?

Not Curtiss D, but there is a connection.

Asturias56 27th Nov 2020 08:58

"Each should obtain ones satisfaction by solving the mystery themselves. If the challenge is so easy that one can answer it quickly, the satisfaction must also be less?
I leave those challenges for others to ponder over as they apparently have not fully understood the clues."

beautifully put Bear - its the chase that is the thing on these challenges

Self loading bear 27th Nov 2020 17:13

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....07e166d9b.jpeg

Does this help anyone a bit further?

sycamore 27th Nov 2020 19:11

Baldwin, Bell, McCurdy, Curtiss, Selfridge ,`June Bug`....1911

OH if correct...

and I have flown something similar from the same era...much respect to those pioneers....

Self loading bear 27th Nov 2020 20:12

Yes, the June bug.
Flown by Curtiss as being member of the Aerial Experiment Association.
The prints are from the patent application.
On this Graham Alexander Bell was the first
OH called


https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....3748edbe9.jpeg

Self loading bear 1st Dec 2020 18:16


Originally Posted by sycamore (Post 10935952)
...

and I have flown something similar from the same era...much respect to those pioneers....

While we await the next challenge, could you share your experience?

sycamore 3rd Dec 2020 09:41

SLB, I used to fly /display aircraft of the Shuttleworth Collection between 1974-2000 and flew a lot of aircraft of the Collection,but not all,but I did fly the Bristol Boxkite and the Avro Triplane..It would take me from now to Christmas to `write it up`,as I am only competent at 1-finger typing,however ,there is/was a book written`From Bleriot to Spitfire`,which describes the aircraft characteristics in great detail by Neil Williams...It may be still on sale direct from the SC,or by the `riverside`place...Xmas present...? or maybe someone on here could copy+paste it here...To give a flavour,imagine you really are in a `Fauteil Volant` flying over the countryside at between 20 -45 knots........wind whistling up your trousers,flies in the teeth,deafened by having to run the engine,behind you at max RPM,holding on to a broomstick control column with 2 hands,with minimum lateral and longitudinal stability,marginal directional stability,knowing ,if the engine quits,if you look down between your knees,that will be where you are going to end up.......what a great way to enjoy a calm Summers evening...Great fun...!!!

If you watch a video of a modern `canard equipped` fighter on an approach,or manoeuvring ,you`ll notice the `canard` is working overtime,all by FBW and computers,probably 3,...we did that in the Boxkite.....!!just `by wires,and no computer.....

taken me 45 mins.to write that.....

teusje 6th Dec 2020 20:25

Let's try this one

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8a2bd4ac92.jpg

Asturias56 7th Dec 2020 11:13

Countryside look European but blue & white often means Argentina....... lets ask if it's European?

sycamore 7th Dec 2020 12:38

Looks very much like a jUNGMANN with a makeover; Walter/Avia M -37 motor/prop,Cessna gear,revised struts,and tail off another Czech aircraft(Avia ?)......?

teusje 7th Dec 2020 16:42

Not from Europe I'm afraid. Or Argentina.
The engine is indeed a Walter.

India Four Two 7th Dec 2020 19:33

The interplane struts are very Pitts-like. Any connection?

sycamore 7th Dec 2020 21:17

How about the rest of `the Americas,Canada,USA,or S America.....?

Asturias56 8th Dec 2020 17:23

I keep thinking I've seen this before - a little voice in my head (the one that talks sense) says its American - but what and when ????

teusje 8th Dec 2020 18:01

It's from the USA. Though there somewhat of a link to a politician from Europe.

Asturias56 9th Dec 2020 07:33

Looks like a rather neat picture - so I'd guess post-1960?

teusje 9th Dec 2020 10:58

First flight was in 1973, and still flying until at least 2016.

Asturias56 9th Dec 2020 13:16

Did they build very many???

teusje 9th Dec 2020 17:06

Just the one, actually.

Asturias56 9th Dec 2020 17:21

Ah - looking through names of US small aircraft I came across the "Merkle" - Wiki has it as the " The Merkel Mark II is an American homebuilt aerobatic biplane that was designed by Edwin Merkel and produced by the Merkel Airplane Company of Wichita, Kansas in the form of plans for amateur construction.[size=8333px] [/size]Designer Merkel died on 12 March 2012 and plans are apparently no longer available. The Mark II features a two-seats-in-tandem open cockpit with an optional bubble canopy, fixed conventional landing gear and a single engine in tractor configuration. The Mark II was intended as a two-seat trainer version as a companion to a planned single-seat competition version.[size=8333px] [/size]The aircraft is made from welded steel tubing with the airframe covered in sheet aluminum. Its 25.5 ft (7.8 m) span wings employ a NACA 23012 airfoil and each has a single torsional spar. The standard engine recommended was a 220 hp (164 kW) Franklin Engine Company powerplant.[size=8333px] [/size]The aircraft has an empty weight of 1,200 lb (540 kg) and a gross weight of 1,540 lb (700 kg), giving a useful load of 340 lb (150 kg). With full fuel of 18 U.S. gallons (68 L; 15 imp gal) the payload is 232 lb (105 kg)

Don't see no bubble canopy and you say it has a Walter/Avia but I suspect that this is it? I can't see any other of that era named after a European statesman or woman (tho the idea of the Texas "THATCHER" is an interesting flight of fancy.........

teusje 9th Dec 2020 17:57

You found it Asturias. You have control.
It had the Walter engine fitted in the early 2000's apparently.

Asturias56 10th Dec 2020 07:22

That was not easy! The problem is of course that with kit builds people change the design a bit - which makes identification that much more challenging - but it does take us on roads we wouldn't normally travel

Have to be OH I'm afraid


India Four Two 10th Dec 2020 20:52

Aviation journalist Roger Bacon interviewing an Atlantic Baron; "Tell me Captain, why do you only fly in four-engined airplanes?"

Captain Speaking: "Because there are no five-engined airplanes, laddie!"

RB: "Well, actually there are!"


This should be easier than the last challenge. :)

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....7103eec6c7.jpg



Self loading bear 10th Dec 2020 21:14

Actually the choice is large than I expected!

CoodaShooda 10th Dec 2020 21:24

I'd hazard a guess at the Zeppelin Staaken R XIV.. OH if correct.

India Four Two 11th Dec 2020 02:44

CoodaShooda has it - the Zeppelin-Staaken R.XIVa


... a fifth Maybach engine was installed in the nose.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeppelin-Staaken_R.XIV

138' wingspan! Adjusting the wing incidence must have been fun.
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b20d8b130d.jpg


Open House has been declared.

washoutt 11th Dec 2020 09:22

How do you get about, adjusting a double wing with numerous struts?

Asturias56 11th Dec 2020 16:48

100 fitters and BIG megaphone?

DownWest 12th Dec 2020 06:54


Originally Posted by washoutt (Post 10944890)
How do you get about, adjusting a double wing with numerous struts?

Level the fuselarge, get your clinometer out and start with the port lower..:) Must say, that is BIG. Not done one larger than a DH87 Rapide.

bafanguy 12th Dec 2020 15:14

I know I'm getting a little older with the occasional lapse in short-term memory but I could swear there was a post in this thread about the Bréguet 763 Deux-Ponts. Now I can't find it even using the search function. What happened to it ?

After looking at some cockpit pix, I was going to ask about the crew make up.

FlightlessParrot 13th Dec 2020 04:52


Originally Posted by bafanguy (Post 10945759)

After looking at some cockpit pix, I was going to ask about the crew make up.

Standard Air France full face of slap, I think.

I'm sorry, it's been a hard year. And I have the same recollection about the Deux Ponts (perhaps without a hyphen), but can't locate it.

Self loading bear 15th Dec 2020 21:59

I do not recall the Deux Ponts challenge but We have had contributors who deleted their own challenge after it was solved. But then the replies should still be visible...
Anyway you have at least a possible subject for a future challenge.

As it is open house:
This made my somewhat dormant shipbuilding heart beat faster:

Beautiful craftsmanship in teak and mahogany.
If that would be built today Greenpeace would be screaming out loud.
(and rightfully so).


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....2f2038bde.jpeg


sycamore 15th Dec 2020 22:47

Italian...?

Self loading bear 16th Dec 2020 21:07


Originally Posted by sycamore (Post 10948037)
Italian...?

No not Italian.

You can see all the wood strips pointing towards the same point. That makes it almost a developable surface like a cone. Took me back to my schooldays in bachelor engineering Shipbuilding.


Self loading bear 17th Dec 2020 16:31

Time for a next clue:
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d22700c10.jpeg


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:35.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.