PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   Name that Flying Machine (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/626547-name-flying-machine.html)

evansb 17th Jan 2020 17:20

Indeed, the first photograph is a GA-21 with side-by-side seating. A very advanced training concept at the time, not to even mention the flaps.

Asturias56 17th Jan 2020 17:23

that engine installation look American to me................... another trainer??

zetec2 17th Jan 2020 17:24

That's got some P51 in it ?.

Quemerford 17th Jan 2020 17:35

Yes American, yes a trainer and I agree about the P-51 look, but apparently no link between the two.

dook 17th Jan 2020 18:01

The fin is a dead ringer for a P51.

dook 17th Jan 2020 18:24

Try Googling P51 designer and it will come up with Edgar Schmued………….

Quemerford 17th Jan 2020 18:50


Originally Posted by dook (Post 10665585)
Try Googling P51 designer and it will come up with Edgar Schmued………….

That kind of gives it away, but I have to admit I didn't know that bit.

treadigraph 17th Jan 2020 22:10

Evansb, what was the info on the flaps above the wing, looked like dive brakes?

evansb 17th Jan 2020 22:27

Dear treadi, the Cunningham-Hall GA-21/36 was the first aeroplane to feature double motion wing flaps devised to lower landing speeds and not flying speeds.

Card model kit link:
https://www.oldmodelkits.com/index.php?detail=20962

Asturias56 18th Jan 2020 08:29

treadi - post # 775

"https://niagaraaerospacemuseum.org/c...am-hall-ga-36/

"It is the first plane to feature double motion wing flaps devised to lower landing speeds and not flying speeds. The GA-36 featured two cockpits and fixed landing gear. Cunningham-Hall tried to sell this design to the Army and Navy. Both declined, saying the aircraft was too expensive to produce."

meleagertoo 18th Jan 2020 15:53

It did!
it's a Morrow Victory trainer
Never heard of it before!

Quemerford 18th Jan 2020 16:11

That'll do: over to you :)

dook 18th Jan 2020 16:19

Off topic.

Whilst we have a break, can anyone tell me how to check incoming PMs on the new look site ?

Asturias56 18th Jan 2020 17:42

If you are logged in its the same as it used to be

Click on hte figure outline top right on the bar and select private Messages - then chose Inbox or Outbox

dook 18th Jan 2020 18:16

I don't have that option.

dook 18th Jan 2020 18:21

This is how it looks:

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1e0633368b.jpg

treadigraph 18th Jan 2020 18:49

Dook, is it perchance under the menu (3 horizontal bars) on the left of the dark blue PPRuNe title bar? That's where messages are on my smart phone.

Evans/Asturias - thanks, be interested to see how the system worked in flight - shame the aeroplane is in a museum but then again amazing it has survived!

dook 18th Jan 2020 18:54

Thank you all.

I have now selected all site and things are back to normal.

It must be either my machine or browser.

meleagertoo 18th Jan 2020 23:17


Originally Posted by Quemerford (Post 10666184)
That'll do: over to you :)

Thanks buddy.
I have nothing to contribute so may I invite another Open House?

Asturias56 19th Jan 2020 17:41

Ok - another best seller................. not .............

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....2ed82a7fe2.jpg

oncemorealoft 19th Jan 2020 18:45

There’s a bit of Miles about it but I’m sure it will be something else.

Quemerford 19th Jan 2020 19:39

What does the other end look like?

Herod 19th Jan 2020 19:53

I'll go along with Miles. M.38 Messenger perhaps? The tail end might be a bit of a giveaway.

dook 19th Jan 2020 21:14

The glazed area behind the cockpit reminds me of the GA Cygnet.

Herod 19th Jan 2020 21:20

The tail would give a clue. Whitney Straight or Monarch?

DaveReidUK 19th Jan 2020 21:20

I can't see there being much swanning around trying to guess this one.

meleagertoo 19th Jan 2020 22:53


Originally Posted by dook (Post 10666985)
The glazed area behind the cockpit reminds me of the GA Cygnet.

No wonder it 'reminds you of..."
It is a General Aircraft GAL42 Cygnet.

I'm not claiming that one as dook clearly got thre first.

DaveReidUK 20th Jan 2020 06:38


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 10667037)
No wonder it 'reminds you of..."
It is a General Aircraft GAL42 Cygnet.

I'm not claiming that one as dook clearly got thre first.

Extra points for spotting that it's the prototype CW Aircraft (Chronander/Waddington) Cygnet, notable for its single fin and taildragger configuration, unlike its twin-fin, tricycle-gear GAL Cygnet successors.

Asturias56 20th Jan 2020 07:42

Y'all come back this evening.......................

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ea3bc46c6a.jpg
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....6a2fb41245.jpg

Quemerford 20th Jan 2020 09:41

Cropped again...

dook 20th Jan 2020 09:46

Well, he's given us the front and back end views now.

Asturias56 20th Jan 2020 17:25

It's almost 24 hours and I'm off out - yes it's the GA42 Cygnet in both it's manifestations.

Looks like Dook has the wheel......

dduxbury310 20th Jan 2020 23:55

Slight thread drift, but when operated by the RAF, the GA Cygnet (yes, a baby swan) becomes an owlet! I just cannot explain how it did that. Have an idea that the RAF also threw away the canopy to suit their own purposes (possibly being evaluated as a military trainer?)
David D

10 DME ARC 21st Jan 2020 06:33

I have got to say as a non UK/GMT member who has regularly read this and the which airport page, with the odd guess and win, the latest MOD's rules are totally spoiling what used to be really interesting pages!

Asturias56 21st Jan 2020 06:45


Originally Posted by dduxbury310 (Post 10667673)
Slight thread drift, but when operated by the RAF, the GA Cygnet (yes, a baby swan) becomes an owlet! I just cannot explain how it did that. Have an idea that the RAF also threw away the canopy to suit their own purposes (possibly being evaluated as a military trainer?)
David D


They bought a few to check out crews on tricycle wheel aircraft as they'd bought a load of Havoc's I think from the USA - at eh time the RAF didn't operate anything with a nose wheel.

Asturias56 21st Jan 2020 18:58

But "faded" beyond recognition!!!! :ok:

That normally means Russian - they never seemed to have decent photographic film under J V Stalin.......................

Quemerford 21st Jan 2020 19:25


Originally Posted by dook (Post 10668139)
Good morning/afternoon/evening all.

Especially for Quemerford - look - not cropped. ;)

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e8ca0b2362.jpg

That'll do!

No idea....:confused:

Asturias56 23rd Jan 2020 08:02

looks like solid interwing strut - the Polikarpov I15 had them bu that was had a bloody great radial.............

maybe the DI-1 (2I-N1)??

sycamore 23rd Jan 2020 12:51

Is it Japanese...?

Asturias56 23rd Jan 2020 14:20

Dook has deleted the thread I believe but a copy still exists above in his reply to Quem - he has told me what it is and neither I nor sycamore are correct

I'll try and PM him


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:29.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.