PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Airlines, Airports & Routes (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes-85/)
-   -   NEWCASTLE - 8 (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes/350781-newcastle-8-a.html)

sean377 27th Feb 2012 16:11

So when is this supposed press conference?

Call Established 27th Feb 2012 16:30

It was for 1200 today......but was actually cancelled in the end. It was based around Eastern and NCL route but will be rescheduled I am told!

CentreFix25 27th Feb 2012 17:10


Could be a few people with egg on their face
Just like the DTV thread - always good for a laugh:ok:

skyman771 27th Feb 2012 17:12

Eastern NCL - BHX certainly not exciting, done it enough times, & if existing fares had any relevance, then total cost to :mad: would be ridiculous. Might as well drive to MAN , or even EDI if "3:3" in a 757 turns you on (unless you really want to splash out on business) !!:ugh:
No wonder some one got a reality check & canx the press conference:E
Even Aer Lingus in the good old days didn't get excited on a connecting flight & they actually had the significant advance customs clearance advantage, indeed they also actually flew a sector in the right direction;)

fa2fi 27th Feb 2012 18:20

I laid the NY idea to rest years ago. Not going to happen. Incidentally I did a 8.5 hour flight non stop SFB-GLA in seat A. Was no different to an A seat on TCX, CO etc.And many times better than Americans E seat on the 777. Don't see what's wrong with it. BA did tatl on the 75 for years. Don't see the benefit of twin aisles. People say its easier to move round but not the case in my experiences. If one aisle is blocked by a service cart the chances are the other aisle is blocked by same service.

fl dutchman 27th Feb 2012 19:28

New York
 
Oh well.

Maybe tommorrow, or the day after, or the day after that or two days after that.

Dont think it will happen in my lifetime. ( If it does then I will do something in Fenwicks window as they used to say on Tyneside)

Keep on using good old KL, BA, AF, to the US via AMS, CDG, LHR, etc, its not that bad infact the service and connectiond are very good.

There was once a weekly direct service to New York from NCL I think in the Sixties or seventies (Jetsave charter ). Unlikely to be repeated these days.

ncleflights, completely agree with your last post.

nigel osborne 27th Feb 2012 19:47

Think Ive heard everything now... Eastern flying from BHX to NCL to fed a New York flight why would that happen,when the passengers can just fly from BHX:O:}


Nigel

BHX5DME 27th Feb 2012 19:50

Maybe I got it the wrong way around, Eastern offering NCL pax EWR via BHX !

Jamesair 27th Feb 2012 20:35

Oh well, at least it livened up the thread yesterday...what we need is an FRA route announcement.

HH6702 28th Feb 2012 01:49

ncleflights you say the airport is too wrapped up in trying to get new york service and has missed other ones like Frankfurt??

The airport has stated it hopes to get a service to FRA with LH.
Its down to getting the right slots for the service and i guess we will get it in the next 12 months.....??

Also the current management have got the following over last few months

Jet2 loads of new routes and 6 based aircraft in total
EK now a 777 daily

I also see that Thomson will be offering Naples in march/april 2013 which im sure hasnt been done before....

so i wouldnt say that the airport has missed other opportunties.......
im sure the airport will be talking to a range of new airlines and current airlines about a list of new routes and im sure we will be surprised at some of the new routes we get in the next few months....

Did anyone see Flybe coming with Bergen??

ncleflights 28th Feb 2012 07:33

HH6702 - Whilst you have me on this subject of Frankfurt when slots became available recently we did miss out on Frankfurt, when the Aberdeen - Frankfurt route was announced. I fail to see how a business case could not have been made that NCL would not have achieved better loads/yields than Aberdeen for the airline.

Jet2 yes great news and well done to the airport management for getting the extra based units

On the subject of EK upgrade yes its truly great news but lets remember it was under the regime of Mr Parkin that the Airport secured EK in the first place. I doubt the current airport management would have been able to achieve this route because of this ridiculous New York pre-occupation.

SWBKCB 28th Feb 2012 07:43


I fail to see how a business case could not have been made that NCL would not have achieved better loads/yields than Aberdeen for the airline.
ABZ isn't really a valid comparison - ABZ has a route to FRA for the same reason it has flights to Baku and NCL doesn't...

Somewhere like BRS is a fairer comparison and they don't have a FRA route either.

skyman771 28th Feb 2012 09:16


Somewhere like BRS is a fairer comparison and they don't have a FRA route either.
Perhaps more relevant and specific to the point is that BRS no longer has CO !
which if nothing else reflects current trends. In reality nothing is achieved in making such comparisons :ugh:

10 DME ARC 28th Feb 2012 12:44

ncleflights - The NYC route is not the be all and end all to the airport management team, actually this is a route that the NE needs as the US is the biggest trading partner of NE England. It is not an unrealistic aspiration I have heard that it creates the biggest interest of any unserved route amongst the business and leisure traveling public in the North East! With lots of people having to use other airports, e.g. Manchester and Heathrow, when they would prefer a transatlantic flight direct from their local airport. **If Emirates works from NCL then there is no reason why NYC can’t as well!

As for FRA, this again is a route which should work and who is to say the airport are not working on this one too! One problem would be the perfect airline for the route is also the one who would loose the most from it, LH and DUS! I am sure the airport whilst wanting new routes is balancing the needs of other airport partner airlines Emirates/KLM/AF/BA. Running a successful regional airport is a balancing act!

*As for Mr Parkin I know from my time at the airport and a few inside sources, that he may have made the announcement, shortly before he was suspended! but it’s the people who are still at the airport who initiated the analysis, looking at the feasibility and who then delivered Emirates at the end of the day. :)

Piltdown Man 28th Feb 2012 13:44


The North East economy is certainly not as you put it "a basket case".
Any economy made up by burger eating, mouth-breathing, tracky-suit wearing, facebook using, illiterate, social housing dwelling half-wits is a basket case. Only when the region becomes self-supporting (ie. a net contributor to the exchequer) will it be anything else. To do that will take two generations of 'hard love', something which they won't get. Until then, it will be anywhere cheap with sunshine.

PM

Skipness One Echo 28th Feb 2012 14:10

Saying there is no reason a route should work is often because you haven't looked far enough. GLA has both EWR and PHL as well as DXB but still no FRA and CDG is EZY and not AF, whereas EDI has multiple dailies to both with LH and AF.

GAXLN 28th Feb 2012 15:59

Piltdown man,

That'll be the same people who are using the Emirates service and have made it a success then? Plenty of burgers in America so we should be alright with New York. There's a great danger in stereotyping regions particularly using words such as those you have used as I doubt whether there's any region outside the South East that is a net contributor to the Exchequer given the budget defecit. However, can someone then rationalise why £2000 per head is spent on transport in London and c£5 per head here in the North East? This is the only UK region which exports more than it imports in respect of physical goods. The country needs an export led recovery and that will benefit the North East. If we don't get an export led recovery then we are likely to all be in a big mess and living in caves again. Are you leading the way?

ncleflights 28th Feb 2012 17:30

10 DME ARC - You say that the NYC route is not the be all and end all to airport management, however the evidence clearly states that it is. As I have already posted at every opportunity the airport management at press releases and interviews devote a huge amount of time to stating how important this route is. Back in October Mr Mason stated in public that securing the NYC route was the number one priority! securing no other new route is ever given a mention. If that is not evidence enough I dont know what is.

I do fully agree with you though that a route to NY is important to the region and the with the right airline would certainly work all the data gathered and stats we have to hand prove this . However until the economy picks up I think a route announcement is unlikely. Personally I think that AA was the wrong airline for the route when it was announced back in 2005 perhaps if we had waited the extra year when CO had available aircraft to start up on the route we would not be having this debate now as we would be having a successful scheduled service to NY, but hindsight is great I suppose.

With regard to Mr Parkin and the emirates route I also now from my time at the airport who was key in securing this route so we will have to agree to disagree on this one I am afraid.

GAXLN - Piltdown is obviously a complete idiot and very ignorant and has not got a clue what he is talking about the best thing is to ignore him his post really does not warrant a reply

Sam Chipperfield 28th Feb 2012 18:37

Newcastle
 
New York Wont Happen Here, Its About Time You Get Realistic, Maybe Frankfurt From Lufthansa Or Flybe, Or Even Getting The Stansted Flight Back With Jet2, Newcastle Is Not Popular For New York Over 5-7 Days A Week

CentreFix25 28th Feb 2012 19:36


NY is important to the region and the with the right airline would certainly work all the data gathered and stats we have to hand prove this
I've been of the opinion that this route won't work, and the reasons it is not operated today is because the airlines share that opinion.

I've obviously missed the stats and data gathered that say otherwise.

Can you point me in the direction of these stats, or give me the gist of it and the source and I might change my thinking. Thanks!


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:39.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.