PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Turkish F16 shoots down unidentified aircraft in their airspace. (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/571040-turkish-f16-shoots-down-unidentified-aircraft-their-airspace.html)

RHINO 24th Nov 2015 07:12

Turkish F16 shoots down unidentified aircraft in their airspace.
 
Reporting on Sky news.

Kitbag 24th Nov 2015 07:18

Link to story such as it is

rjtjrt 24th Nov 2015 07:27

Video

http://youtu.be/s9xhOkQf8JU

https://mobile.twitter.com/sakirkhad...rc=twsrc%5Etfw

https://t.co/lSaHCCPWCc

Eclectic 24th Nov 2015 07:35

SU-24?
Pilot captured by Turks?

Update: Russian media confirm plane shot down by Turkey is Russian. One of the pilots captured -

LOL. Now Russian media changing the "facts" to suit their agenda: Russian media claims that a Syrian MIG-23 was shot down by Turkey, not SU-24
https://twitter.com/SaadAbedine/stat...74242978213889

me myself and fly 24th Nov 2015 07:36

Russia confirms the plane shot down by Turkey is Russian.

https://twitter.com/GazetaRu/status/669063568281743360

СРОЧНО. Упавший в Сирии самолет был российским
СМИ: упавший в Сирии самолет был российским, пилот катапультировался - Газета.Ru | Новости

URGENTLY. The fallen aircraft was Russian in Syria СМИ: упавший в Сирии самолет был российским, пилот катапультировался - Газета.Ru | Новости

me myself and fly 24th Nov 2015 07:52

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CUkC4EgUEAAkIuR.jpg

Eclectic 24th Nov 2015 07:53

OOPS!:
"Turkey called this week for a UN Security Council meeting to discuss attacks on Turkmens in neighbouring Syria, and last week Ankara summoned the Russian ambassador to protest the bombing of their villages.

Ankara has traditionally expressed solidarity with Syrian Turkmens, who are Syrians of Turkish descent."

Russian propagandist liars now claiming there was no intrusion of Turkish airspace: https://www.rt.com/news/323215-warpl...-syria-turkey/

This looks like it is going from warm to hot.

Eclectic 24th Nov 2015 08:11

Turkey downs Russian fighter jet near Syrian border after violation of airspace - Daily Sabah

"The downed fighter jet was warned 10 times in 5 minutes according to a statement released by the Turkish Armed Forces."

Kulverstukas 24th Nov 2015 08:18

Plane crash site and both pilots are on Syrian territory, BTW. Controlled by Syrian turkomans, fighting against Syrian government. So?

Kulverstukas 24th Nov 2015 08:23

Turkish President Erdogan confirmed that the Turkish military was shot down Russia's Su-24 over Syria.

UPD: Plane fell at Yamady turkoman refugee camp in Latakia. Pilots held hostage by turkomans, who open fire at helicopters sent to rescue operation.

AFTA 24th Nov 2015 08:49

This one should be easy. I am sure both Nato and Russia will have the complete air picture and recordings. But will it agree?

alwayzinit 24th Nov 2015 08:51

Would suggest that all who fly around the ME turn up 121.5 mhz and wear headsets so as not to miss any calls!!!:eek:

Kitiara 24th Nov 2015 09:05

This is a real wild card right now. If the plane crashed at Latakia, then it is nearly 40km inside Syria, which would tend to cast doubt on claims it was violating Turkish airspace.

How Putin will react is the key thing though. It could be as restrained as diplomatic protests, though unless his pilot is released promptly and unharmed, that level of restraint is unlikely.

At the other extreme, he could react by providing the Kurds with air-defense systems to assist them in resisting the Turkish bombing campaign that is targeting them. It would be easy to justify doing so on the basis that they were fighting against IS before Turkey started targeting them.

RexBanner 24th Nov 2015 09:07

At 500 mph the aircraft would be doing 8 miles a minute, three minutes to fall depending on height takes it 24 miles (roughly 40km) and that's just back of fag packet maths. The aircraft doesn't fall straight down.

Slow and curious 24th Nov 2015 09:08

Quote:
"I am sure both Nato and Russia will have the complete air picture and recordings."

Are you suggesting it's Nato vs Russia?

ExDubai 24th Nov 2015 09:16


Are you suggesting it's Nato vs Russia?
Don't think so. Nobody knows what's the role of Erdogan in this "game". Erdogan proofed that he has his own agenda. And his agenda might be totally different.....

ShotOne 24th Nov 2015 09:18

He didn't say that, slow but obviously Turkey is in NATO. As with the Israeli shootdown of a Syrian aircraft, IS must be laughing their socks off!

Hawker 800 24th Nov 2015 09:19

BBC reporting one pilot killed.

Sokol 24th Nov 2015 09:22


At 500 mph the aircraft would be doing 8 miles a minute, three minutes to fall depending on height takes it 24 miles (roughly 40km) and that's just back of fag packet maths. The aircraft doesn't fall straight down.
Simple maths of course. If the Pilots had pulled the Ejection Seat at 800km/h IAS (not Gspd.!)there would be less diplomatic trouble.
Betting would be more exact if the last Course of the Airplane is verified.

Hawker 800 24th Nov 2015 09:23

Exactly.

NATO Vows Military Support If Turkey Goes To War With Russia

silvertate 24th Nov 2015 09:27


The downed fighter jet was warned 10 times in 5 minutes according to a statement released by the Turkish Armed Forces
In what language?

One presumes in English, as that is likely to be the only common language. But in my experience the Turkish military English is as bad as Russian military English. In which case, there is ample room for confusion, especially when a military pilot is very busy planning an active sortie.

If the Turks are so jumpy that they cannot realise the potential problems, and observe rather than engage, then they are not very clever. Did they really think this aircraft was about to attack Antakya? Frankly, the initial analysis suggests that trigger-happy Turks have (predictably) precipitated an unesessary international incident.

ST

JCviggen 24th Nov 2015 09:28


If the plane crashed at Latakia, then it is nearly 40km inside Syria, which would tend to cast doubt on claims it was violating Turkish airspace.
If you google maps Yamadi, Latakia (the closest thing to the site apparently) it's right on the border with Turkey. Turkey's border is anything but a straight line down there though.

It's probably close enough to the border that we can't tell from the crash location which airspace it was in when it got hit.

Meanwhile, Russian media actively discussing the possibility of the plane coming down from a MANPAD while Turkey has been saying it did it all along :suspect:

beamender99 24th Nov 2015 09:29

Turkey 'shoot down warplane on Syria border' - BBC News

Video clip shows two chutes

Tourist 24th Nov 2015 09:31


Originally Posted by silvertate (Post 9190129)
Frankly, the initial analysis suggests that trigger-happy Turks have (predictably) precipitated an unesessary international incident.

Or B. The Russians finally managed to exhaust the Turks patience for repeated incursions by a known bully who has a habit of messing around inside other people's countries whilst issuing denials......

AFTA 24th Nov 2015 09:36


Originally Posted by Slow and curious (Post 9190102)
Quote:
"I am sure both Nato and Russia will have the complete air picture and recordings."

Are you suggesting it's Nato vs Russia?

I am not suggesting anything. I would just assume both sides of this situation will probably know what happened. As both parties will probably have air picture recordings that i will assume at least one of them will release to the media.

AlphaZuluRomeo 24th Nov 2015 09:38


Originally Posted by Kitiara (Post 9190098)
If the plane crashed at Latakia, then it is nearly 40km inside Syria, which would (...)

It was said "Yamadi, Latakia" as in "Yamadi, region of Latakia".

Here it is: https://goo.gl/maps/QipzQZVymNk

rightstuffer 24th Nov 2015 09:46

Radar plot
 
Here's the link to the radar plot
http://twitter.com/CNNTURK_ENG/status/669098577524822016/photo/1

marchino61 24th Nov 2015 09:48

Turkey Supports Turkmen in Syria
 
Whichever side of the border it was on, last week Turkey protested to Russia about their targeting of Turkmen (ethnic Turks in Syria).

One way of interpreting this is that Turkey is telling Russia "Hands off the Turkmen".

Mozella 24th Nov 2015 10:04


Quote:
The downed fighter jet was warned 10 times in 5 minutes according to a statement released by the Turkish Armed Forces
In what language?

One presumes in English, as that is likely to be the only common language. But in my experience the Turkish military English is as bad as Russian military English. In which case, there is ample room for confusion, especially when a military pilot is very busy planning an active sortie.
Transmitting a warning is not the same thing as that warning being received and ignored, no matter what the language in use. I've got 153 combat missions under my belt and there were plenty of times my side was unsuccessful when trying to communicate with me while on a mission.

I've also made a number of non-combat intercepts of Russian bombers and not once were they able to make contact with me (and vice versa), although they were able to hold up the latest issue of Playboy magazine for my viewing pleasure.

The press may assume the Turkish warning was received and ignored, but we pilots, especially those with combat experience, should be more prudent and not jump to conclusions.

AmuDarya 24th Nov 2015 10:09

Based on that radar plot and the Google maps scale, each of two overflights was over
a 2.5-3.5km spur of Turkish territory.

That's a 10 second overflight at Mach 1.

rightstuffer 24th Nov 2015 10:14


Originally Posted by AmuDarya (Post 9190177)
Based on that radar plot and the Google maps scale, each of two overflights was over
a 2.5-3.5km spur of Turkish territory.

That's a 10 second overflight at Mach 1.

...but it's still an overflight. Twice by the look of it.

Hasherucf 24th Nov 2015 10:19

I'm sure Turkey wont be happy if Russia puts a ban on Turkish holidays. Would certainly hurt the tourist industry. Interested in Putins response !

ILS27LEFT 24th Nov 2015 10:23

Syrian rebels release a video of a dead Russian pilot
 
From LiveLeak:

Syrian rebels release a video of a dead Russian pilot, video is on LiveLeak.

First time a NATO member has downed a Russian or Soviet military aircraft since the 1950s: this could turn really nasty indeed. Past major wars and conflicts (including World Wars) have often been triggered by similar accidents.
From below: "My personal opinion is that Putin will mostly take this one on the chin, and not react in a way likely to escalate a confrontation with the forces of NATO countries." The entire planet is hoping for the same.

Let's hope pilots are still both alive and video is not genuine (unfortunately video looks real). :(

AmuDarya 24th Nov 2015 10:28


Horizontal distance traveled : 7.8km
Based on the Turkish radar plot (if accurate) and overlaying on Google maps, the SU-24 was at no point further than 2.5-3.5 km from getting back into Syrian airspace. See my post above.

JCviggen 24th Nov 2015 10:32


...but it's still an overflight. Twice by the look of it.
It's not unreasonable to think after those warnings a few weeks back that the Turkish military was under pretty strict guidelines. Turkey doesn't like what has been happening right outside its borders so that doesn't help.

(could one imagine the opposite scenario where a NATO mission is doing bombing raids a few miles from the Russian border and "accidentally" crossing into Russia's airspace for a few moments every now and then? Russia would never in a million years accept what it is doing to Turkey now)

ExDubai 24th Nov 2015 10:37


I'm sure Turkey wont be happy if Russia puts a ban on Turkish holidays. Would certainly hurt the tourist industry. Interested in Putins response !
Sure, but it would hurt the "normal russian citizen" too. Crimea is more expensive and less quality then the turkish 4-5* all inclusive offer and Egypt is currently not an option.

oldoberon 24th Nov 2015 10:37

It was suggested earlier the reason for this may not be the minor incursion of their airspace but the fact that russia is bombing the turkmens.

How ever Turkey has been bombing the most successful on th ground anti ISIS fighters namely the kurds. Going to be "interesting" next time Turkey invades syrian airspace to bomb the kurds.

ExDubai 24th Nov 2015 10:40


Treated in accordance with the Geneva Convention? Not a chance. Not with those nutters.
Yepp, like the Jordan pilot a couple of months ago.

Kitiara 24th Nov 2015 10:41


Originally Posted by http://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/571040-turkish-f16-shoots-down-unidentified-aircraft-their-airspace-2.html#post9190131

If you google maps Yamadi, Latakia (the closest thing to the site apparently) it's right on the border with Turkey. Turkey's border is anything but a straight line down there though.

It's probably close enough to the border that we can't tell from the crash location which airspace it was in when it got hit.

Meanwhile, Russian media actively discussing the possibility of the plane coming down from a MANPAD while Turkey has been saying it did it all along

Fair enough. All I'd seen when I posted was Latakia. Given this, anything could be true about where the plane was during the flight prior to the shoot down and unfortunately it's near impossible to trust statements on that point made by anyone involved.

In political terms though, the truth is less important than the ability of the various participants to dictate the narrative.

My personal opinion is that Putin will mostly take this one on the chin, and not react in a way likely to escalate a confrontation with the forces of NATO countries.

AmuDarya 24th Nov 2015 11:07

Pilots with combat experience can perhaps enlighten?

How does a pilot stay inside friendly airspace when conducting a combat mission near such a convoluted border with only a few seconds margin of error?

Is the navigation instrumentation capable of showing a finely delineated border accurately? And is it at all feasible to keep within the border?


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:38.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.