From the Report
Two kinds of explanation could be considered: 1).... 2)....The wreckage was found at elevation approximately 8,300 feet, higher than the 8,000 feet MSA published, which they may have believed they were safe. It appears you cannot rely on the published MSA. |
That’s a very valid point ! Wombat. Sort of makes the the other causes superficial.
|
Originally Posted by flash8
(Post 10005894)
Not exactly recommended....
I am not saying this is a recommended practise, but we considered the risk of having a panicking passenger bursting into the cockpit greater than the risk of a true alarm on approaches that we knew well and had flown recently. |
Originally Posted by Wombaticus
(Post 10005946)
From the Report
One would hope to believe you were safe above the published MSA. It appears you cannot rely on the published MSA. But then, it would need low temperatures and pressures that occur over Greenland, hardly the case here I suppose... |
It looks to me from the VFR chart that the highest terrain within 25NM in that sector is over 14000ft which would mean the real MSA is over 15000ft, in other words the published MSA is completely spurious. Was the chart produced entirely by the operator?
|
The chart depicts an MSA within 20nm of the airport. The report does indicate that this is an entirely operator produced chart.
So yes a work of fiction bearing no relation to reality. |
Originally Posted by Trim Stab
(Post 10006349)
I don't know about the type in question, or at the accident location, but on other types I have flown in mountainous territory EGPWS got triggered even when accurately flying a published approach due to terrain ahead before intercepting the loc, or else terrain directly ahead on the go-around. I remember this being the case at Berne, Sion and Chambery.
What type if I may ask? |
If your EGPWS triggers during a straight in ILS approach in Bern you may want to heed the warning...
|
atakacs
This was on various C525s and C510. Quite a few years ago now so memory not that precise. But I do remember a colleague had a panicking passenger run into cockpit on an approach into Bern, so we used to pull the CB on subsequent approaches. It was something we used to do only after careful briefing, and if it was a pax we did not know. If a regular pax, we would brief them that the alarm might be triggered. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 17:58. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.