PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Bhoja Air 213 down near Islamabad (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/483196-bhoja-air-213-down-near-islamabad.html)

jwhitley 20th Apr 2012 14:21

Bhoja Air 213 down near Islamabad
 
Breaking from Reuters. Any news?

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 14:24

Bhoja Air 213 down near OPRN.
 
confirmed, Bhoja Air 213 with 127 onboard has crashed about 30 mins ago.

apparently landed short. no news on survivors.

jwhitley 20th Apr 2012 14:27

From columnpk.com

"
RAWALPINDI: A plane crashed at the Koral Chowk on Islamabad Express Highway in Rawalpindi on Friday, reported Express News.
According to initial reports, the plane was a Boeing 737 and belonged to Bhoja Air. It was also reportedly carrying 137 passengers from Islamabad to Karachi.
7:17pm
It is currently raining in Rawalpindi and it being suggested that the bad weather could have been the cause of the plane crash.
According to authorities, the plane crashed 10km away from the runway of Islamabad airport, near Chaklala airbase.
Rescue officials from Islamabad and Rawalpindi, as well as the Civil Aviation Authority, have left for the crash site.
"

Load Toad 20th Apr 2012 14:31

BBC News - Airliner crashes near Islamabad airport

SV_741_India_Bravo 20th Apr 2012 14:32

116 pax on board, a/c 737-200, was on approach.

OPRN 201400Z 23020KT 3000 TSRA FEW025CB SCT030 BKN100 20/16 Q1011.0/29.85
TAF OPRN 200930Z 2012/2118 23005KT 6000 SCT040 SCT100
TEMPO 2012/2018 23015G25KT 4000 TS FEW030CB SCT035 BKN100
TEMPO 2019/2022 23015G25KT 4000 TS FEW030CB SCT035 BKN100
TEMPO 2100/2103 23010G20KT 4000 FEW030TCU SCT035 BKN100

Airbubba 20th Apr 2012 14:33


Passenger plane with 127 on board crashes near Chaklala airbase

Updated 23 minutes ago

RAWALPINDI: A Bhoja Airline flight # B4-213 has reportedly crashed near Chaklala airbase, Geo News reported.

According to sources, the a Boeing 737 with 127 passengers on board, which flew from Karachi at 5:00PM was suppose to land in Islamabad at 6:40PM, but crashed just before touchdown.

Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) has confirmed the reports of crash.

Rescue teams have rushed to the crash site.

More details are yet awaited.
Passenger plane with 127 on board crashes near Chaklala airbase - geo.tv

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 14:41

crash in populated area. most likely casualties on the ground too. news showing pictures of wrecked houses

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 14:50

118 pax, 9 crew

crashed confirmed in residential area. reports suggest crash site around 2NM from threshold and left of centerline RWY30

SV_741_India_Bravo 20th Apr 2012 14:56

First views are in. Bits and pieces of the aircraft are scattered among houses. Very slim chance of survivors :(

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 15:04

pretty much inline with the runway just about 2.5NM from threshold

inducedrag 20th Apr 2012 15:05

AP-BKD - 1984-built Boeing 737-236 Advanced (C/N 23163) previous regisrtration ZS-OLA.

TWT 20th Apr 2012 15:22

Geo News Live | Geo Tv Live | Watch Geo News | Live Geo Streaming

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 15:23

looks like they got caught in a downdraft. wreckage seems to indicate high speed crash. lots of houses damaged and very likely there are casualties on the ground.

SV_741_India_Bravo 20th Apr 2012 15:39

http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/a...420_203118.jpg
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/a...420_203137.jpg
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/a...420_203141.jpg
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/a...420_203149.jpgmage_120420_203254.jpg[/IMG]
http://i198.photobucket.com/albums/a...420_203255.jpg

fantom 20th Apr 2012 15:41

It's good to see the experts are here already.

Melax 20th Apr 2012 16:02

The following quote from Wikipedia if true is quite troubling,,,
Aircraft

The accident aircraft was a Boeing 737-200, registration AP-BKD.[1] The aircraft had been purchased from Shaheen Airlines, which had retired it as unairworthy.[2] The aircraft is reported to have been 32 years old at the time of the accident.

Tableview 20th Apr 2012 16:09

It was in service with BA/Comair in ZA until mid-2009. A lot can happen in 3 years.

Tragic anyway, hopefully yet another accident in this part of the world will lead to higher standards.

GarageYears 20th Apr 2012 16:09

BBC report states a "violent thunderstorm" at the time of the crash.

Getinitus? :rolleyes:

denlopviper 20th Apr 2012 16:32

yeah there was an active CB and lightening activity over the field at the time of the crash, hence the me thinking of wind shear. getting into a downdraft 2.5 from touchdown is very close to being unrecoverable



edit....disregard, airport now open

hetfield 20th Apr 2012 16:37

Non Precission Approach?

pudoc 20th Apr 2012 16:39

I haven't heard of an accident where a a/c was brought down by lightning alone (stand to be corrected)...but you never know.

Can't believe such old aircraft are in service. I know if an a/c is maintained well it can last for years (WW2 a/c etc) but I think 32 years for a commercial a/c is pushing it.

Will wait for the report before I jump to conclusions though...

StainesFS 20th Apr 2012 17:03

Aviation Herald is now reporting that the aircraft was, in fact, AP-BKC. This was also an ex-BA/Comair aircraft dating from 1984 (formerly G-BKYI, ZS-OLB).

Efe Cem Elci 20th Apr 2012 17:04

Since its Pakistan, shouldn't experience lead us to believe the report will never be released?

lomapaseo 20th Apr 2012 17:06


I haven't heard of an accident where a a/c was brought down by lightning alone (stand to be corrected)...but you never know.

Can't believe such old aircraft are in service. I know if an a/c is maintained well it can last for years (WW2 a/c etc) but I think 32 years for a commercial a/c is pushing it
Iran Air (sister ship of TWA800).

Obviously extremely rare and even more so today

It aint the years of service, its the flight cycles and the repair cycles.

hetfield 20th Apr 2012 17:07


Since its Pakistan, shouldn't experience lead us to believe the report will never be released?
Well, maybe the findings are toward India.....

Kamran Bhatti 20th Apr 2012 17:10

Heavy rain and storm at the time of crash
 
There was heavy rain and storm at the time of accident,127 on board including 6 crew members.Captain was ex Group Captain Pakistan Airforce,

So far there are different reports, Lightning,one eye witness said,and rumors are Plane,s ILS was faulty,Don,t know.

40 houses damaged .

Old King Coal 20th Apr 2012 17:26

OPRN 201400Z 23020KT 3000 TSRA FEW025CB SCT030 BKN100 20/16 Q1011.0/29.85

Nb. Islamabad (ISB/OPRN) has the following approach to Runway 30 (runway QDM = 296 degrees) :

ILS DME - inbound QDM = 296 degrees / visibility minima for Cat C aircraft = 700m
ILS LOC - inbound QDM = 296 degrees / visibility minima for Cat C aircraft = 750m
VOR DME - inbound QDM = 296 degrees / visibility minima for Cat C aircraft = 1100m
VOR Circling - inbound QDM = 340 degrees / visibility minima for Cat C aircraft = 2400m
NDB Circling - inbound QDM = 320 degrees / visibility minima for Cat C aircraft = 2400m

Had they been following a standard 3 degree approach, in the above reported (METAR) visibility of 3000 metres (approx 1.6Nm), they should have expect to see the runway when at approximately 500 feet above ground level.

If Pakistani news reports are correct, i.e. that they crashed at / into the village of 'Hussain Abad' ( N33° 35' 19.48" / E073° 8' 51.69" ), that puts the crash site approximately 2.1 Nm short of the threshold for R30. It is also approximately 0.3 Nm to left of the R30 extended centreline.

Given that they should have been following a 3 degree glide path (regardless of the approach type), this might suggest that - at the point of impact - they were approximately 600 feet below an ideal (3 degree) glide path and also substantially left of the centreline of R30.

Just my $0.02 worth.

Abraham Zapruder 20th Apr 2012 18:07


Aviation Herald is now reporting that the aircraft was, in fact, AP-BKC. This was also an ex-BA/Comair aircraft dating from 1984 (formerly G-BKYI, ZS-OLB).
http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7179/6...de1bf05f_b.jpg

llagonne66 20th Apr 2012 18:14

Data from Airfleets.net
 
Delivery date Airline Registration Remark
23/02/1980 British Airways G-BGDD
21/04/1995 Transavia Airlines PH-TSE
13/09/1995 Comair ZS-NNG Stored 01/2011
10/02/2012 Bhoja Air AP-BKD 20/04/12 Crashed Islamabad

El_Presidente 20th Apr 2012 18:28

Lansa Flight 508 - struck by lightning which ignited the ullage in the wing tanks.

LANSA Flight 508 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

arem 20th Apr 2012 18:41

Panam 707 over Maryland in '60's

Iranian AF 747 near Madrid - I forget the date

Efe Cem Elci 20th Apr 2012 18:53

arem the Iranian AF 747 was ULF48 and the date was May 9, 1976

CSRTG Aircraft Accident Database

The Ancient Geek 20th Apr 2012 19:32

BBC is reporting that wreckage is scattered over several kilometers.
If this is true (early reports are always suspect) it would indicate an inflight breakup of some kind.

OTOH, in bad weather lightweight debris can be scattered by high winds.
The scattered debris could also be domestic rather than aircraft related if the aircraft ploughed through several houses before coming to a stop.

chubbychopper 20th Apr 2012 21:36


Given that they should have been following a 3 degree glide path (regardless of the approach type), this might suggest that - at the point of impact - they were approximately 600 feet below an ideal (3 degree) glide path
Err....usually impact before the threshold tends to indicate that. Are you a rocket scientist by any chance?

umairch 20th Apr 2012 23:39

Lightening strike & port wing on fire. An eyewitness snapped off a few pictures before the crash. The atittude suddenly shifted after the strike.
This has hit somewhat close to home. Both the Captain & Co-pilot were ex PAF & friends of both my uncle(ex PAF) (married to my aunt) & best friend's father (in service AVM). I even met the capt as a kid once when visiting my aunt. Sad day. The airline was idle from 93-2012 not only due to finances but also it's maintenance practices. They used to send landing gear tyres tp car tyre repair shops to be serviced. What do you expect. A PIA flight was diverted to Lahore just before. Unfortunately if Captain Afridi had diverted the airline Bhoja would have canned him for making them suffer an economic loss. The bloody bas*** are selling the passenger manifest for Rs 20 to the families even now!

roaldp 21st Apr 2012 05:18

Checks "not fully adhered to"
 
The inauguration of Bhoja Air on March 3 2012 was only possible following the exertion of immense political pressure on the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) resulting in Friday's disaster, according to TheNews.com/pk. The CAA sources have said that the old plane was allowed to commence flights from April 20 although procedures and professional checks were not fully adhered to before doling out a licence to the Bhoja Air as a political favour.

This article also mentions several other disquieting details about the company:
Political pressure allowed Bhoja Air to relaunch - thenews.com.pk

oceancrosser 21st Apr 2012 05:55

Seems there should be a Category 3 or lower for some countries :ugh:

de facto 21st Apr 2012 06:04

Just listening to BBC.
Airline reportedly said pilot was highly experienced,weather was to blame...
But who lead this aircaft into that weather??:ugh:

fotoguzzi 21st Apr 2012 08:14

[not a pilot] Perhaps an investigation will not be necessary:

Bhoja Air crash: ‘Acceleration at low height caused mid-air explosion’ – The Express Tribune

@umairch: Are you able to provide a link to the pictures?

Tableview 21st Apr 2012 08:42

Just heard an interview on a ZA news broadcast with someone from Comair who said they they sold 2 a/c last year to Bhoja Air. They say both were in service with them until 2010 but can't confirm if the one in this accident is one of those.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:45.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.