Spice Jet. Pilot fails booze test 3rd time, grounded
Thread Starter
Spice Jet. Pilot fails booze test 3rd time, grounded
NEW DELHI: A senior commander of SpiceJet was stripped off his flying rights after failing the breath analyzer (BA) test for the third time. The commander used to fly Boeing 737 till the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) cancelled his license on Friday.
Doesn't sound good....
"Mildly" Eccentric Stardriver
From the article, it's three months, three years and life. If a three-year ban isn't going to do the trick, there is no sense in another innings. It seems also that he failed the test after a flight. It seems nothing is going to work in this case.
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: Scotland
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
spicejet pilot caught drunk 3rd time
I find it difficult to see why a pilot would fail a post-flight test after (presumably) passing the mandatory pre-flight test: surely drinking during flight (or during walk-round) must be noticed? Post-flight testing is really locking the stable door after the horse has bolted.......
A quick look on google is your friend and it appears that the test demands absolutely zero. So any contamination, mouthwash, a urinary tract infection etc etc etc is a fail. Scientific madness
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No. This has been discussed before. The answer is no, those "contaminations" will not cause a fail:
http://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/5...ml#post9593924
But breath analysis machines are different. These are calibrated, lab-grade gas spectrometers tuned to detect ethanol. They also have specialized algorithms (called "slope detectors") to reject mouth alcohol and other causes of false-positives (MTBE additives, paint thinners, etc.). They are operated by specialized technicians following strict legal procedures.
Since these machines are detecting ethanol specifically, they are extremely accurate. False positives are rare. Due to their accuracy these machines are typically acceptable in a court of law in lieu of a blood test.
A disease which could produce ethanol in detectable levels is also extremely rare (known as auto-brewery syndrome). Most of us may produce a trace amount of ethanol in our guts, yet in the entire history of humankind there are less than 100 recorded cases of auto-brewery syndrome. If you are unlucky enough to suffer from this disease, you may lose your flight medical anyway because you are essentially drunk all the time.
Since these machines are detecting ethanol specifically, they are extremely accurate. False positives are rare. Due to their accuracy these machines are typically acceptable in a court of law in lieu of a blood test.
A disease which could produce ethanol in detectable levels is also extremely rare (known as auto-brewery syndrome). Most of us may produce a trace amount of ethanol in our guts, yet in the entire history of humankind there are less than 100 recorded cases of auto-brewery syndrome. If you are unlucky enough to suffer from this disease, you may lose your flight medical anyway because you are essentially drunk all the time.
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As I understand it, each airline in India must ensure availability of test equipment for their own pilots, at every airport they regularly operate from. I don't know what SpiceJet uses, it could be any one of many models as breath analyzers are almost a commodity these days.
If you really believe 'gas' spectrometers with full time laboratory technicians are available in India to test every pilot at the start and end of every flight then please proceed. I have used these machines for research - they are a nightmare in the field.
I stand by my comments. Auto brewery syndrome is indeed rare but there are other commoner causes of ethanol production.
If all this is totally foolproof how is it that the UK police have so many limitations and the UK courts have let people off on these bases? I am just glad I dont fly in India.
I stand by my comments. Auto brewery syndrome is indeed rare but there are other commoner causes of ethanol production.
If all this is totally foolproof how is it that the UK police have so many limitations and the UK courts have let people off on these bases? I am just glad I dont fly in India.
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: UK
Age: 85
Posts: 697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So any contamination, mouthwash, a urinary tract infection etc etc etc is a fail. Scientific madness
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: I wouldn't know.
Posts: 4,499
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Even a glass of orange or apple juice for breakfast can cause a false positive in common portable breathalyzer tests. In germany those tests would not hold in front of a court, a blood test would be needed to confirm that. Which is why a positive breathalyzer tests leads directly to a court appointed MD to take a blood test, a court order is needed for that as a blood test is legally malicious injury, something a policeman may not do under normal circumstances.
Silly comment funfly. If you engaged brain before posting you will see I am medical!!! I note from your age that automatic testing before every flight would not effect you as a commercial pilot. Can you imagine the unfairness and stress your colleagues in India must go through with the risk of having their license pulled every time they fly? I find it incredible any sensible person would support this politically inspired nonsense.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: here and there
Posts: 242
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flying here in India which I believe is the only country (correct me if I'm wrong) to have mandatory BA every flight originating in India or post flight BA if originating outside India can be stressful.
I don't drink ( a teetotaller) and I've had one BA positive( alcosensor 4) from having just gargled with mouthwash before an early morning flight . Luckily , as per rule , a second BA test is mandated after 15 minutes which was 0.0 , I made sure my mouth was well rinsed and had some water before the second blow but I was sweating with the thought of a 3 month grounding. Another friend had a positive as he'd just doused himself with perfume 5 mins before the test and then we laughed later about him doing the second test in his undershirt vest which came negative but wasn't funny at the time.
Another forgot to do the post flight BA as he had to rush to connect ACM flight and he had a cool 3 month grounding to reflect on that mishap. I'm all for going after people coming drunk to work but this is just plain silly. Now with the proposed 1 year notice period proposed by DGCA, stress among pilots flying here is bound to increase .
I don't drink ( a teetotaller) and I've had one BA positive( alcosensor 4) from having just gargled with mouthwash before an early morning flight . Luckily , as per rule , a second BA test is mandated after 15 minutes which was 0.0 , I made sure my mouth was well rinsed and had some water before the second blow but I was sweating with the thought of a 3 month grounding. Another friend had a positive as he'd just doused himself with perfume 5 mins before the test and then we laughed later about him doing the second test in his undershirt vest which came negative but wasn't funny at the time.
Another forgot to do the post flight BA as he had to rush to connect ACM flight and he had a cool 3 month grounding to reflect on that mishap. I'm all for going after people coming drunk to work but this is just plain silly. Now with the proposed 1 year notice period proposed by DGCA, stress among pilots flying here is bound to increase .
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you really believe 'gas' spectrometers with full time laboratory technicians are available in India to test every pilot at the start and end of every flight then please proceed. I have used these machines for research - they are a nightmare in the field.
I believe in India all the pre-flight alcohol testing must be performed by a doctor or a paramedic.