Air Vanuatu Twin Otter elevator cable snap
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Germany
Age: 76
Posts: 1,561
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I once had an engineer install a hose incorrectly on a Cessna 404, the hose that connected the turbocharger to the inlet manifold. When it popped off, I lost the engine due to the mixture suddenly going far too rich for the suddenly reduced manifold pressure.
This was in a fully-loaded aircraft off a short strip on a very hot afternoon, when I was very lucky to have the hose pop off during extended climb, not too late to abort or right after lift-off.
When I got back to base, the guilty party told me that all I would have had to do was to lean the mixture to get the engine back, that there was no real problem there if I had simply known what to do. That's the closest I have ever come to slugging an engineer, with his blithe notion that I was going to to sit there and twiddle with a few controls to see what might work, in a machine with a highly negative rate of climb due to gear and flaps down and a windmilling prop on a failed engine.
So there you are when the elevator cable on your Twotter goes "Twang!" but you can sort it out no probs by playing with the elevator trim ... on short final or on take-off? Better yet, simply turn around and ask the SLF to run this way or that. These things I would like to see done in practice!
The Twin Otter uses a control lock for the elevator that locks the pilot's controls, just a rod that runs between the control column and the bottom of the instrument panel. That means that the elevator cables are still exposed to stress from winds and jet blast whether the controls are locked or not. The elevator itself is protected from banging around, as are the ailerons and the rudder, but none of the control cables is protected.
This was in a fully-loaded aircraft off a short strip on a very hot afternoon, when I was very lucky to have the hose pop off during extended climb, not too late to abort or right after lift-off.
When I got back to base, the guilty party told me that all I would have had to do was to lean the mixture to get the engine back, that there was no real problem there if I had simply known what to do. That's the closest I have ever come to slugging an engineer, with his blithe notion that I was going to to sit there and twiddle with a few controls to see what might work, in a machine with a highly negative rate of climb due to gear and flaps down and a windmilling prop on a failed engine.
So there you are when the elevator cable on your Twotter goes "Twang!" but you can sort it out no probs by playing with the elevator trim ... on short final or on take-off? Better yet, simply turn around and ask the SLF to run this way or that. These things I would like to see done in practice!
The Twin Otter uses a control lock for the elevator that locks the pilot's controls, just a rod that runs between the control column and the bottom of the instrument panel. That means that the elevator cables are still exposed to stress from winds and jet blast whether the controls are locked or not. The elevator itself is protected from banging around, as are the ailerons and the rudder, but none of the control cables is protected.
One gets the impression from reading this that this problem essentially only affects Twin Otters?
It's interesting that reports indicate that the broken cable in the Vanatu incident had only 6 months in service at the time of failure. Investigators should soon know whether it was a manufacturing or installation defect if they don't already.
Other types of aircraft are of course affected by cable wear and corrosion. In fact life limits have been imposed on all primary flight control cables for all Aussi registered aircraft. Though US registered A/C currently only have such life limits if imposed by a specific type AD, the Aussie approach could be in our future too. One source of undetectable corrosion cited by the Aussie CASA is the cable terminal ends that were swaged on during the cable assembly manufacturing process. There has been allot pushback over this issue but failed cable terminals continue to be found worlwide.
The simple fact is, the aviation industry has known about this since the advent of steel control cables! For the most part, periodic cleaning, visual inspection and lubrication (where applicable) has been considered sufficient. More recently, field generated service difficulty reports are indicating that undetected wear and corrosion has become more problematic. Hence the CASA reaction.
Some airplanes require a significant number of man-hours to properly carry out inspection and maintenance activities on cable systems. In some instances the cables must be removed from the aircraft to inspect them properly. Then they must be re-installed and rigged. My belief is that many of these cable system inspections aren't being properly accomplished. Many annual inspections are completed in the time it would take just to properly inspect the cables. Mandatory replacement is probably coming to much of the rest of the world outside Australia!
.
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: S E Asia
Posts: 198
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Twotter is a magnificently rugged little aircraft - loved every minute of the 1500 hours I spent on it, and have to say that technical problems were really rare. There were several occasions (not technical related) sitting in the left seat of a 777 in the middle of the night staring into the dark somewhere over an ocean with 10 hours to go that I would have willingly gone back to a Twotter if someone would have paid me the same money . Having said that, the Boeing is a bloody fine piece of kit, too.
Psychophysiological entity
Non event - just fly it with the trim wheel.
Luxury!! I dreamed of having a trim wheel when my elevator was solid.
Freelancing on a Shorts out of SEN. I was at about 6,000' in the London TMA.
Thank heavens, nice day and smooth. So smooth in fact that I only became aware of the stiffness of the trim gradually. Then it wouldn't move at all. Gentle pressure on the stick gave the same reaction.
Via my FO I asked London for, and got, a long gentle turn back roughly to SEN with Stansted alerted. I had asked to be routed away from populated areas. Pax strapped in, and our lovely young FA was standing at the door behind me trying to maintain her smile. I briefed on moving the passengers, but stressed that only one must move just a foot or so at a time. My FO went back to eating his sandwiches.
Moving the pax. Okay you, "I wouldn't let that happen" guys. What the hell would you have done?*
I had pressed on the Yoke just about as hard as I dared. After all, if it had gone forward sharply, and then stuck, doing a Neil Williams probably would have done nothing but keep my mind off the metaphorical hole I was in and the smoking hole I would have shortly been in.
Yes, I was gingerly altering the power to make minute changes of attitude but the approach was going to be somewhat more challenging. I had a mild sense of unreality and it made me mindful then, that an order to a passenger might be met with nothing but a blank stare. I thought through a lot of things during that time but despite having thousands of hours in command of medium weight turbo-props I hadn't got my usual bag of tricks open to me. Side-slipping, even on quite large aircraft, had always been a powerful tool for bush-style flying but that always required immediate elevator input, so a non-starter. Just keeping stable was about all I had.
Decent into warmer air freed the controls. I still recall the disappointment of the challenge being stripped away. One is really alive during situations like this.
It seemed the Shed's control run was in the belly. There had formed an emulsion of aviation goo and water - which has frozen over a longish length of the cables. I'd pushed quite hard with the above mentioned caution, but I recall bracing my entire body ready to stop pushing should it suddenly move. While frozen it was solid.
*Flying on trim. There has not been an airline I've worked for where the PF did not use the trim on a moment by moment basis. My first jet transport, the BAC 1-11, had a small gap - 3 degrees I think it was to allow micro switches to cut the Mach trim - and I still recall the clank clank of that hysteresis being taken up. Remember, we hand flew almost everything except cruise - just because we wanted to. When I fist stepped into the ATR for a somewhat impromptu bash at flying it, I reached for a trim wheel that wasn't there. It seemed insane - just as though a major flying control had gone missing.
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: UK
Age: 85
Posts: 697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flying using the trim might be OK if the elevator is jammed but if the cable has broken it is very possible that the elevator would be able to move around offering a quite different scenario.
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Moses Lake, WA
Age: 63
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the elevator is locked completely solid, then you only have the tiny trim tab moving, instead of the much larger elevator, so the aircraft pitch response response will be very minimal. And, to further complicate your life, the pitch movement will be in the other sense of normal response to trim movement - i.e. if the elevator is completely frozen, trim nose up to cause a very slow pitch down. Note: this is referring to an aircraft with a trim tab on the elevator. It does not apply to aircraft where a moveable stabilizer is used for pitch trim.
The Twin Otter AFM has an Emergency Procedure to cover loss of elevator control, so the pilots would hopefully have some idea what to do.
From the DHC-6-300 AFM:
Elevator Control Malfunction
WARNING
AIRCRAFT LONGITUDINAL RESPONSE TO ELEVATOR TRIM CONTROL AND POWER CHANGES WILL BE REDUCED. AVOID LARGE AND/OR RAPID CHANGES IN TRIM AND POWER.
SECTION 3 EMERGENCY AND ABNORMAL PROCEDURES
TC Approved
If movement of the control column does not produce a corresponding change in pitch attitude, longitudinal control can be managed by using the elevator trim. Engine power should be used to control vertical speed and airspeed.
Flaps should be extended or retracted cautiously, in increments of 5° or less.
Application of power will usually result in a nose-up pitching moment, and reduction of power will usually result in a nose-down pitching moment.
Extension of flap will usually result in a nose-up pitching moment, and retraction of flap will usually result in a nose-down pitching moment.
WARNING
AIRCRAFT LONGITUDINAL RESPONSE TO ELEVATOR TRIM CONTROL AND POWER CHANGES WILL BE REDUCED. AVOID LARGE AND/OR RAPID CHANGES IN TRIM AND POWER.
SECTION 3 EMERGENCY AND ABNORMAL PROCEDURES
TC Approved
If movement of the control column does not produce a corresponding change in pitch attitude, longitudinal control can be managed by using the elevator trim. Engine power should be used to control vertical speed and airspeed.
Flaps should be extended or retracted cautiously, in increments of 5° or less.
Application of power will usually result in a nose-up pitching moment, and reduction of power will usually result in a nose-down pitching moment.
Extension of flap will usually result in a nose-up pitching moment, and retraction of flap will usually result in a nose-down pitching moment.
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Victoria, B.C.
Age: 69
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Another related accident (fatal) from 1994, on the west coast of Canada, near Port Hardy. Elevator cable failed due corrosion. The pilot survived, with very serious injuries.
Transportation Safety Board of Canada - Aviation Investigation Report A94P0215
Transportation Safety Board of Canada - Aviation Investigation Report A94P0215
Another related accident (fatal) from 1994, on the west coast of Canada, near Port Hardy. Elevator cable failed due corrosion.
Last time I was in Port Hardy, the big issue was how to get thousands of birds off the runway so we could take off. Taxiing down to midfield and blasting them with engine noise and jet exhaust was the locally recommended procedure. It worked too! They even stayed away long enough for us to take off without hitting any.
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: last time I looked I was still here.
Posts: 4,507
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flying on the trim: I'm sure it would take quite a bit of trial & error and experimentation before I'd make an approach. Is the elevator frozen or is it floating? Which way does the a/c pitch with what trim input? How much trim input = how much change in attitude? What happens with power changes and can the trim control counteract pitch changes caused by power changes? There would be many variables to ascertain and gain confidence with before going near finals. Remember, you still might not know what will happen if you decide to GA. That would also be a manoeuvre to practice at height; and we haven't even discussed pitch changes with flaps yet.
Not quite so easy as first imagined. With a trimming stabiliser, à la B737, some what easier than an elevator & trim tab.
A slight drift about different ways to achieve the same using trim tabs. I was taxying out behind an old DC-9/MD-80 family. The high level stabiliser had elevators, but one was up & one was down. I was totally confused and asked, via ATC, to alert the crew. The reply was "eet's a normal" in accented italian english. Later, in discussion with a type rated pilot he explained, if I can remember correctly, the elevators were floating and pitch control was via the training edge tabs. With airspeed the elevators streamlined and all was good. So I wonder what would have happened if those elevators became stuck. Back to my PPL books about balance tabs & anti-balance tabs etc. etc.
Not quite so easy as first imagined. With a trimming stabiliser, à la B737, some what easier than an elevator & trim tab.
A slight drift about different ways to achieve the same using trim tabs. I was taxying out behind an old DC-9/MD-80 family. The high level stabiliser had elevators, but one was up & one was down. I was totally confused and asked, via ATC, to alert the crew. The reply was "eet's a normal" in accented italian english. Later, in discussion with a type rated pilot he explained, if I can remember correctly, the elevators were floating and pitch control was via the training edge tabs. With airspeed the elevators streamlined and all was good. So I wonder what would have happened if those elevators became stuck. Back to my PPL books about balance tabs & anti-balance tabs etc. etc.
Join Date: May 2010
Location: UK
Age: 79
Posts: 1,086
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If a cable breaks the elevators will be floating and trim will work. This is clearly documented in the POH along with other factors affecting pitch such as flaps. This procedure should be regularly practiced and trained for. We were aware of this and practiced it in Africa but that was a long time ago. I doubt is standards have slipped in the meanwhile but.......
The danger is a cable break at low level with little time to respond, if the aircraft is fully trimmed at all times you have a chance, if you fly with pressure on the yoke it can all go wrong very quickly.
The danger is a cable break at low level with little time to respond, if the aircraft is fully trimmed at all times you have a chance, if you fly with pressure on the yoke it can all go wrong very quickly.
Originally Posted by Small cog
ISTR from my flying the Twotter many, many years ago that there is an elevator trim / flap / interlink to prevent a recurrence of tailplane overstress during flap retraction.
Originally Posted by khorton
...If the elevator is locked completely solid, then you only have the tiny trim tab moving, instead of the much larger elevator, so the aircraft pitch response response will be very minimal.
The pilot was able to land the aircraft successfully by using the trim tab to control pitch and being very judicious with engine power adjustments.
The AFM extract that you quoted earlier in this thread was added as a result of that incident.
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Among camels and dunes
Posts: 425
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
25 Years ago, I flew a KingAir C90 that would trim nose up in the cruise and then, disconnect the autopilot with a violent nose up response after an hour of flight or so. Months went by with this snag, changing autopilots and "Please Report Back". GTFS! Ground Tested, Found Satisfactory was the usual response.
Then one day while hand flying the departure, the trim cable snapped in flight. I reduced speed to find the trim speed and fly it from there on wards to landing.
On the ground the authorities got involved, rightly so, following up on each snag in the Flight Folio, and all those about the autopilot problem.
The trim cable became frayed and was rolling onto the autopilot drive pulley and wasn't able to leave the drive pulley as it had wound up on itself. Hence each flight, it got a little worse and worse and eventually snap.
Lessons learn't back then already, that anything wrong with trims, flight controls, stickiness in full flight control check, go straight back to the hangar!
Then one day while hand flying the departure, the trim cable snapped in flight. I reduced speed to find the trim speed and fly it from there on wards to landing.
On the ground the authorities got involved, rightly so, following up on each snag in the Flight Folio, and all those about the autopilot problem.
The trim cable became frayed and was rolling onto the autopilot drive pulley and wasn't able to leave the drive pulley as it had wound up on itself. Hence each flight, it got a little worse and worse and eventually snap.
Lessons learn't back then already, that anything wrong with trims, flight controls, stickiness in full flight control check, go straight back to the hangar!
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: last time I looked I was still here.
Posts: 4,507
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Trimming issues can be easily dismissed. Remember Air Alaska DC-9/MD family that spiralled down onto the Pacific after the trim jack broke due to under greasing in maintenance.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Canada
Posts: 631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Trimming issues can be easily dismissed. Remember Air Alaska DC-9/MD family that spiralled down onto the Pacific after the trim jack broke due to under greasing in maintenance.
The second flap interconnecting trim tab is, as stated, there to minimize pitch control forces with flap position changes. Twin Otter flaps are hugely effective, and this additional system is required.
Control system linkages are known to freeze (in the low temperature sense) in several types. That's a bit of a design oversight that it's possible. Other than that, the seizing of an elevator control in a certain position is much more rare than a one side linkage failure. In such a case, the elevator will generally float free in one direction, and can be controlled against a deliberate out of trim selected by the pilot. But this is not something that most pilots will diagnose, and correctly set up in seconds, so is not an instant fix. I have flown an aircraft on two occasions where a massive pitch control rigging error resulted in flying a circuit while applying only variations in high "push" forces on the control wheel, as opposed to being trimmed, or "pulling" for some of the desired pitch changes. This is counter intuitive, and requires a careful thought, which many pilots could not be expected to get right on short final.